Hampshire’s Nancy Harman believes cricket is “less inclusive” after the ECB banned transgender women from female competitions at all levels.
The ECB said the policy change was “necessary” after the UK Supreme Court ruled on the status of transgender women under UK equality law on April 16, deciding that the definition of a “woman” and “sex” in the Equality Act 2010 refers to “a biological woman and biological sex” – the sex they were assigned at birth.
Trans women were not permitted to take part in the top two tiers of elite women’s cricket and The Hundred since the start of this year, but could still compete throughout recreational cricket and up to tier three of the women’s game.
However, this new ruling confirmed transgender women can no longer play women’s cricket at any level with immediate effect.
“I’m disappointed by the [ECB’s] ruling,” Harman told Sky Sports News.
Harman plays for Hampshire and has previously represented Southern Vipers and London Spirit, among other sides
“I can see how the Supreme Court has forced the ECB’s hand but, for me it’s about what is now going to happen to continue to make the sport inclusive at the recreational level.
“I disagree with anything that makes this sport less inclusive and banning trans women from competing with other women seems to do that in my opinion.
“It feels like a certain few people are going to feel particularly targeted and marginalised.
“Cricket can play a role in young trans people’s lives in terms of making friends and having an adult support network during transition and teenage years. The blanket ruling has ignored those factors which will affect trans women of any age.”
‘How will ECB make sport inclusive for trans women?’
The ECB acknowledges that transgender women and girls will feel a “significant impact” and will work with Recreational Cricket Boards to support those affected.
Though transgender women and girls can continue playing in open and mixed cricket, Harman has called for action to make this a viable option around the country.
“The ECB probably had a chance to stand up and say we understand the Supreme Court ruling but we want to continue to make this an inclusive sport. For example, operating a case-by-case policy, consulting trans women, and seeing what impact trans inclusion is having,” she said.
“If they can’t change [the ban], my challenge is what support will be provided to make the sport inclusive for trans women?
Nancy Harmann: ‘I can’t sit by and watch people being told that they can’t do all the things that I have personally benefited from: sport, activity, making friends’
“We need to make sure there’s a mixed league in every area of the country and make sure there’s buy-in because there probably aren’t enough trans women to make a team, let alone a team that could compete against another in a geographical area.”
The 25-year-old has chosen to speak publicly as trans rights are “close to [her] heart” and believes they are being “eroded” across society.
“There’s a trans woman in my close family, and as a member of the LGBTQ+ community myself, I’ve been afforded such inclusivity from being part of a sport that has given the community a place to be themselves,” she explains.
“I can’t sit by and watch people being told that they can’t do all the things that I have personally benefited from: sport, activity, making friends. Why should I get all that opportunity and not a trans person? It’s not equal. It’s not right.
“I want to use my platform because it’s important that trans people are supported with their mental and physical health by playing sport in a time when they need that more than ever.”
Sky Sports News senior reporter Rob Dorsett explains the Football Association’s confirmation that transgender women will no longer be able to play in women’s football in England from June 1.
Harman: Everyone’s body is different
All-rounder Harman – who contributed to two winning Charlotte Edwards Cup campaigns for Southern Vipers as well as the victory in the 2023 Rachael Heyhoe Flint Trophy – worries the ban will have implications beyond transgender women and girls.
“Will you have to go to a women’s team with your birth certificate? How is that going to be policed?
“In terms of questions being asked, it leaves a massive grey area because there’s an assumption you’re going to know if somebody’s trans when that is not true. Clubs need support with that.”
Supporters of bans on transgender women from women’s sport, such as campaign group Sex Matters, have argued measures are necessary for safety and fairness.
Nancy Harman: ‘We can’t say that we play a sport that’s fully inclusive when this ruling doesn’t make it fully inclusive’
Harman says: “To that I say everyone’s body is different. There are bowlers born women who are over six foot and probably stronger than men.
“It would be wild to assume that at the recreational level, there isn’t a difference in the physical abilities and genetic makeup of the women who play. Assuming trans women are the only ones with [an advantage] is wrong.
“I grew up playing men’s cricket and a lot of women in the women’s game will have played men’s cricket because some clubs still don’t have women’s teams and that’s been okay. Nobody was questioning the fairness then.”
While Harman admits professional athletes may have limited influence over recreational-level cricket, she hopes to encourage other athletes to speak out and question their governing bodies’ decisions.
“We can’t say that we play a sport that’s fully inclusive when this ruling doesn’t make it fully inclusive.”
When contacted by Sky Sports News, the ECB referred to its original statement.
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
Flamengo anuncia Rodrigo Caio como seu novo auxiliar técnico
Rodrigo Caio, novo auxiliar técnico do Flamengo (Site oficial Flamengo) Nesta terça-feira (13), o Flamengo oficializou o retorno de Rodrigo Caio. Depois de uma passagem vitoriosa no clube, o agora ex-zagueiro irá exercer o cargo de auxiliar técnico. Será o primeiro desafio do ex-jogador fora dos campos, em seu reencontro com Filipe Luís, seu companheiro na Gávea durante seu primeiro período na equipe carioca. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADE Importante citar que Rodrigo Caio fará parte da comissão técnica permanente. Dessa forma, ele seguirá no cargo mesmo em caso de uma eventual saída / demissão do atual treinador. “A chegada de Rodrigo Caio faz parte de um projeto estratégico da Diretoria de Futebol, que busca integrar à comissão técnica profissionais preparados, com identidade rubro-negra e histórico de conquistas com o Manto Sagrado. A presença de um jogador que marcou época no clube tem […]
Flamengo anuncia Rodrigo Caio como seu novo auxiliar técnico
Rodrigo Caio, novo auxiliar técnico do Flamengo (Site oficial Flamengo) Nesta terça-feira (13), o Flamengo oficializou o retorno de Rodrigo Caio. Depois de uma passagem vitoriosa no clube, o agora ex-zagueiro irá exercer o cargo de auxiliar técnico. Será o primeiro desafio do ex-jogador fora dos campos, em seu reencontro com Filipe Luís, seu companheiro na Gávea durante seu primeiro período na equipe carioca. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADE Importante citar que Rodrigo Caio fará parte da comissão técnica permanente. Dessa forma, ele seguirá no cargo mesmo em caso de uma eventual saída / demissão do atual treinador. “A chegada de Rodrigo Caio faz parte de um projeto estratégico da Diretoria de Futebol, que busca integrar à comissão técnica profissionais preparados, com identidade rubro-negra e histórico de conquistas com o Manto Sagrado. A presença de um jogador que marcou época no clube tem […]
New USMNT, USWNT kits feature classic looks with a nod to an iconic throwback
It took Peter Moore about 30 minutes at a Xerox machine in 1993 to create the most iconic piece of design in American soccer history.Moore had made his name years earlier at Nike, as the designer of the first Air Jordan sneaker and the iconic “Jumpman” logo. He’d helped grow the sportswear and shoe brand from a tiny Oregon startup to a global titan before leaving for Adidas in the early 90s. There, he’d continued knocking almost every design out of the park. By the time Moore stood at the copy machine, most of the world’s soccer jerseys bore the ascending three stripes of the modern Adidas logo that he’d designed.AdvertisementThis was not Moore’s first soccer project. Among his first tasks at Adidas had been designing the beautiful, baggy men’s and women’s kits they’d worn in the early 90s, with […]
„Sehr stolz auf dich” – Ronaldo-Sohn feiert Debüt für Portugal
Mini-CR7 erstmals im Nationaltrikot!Cristiano Ronaldo (40) ist mächtig stolz – und das nicht wegen eines weiteren persönlichen Rekords, sondern wegen seines Sohnes!Lesen Sie auch<!-->[-->Cristiano Ronaldo Júnior (14) hat sein erstes Länderspiel für die U15-Nationalmannschaft Portugals absolviert. Beim 4:1-Sieg gegen Japan wurde der Sprössling des Weltstars in der 54. Minute eingewechselt. Ein Tor gelang ihm nicht – aber allein der Einsatz war für Vater Ronaldo ein emotionaler Moment.Auf der Plattform X schrieb der fünfmalige Weltfußballer: „Herzlichen Glückwunsch zu deinem Debüt in Portugals Auswahlteam, Sohn. Bin sehr stolz auf dich!“ Dazu teilte er Fotos seines Juniors im Spiel mit den markanten Locken und im Nationaltrikot. An dieser Stelle findest du Inhalte aus Twitter Um mit Inhalten aus Twitter und anderen sozialen Netzwerken zu interagieren oder diese darzustellen, brauchen wir deine Zustimmung. soziale Netzwerke aktivieren Um eingebettete Inhalte anzuzeigen, ist Ihre jederzeit widerrufliche […]
PGA Championship: Is completing a career grand slam better than winning more majors?
Tuesday is a packed day at the PGA Championship, with a combined 24 majors’ worth of champions taking their turn at the media podium. Here’s a rundown of the major quotes, topics and storylines that emerged from the day.Jon Rahm: Lessons learned from a decade of majorsJon Rahm arrives in Charlotte in a good news-bad news situation. Good news is, he’s playing well; bad news is, he’s only been testing himself in LIV Golf fields. He finished T14 at the Masters last month, and has struggled at the PGA Championship. In nine starts, he has no finish higher than T4, and his missed cut last year was his first at any major since 2019.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementAs he began his press conference, he shook his head at the fact that he’s been doing this for a decade now. “It goes by fast,” he […]
Rizek crava ‘vantagem’ do Palmeiras sobre o Flamengo hoje: “Encaminhou”
Palmeiras e Flamengo pelo Brasileirão 2024 - Alexandre Schneider/Getty Images Classificado para as oitavas de final da Libertadores e líder do Brasileirão, o Palmeiras tem uma vantagem significativa sobre o Flamengo. Segundo André Rizek, o Rubro-Negro, com chances de eliminação na fase de grupos, vai usar força máxima nestas duas últimas rodadas. Por outro lado, o Verdão poderá preservar aqueles mais desgastados fisicamente e focar exclusivamente na Série A, podendo até mesmo abrir uma distância maior sobre seu rival. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADE “Até nisso o Palmeiras tem uma vantagem muito grande em relação ao Flamengo, já encaminhou na Libertadores. Ele vai poder descansar, digo no modo de falar, poupar jogadores nos jogos em casa na Libertadores e mesmo poupando tende a ganhar. Agora, o Flamengo não pode fazer, Bahia, Inter, Botafogo”, disse Rizek. “O Palmeiras tem essa vantagem e também poderá […]
Related
Flamengo anuncia Rodrigo Caio como seu novo auxiliar técnico
Rodrigo Caio, novo auxiliar técnico do Flamengo (Site oficial Flamengo) Nesta terça-feira (13), o Flamengo oficializou o retorno de Rodrigo Caio. Depois de uma passagem vitoriosa no clube, o agora ex-zagueiro irá exercer o cargo de auxiliar técnico. Será o primeiro desafio do ex-jogador fora dos campos, em seu reencontro com Filipe Luís, seu companheiro na Gávea durante seu primeiro período na equipe carioca. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADE Importante citar que Rodrigo Caio fará parte da comissão técnica permanente. Dessa forma, ele seguirá no cargo mesmo em caso de uma eventual saída / demissão do atual treinador. “A chegada de Rodrigo Caio faz parte de um projeto estratégico da Diretoria de Futebol, que busca integrar à comissão técnica profissionais preparados, com identidade rubro-negra e histórico de conquistas com o Manto Sagrado. A presença de um jogador que marcou época no clube tem […]
Flamengo anuncia Rodrigo Caio como seu novo auxiliar técnico
Rodrigo Caio, novo auxiliar técnico do Flamengo (Site oficial Flamengo) Nesta terça-feira (13), o Flamengo oficializou o retorno de Rodrigo Caio. Depois de uma passagem vitoriosa no clube, o agora ex-zagueiro irá exercer o cargo de auxiliar técnico. Será o primeiro desafio do ex-jogador fora dos campos, em seu reencontro com Filipe Luís, seu companheiro na Gávea durante seu primeiro período na equipe carioca. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADE Importante citar que Rodrigo Caio fará parte da comissão técnica permanente. Dessa forma, ele seguirá no cargo mesmo em caso de uma eventual saída / demissão do atual treinador. “A chegada de Rodrigo Caio faz parte de um projeto estratégico da Diretoria de Futebol, que busca integrar à comissão técnica profissionais preparados, com identidade rubro-negra e histórico de conquistas com o Manto Sagrado. A presença de um jogador que marcou época no clube tem […]
New USMNT, USWNT kits feature classic looks with a nod to an iconic throwback
It took Peter Moore about 30 minutes at a Xerox machine in 1993 to create the most iconic piece of design in American soccer history.Moore had made his name years earlier at Nike, as the designer of the first Air Jordan sneaker and the iconic “Jumpman” logo. He’d helped grow the sportswear and shoe brand from a tiny Oregon startup to a global titan before leaving for Adidas in the early 90s. There, he’d continued knocking almost every design out of the park. By the time Moore stood at the copy machine, most of the world’s soccer jerseys bore the ascending three stripes of the modern Adidas logo that he’d designed.AdvertisementThis was not Moore’s first soccer project. Among his first tasks at Adidas had been designing the beautiful, baggy men’s and women’s kits they’d worn in the early 90s, with […]
„Sehr stolz auf dich” – Ronaldo-Sohn feiert Debüt für Portugal
Mini-CR7 erstmals im Nationaltrikot!Cristiano Ronaldo (40) ist mächtig stolz – und das nicht wegen eines weiteren persönlichen Rekords, sondern wegen seines Sohnes!Lesen Sie auch<!-->[-->Cristiano Ronaldo Júnior (14) hat sein erstes Länderspiel für die U15-Nationalmannschaft Portugals absolviert. Beim 4:1-Sieg gegen Japan wurde der Sprössling des Weltstars in der 54. Minute eingewechselt. Ein Tor gelang ihm nicht – aber allein der Einsatz war für Vater Ronaldo ein emotionaler Moment.Auf der Plattform X schrieb der fünfmalige Weltfußballer: „Herzlichen Glückwunsch zu deinem Debüt in Portugals Auswahlteam, Sohn. Bin sehr stolz auf dich!“ Dazu teilte er Fotos seines Juniors im Spiel mit den markanten Locken und im Nationaltrikot. An dieser Stelle findest du Inhalte aus Twitter Um mit Inhalten aus Twitter und anderen sozialen Netzwerken zu interagieren oder diese darzustellen, brauchen wir deine Zustimmung. soziale Netzwerke aktivieren Um eingebettete Inhalte anzuzeigen, ist Ihre jederzeit widerrufliche […]
PGA Championship: Is completing a career grand slam better than winning more majors?
Tuesday is a packed day at the PGA Championship, with a combined 24 majors’ worth of champions taking their turn at the media podium. Here’s a rundown of the major quotes, topics and storylines that emerged from the day.Jon Rahm: Lessons learned from a decade of majorsJon Rahm arrives in Charlotte in a good news-bad news situation. Good news is, he’s playing well; bad news is, he’s only been testing himself in LIV Golf fields. He finished T14 at the Masters last month, and has struggled at the PGA Championship. In nine starts, he has no finish higher than T4, and his missed cut last year was his first at any major since 2019.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementAs he began his press conference, he shook his head at the fact that he’s been doing this for a decade now. “It goes by fast,” he […]
Rizek crava ‘vantagem’ do Palmeiras sobre o Flamengo hoje: “Encaminhou”
Palmeiras e Flamengo pelo Brasileirão 2024 - Alexandre Schneider/Getty Images Classificado para as oitavas de final da Libertadores e líder do Brasileirão, o Palmeiras tem uma vantagem significativa sobre o Flamengo. Segundo André Rizek, o Rubro-Negro, com chances de eliminação na fase de grupos, vai usar força máxima nestas duas últimas rodadas. Por outro lado, o Verdão poderá preservar aqueles mais desgastados fisicamente e focar exclusivamente na Série A, podendo até mesmo abrir uma distância maior sobre seu rival. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADE “Até nisso o Palmeiras tem uma vantagem muito grande em relação ao Flamengo, já encaminhou na Libertadores. Ele vai poder descansar, digo no modo de falar, poupar jogadores nos jogos em casa na Libertadores e mesmo poupando tende a ganhar. Agora, o Flamengo não pode fazer, Bahia, Inter, Botafogo”, disse Rizek. “O Palmeiras tem essa vantagem e também poderá […]
Be the first to leave a comment