TORONTO — It was different this year.
These weren’t the same Maple Leafs. They played a different style, a playoff style, a Craig Berube style. They were playing the way they needed to play to win in the playoffs. They knew how to win close games. They responded to adversity. They were tough. They were heavy. Their stars had embraced the right mentality to finally win.
Advertisement
Not so much. The first two games of their second-round series with the defending champs have proved to be an aberration.
Even with a stronger defence and better goaltending, the Leafs are proving they aren’t so different after all. An embarrassing, humbling, shocking Game 5 defeat showed that.
All the same problems, the ones that destroyed Leaf team after Leaf team and ultimately ended Sheldon Keefe’s time as head coach, are emerging again at the worst possible time.
The stars have disappeared — again.
Mitch Marner and Auston Matthews got another chance to play together on Wednesday night and were promptly rolled by the Panthers’ No. 1 line in devastating fashion. The carnage happened almost right away. Shot attempts were 11-1 for Florida in the first period when Marner, Matthews and Matthew Knies were on the ice together – and crucially, the Panthers scored the first goal of the night when their top line was up against the Leafs top line and one more after that.
Home ice was supposed to bring back a matchup advantage for the Leafs.
Matthews and Marner would be a formidable counterpoint for Aleksander Barkov and Sam Reinhart.
They were the opposite.
The line was one and done on offence, stuck on the walls, unable to get inside and generate much of anything.
Matthews’ two best looks of the night were both denied by Sergei Bobrovsky, one off the right pad, one off the left pad.
Often, he parked himself in front of the net and tried to establish net-front position for tips and rebounds.
Matthews has scored two goals in 11 games this postseason, three in the last 21, a streak that dates back to the beginning of the second-round series with the Panthers in 2023. He has yet to score in 10 career playoff games against the Panthers.
It’s the similarity to past postseasons that makes it difficult to pin this solely on injury.
Advertisement
Matthews is almost certainly not at 100 percent. It’s evident in the way he moves and shoots the puck, especially from distance. But he’s playing and the Leafs have needed more from him. They needed goals from him, just as they have (and haven’t gotten) in previous postseasons.
Matthews didn’t get enough help from his sidekick again either.
This game looked disturbingly similar to past big games for both Matthews and Marner. An extra gear is missing. An extra level of fire, urgency and engagement. Too much on the perimeter. Not dangerous. Not like the regular season.
Once again, Marner couldn’t create enough (anything?) for Matthews or himself. His failed blind pass into the middle cost the Leafs on the Panthers’ third goal. He has one goal since Game 1 of the first round.
THAT’S THREE UNANSWERED ‼️
Jesper Boqvist finishes off a Sam Reinhart feed to give the Panthers a 3-0 lead in Game 5 pic.twitter.com/3zab7M2Cg7
— Sportsnet (@Sportsnet) May 15, 2025
The Leafs need him to score and create for others.
Yet again, the Matthews-Marner connection is failing when the Leafs needed it most. The way the Leafs are built, these two need to be great, especially on nights like this.
Berube tried to stay the course with the twosome after Game 4, to keep things calm as he always had, to not panic. And besides, he didn’t like how things looked when William Nylander played with Matthews — even though he gave it very little runway to succeed in the regular season and even though the connection has proved tantalizing in the past.
The problem with his line of thinking was simple: How did it look with Marner? That wasn’t working either. Though their line fared OK early in the series, they were increasingly quiet as Matthews struggled to score and Marner struggled to get him the puck.
Berube declined to adjust.
Advertisement
Flipping Nylander onto Matthews’ right wing might not have worked. Or maybe it would have sparked something different, anything different to change Game 5 before it broke open.
It was the same kind of decision on a smaller scale that’s hurt the Leafs again and again and again: Believing that doing things the same will lead to a different result if they just stick with it long enough.
The Leafs coach waited too long to make changes. It wasn’t until Game 5 was already effectively over that he removed Marner from Matthews’ wing and tried something else — playing Matthews with Nylander and John Tavares for a shift. He worked the blender more after that, when it was already too late. Maybe playing with Tavares might have gotten Marner going or Tavares, who has been held without a point in four of five games this series.
It’s one thing to be steady. It’s another to adjust when the situation warrants it.
Berube came in with the reputation of a coach who would challenge the stars, push them to greater heights — finally.
Unlike Keefe, he has declined to publicly criticize them at any point. Full-on meritocracy hasn’t really been there either. While others such as Nick Robertson and David Kämpf came in and out of the lineup for their errors and subpar play, Berube stood by a struggling Max Domi, even in the postseason when his rash of penalties stung the team.
Will Berube scratch him now?
A coach can only do so much, though this particular style, for this particular team, may not work in the playoffs after all.
Depth too is proving, again, to be an issue.
The Leafs have gotten nothing from their bottom six. And while it’s undoubtedly on the top players — the Matthews, Marners, Nylanders, John Tavares’ — to drive the team, others are allowed to contribute as well.
They did in the first round.
Advertisement
This particular bunch though hasn’t proven good enough to do it in this series, not against the defending champs.
Too many one-dimensional players. Not like Florida.
The lack of a quality third-line centre (a longstanding issue) has been highlighted yet again in this series as Anton Lundell shines for the Panthers. Florida has had three — and even four — lines hurt the Leafs in this series.
With all of that said, this series isn’t over yet.
The Leafs could still win Game 6. Another Game 7 could still be in the cards. The Leafs can still prove they are in fact different. Right now, this team is looking just like the rest.
(Photo of Auston Matthews and Aleksander Barkov: Claus Andersen / Getty Images)
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
Simon v prosinci po deseti letech skončí v čele WTA
Simon byl třináct let ředitelem turnaje v Indian Wells a v roce 2015 se stal výkonným ředitelem WTA. Organizace se pod jeho vedením mimo jiné zavázala zajistit tenistkám na více turnajích stejné odměny, jako mají muži.Sedmdesátiletý Američan byl také terčem kritiky za nevydařenou organizaci Turnaje mistryň v roce 2023 v Cancúnu a poté i za přesunutí akce do Saúdské Arábie. Spolu s WTA loni čelil žalobě za to, jak se asociace po invazi na Ukrajinu postavila k ruským a běloruským hráčkám.
QB Caleb Williams and family tried to avoid being drafted by the Bears, new book reveals
Caleb Williams and his family openly expressed concern over the quarterback going to Chicago before the Bears drafted him in 2024, according to a new book.Leading up to the 2024 NFL Draft, Caleb's father, Carl Williams, told ESPN's Seth Wickersham, author of "American Kings: A Biography of the Quarterback," of their lack of interest in the Windy City.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisement"Chicago is the place quarterbacks go to die," Carl said.Caleb also saw a bad fit in Chicago, saying, "Do I want to go there? I don't think I can do it with [former Bears offensive coordinator Shane] Waldron."The Bears selected Williams with the No. 1 pick, and the Bears ended up firing Shane Waldron in November before firing head coach Matt Eberflus.This breaking news story will be updated.
Denílson faz cobrança ao sinalizar possível vexame em 2025: “É gigante”
Denílson, em participação no Globo Esporte (Reprodução) Denílson, antes do Corinthians encarar o Racing-URU, trouxe um alerta ao Timão. Lidando com uma campanha irregular, a equipe alvinegra, fora de casa, precisa somar três pontos para seguir vivo na Sul-Americana. Porém, houve uma hipótese levantada por Fred Bruno sobre a possibilidade do clube paulista deixar o torneio continental de lado para focar no Brasileirão e Copa do Brasil. “Tá bem complicado e, para falar a verdade, jogando a vida! Precisa vencer ou vencer para continuar sonhando com a classificação.”, disse Denílson, no Globo Esporte. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADE “Caso queira…”, lembrou Fred Bruno. “Tem essa também.”, completou o ex-jogador. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADE Obrigação do Corinthians Apesar da ressalva, Denílson lembrou que o Corinthians tem obrigação de seguir rumo ao mata-mata da Sul-Americana. Diante da grandeza do Timão, a escolha em forçar uma eliminação causaria […]
Com 7 Copas do Mundo no currículo, Formiga revela desejo para 2027 no Brasil: “é um sonho…”
Formiga atuando pela Seleção brasileira feminina (Lucas Figueiredo/CBF) A Seleção brasileira feminina vive bom momento nos últimos anos. Desde a chegada de Arthur Elias, o clima parece leve e a reformulação parece ter resultados cada vez melhores, porém, ainda não chegamos no nível da antiga geração. Com Formiga, Marta e Cristiane como principais nomes da amarelinha, o Brasil conseguiu grandes feitos, como participação em finais de Copa do Mundo e Olimpíadas, além da divulgação e popularização da modalidade no nosso país. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADE Formiga é a recordista entre homens e mulheres no número de participações em Copa do Mundo. Em toda a história, ela participou de 7 edições. Ela se aposentou da Seleção em 2021, deixando um legado gigante para as jogadoras da atual geração. Agora fora dos gramados, Formiga olha com otimismo para a Copa do Mundo de 2027, […]
Free MLB picks, predictions, props, bets on Thursday, May 15: This three-leg baseball parlay pays over 7-1
Imagn Images The Thursday MLB schedule is light with only six games on the slate. One of the most notable matchups of the day is Rangers vs. Astros in a rivalry game at 8:05 p.m. ET. This game projects to be a pitching duel with Hunter Brown (6-1, 1.48 ERA, 0.90 WHIP) starting for Houston and Jacob deGrom (3-1, 2.72 ERA, 1.02 WHIP) on the mound for the Rangers. The rubber match of this series will be played at Globe Life Field in Arlington.The Rangers are -131 favorites (risk $131 to win $100) on the money line, while the over/under is 7 runs in the latest MLB odds for Thursday. Should you back the Astros or Rangers when making MLB picks on Thursday? Before making any MLB picks or building any MLB parlay cards, you'll want to see the MLB […]
San Francisco 49ers to sell minority stake in team to trio of local families
The San Francisco 49ers are in the process of selling 6.2 percent of the team to a trio of Bay Area families, according to a league source familiar with the proposal.The York family, who own the 49ers, would sell 3.1 percent to the Khosla family, 2.1 percent to the Deeter family and 1 percent to William Griffith.AdvertisementThe league’s finance committee has recommended approval of the transactions at next week’s NFL owners meeting in Minnesota.Vinod Khosla, 70, was the co-founder of Sun Microsystems and is currently the managing director of Khosla Ventures out of Menlo Park.Byron Deeter, 50, is a partner at Bessemer Venture Partners, which has offices in San Francisco and Redwood City. Deeter graduated from UC Berkeley, where he played rugby.Griffith, 53, is a partner at ICONIQ Capital in San Francisco. He played football at Dartmouth and earned an MBA […]
Related
Simon v prosinci po deseti letech skončí v čele WTA
Simon byl třináct let ředitelem turnaje v Indian Wells a v roce 2015 se stal výkonným ředitelem WTA. Organizace se pod jeho vedením mimo jiné zavázala zajistit tenistkám na více turnajích stejné odměny, jako mají muži.Sedmdesátiletý Američan byl také terčem kritiky za nevydařenou organizaci Turnaje mistryň v roce 2023 v Cancúnu a poté i za přesunutí akce do Saúdské Arábie. Spolu s WTA loni čelil žalobě za to, jak se asociace po invazi na Ukrajinu postavila k ruským a běloruským hráčkám.
QB Caleb Williams and family tried to avoid being drafted by the Bears, new book reveals
Caleb Williams and his family openly expressed concern over the quarterback going to Chicago before the Bears drafted him in 2024, according to a new book.Leading up to the 2024 NFL Draft, Caleb's father, Carl Williams, told ESPN's Seth Wickersham, author of "American Kings: A Biography of the Quarterback," of their lack of interest in the Windy City.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisement"Chicago is the place quarterbacks go to die," Carl said.Caleb also saw a bad fit in Chicago, saying, "Do I want to go there? I don't think I can do it with [former Bears offensive coordinator Shane] Waldron."The Bears selected Williams with the No. 1 pick, and the Bears ended up firing Shane Waldron in November before firing head coach Matt Eberflus.This breaking news story will be updated.
Denílson faz cobrança ao sinalizar possível vexame em 2025: “É gigante”
Denílson, em participação no Globo Esporte (Reprodução) Denílson, antes do Corinthians encarar o Racing-URU, trouxe um alerta ao Timão. Lidando com uma campanha irregular, a equipe alvinegra, fora de casa, precisa somar três pontos para seguir vivo na Sul-Americana. Porém, houve uma hipótese levantada por Fred Bruno sobre a possibilidade do clube paulista deixar o torneio continental de lado para focar no Brasileirão e Copa do Brasil. “Tá bem complicado e, para falar a verdade, jogando a vida! Precisa vencer ou vencer para continuar sonhando com a classificação.”, disse Denílson, no Globo Esporte. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADE “Caso queira…”, lembrou Fred Bruno. “Tem essa também.”, completou o ex-jogador. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADE Obrigação do Corinthians Apesar da ressalva, Denílson lembrou que o Corinthians tem obrigação de seguir rumo ao mata-mata da Sul-Americana. Diante da grandeza do Timão, a escolha em forçar uma eliminação causaria […]
Com 7 Copas do Mundo no currículo, Formiga revela desejo para 2027 no Brasil: “é um sonho…”
Formiga atuando pela Seleção brasileira feminina (Lucas Figueiredo/CBF) A Seleção brasileira feminina vive bom momento nos últimos anos. Desde a chegada de Arthur Elias, o clima parece leve e a reformulação parece ter resultados cada vez melhores, porém, ainda não chegamos no nível da antiga geração. Com Formiga, Marta e Cristiane como principais nomes da amarelinha, o Brasil conseguiu grandes feitos, como participação em finais de Copa do Mundo e Olimpíadas, além da divulgação e popularização da modalidade no nosso país. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADE Formiga é a recordista entre homens e mulheres no número de participações em Copa do Mundo. Em toda a história, ela participou de 7 edições. Ela se aposentou da Seleção em 2021, deixando um legado gigante para as jogadoras da atual geração. Agora fora dos gramados, Formiga olha com otimismo para a Copa do Mundo de 2027, […]
Free MLB picks, predictions, props, bets on Thursday, May 15: This three-leg baseball parlay pays over 7-1
Imagn Images The Thursday MLB schedule is light with only six games on the slate. One of the most notable matchups of the day is Rangers vs. Astros in a rivalry game at 8:05 p.m. ET. This game projects to be a pitching duel with Hunter Brown (6-1, 1.48 ERA, 0.90 WHIP) starting for Houston and Jacob deGrom (3-1, 2.72 ERA, 1.02 WHIP) on the mound for the Rangers. The rubber match of this series will be played at Globe Life Field in Arlington.The Rangers are -131 favorites (risk $131 to win $100) on the money line, while the over/under is 7 runs in the latest MLB odds for Thursday. Should you back the Astros or Rangers when making MLB picks on Thursday? Before making any MLB picks or building any MLB parlay cards, you'll want to see the MLB […]
San Francisco 49ers to sell minority stake in team to trio of local families
The San Francisco 49ers are in the process of selling 6.2 percent of the team to a trio of Bay Area families, according to a league source familiar with the proposal.The York family, who own the 49ers, would sell 3.1 percent to the Khosla family, 2.1 percent to the Deeter family and 1 percent to William Griffith.AdvertisementThe league’s finance committee has recommended approval of the transactions at next week’s NFL owners meeting in Minnesota.Vinod Khosla, 70, was the co-founder of Sun Microsystems and is currently the managing director of Khosla Ventures out of Menlo Park.Byron Deeter, 50, is a partner at Bessemer Venture Partners, which has offices in San Francisco and Redwood City. Deeter graduated from UC Berkeley, where he played rugby.Griffith, 53, is a partner at ICONIQ Capital in San Francisco. He played football at Dartmouth and earned an MBA […]
Be the first to leave a comment