If you can’t beat it, ban it.
That was the mindset of 22 teams in the NFL Wednesday when they voted to ban the Tush Push. Thankfully, they failed, though by only two votes.
If you’re mad about the vote failing, send condolences to the Green Bay Packers, who brought the ban proposal to an owners’ vote. If you’re happy, deride the Packers for turning to the rule book to stop what they (and others) couldn’t on the field.
Advertisement
I’m not a Tush Push fan, but I’m firmly in the deride-the-Packers camp here, mainly because there wasn’t a compelling argument made as to why the Tush Push should be banned.
The Packers began this quest with an argument centered around injury, but when no data could be shown that the play caused a single injury — not one — they shifted their focus to the old “let’s get back to how things used to be” mantra, meaning going back to 2005 rules when pushing and pulling ball carriers was illegal.
The problem here is they already showed their cards. They weren’t interested in reverting to 2005 rules until it became necessary to do so. And while trial and error can be a useful tool when it comes to optimizing methodology, it reeks of desperation when you’re just trying to get your way.
I’d respect the Packers more had they just admitted they don’t like the play — “that’s it, that’s our reasoning” — but instead, they hid behind an integrity-of-the-game argument where, to use an appropriate phrase here, the goalposts kept moving.
Advertisement
The Packers, of course, shouldn’t shoulder all the derision here; 21 other teams reportedly voted with them. If we’re being blunt, cowards are what they are.
Why so harsh?
Because this is a play that is so simple every team in the league could run it; a play so obvious, every coach, player and yahoo watching at home knows it’s coming; a play that embodies the core of the game of football — strength vs. strength — more than any other. And yet it’s a play that only two teams have figured out how to run effectively.
That should be celebrated, not banned. That should be a wake-up call to the 30 other teams to figure out how to stop it and come up with the right personnel to execute their own version.
Advertisement
The Eagles and Bills, the only two teams that appear to have figured it out, are successful at it because they have Mack trucks for quarterbacks. Sorry if you have Jordan Love under center and he doesn’t have tree trunks for thighs, but that’s on you, Green Bay. Find a tight end who does and join the guaranteed fourth-and-1 conversion party.
Unfortunately, this probably isn’t the end of this push to ban the push. The ban camp received 22 votes. That’s six more than it reportedly had in April, and only two short of prevailing.
But the “no” votes aren’t going away. They’re going to gather their strength, focus it in a common direction, and keep push, push, pushing until they get it across the goal line … you know, like football ought to be played.
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
Oilers out of their depth as Matt Duchene and Stars’ other scorers finally step up
DALLAS — Less than four minutes into the Western Conference final, Connor McDavid received a pass at center ice at full speed, blew through a Mikko Rantanen stick check and turned Esa Lindell inside out, going straight through the Dallas Stars, straight to their net and straight for their hearts.Jake Oettinger made the save, but it was clear right away in Game 1 that McDavid was rested, raring to go and in rare form — a half-step quicker than usual, if that’s even possible. So was Leon Draisaitl, who commanded the puck whenever he was on the ice and was dangerous every time he got it.AdvertisementMan, the Edmonton Oilers were flying in this one, and the Stars looked, well, star-struck.“It’s definitely a different game than the last series,” Dallas coach Pete DeBoer said.The Stars don’t have a Connor McDavid. Or […]
Connections: Sports Edition hints for May 22, 2025, puzzle No. 241
This season, the teams who never win have won – and football is better for it Spurs waited 17 years, Newcastle 70 and Crystal Palace had never won a trophy - surely that is better than 'Big Six' dominance?
Stars vs. Oilers scores, schedule, odds, where to watch as Dallas rallies for come-from-behind Game 1 win
Getty Images The Dallas Stars looked dead in the water for the first 40 minutes of Game 1 of the Western Conference final against the Edmonton Oilers on Wednesday. But in the final 20 minutes, the Stars unleashed a five-goal barrage for a 6-3 win to take a 1-0 series lead.In the first two periods, the Oilers were clearly the better team, and they took a 3-1 lead into the final frame. Unfortunately for them, there was one period remaining, and it belonged to the Stars.Just 32 seconds into the third, Miro Heiskanen gave the Stars life with a power play goal from the point to make it a 3-2 game.That kicked off a parade to the penalty box for Edmonton, and Dallas took advantage. The Stars scored on three consecutive power plays with Mikael Granlund tying the game just […]
Caitlin Clark’s viral reaction captures wild Pacers comeback in Game 1 thriller
Caitlin Clark may be just starting her professional career with the Indiana Fever, but she's already become an invested figure in the state's wider sports scene. On Wednesday night, as the Indiana Pacers stunned the New York Knicks in Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals, Clark couldn't help but share her excitement with fans on social media.The Pacers rallied from a late deficit to force overtime, eventually defeating the Knicks 138-135 in one of the most electrifying NBA postseason finishes of the year. Tyrese Haliburton dropped 31 points and 11 assists, and Aaron Nesmith erupted with 30 points, including eight three-pointers on nine attempts. Their clutch performance helped Indiana erase what appeared to be a sure Knicks victory, stunning the Madison Square Garden crowd.Indiana Pacers vs. New York Knicks - Game HighlightsClark, watching the madness unfold, posted a simple […]
Pacers’ shocking comeback over Knicks creates result that’s never been seen before in NBA playoffs
Getty Images If the New York Knicks' fourth-quarter collapse in Game 1 of the Eastern Conference finals was unbelievable that's probably because it was the first of its kind, dating back to the start of the play-by-play era in 1997.With 2:45 remaining in the fourth-quarter, just six seconds after Jalen Brunson knocked down a 3-point attempt, the Knicks led the Indiana Pacers by 14 points. That lead looked pretty safe, especially since teams in that exact scenario in playoff games were 994-0 in the play-by-play era.They are now 994-1. The Knicks could only watch as Aaron Nesmith sank four 3-pointers — and added a pair of free throws — in the final 2:04 of regulation. Things only got worse for New York when Tyrese Haliburton knocked down a circus shot to tie the game at the buzzer before hitting the […]
Charles Barkley calls on NBA, Pacers to let Tyrese Haliburton’s dad return to games after Giannis Antetokounmpo incident
At least in the eyes of Charles Barkley, John Haliburton has more than served his punishment.Barkley, after the Indiana Pacers’ overtime win against the New York Knicks in Game 1 of the Eastern Conference finals on Wednesday night, called on NBA commissioner Adam Silver to let John attend Games 3 and 4 of the series in Indianapolis.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementJohn, the father of Pacers star Tyrese Haliburton, hasn’t attended a Pacers game since his on-court confrontation with Milwaukee Bucks star Giannis Antetokounmpo in the first round of the playoffs.“Hey, my man paid his dues,” Barkley said on TNT. “He did something really, really stupid. But he’s been punished. I’m asking you and the Indiana Pacers to let Mr. Haliburton back in the building for Games 3 and 4. Listen, he paid his dues. It shouldn’t be indefinite. He’s been punished enough, he will […]
Related
Oilers out of their depth as Matt Duchene and Stars’ other scorers finally step up
DALLAS — Less than four minutes into the Western Conference final, Connor McDavid received a pass at center ice at full speed, blew through a Mikko Rantanen stick check and turned Esa Lindell inside out, going straight through the Dallas Stars, straight to their net and straight for their hearts.Jake Oettinger made the save, but it was clear right away in Game 1 that McDavid was rested, raring to go and in rare form — a half-step quicker than usual, if that’s even possible. So was Leon Draisaitl, who commanded the puck whenever he was on the ice and was dangerous every time he got it.AdvertisementMan, the Edmonton Oilers were flying in this one, and the Stars looked, well, star-struck.“It’s definitely a different game than the last series,” Dallas coach Pete DeBoer said.The Stars don’t have a Connor McDavid. Or […]
Connections: Sports Edition hints for May 22, 2025, puzzle No. 241
This season, the teams who never win have won – and football is better for it Spurs waited 17 years, Newcastle 70 and Crystal Palace had never won a trophy - surely that is better than 'Big Six' dominance?
Stars vs. Oilers scores, schedule, odds, where to watch as Dallas rallies for come-from-behind Game 1 win
Getty Images The Dallas Stars looked dead in the water for the first 40 minutes of Game 1 of the Western Conference final against the Edmonton Oilers on Wednesday. But in the final 20 minutes, the Stars unleashed a five-goal barrage for a 6-3 win to take a 1-0 series lead.In the first two periods, the Oilers were clearly the better team, and they took a 3-1 lead into the final frame. Unfortunately for them, there was one period remaining, and it belonged to the Stars.Just 32 seconds into the third, Miro Heiskanen gave the Stars life with a power play goal from the point to make it a 3-2 game.That kicked off a parade to the penalty box for Edmonton, and Dallas took advantage. The Stars scored on three consecutive power plays with Mikael Granlund tying the game just […]
Caitlin Clark’s viral reaction captures wild Pacers comeback in Game 1 thriller
Caitlin Clark may be just starting her professional career with the Indiana Fever, but she's already become an invested figure in the state's wider sports scene. On Wednesday night, as the Indiana Pacers stunned the New York Knicks in Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals, Clark couldn't help but share her excitement with fans on social media.The Pacers rallied from a late deficit to force overtime, eventually defeating the Knicks 138-135 in one of the most electrifying NBA postseason finishes of the year. Tyrese Haliburton dropped 31 points and 11 assists, and Aaron Nesmith erupted with 30 points, including eight three-pointers on nine attempts. Their clutch performance helped Indiana erase what appeared to be a sure Knicks victory, stunning the Madison Square Garden crowd.Indiana Pacers vs. New York Knicks - Game HighlightsClark, watching the madness unfold, posted a simple […]
Pacers’ shocking comeback over Knicks creates result that’s never been seen before in NBA playoffs
Getty Images If the New York Knicks' fourth-quarter collapse in Game 1 of the Eastern Conference finals was unbelievable that's probably because it was the first of its kind, dating back to the start of the play-by-play era in 1997.With 2:45 remaining in the fourth-quarter, just six seconds after Jalen Brunson knocked down a 3-point attempt, the Knicks led the Indiana Pacers by 14 points. That lead looked pretty safe, especially since teams in that exact scenario in playoff games were 994-0 in the play-by-play era.They are now 994-1. The Knicks could only watch as Aaron Nesmith sank four 3-pointers — and added a pair of free throws — in the final 2:04 of regulation. Things only got worse for New York when Tyrese Haliburton knocked down a circus shot to tie the game at the buzzer before hitting the […]
Charles Barkley calls on NBA, Pacers to let Tyrese Haliburton’s dad return to games after Giannis Antetokounmpo incident
At least in the eyes of Charles Barkley, John Haliburton has more than served his punishment.Barkley, after the Indiana Pacers’ overtime win against the New York Knicks in Game 1 of the Eastern Conference finals on Wednesday night, called on NBA commissioner Adam Silver to let John attend Games 3 and 4 of the series in Indianapolis.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementJohn, the father of Pacers star Tyrese Haliburton, hasn’t attended a Pacers game since his on-court confrontation with Milwaukee Bucks star Giannis Antetokounmpo in the first round of the playoffs.“Hey, my man paid his dues,” Barkley said on TNT. “He did something really, really stupid. But he’s been punished. I’m asking you and the Indiana Pacers to let Mr. Haliburton back in the building for Games 3 and 4. Listen, he paid his dues. It shouldn’t be indefinite. He’s been punished enough, he will […]
Be the first to leave a comment