Few living personalities embody football’s old school more than Nick Saban.
So when the greatest coach of all time publicly endorses a dramatic change to the game’s traditions, it isn’t a knee-jerk reaction.
Saban gave his approval for College Football Playoff expansion this week. The seven-time national championship winner — three of which came in the initial four-team Playoff format — pivoted from his previous stance. He was staunchly against postseason expansion.
However, with the field moving to 12 teams a season ago and further reformatting approved on Thursday, Saban’s comments marked a high-profile embrace of the inevitable. The Playoff will expand, so we might as well adopt the best possible solution.
College football power brokers Fox and ESPN — excuse me, the Big Ten and SEC — support a restructuring that guarantees them four bids each. Meanwhile, the Big 12 and ACC would receive two guaranteed spots apiece.
The proposal is farcical and serves as a safety net for two leagues that have already shaped the sport’s landscape in their favor. What’s more, it’s needlessly convoluted when other levels of college football offer postseason blueprints that are proven successful, expand access for more participants and still reward the “best” conferences.
Adopting the core format concepts from the Football Championship Subdivision or NCAA Division II postseason makes for a more straightforward College Football Playoff than either the existing or proposed systems.
Each format has its advantages when applied to the FBS, though both come with the caveat that conference championship games would no longer be necessary.
FCS Format
Launched in 1978 upon the split of NCAA Division I into two subdivisions, the former Division I-AA/FCS Playoffs quickly expanded from four participants at inception to 16 by 1986. The tournament remained at 16 teams for 24 years before briefly growing to 20, then settling at its current total of 24 in 2013.
The current iteration invites every FCS conference champion except the Ivy League, SWAC and — since the 2016 launch of the Celebration Bowl — the MEAC. Ten automatic bids leave 14 at-large berths, most of which are occupied by the powerhouse Big Sky and Missouri Valley Football conferences.
That format should appeal to the Big Ten and SEC, offering a trade-off in exchange for opening spots to every FBS conference champion. Based on league standings and Playoff committee rankings prior to conference championship games, a 2024 College Football Playoff using the FCS format might have looked as follows:
Automatic Bids
American: Army
ACC: SMU
Big 12: Arizona State
Big Ten: Oregon
Conference USA: Jacksonville State
MAC: Miami (Ohio)
Mountain West: Boise State
SEC: Texas
Sun Belt: Marshall
At-Large Bids
ACC: Miami, Clemson
Big 12: Iowa State, BYU
Big Ten: Penn State, Ohio State, Indiana
Independent: Notre Dame
Mountain West: UNLV
SEC: Georgia, Tennessee, Ole Miss, Alabama, South Carolina, Missouri
Bracket
First-Round Byes
Oregon
Texas
Penn State
Notre Dame
Georgia
Ohio State
Tennessee
SMU
First-Round Matchups
Jacksonville State at No. 9 Indiana
Miami (Ohio) at No. 10 Boise State
Marshall at No. 11 Alabama
Army at No. 12 Miami
Missouri* at No. 13 Ole Miss
UNLV* at No. 14 South Carolina
Clemson* at No. 15 Arizona State
BYU at No. 16 Iowa State
*The selection committee avoids regular-season rematches in the opening round, so Missouri and Clemson — both of whom faced South Carolina — require reseeding. Mizzou–Ole Miss and BYU–Iowa State are both conference matchups, but the teams did not meet in the regular season.
Division II Format
Participation in the NCAA Division II Playoffs fluctuates more regularly than in the FCS tournament. For the sake of this exercise, let’s use the 2024 season, in which 28 teams qualified.
The Division II playoff bracket is somewhat comparable to March Madness in that it features definitive regions — or Super Regions. While in the basketball tournament a region refers to a host location, the Division II Playoffs use geographic clusters to form their regions.
That’s easier to accomplish in Division II, where conferences tend to have actual geographic footprints. Applied to the FBS, splitting conference representation across regions could be beneficial. The example below from this past season demonstrates how the Big Ten and SEC could each occupy the No. 1 seeds in different Super Regions and thus receive first-round byes.
Conference titles do not guarantee entry into the Division II Playoffs; instead, teams are invited based on rankings. The following uses the same approach.
East
No. 1 Penn State
Louisville at No. 2 Notre Dame
Army at No. 3 Ohio State
Syracuse at No. 4 Indiana
Central
No. 1 Texas
Texas A&M at No. 2 SMU
Illinois at No. 3 Ole Miss
Missouri at No. 4 Iowa State
South
No. 1 Georgia
Memphis at No. 2 Tennessee
Clemson at No. 3 Alabama
South Carolina at No. 4 Miami
West
No. 1 Oregon
Washington State at No. 2 Boise State
Colorado at No. 3 Arizona State
UNLV at No. 4 BYU
Following the templates that already exist within the sport provides the College Football Playoff with sensible solutions for its inevitable expansion. Borrowing from the established roadmaps of the game’s lower levels honors tradition while introducing a clear-cut method of deciding the national championship on the field.
It’s a strategy that perhaps even the most old-school football mind — like Nick Saban — can appreciate.
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
Pollock targets becoming European champion and then Test Lion
Henry Pollock speaks to Sky Sports ahead of Saturday's Champions Cup final in Cardiff, revealing his eyes are fixed on becoming a European champion and then a Test British and Irish Lion.Still aged just 20, the brash but supremely talented back-row has had a remarkable breakout season. He only became a regular starter for Northampton in October, was still playing for the England U20s during the Six Nations and made his senior England debut off the bench against Wales in March - his only cap to date.And yet, has a player so lacking in experience ever been more of a sure thing as far as a British and Irish Lions call-up goes? On Saturday May 3, Pollard faced three of the best back-row players in the world in Dublin in Josh van der Flier, Jack Conan and Caelan Doris as […]
Pacers vs. Knicks, Game 2: New York’s big problem? Its starters continue to be no match for Indiana
NEW YORK — If you find yourself in a hole, you should probably stop digging.The New York Knicks are in the Eastern Conference finals for the first time since 2000. They won 51 games this season — the most any Knicks team has won since 2011-12. They’ve won 50-plus in consecutive seasons for the first time since the 1993-94 and 1994-95 campaigns. On Friday, point guard Jalen Brunson and center Karl-Anthony Towns were both named to the All-NBA team — just the fifth time in franchise history two Knicks earned selection in the same year.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementThis has been, by virtually any measuring stick, the franchise’s best season in a quarter-century. The Knicks have gotten this far. Might as well stick with what got you here, right?Well, about that:The Knicks’ starting five — Brunson, Towns, Mikal Bridges, OG Anunoby and Josh Hart […]
Pacers vs. Knicks, Game 2: New York starters continue to be no match for Indiana’s first five
NEW YORK — If you find yourself in a hole, you should probably stop digging.The New York Knicks are in the Eastern Conference finals for the first time since 2000. They won 51 games this season — the most any Knicks team has won since 2011-12. They’ve won 50-plus in consecutive seasons for the first time since the 1993-94 and 1994-95 campaigns. On Friday, point guard Jalen Brunson and center Karl-Anthony Towns were both named to the All-NBA team — just the fifth time in franchise history that two Knicks earned selection in the same year.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementThis has been, by virtually any measuring stick, the franchise’s best season in a quarter-century. The Knicks have gotten this far. Might as well stick with what got you here, right?Well, about that:The Knicks’ starting five — Brunson, Towns, Mikal Bridges, OG Anunoby and Josh […]
Dodgers begin grueling stretch with soggy marathon win over Mets despite undermanned pitching staff
NEW YORK — On Friday night, the Dodgers emerged victorious, technically speaking. The defending champions outlasted the Mets 7-5 in an ugly, delirious, rain-soaked, 13-inning slopfest. The game started at 7:10 p.m. ET. It ended just before 1 a.m.There will be bleary-eyed ballplayers on Saturday.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementEven though L.A. won the battle, the night that would not end has created something of a conundrum. Ahead of the Dodgers: a grueling month-long stretch, 26 consecutive games against teams with winning records. To commence that imposing slice of the schedule, this club would have loved a simple, painless opening act. One that might have allowed its overtaxed pitching staff a breather.That’s not what happened.Instead, a combo of rain and extra innings forced Dodgers skipper Dave Roberts to use nearly every arm in his already exhausted bullpen. It was a pyrrhic victory of epic proportions.When […]
Oilers ‘punch back’ with strong Game 2 — and with Stuart Skinner back in shutout form
DALLAS — Once is a coincidence; twice is a pattern. And that pattern is starting to look like a good omen for the Edmonton Oilers and their Stanley Cup chances.For the second time in these playoffs, the Oilers followed up a crushing loss with a convincing win. The latest one was Game 2 on Friday, when they beat the Dallas Stars 3-0 to even the Western Conference final at 1-1, with Game 3 on Sunday in Edmonton.Advertisement“That’s the playoffs. You have to be able to punch back,” Oilers winger Zach Hyman said. “We recognize how important each game is, but especially after a loss. You have to come out strong and earn a split, and we were able to do it.”The Oilers’ response came after they dropped the series opener 6-3 on Wednesday, when they allowed five unanswered goals in […]
Why Knicks went away from Karl-Anthony Towns in Game 2 when ‘searching for a win’
NEW YORK — In a crucial, nearly seven-minute stretch of the fourth quarter, with the New York Knicks trailing the Indiana Pacers and desperately needing to score, Karl-Anthony Towns was on the bench.Just a couple of hours before that, the Knicks’ big man was named to the All-NBA third team, voted on by 100 media members who cover the league, for averaging 24.4 points, grabbing a career-high 12.8 rebounds and shooting a career-best 42.0 percent from 3 during the regular season.AdvertisementThough both true, these two pieces of Towns’ Friday evening don’t match. A player that good just shouldn’t be on the bench for that long near the end of such an important game.And yet, there was Towns, a five-time All-Star (including this season), subbing out with nine minutes left and the Knicks trailing by 9 to the Pacers. He did […]
Related
Pollock targets becoming European champion and then Test Lion
Henry Pollock speaks to Sky Sports ahead of Saturday's Champions Cup final in Cardiff, revealing his eyes are fixed on becoming a European champion and then a Test British and Irish Lion.Still aged just 20, the brash but supremely talented back-row has had a remarkable breakout season. He only became a regular starter for Northampton in October, was still playing for the England U20s during the Six Nations and made his senior England debut off the bench against Wales in March - his only cap to date.And yet, has a player so lacking in experience ever been more of a sure thing as far as a British and Irish Lions call-up goes? On Saturday May 3, Pollard faced three of the best back-row players in the world in Dublin in Josh van der Flier, Jack Conan and Caelan Doris as […]
Pacers vs. Knicks, Game 2: New York starters continue to be no match for Indiana’s first five
NEW YORK — If you find yourself in a hole, you should probably stop digging.The New York Knicks are in the Eastern Conference finals for the first time since 2000. They won 51 games this season — the most any Knicks team has won since 2011-12. They’ve won 50-plus in consecutive seasons for the first time since the 1993-94 and 1994-95 campaigns. On Friday, point guard Jalen Brunson and center Karl-Anthony Towns were both named to the All-NBA team — just the fifth time in franchise history that two Knicks earned selection in the same year.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementThis has been, by virtually any measuring stick, the franchise’s best season in a quarter-century. The Knicks have gotten this far. Might as well stick with what got you here, right?Well, about that:The Knicks’ starting five — Brunson, Towns, Mikal Bridges, OG Anunoby and Josh […]
Pacers vs. Knicks, Game 2: New York’s big problem? Its starters continue to be no match for Indiana
NEW YORK — If you find yourself in a hole, you should probably stop digging.The New York Knicks are in the Eastern Conference finals for the first time since 2000. They won 51 games this season — the most any Knicks team has won since 2011-12. They’ve won 50-plus in consecutive seasons for the first time since the 1993-94 and 1994-95 campaigns. On Friday, point guard Jalen Brunson and center Karl-Anthony Towns were both named to the All-NBA team — just the fifth time in franchise history two Knicks earned selection in the same year.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementThis has been, by virtually any measuring stick, the franchise’s best season in a quarter-century. The Knicks have gotten this far. Might as well stick with what got you here, right?Well, about that:The Knicks’ starting five — Brunson, Towns, Mikal Bridges, OG Anunoby and Josh Hart […]
Dodgers begin grueling stretch with soggy marathon win over Mets despite undermanned pitching staff
NEW YORK — On Friday night, the Dodgers emerged victorious, technically speaking. The defending champions outlasted the Mets 7-5 in an ugly, delirious, rain-soaked, 13-inning slopfest. The game started at 7:10 p.m. ET. It ended just before 1 a.m.There will be bleary-eyed ballplayers on Saturday.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementEven though L.A. won the battle, the night that would not end has created something of a conundrum. Ahead of the Dodgers: a grueling month-long stretch, 26 consecutive games against teams with winning records. To commence that imposing slice of the schedule, this club would have loved a simple, painless opening act. One that might have allowed its overtaxed pitching staff a breather.That’s not what happened.Instead, a combo of rain and extra innings forced Dodgers skipper Dave Roberts to use nearly every arm in his already exhausted bullpen. It was a pyrrhic victory of epic proportions.When […]
Oilers ‘punch back’ with strong Game 2 — and with Stuart Skinner back in shutout form
DALLAS — Once is a coincidence; twice is a pattern. And that pattern is starting to look like a good omen for the Edmonton Oilers and their Stanley Cup chances.For the second time in these playoffs, the Oilers followed up a crushing loss with a convincing win. The latest one was Game 2 on Friday, when they beat the Dallas Stars 3-0 to even the Western Conference final at 1-1, with Game 3 on Sunday in Edmonton.Advertisement“That’s the playoffs. You have to be able to punch back,” Oilers winger Zach Hyman said. “We recognize how important each game is, but especially after a loss. You have to come out strong and earn a split, and we were able to do it.”The Oilers’ response came after they dropped the series opener 6-3 on Wednesday, when they allowed five unanswered goals in […]
Why Knicks went away from Karl-Anthony Towns in Game 2 when ‘searching for a win’
NEW YORK — In a crucial, nearly seven-minute stretch of the fourth quarter, with the New York Knicks trailing the Indiana Pacers and desperately needing to score, Karl-Anthony Towns was on the bench.Just a couple of hours before that, the Knicks’ big man was named to the All-NBA third team, voted on by 100 media members who cover the league, for averaging 24.4 points, grabbing a career-high 12.8 rebounds and shooting a career-best 42.0 percent from 3 during the regular season.AdvertisementThough both true, these two pieces of Towns’ Friday evening don’t match. A player that good just shouldn’t be on the bench for that long near the end of such an important game.And yet, there was Towns, a five-time All-Star (including this season), subbing out with nine minutes left and the Knicks trailing by 9 to the Pacers. He did […]
Be the first to leave a comment