In Behind the Whistle, former Premier League referee Chris Foy goes through a selection of key match decisions from the latest action in the Sky Bet Championship, League One and League Two.
Behind the Whistle aims to give supporters of EFL clubs an insight into the decision-making considerations and also clarification of certain calls to provide an understanding of how the laws of the game are interpreted.
As part of a regular feature on Sky Sports following the conclusion of a matchday, Foy will be here to run you through some refereeing matters in the EFL…
Sky Bet Championship
Norwich City 1-0 West Bromwich Albion
West Brom’s Mason Holgate saw a goal disallowed for offside from a corner against Norwich
Incident – Goal scored, possible offside (West Bromwich Albion)
Decision – Goal disallowed, offside (West Bromwich Albion)
Foy says: “This situation is well read by the assistant referee, as he correctly identifies that West Bromwich Albion No3 is in an offside position as the ball is headed by his team-mate and then becomes involved in active play.
“This type of incident can be difficult for the assistant referee to judge, as the attacking player is moving back towards the edge of the penalty area, whilst the defending players are moving in the opposite direction towards the goal, creating a cross-over.
“This highlights the importance of focus and awareness, with the cross-over happening. As you can see from the replay alongside the 18 yard-box, No3 doesn’t quite get back onside in time, and therefore the flag is correctly raised.”
Should Sunderland’s Wilson Isidor have seen red against Millwall during their Championship clash?
Incident – Possible red card, serious foul play (Sunderland)
Decision – Caution offence (Sunderland)
Foy says: “I think the action of Sunderland’s No18 here is reckless and the referee correctly judges the situation by only showing him a yellow card.
“Following a heavy touch, the Sunderland No18 commits to a tackle and follow through contact is made with the Millwall No52 who also attempts to play the ball.
“Whilst Sunderland No18 does get a touch on the ball, the challenge disregards the consequence to his opponent who he should see approaching, and the referee does well to correctly identify that the challenge lacks the excessive force and high degree of danger that would be required for a red card for serious foul play. A yellow card is therefore the correct outcome.”
Sky Bet League One
Blackpool 2-1 Bolton Wanderers
The referee initially gave Aaron Morley a yellow card before speaking to his team and decided to change his decision to a red card, was this the correct decision
Incident – Possible red card, denying a goal or an obvious goal-scoring opportunity (Bolton Wanderers)
Decision – Red card, denying a goal or an obvious goal-scoring opportunity (Bolton Wanderers)
Foy says: “This clip is an interesting one as it highlights the importance of communication between officials to ensure that they are aware of all the key facts in order to provide the best chance of arriving at the correct outcome.
“As Blackpool No14 is moving directly towards the Bolton goal, he is cynically pulled back by Bolton No16. The referee gives the free kick and shows a yellow card for stopping a promising attack.
“However, what was not initially recognised by the referee was that the Bolton goalkeeper was not in his penalty area, but in the midfield returning back towards his goal from a corner kick at the other end of the field. After consulting with his team, the referee rescinds the yellow card and shows a direct red card.
“As the goalkeeper was absent from his goal, the holding offence on the Blackpool No14 was a denial of an obvious goalscoring opportunity. The correct outcome is reached following the additional information being provided to the referee.”
Birmingham City 4-1 Shrewsbury Town
Shrewsbury defender appeared to hold the Birmingham player for a long period of time before pulling him down in the box, but the referee did not award a penalty
Incident – Possible penalty, sustained holding (Birmingham City)
Decision – No penalty (Birmingham City)
Foy says: “For me, Shrewsbury Town’s No2 should have been penalised and conceded a penalty here, as he has hold of Birmingham City’s captain for a sustained period of time.
“The replay confirms that the Shrewsbury defender has no eyes on the ball and pulls his opponent to the ground with a sustained and impactful non-footballing action, preventing the Birmingham player from reaching the ball as it drops into his location. A penalty kick should therefore have been awarded to Birmingham.”
Sky Bet League Two
The Swindon defender appeared to arrive at pace and committed to the sliding tackle however the referee chose to award a goal kick instead
Incident – Possible penalty, foul (Morecambe)
Decision – No penalty (Morecambe)
Foy says: “The referee has three different options here and for me he chooses correctly by giving Swindon Town a goal-kick.
“As Morecambe’s No4 drives into the box, Swindon No20 inherits the risk by committing to a sliding challenge, however, whilst there is contact between the two players, the referee recognises the touch of the ball to the left by the Morecambe No4, without changing his path of movement, and considers it to have created contact. Although the Swindon defender arrives at pace, he pulls his leg away at the last moment and any contact made is by Morecambe No4 on Swindon Town No20.
“Whilst a subjective call, I think the referee selects the best option of awarding a goal-kick.”
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
Emotivní závěr El Clásica. Tři červené karty pro Real, na rozhodčího letěly sáčky s ledem
Barcelona vstoupila do finále aktivněji a odměnou jí byla vedoucí branka v 28. minutě. Pedri se po kombinaci s Lamine Yamalem dostal k míči na hranici vápna a tvrdou střelou překonal brankáře Courtoise.Real Madrid dlouho hledal cestu k vyrovnání, ale po přestávce zabral. V 70. minutě Kylian Mbappé nádherně zakroutil míč z přímého kopu a srovnal skóre. O chvíli později využil Aurélien Tchouaméni rohový kop a hlavou dokonal obrat Realu.Barcelona však nesložila zbraně. V 84. minutě se po rychlém protiútoku trefil Ferran Torres a vrátil zápasu nerozhodný stav. Drama poprvé vrcholilo už v samotném závěru základní hrací doby, kdy byla Barceloně nařízena penalta po pádu Raphinhy. Zásah VAR rozhodnutí zvrátil kvůli simulaci, brazilská hvězda za svůj letargický pád viděla žlutou kartu. O vítězi tak muselo rozhodnout prodloužení.Rozuzlení zápletky přišlo až ve 116. minutě. Obránce Jules Koundé vystihl špatnou rozehrávku Realu a pohotovou střelou zpoza vápna překonal Courtoise. Barcelona si těsný náskok pohlídala a mohla slavit. Napětí na hřišti i na lavičce Realu […]
Wieder Skandal um DFB-Star – Übler Rüdiger-Ausraster im Clasico!
Wieder einmal brennen bei Antonio Rüdiger alle Sicherungen durch – dieses Mal im Clasico gegen Real Madrid.Es passiert in der Nachspielzeit der Verlängerung – kurz nach dem entscheidenden 2:3. Ausraster auf der Bank. Mittendrin: Antonio Rüdiger!Schiedsrichter Ricardo de Burgos Bengoetxea (39) pfeift ein vermeintliches Stürmer-Foul von Kylian Mbappé (26) an Eric García (24). Sehr zum Unmut der Real-Stars.Was für eine Szene!: Rüdiger-Ausraster bei Clasico-Spektakel<!-->[-->Quelle: Sportdigital27.04.2025Vor allem Rüdiger ist kaum noch zu halten! Der Abwehrspieler war in der 111. Minute ausgewechselt worden, hält sich Eisbeutel an die Knie. Nach dem Pfiff springt er auf – und wirft etwas aufs Spielfeld. In Richtung des Schiedsrichters! Er trifft ihn nicht, aber es gibt die Rote Karte.Der gebürtigen Berliner muss von drei Betreuern und Mitspielern zurückgehalten werden – sieht so aus, als wäre er sonst aufs Feld gestürmt. Dann wirft Rüdiger mit deutschen Beleidigungen wie „Hurensohn“ […]
How overly-cautious Aston Villa wasted an opportunity to reach the FA Cup final
The cameras lingered on crestfallen Aston Villa faces.One half of Wembley was despondent and increasingly empty. Supporters were leaving early and, such were the queues for the exits, many had their backs turned as Ismaila Sarr’s second goal — Crystal Palace’s third — went in.Any suckers for punishment who decided to glance over their shoulder would have seen a portrait of starkly different emotions. At the far end, Palace fans were a vibrant shade of red and blue, flags waving and people bouncing. Look closer and Villa’s players appeared pale and colourless as the realisation of a spurned opportunity set in.AdvertisementFew Villa fans hung around for full-time. Players tentatively approached those that did, a reflection of the passive nature of how they played, as Palace’s ‘Glad All Over’ anthem reverberated around Wembley. The internal mood was so despondent that Villa’s social […]
STJ barra novo recurso da Fifa em disputa contra empresa brasileira sobre ‘spray de barreira’
O Superior Tribunal de Justiça (STJ) negou seguimento ao recurso extraordinário apresentado pela Fifa, no caso envolvendo a acusação de violação de patente e quebra de boa-fé objetiva nas tratativas com a empresa brasileira Spuni Comércio de Produtos Esportivos e Marketing Ltda. O recurso tentava levar a discussão ao Supremo Tribunal Federal (STF), sob a alegação de ofensa a preceitos constitucionais, o que foi rejeitado. Trata-se de mais um capítulo da disputa pelos direitos sobre o spray evanescente — usado para demarcar a distância da barreira em cobranças de falta — desenvolvido pela Spuni e que, segundo a empresa, foi indevidamente utilizado pela Fifa após tratativas negociais frustradas. A decisão que negou seguimento ao recurso foi assinada no dia 20 de abril pelo vice-presidente do STJ, ministro Luis Felipe Salomão. Segundo ele, a Corte reconheceu que a FIFA agiu em […]
David Moyes knows what he wants at Everton next season: A ruthless streak
Not for the first time, David Moyes had his head in his hands.The source of his frustration on this occasion was midfielder James Garner, who with time ticking away and Everton 1-0 down at Chelsea, had just sent a late corner straight into Robert Sanchez’s arms.Moyes was witnessing a familiar failing come back to haunt Everton. He places great stock in set pieces but has bemoaned his side’s poor delivery and execution already this season.AdvertisementOn Saturday, that absence of quality cost them a potential route back into the game as Chelsea teetered.In truth, Moyes had cut a frustrated figure throughout Saturday’s defeat.Sporting a baseball cap in the west London sun, he fumed early on at the fourth official after they took too long to punish some rough treatment on Beto close to the dugout. When Chelsea left-back Marc Cucurella complained, […]
Real e Barça têm mais dinheiro e poder do que os clubes brasileiros, mas também são capazes de cometer grandes erros
Não pude esperar o fim de Real Madrid x Barcelona, pela final da Copa do Rei da Espanha (o time catalão venceu na prorrogação), para escrever esta coluna. Mas também não pude fugir de falar desses dois rivais gigantes – tão distantes da realidade financeira do futebol brasileiro e tão próximos no aspecto cultural. Talvez por nunca terem aberto mão do modelo associativo, seus dirigentes ainda tomam decisões movidos pela paixão e se deixam influenciar pela opinião dos torcedores, muito mais do que uma SAF ou um clube com dono costuma fazer. O Barcelona é o pobre menino rico do futebol europeu. Há anos ouvimos falar da crise financeira em que o clube se meteu. Messi, Neymar e Suárez foram embora, e era fácil imaginar que sem eles se encerraria uma era de conquistas. Mas foi curiosa a forma como […]
Related
Emotivní závěr El Clásica. Tři červené karty pro Real, na rozhodčího letěly sáčky s ledem
Barcelona vstoupila do finále aktivněji a odměnou jí byla vedoucí branka v 28. minutě. Pedri se po kombinaci s Lamine Yamalem dostal k míči na hranici vápna a tvrdou střelou překonal brankáře Courtoise.Real Madrid dlouho hledal cestu k vyrovnání, ale po přestávce zabral. V 70. minutě Kylian Mbappé nádherně zakroutil míč z přímého kopu a srovnal skóre. O chvíli později využil Aurélien Tchouaméni rohový kop a hlavou dokonal obrat Realu.Barcelona však nesložila zbraně. V 84. minutě se po rychlém protiútoku trefil Ferran Torres a vrátil zápasu nerozhodný stav. Drama poprvé vrcholilo už v samotném závěru základní hrací doby, kdy byla Barceloně nařízena penalta po pádu Raphinhy. Zásah VAR rozhodnutí zvrátil kvůli simulaci, brazilská hvězda za svůj letargický pád viděla žlutou kartu. O vítězi tak muselo rozhodnout prodloužení.Rozuzlení zápletky přišlo až ve 116. minutě. Obránce Jules Koundé vystihl špatnou rozehrávku Realu a pohotovou střelou zpoza vápna překonal Courtoise. Barcelona si těsný náskok pohlídala a mohla slavit. Napětí na hřišti i na lavičce Realu […]
Wieder Skandal um DFB-Star – Übler Rüdiger-Ausraster im Clasico!
Wieder einmal brennen bei Antonio Rüdiger alle Sicherungen durch – dieses Mal im Clasico gegen Real Madrid.Es passiert in der Nachspielzeit der Verlängerung – kurz nach dem entscheidenden 2:3. Ausraster auf der Bank. Mittendrin: Antonio Rüdiger!Schiedsrichter Ricardo de Burgos Bengoetxea (39) pfeift ein vermeintliches Stürmer-Foul von Kylian Mbappé (26) an Eric García (24). Sehr zum Unmut der Real-Stars.Was für eine Szene!: Rüdiger-Ausraster bei Clasico-Spektakel<!-->[-->Quelle: Sportdigital27.04.2025Vor allem Rüdiger ist kaum noch zu halten! Der Abwehrspieler war in der 111. Minute ausgewechselt worden, hält sich Eisbeutel an die Knie. Nach dem Pfiff springt er auf – und wirft etwas aufs Spielfeld. In Richtung des Schiedsrichters! Er trifft ihn nicht, aber es gibt die Rote Karte.Der gebürtigen Berliner muss von drei Betreuern und Mitspielern zurückgehalten werden – sieht so aus, als wäre er sonst aufs Feld gestürmt. Dann wirft Rüdiger mit deutschen Beleidigungen wie „Hurensohn“ […]
How overly-cautious Aston Villa wasted an opportunity to reach the FA Cup final
The cameras lingered on crestfallen Aston Villa faces.One half of Wembley was despondent and increasingly empty. Supporters were leaving early and, such were the queues for the exits, many had their backs turned as Ismaila Sarr’s second goal — Crystal Palace’s third — went in.Any suckers for punishment who decided to glance over their shoulder would have seen a portrait of starkly different emotions. At the far end, Palace fans were a vibrant shade of red and blue, flags waving and people bouncing. Look closer and Villa’s players appeared pale and colourless as the realisation of a spurned opportunity set in.AdvertisementFew Villa fans hung around for full-time. Players tentatively approached those that did, a reflection of the passive nature of how they played, as Palace’s ‘Glad All Over’ anthem reverberated around Wembley. The internal mood was so despondent that Villa’s social […]
STJ barra novo recurso da Fifa em disputa contra empresa brasileira sobre ‘spray de barreira’
O Superior Tribunal de Justiça (STJ) negou seguimento ao recurso extraordinário apresentado pela Fifa, no caso envolvendo a acusação de violação de patente e quebra de boa-fé objetiva nas tratativas com a empresa brasileira Spuni Comércio de Produtos Esportivos e Marketing Ltda. O recurso tentava levar a discussão ao Supremo Tribunal Federal (STF), sob a alegação de ofensa a preceitos constitucionais, o que foi rejeitado. Trata-se de mais um capítulo da disputa pelos direitos sobre o spray evanescente — usado para demarcar a distância da barreira em cobranças de falta — desenvolvido pela Spuni e que, segundo a empresa, foi indevidamente utilizado pela Fifa após tratativas negociais frustradas. A decisão que negou seguimento ao recurso foi assinada no dia 20 de abril pelo vice-presidente do STJ, ministro Luis Felipe Salomão. Segundo ele, a Corte reconheceu que a FIFA agiu em […]
David Moyes knows what he wants at Everton next season: A ruthless streak
Not for the first time, David Moyes had his head in his hands.The source of his frustration on this occasion was midfielder James Garner, who with time ticking away and Everton 1-0 down at Chelsea, had just sent a late corner straight into Robert Sanchez’s arms.Moyes was witnessing a familiar failing come back to haunt Everton. He places great stock in set pieces but has bemoaned his side’s poor delivery and execution already this season.AdvertisementOn Saturday, that absence of quality cost them a potential route back into the game as Chelsea teetered.In truth, Moyes had cut a frustrated figure throughout Saturday’s defeat.Sporting a baseball cap in the west London sun, he fumed early on at the fourth official after they took too long to punish some rough treatment on Beto close to the dugout. When Chelsea left-back Marc Cucurella complained, […]
Real e Barça têm mais dinheiro e poder do que os clubes brasileiros, mas também são capazes de cometer grandes erros
Não pude esperar o fim de Real Madrid x Barcelona, pela final da Copa do Rei da Espanha (o time catalão venceu na prorrogação), para escrever esta coluna. Mas também não pude fugir de falar desses dois rivais gigantes – tão distantes da realidade financeira do futebol brasileiro e tão próximos no aspecto cultural. Talvez por nunca terem aberto mão do modelo associativo, seus dirigentes ainda tomam decisões movidos pela paixão e se deixam influenciar pela opinião dos torcedores, muito mais do que uma SAF ou um clube com dono costuma fazer. O Barcelona é o pobre menino rico do futebol europeu. Há anos ouvimos falar da crise financeira em que o clube se meteu. Messi, Neymar e Suárez foram embora, e era fácil imaginar que sem eles se encerraria uma era de conquistas. Mas foi curiosa a forma como […]
Be the first to leave a comment