Last week, as NFL teams were preparing to head to Palm Beach, Florida, for the league’s annual spring owners meetings, an AFC executive shared his vantage on different rules proposals expected to head to a vote. One in particular had his attention — much like the rest of the NFL — and also his venom: The potential banning of the quarterback sneak known as the “tush push.”
“There’s nothing to support making it an issue worth a vote,” the executive said. “If it’s safety, things that might happen is not really going to [carry a vote]. We shouldn’t change rules to get away from injuries that aren’t actually happening. … This is a proposal because some people are pissed that the offense has an advantage over the defense and the [Philadelphia] Eagles just run it better — different offensive linemen, different coordinators, they just keep going. Now it’s suddenly an injury concern, even though the data shows it isn’t?”
Advertisement
“Imagine if that’s how the NFL worked,” he continued. “If some of these guys were running things around the [Johnny] Unitas years, we’d be voting on [banning] the forward pass.”
It was a hyperbolic jab at the Green Bay Packers and team prudent Mark Murphy, who many believe to be the root source of the Packers’ proposal to effectively ban the tush push. But it’s also a moment that showcases the disdain for changing a rule without data to support it.
Bills head coach Sean McDermott doesn’t sound like he’s a fan of shoving Josh Allen toward first downs. (Photo by Harry How/Getty Images)
(Harry How via Getty Images)
That debate continued in full view Monday, when AFC head coaches met with the media and Buffalo Bills head coach Sean McDermott — whose team runs a version of the tush push but also supports a ban — cast the proposal as being proactive. His argument was that a lack of injuries doesn’t necessarily give an accurate picture in terms of the risks involved. The NFL’s chief medical officer, Allen Sills, is also wrapped up in the back and forth, becoming a key figure advising the league office on what he believes is a legitimate concern if the play remains in the game.
Advertisement
How could all of this play out in a vote Tuesday? Needing 24 of 32 team votes to approve the Packers’ proposal banning the play, there already appears to be a lean away from it. If nine teams vote against the measure, it fails. And as of Monday night, it appeared as many as 10 were against a ban, three were for it and three were on the fence.
How it breaks down …
Teams with a lean toward banning tush push (3)
Buffalo Bills: Head coach Sean McDermott framed a tush push ban as a “proactive” measure Monday, despite a lack of data showing the play results in a higher injury rate.
Dallas Cowboys: Team CEO and co-owner Stephen Jones has come out in favor of banning the play, citing consistency when it comes to “leverage” plays. He noted that on field goals and extra points, linebackers aren’t allowed to create leverage against the offensive line by pushing the backs of their defensive linemen.
Advertisement
Green Bay Packers: The ban is Green Bay’s proposal on the table and team president Mark Murphy has been a strong proponent of getting the play out of the game. Head coach Matt LaFleur and general manager Brian Gutekunst seemed to want nothing to do with talking about it Monday, but Murphy has the steering wheel on this one.
Teams that appear to lean against banning tush push (10)
Baltimore Ravens: Head coach John Harbaugh said he believed the tush push qualified as a “football play” in what seemed to be a brushback of the criticism that it’s closer to a rugby scrum. He added that he’d be open to changing his mind on the play if healthy and safety concerns overrode it.
Advertisement
Cleveland Browns: Head coach Kevin Stefanski came out against a rule change and also said the Browns expect to use their own version of the tush push moving forward.
Detroit Lions: General manager Brad Holmes has indicated publicly the Lions are against banning the tush push.
Houston Texans: Head coach DeMeco Ryans suggested a ban would “punish” teams for being successful at executing a play.
Indianapolis Colts: A former offensive coordinator for the Eagles when the tush push was developed, Colts head coach Shane Steichen has said publicly he’s against banning the play.
New England Patriots: Head coach Mike Vrabel has said publicly he’s against banning the play.
Advertisement
New York Jets: Head coach Aaron Glenn has indicated publicly he’s against banning the play.
Philadelphia Eagles: It’s their bread-and-butter play on fourth-and-short and head coach Nick Sirianni is arguably the historical mastermind of the play’s existence. He has been strongly against banning the play and said so at every opportunity.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Head coach Todd Bowles has said publicly that it’s up to defensive coaches to figure out how to stop the play and that he has nothing against it.
Tennessee Titans: Head coach Brian Callahan said publicly that it’s a good play and doesn’t agree that it needs to be legislated out of football.
Advertisement
Teams sitting on the fence when it comes to a tush push ban (3)
Los Angeles Rams: We’ve gotten some conflicting feelings inside the Rams on the ban. General manager Les Snead told Yahoo Sports’ Jori Epstein that he doesn’t believe the injury data supports a ban. But head coach Sean McVay has come out and said two definitive things. First, that he doesn’t believe it looks like a “football play,” which is a common theme among critics of the tush push. Second, McVay said he doesn’t think the play should ever have been allowed into the league in the first place. It seems Snead doesn’t support banning the play, while McVay doesn’t support the play existing at all. The Rams go on the fence without a clear unified opinion.
Advertisement
Kansas City Chiefs: While agreeing the tush push could be banned if it’s putting a player into jeopardy from a health and safety standpoint, head coach Andy Reid also said both sides of the argument have merits.
Pittsburgh Steelers: Head coach Mike Tomlin said he’s keeping an open mind about the arguments for and against the play.
The league’s debate over the rule is expected to resume Tuesday morning with a potential vote — or tabling of the proposal — soon after.
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
Osm zápasů, tři trenéři. Vaclík o veletoči v novém klubu: Byl to extrém
Porto (od našeho zpravodaje) - Osmibodová ztráta na barážové místo je téměř pryč, Boavista stále může pomýšlet na udržení mezi elitou. V klubu z Porta lucemburského podnikatele Gérarda Lópeze je poslední měsíce ale rušno snad po všech stránkách. V zimě po odblokování přestupů dorazilo hned deset hráčů včetně Vaclíka právě s cílem se zachránit. V týdnu portugalská média informovala, že v areálu stadionu nešla kvůli dluhům elektrika. Zároveň od startu jarní části došlo k mnoha dalším personálním rošádám.Můžete krátce popsat, co všechno se v prvním týmu událo?Asi dva dny po mém příchodu skončil sportovní ředitel. Několikrát se změnil trenér gólmanů, na jedno utkání jsme dokonce žádného neměli. Co se týče hlavních koučů, skončil Lito Vidigal, který vedl tým jen šest utkání. Na dva zápasy to vzal Jorge Couto, tedy muž, který v Boavistě historicky pracoval. Následně byl angažován současný kouč Stuart Baxter. Takže tři hlavní a tři trenéři gólmanů za […]
Novak Djokovic’s tennis record made his ranking irrelevant, but he needs to care about it now
Novak Djokovic was as unequivocal as an athlete could be earlier this month, when he was asked what his goals were for the ongoing clay-court season.“Roland Garros,” he answered, referring to the French Open, in late May and early June, after losing his opening match in Monte Carlo, Monaco, to Alejandro Tabilo. “That’s it.”AdvertisementUnderstood. So what’s a player like that doing at a tournament like the Madrid Open?Sure, Madrid, which got underway this week, takes place on the red clay, just as the French Open does, but the similarities largely end there.The Spanish capital sits more than 2,000 feet above sea level, which allows the ball to fly and bounce during tennis matches in ways it won’t in Paris. The air is also dry, allowing the sun to bake the surface and make it behave more like a hard court […]
Welchem Klub er sich selbst anbietet – Spektakuläre Wende im Poker um Bayern-Flirt!
Alles schien klar mit Arsenal! Die Herausforderung der Premier League, die Chance auf Tore in der Königsklasse, große Titelhoffnungen – für Viktor Gyökeres (26) von Sporting Lissabon passte alles. Doch jetzt kommt es offenbar alles anders. Weil der Bayern-Flirt es offenbar so will!Obwohl die Gespräche mit den „Gunners“ bereits seit einiger Zeit laufen, hat sich der Schwede nun offenbar in den Kopf gesetzt, doch einem anderen Top-Verein den Vorzug zu geben. Seine Agenten sollen auf seinen „ausdrücklichen Wunsch“ Kontakt zu Real Madrid aufgenommen haben, um einen möglichen Wechsel zu besprechen, meldet „Defensa Central“.London oder doch lieber Madrid?Lesen Sie auch<!-->[-->Gyökeres hat sich in den letzten Jahren zu einem der besten Stürmer Europas entwickelt. 48 Tore und 12 Vorlagen in 47 Spielen in dieser Saison sprechen eine deutliche Sprache. Sporting-Trainer Rui Borges lobte ihn kürzlich als „außergewöhnlichen Stürmer“ und „besten der Liga“.Gyökeres will […]
NHL playoff picks, odds, schedule for Saturday’s Stanley Cup action including Stars-Avalanche
Saturday brings a quadruple header of Stanley Cup Playoffs action, including the first elimination game of the postseason. The Toronto Maple Leafs go for the sweep of the Ottawa Senators.In the first game of the day, the defending champion Florida Panthers go for a 3-0 lead after winning both games in Tampa. Plus, there are pivotal Game 4s in Minnesota and Colorado.AdvertisementViewing guide for Saturday GameTime (ET)TVStreamLightning at Panthers1 p.m.US: TBS, truTV, FDSN SunCanada: SportsnetGolden Knights at Wild4 p.m.US: TBS, truTV, FDSN NorthCanada: SportsnetMaple Leafs at Senators7 p.m.US: TBS, truTVCanada: Sportsnet, CBCMaxStars at Avalanche9:30 p.m.US: TBS, truTV, AltitudeCanada: Sportsnet All games on Saturday can be streamed on Max.Watching in person? Get tickets on StubHub.Tampa Bay Lightning at Florida PanthersPanthers lead series 2-0Series odds: Panthers -650, Lightning +475After the Panthers took Games 1 and 2 on the road, the biggest story […]
NASCAR Cup Series at Talladega odds, predictions: Team Penske favored but long shots shine at superspeedway
After the Easter break, the NASCAR Cup Series heads to party city Talladega this weekend for the Jack Link’s 500. Drivers will be looking for a dose of good luck at the superspeedway in their attempts to avoid the “Big One” and clinch a win. With an unbroken stretch of races from now until November, the unpredictability of Talladega could be exactly what a long-shot driver needs.AdvertisementAs always, we’re previewing the race and getting predictions from our NASCAR experts, Jeff Gluck and Jordan Bianchi. They’re answering our questions about the Cup Series’ upcoming schedule, All-Star race controversies, Rodney Childers’ future and who might cross the finish line first this weekend.Take it away, guys!How to watch the Jack Link’s 500 Track: Talladega Superspeedway — Lincoln, Ala. Time: Sunday, April 27, 3 p.m. ET TV: Fox Streaming: Fubo (try for free) NASCAR Cup Series […]
After spending big on defense in free agency, Colts continue to invest in revamped unit
INDIANAPOLIS — JT Tuimoloau knew he was in rare air. As a teenager at East Side Catholic High School in Seattle, his dream was to play in the NFL. But unlike most teenagers, his talent at the prep level put him in rooms few others his age could enter. Before the Indianapolis Colts selected Tuimoloau with the No. 45 pick in the 2025 NFL Draft on Friday night, the blueprint was laid before him years prior when he crossed paths with Seahawks legends Cliff Avril and Bobby Wagner — and an underdog still trying to prove himself at the highest level.AdvertisementThat underdog?Zaire Franklin, the Indianapolis Colts’ second-team All-Pro linebacker. But back then, he was a recent seventh-round pick training at Ford Sports Performance in Seattle with Avril and Wagner. Tuimoloau was there, too, having already soaked up a few years […]
Related
Osm zápasů, tři trenéři. Vaclík o veletoči v novém klubu: Byl to extrém
Porto (od našeho zpravodaje) - Osmibodová ztráta na barážové místo je téměř pryč, Boavista stále může pomýšlet na udržení mezi elitou. V klubu z Porta lucemburského podnikatele Gérarda Lópeze je poslední měsíce ale rušno snad po všech stránkách. V zimě po odblokování přestupů dorazilo hned deset hráčů včetně Vaclíka právě s cílem se zachránit. V týdnu portugalská média informovala, že v areálu stadionu nešla kvůli dluhům elektrika. Zároveň od startu jarní části došlo k mnoha dalším personálním rošádám.Můžete krátce popsat, co všechno se v prvním týmu událo?Asi dva dny po mém příchodu skončil sportovní ředitel. Několikrát se změnil trenér gólmanů, na jedno utkání jsme dokonce žádného neměli. Co se týče hlavních koučů, skončil Lito Vidigal, který vedl tým jen šest utkání. Na dva zápasy to vzal Jorge Couto, tedy muž, který v Boavistě historicky pracoval. Následně byl angažován současný kouč Stuart Baxter. Takže tři hlavní a tři trenéři gólmanů za […]
Novak Djokovic’s tennis record made his ranking irrelevant, but he needs to care about it now
Novak Djokovic was as unequivocal as an athlete could be earlier this month, when he was asked what his goals were for the ongoing clay-court season.“Roland Garros,” he answered, referring to the French Open, in late May and early June, after losing his opening match in Monte Carlo, Monaco, to Alejandro Tabilo. “That’s it.”AdvertisementUnderstood. So what’s a player like that doing at a tournament like the Madrid Open?Sure, Madrid, which got underway this week, takes place on the red clay, just as the French Open does, but the similarities largely end there.The Spanish capital sits more than 2,000 feet above sea level, which allows the ball to fly and bounce during tennis matches in ways it won’t in Paris. The air is also dry, allowing the sun to bake the surface and make it behave more like a hard court […]
Welchem Klub er sich selbst anbietet – Spektakuläre Wende im Poker um Bayern-Flirt!
Alles schien klar mit Arsenal! Die Herausforderung der Premier League, die Chance auf Tore in der Königsklasse, große Titelhoffnungen – für Viktor Gyökeres (26) von Sporting Lissabon passte alles. Doch jetzt kommt es offenbar alles anders. Weil der Bayern-Flirt es offenbar so will!Obwohl die Gespräche mit den „Gunners“ bereits seit einiger Zeit laufen, hat sich der Schwede nun offenbar in den Kopf gesetzt, doch einem anderen Top-Verein den Vorzug zu geben. Seine Agenten sollen auf seinen „ausdrücklichen Wunsch“ Kontakt zu Real Madrid aufgenommen haben, um einen möglichen Wechsel zu besprechen, meldet „Defensa Central“.London oder doch lieber Madrid?Lesen Sie auch<!-->[-->Gyökeres hat sich in den letzten Jahren zu einem der besten Stürmer Europas entwickelt. 48 Tore und 12 Vorlagen in 47 Spielen in dieser Saison sprechen eine deutliche Sprache. Sporting-Trainer Rui Borges lobte ihn kürzlich als „außergewöhnlichen Stürmer“ und „besten der Liga“.Gyökeres will […]
NHL playoff picks, odds, schedule for Saturday’s Stanley Cup action including Stars-Avalanche
Saturday brings a quadruple header of Stanley Cup Playoffs action, including the first elimination game of the postseason. The Toronto Maple Leafs go for the sweep of the Ottawa Senators.In the first game of the day, the defending champion Florida Panthers go for a 3-0 lead after winning both games in Tampa. Plus, there are pivotal Game 4s in Minnesota and Colorado.AdvertisementViewing guide for Saturday GameTime (ET)TVStreamLightning at Panthers1 p.m.US: TBS, truTV, FDSN SunCanada: SportsnetGolden Knights at Wild4 p.m.US: TBS, truTV, FDSN NorthCanada: SportsnetMaple Leafs at Senators7 p.m.US: TBS, truTVCanada: Sportsnet, CBCMaxStars at Avalanche9:30 p.m.US: TBS, truTV, AltitudeCanada: Sportsnet All games on Saturday can be streamed on Max.Watching in person? Get tickets on StubHub.Tampa Bay Lightning at Florida PanthersPanthers lead series 2-0Series odds: Panthers -650, Lightning +475After the Panthers took Games 1 and 2 on the road, the biggest story […]
NASCAR Cup Series at Talladega odds, predictions: Team Penske favored but long shots shine at superspeedway
After the Easter break, the NASCAR Cup Series heads to party city Talladega this weekend for the Jack Link’s 500. Drivers will be looking for a dose of good luck at the superspeedway in their attempts to avoid the “Big One” and clinch a win. With an unbroken stretch of races from now until November, the unpredictability of Talladega could be exactly what a long-shot driver needs.AdvertisementAs always, we’re previewing the race and getting predictions from our NASCAR experts, Jeff Gluck and Jordan Bianchi. They’re answering our questions about the Cup Series’ upcoming schedule, All-Star race controversies, Rodney Childers’ future and who might cross the finish line first this weekend.Take it away, guys!How to watch the Jack Link’s 500 Track: Talladega Superspeedway — Lincoln, Ala. Time: Sunday, April 27, 3 p.m. ET TV: Fox Streaming: Fubo (try for free) NASCAR Cup Series […]
After spending big on defense in free agency, Colts continue to invest in revamped unit
INDIANAPOLIS — JT Tuimoloau knew he was in rare air. As a teenager at East Side Catholic High School in Seattle, his dream was to play in the NFL. But unlike most teenagers, his talent at the prep level put him in rooms few others his age could enter. Before the Indianapolis Colts selected Tuimoloau with the No. 45 pick in the 2025 NFL Draft on Friday night, the blueprint was laid before him years prior when he crossed paths with Seahawks legends Cliff Avril and Bobby Wagner — and an underdog still trying to prove himself at the highest level.AdvertisementThat underdog?Zaire Franklin, the Indianapolis Colts’ second-team All-Pro linebacker. But back then, he was a recent seventh-round pick training at Ford Sports Performance in Seattle with Avril and Wagner. Tuimoloau was there, too, having already soaked up a few years […]
Be the first to leave a comment