(This article was written with the assistance of Castmagic, an AI tool, and reviewed by our editorial team to ensure accuracy. Please reach out to us if you notice any mistakes.)
On the latest episode of “Baseball Bar-B-Cast,” hosts Jake Mintz and Jordan Shusterman delved into the news of Garrett Crochet’s six-year, $170 million extension with the Boston Red Sox, a contract that raised some eyebrows given Crochet’s limited track record as a starting pitcher.
Advertisement
The extension, which comes just a few months after Crochet was traded from the Chicago White Sox, reflects Boston’s bet on Crochet’s potential to evolve into a top-tier ace, even given his somewhat spotty injury history and unconventional pitching trajectory.
Drafted in 2020, Crochet’s journey to the majors was fast-tracked due to the pandemic-canceled minor-league season that year, but then his emergence as a bullpen weapon was interrupted by Tommy John surgery. So when Crochet was named the White Sox’s Opening Day starter a year ago, the news shocked most of the baseball industry.
“At the time, on this very podcast, we laughed at that,” Mintz said.
Advertisement
Added Shusterman: “Everyone else was like, what are they thinking? What is going on?”
But then, as the hosts noted, Crochet was “simply marvelous” in his first year as a starter in 2024, arguably the lone bright spot on a historically horrible White Sox team. And once the deal with the Red Sox happened in December, it was clear that an extension between Crochet and Boston was the desired outcome on both sides.
However, as Shusterman pointed out, given Crochet’s injury history and single season as a starting pitcher, the details of an extension were probably tricky to figure out.
Advertisement
“This is betting on a small sample of what he did last year and the fact that he is only 26 years old, and even though he’s been in the big leagues now for half a decade, because he debuted immediately, we don’t really know what we’re getting,” he said. “And yet the Red Sox clearly believe in what they’re getting and were willing to commit a serious amount of money to a pitcher who has really only done it for one season.”
Added Mintz: “They’re betting on the package here. They’re betting on the traits, they’re betting on the fastball, they’re betting on the work ethic, they’re betting on the athleticism. They’re betting that it will continue to be difficult to acquire aces.”
The hosts also noted that the extension comes with significant financial nuances, including an opt-out clause after 2030, performance-based incentives and some injury contingencies, all of which underscore the team’s reservations about Crochet’s injury risks. On the flip side, Crochet’s short track record could be seen as a positive thing.
Advertisement
“You could also spin it that way and be like, listen, we’re getting him in his prime years, and he hasn’t really thrown that many innings in his early 20s,” Shusterman said. “So I have to imagine that was probably part of the calculus, too.”
Ultimately, no matter how this deal turns out, the fact that the Red Sox are spending on young players and emerging talent is a good thing.
“The Red Sox are spending. I think that’s what’s significant,” Mintz said. “I think there’s been frustration within the fan base … that they haven’t been willing to push the chips in. They’re doing that now.”
To listen to the full episode and more, tune in to “Baseball-Bar-B-Cast” on Apple, Spotify or YouTube.
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
Alejandro Kirk comes through for Blue Jays: ‘I needed it, the team needed it’
Editor’s note: We’re thrilled to introduce Mitch Bannon as our Blue Jays beat writer. A native of Toronto, he previously covered the team for SI.com. This is his first story for The Athletic.NEW YORK — Opportunity hasn’t been Alejandro Kirk’s problem. The Blue Jays’ catcher has walked to the plate 27 times this season with a runner in scoring position, constantly a swing away from igniting an offense that badly needs a spark.AdvertisementTaking advantage of those chances has been the hard part. A month after signing a five-year, $58 million extension, Kirk entered Friday with just five RBI in the exact situations built for cashing in runs, with a man on second or third. He’d hit just .217 with runners in scoring position this year with a .544 OPS. On Friday, opportunity finally met execution.With a ninth-inning swing, Kirk came […]
2025 NFL Draft picks by college team, school: SEC, Big Ten separate from pack as Ohio State leads the way
Getty Images The first round of the 2025 NFL Draft was dominated by power conference schools, as the SEC and Big Ten were ubiquitous during Thursday night's action with 26 of the first 32 picks coming from the two most powerful conferences in the sport. That trend continued on Friday night during Day 2, as 21 more players from the SEC and Big Ten heard their names called in the 32 second-round picks. While not a surprise, it's a reminder of the direction college football is trending, as the transfer portal and the opportunity to cash in on NIL deals has made it far less likely that an NFL talent will make it through their junior year at a smaller program. In total, 66 of the 102 players selected in the first three rounds of the NFL Draft finished their collegiate careers […]
NFL Draft 2025: Here’s how much money Shedeur Sanders missed out on by not being drafted in first three rounds
Getty Images The story of the 2025 NFL Draft has to do with a player who hasn't even heard his name called yet. Former Colorado quarterback Shedeur Sanders, the Big 12 Offensive Player of the Year and son of NFL legend Deion Sanders, was expected to be a first-round pick, but instead went unselected in the first three rounds of the draft.The Pittsburgh Steelers passed on him multiple times, while the New York Giants, New Orleans Saints, Seattle Seahawks and Cleveland Browns all selected different quarterbacks. Every player will be given the opportunity to compete whether they are a first-round pick or seventh-round pick, but their paychecks will be very different. For example, No. 1 overall pick Cam Ward is expected to sign a deal projected to be worth $48,757,500, according to Spotrac, while Tyler Shough, who was drafted 40th […]
2025 NFL Draft grades for Round 3: Seahawks earn ‘A+’ for Jalen Milroe pick, Browns get ‘C’ for Dillon Gabriel
Getty Images Day 2 of the 2025 NFL Draft concluded on Friday night with Colorado's Shedeur Sanders still not selected.It was slightly surprising to see Sanders not drafted on Thursday as just two quarterbacks (Ward and Jaxson Dart) were taken in the first round. However, Day 2 brought three more quarterbacks selected: Louisville's Tyler Shough went to the Saints at No. 40 in Round 2, Alabama's Jalen Milroe was selected by the Seahawks with the 92nd pick (Round 3), and Oregon's Dillon Gabriel was taken by the Browns with the 94th pick (Round 3).Want to know what I thought of every pick made in the second round of the 2025 NFL Draft? You can read below as I graded all the Round 3 picks from Friday night. Be sure to refresh this page throughout the weekend to get all the latest grades. […]
Luke Keaschall injury: Twins’ hot-hitting rookie suffers broken forearm
Matt Krohn Minnesota Twins promising rookie infielder/outfielder Luke Keaschall suffered a nondisplaced fracture in his right forearm on Friday, the club told reporters following the Twins' 11-4 win over the Los Angeles Angels. Keaschall suffered the injury when he was struck by a pitch from Kyle Hendricks in the first inning. Keaschall, in the lineup at DH, was able to run the bases after being hit on the arm, but he was pinch-hit for when his spot came up again in the bottom of the third. According to Twins dugout reporter Audra Martin, the club does not have a timetable for Keaschall's return. That the fracture is nondisplaced is a positive, but it still figures to be a lengthy absence for the 22-year-old. According to the Baseball Prospectus injury database, recovery time for forearm fractures tends to range from a bit […]
NFL Draft best available players for Chicago Bears: Cam Skattebo, Devin Neal
LAKE FOREST, Ill. — The third day of the NFL Draft will have an earlier start for the Chicago Bears after a Day 2 move with the Buffalo Bills.The Bears exchanged the 41st, 72nd and the 240th selections for Nos. 56, 62 and 109. They get the fourth-round pick back that they traded last year to move up for defensive end Austin Booker.AdvertisementAfter taking offensive tackle Ozzy Trapilo and defensive tackle Shemar Turner on Friday night, does the 109th pick become the Bears’ move at running back?Bears director of player personnel Trey Koziol was asked about the possibility of adding a running back on Day 3.“Sure, any time you have an opportunity to add a good player there,” he said. “There’s still a lot of players on the board we’d be thrilled to add. It’s just gonna depend on how […]
Related
Alejandro Kirk comes through for Blue Jays: ‘I needed it, the team needed it’
Editor’s note: We’re thrilled to introduce Mitch Bannon as our Blue Jays beat writer. A native of Toronto, he previously covered the team for SI.com. This is his first story for The Athletic.NEW YORK — Opportunity hasn’t been Alejandro Kirk’s problem. The Blue Jays’ catcher has walked to the plate 27 times this season with a runner in scoring position, constantly a swing away from igniting an offense that badly needs a spark.AdvertisementTaking advantage of those chances has been the hard part. A month after signing a five-year, $58 million extension, Kirk entered Friday with just five RBI in the exact situations built for cashing in runs, with a man on second or third. He’d hit just .217 with runners in scoring position this year with a .544 OPS. On Friday, opportunity finally met execution.With a ninth-inning swing, Kirk came […]
2025 NFL Draft picks by college team, school: SEC, Big Ten separate from pack as Ohio State leads the way
Getty Images The first round of the 2025 NFL Draft was dominated by power conference schools, as the SEC and Big Ten were ubiquitous during Thursday night's action with 26 of the first 32 picks coming from the two most powerful conferences in the sport. That trend continued on Friday night during Day 2, as 21 more players from the SEC and Big Ten heard their names called in the 32 second-round picks. While not a surprise, it's a reminder of the direction college football is trending, as the transfer portal and the opportunity to cash in on NIL deals has made it far less likely that an NFL talent will make it through their junior year at a smaller program. In total, 66 of the 102 players selected in the first three rounds of the NFL Draft finished their collegiate careers […]
NFL Draft 2025: Here’s how much money Shedeur Sanders missed out on by not being drafted in first three rounds
Getty Images The story of the 2025 NFL Draft has to do with a player who hasn't even heard his name called yet. Former Colorado quarterback Shedeur Sanders, the Big 12 Offensive Player of the Year and son of NFL legend Deion Sanders, was expected to be a first-round pick, but instead went unselected in the first three rounds of the draft.The Pittsburgh Steelers passed on him multiple times, while the New York Giants, New Orleans Saints, Seattle Seahawks and Cleveland Browns all selected different quarterbacks. Every player will be given the opportunity to compete whether they are a first-round pick or seventh-round pick, but their paychecks will be very different. For example, No. 1 overall pick Cam Ward is expected to sign a deal projected to be worth $48,757,500, according to Spotrac, while Tyler Shough, who was drafted 40th […]
2025 NFL Draft grades for Round 3: Seahawks earn ‘A+’ for Jalen Milroe pick, Browns get ‘C’ for Dillon Gabriel
Getty Images Day 2 of the 2025 NFL Draft concluded on Friday night with Colorado's Shedeur Sanders still not selected.It was slightly surprising to see Sanders not drafted on Thursday as just two quarterbacks (Ward and Jaxson Dart) were taken in the first round. However, Day 2 brought three more quarterbacks selected: Louisville's Tyler Shough went to the Saints at No. 40 in Round 2, Alabama's Jalen Milroe was selected by the Seahawks with the 92nd pick (Round 3), and Oregon's Dillon Gabriel was taken by the Browns with the 94th pick (Round 3).Want to know what I thought of every pick made in the second round of the 2025 NFL Draft? You can read below as I graded all the Round 3 picks from Friday night. Be sure to refresh this page throughout the weekend to get all the latest grades. […]
Luke Keaschall injury: Twins’ hot-hitting rookie suffers broken forearm
Matt Krohn Minnesota Twins promising rookie infielder/outfielder Luke Keaschall suffered a nondisplaced fracture in his right forearm on Friday, the club told reporters following the Twins' 11-4 win over the Los Angeles Angels. Keaschall suffered the injury when he was struck by a pitch from Kyle Hendricks in the first inning. Keaschall, in the lineup at DH, was able to run the bases after being hit on the arm, but he was pinch-hit for when his spot came up again in the bottom of the third. According to Twins dugout reporter Audra Martin, the club does not have a timetable for Keaschall's return. That the fracture is nondisplaced is a positive, but it still figures to be a lengthy absence for the 22-year-old. According to the Baseball Prospectus injury database, recovery time for forearm fractures tends to range from a bit […]
NFL Draft best available players for Chicago Bears: Cam Skattebo, Devin Neal
LAKE FOREST, Ill. — The third day of the NFL Draft will have an earlier start for the Chicago Bears after a Day 2 move with the Buffalo Bills.The Bears exchanged the 41st, 72nd and the 240th selections for Nos. 56, 62 and 109. They get the fourth-round pick back that they traded last year to move up for defensive end Austin Booker.AdvertisementAfter taking offensive tackle Ozzy Trapilo and defensive tackle Shemar Turner on Friday night, does the 109th pick become the Bears’ move at running back?Bears director of player personnel Trey Koziol was asked about the possibility of adding a running back on Day 3.“Sure, any time you have an opportunity to add a good player there,” he said. “There’s still a lot of players on the board we’d be thrilled to add. It’s just gonna depend on how […]
Be the first to leave a comment