PALM BEACH, Fla. — As the debate over rule changes approached this week, the NFL competition committee acknowledged an elephant in the room.
They knew that a proposal to ban the tush push was up for debate.
Advertisement
Committee members knew, too, the conspiracy allegations that could follow.
After all, the tush push accounted for just 0.28% of plays last season, per ESPN data. The Philadelphia Eagles and Buffalo Bills ran the play more over the last three seasons than the other 30 teams combined.
Was this a jab at the defending Super Bowl champion Eagles? Why was changing this play a focus?
It’s proven tricky to pass a proposal banning the tush push based on competitive advantage or (effectively non-existent) injury data. But entertainment value? That’s something Cowboys team owner Jerry Jones seems to think might stick. (Grant Thomas/Yahoo Sports)
That concern influenced heavily the Tuesday decision to table the Green Bay Packers’ proposal to eliminate pushing or aiding the ball carrier. A vote was not simply held and failed. Instead, the vote was delayed to explore further rulebook language. Team representatives are expected to receive a broader, less targeted rule change proposal at a May 20-21 meeting in Minneapolis.
Advertisement
Increasingly, the NFL is trending toward reintroducing a pre-2004 rule that prohibits eliminating all pushing and pulling of a ball carrier. The result is to eliminate the tush push but do so in a scope considered more fair by some.
And yet: Where the competition committee believes “nobody likes” the connection to the Eagles and Bills, Jerry Jones appears not to share their concern.
Instead, the Cowboys team owner and general manager voiced support for eliminating a tactic on the basis of a team’s dominance.
“The reason we got the two-point play is [we] said the extra point alone kicking it is not exciting enough,” Jones told Yahoo Sports. “That reminded me of how those things have evolved.
Advertisement
“It was more from the entertainment standpoint — which from my perspective, is a good discussion. The fact that fans could be interested in what we do with it. We do things, and if somebody does it really well or gets an edge, we might make defensive, offensive adjustments.
“That’s the discussion.”
Multiple teams worry about risks of opponent’s overwhelming success
Jones has long been at the forefront of prioritizing the entertainment value, and thus the earning potential, of the NFL.
His reasoning also shines a new light on Feb. 1 comments from Packers president Mark Murphy explaining what ultimately became the team’s rule change proposal.
Advertisement
“I am not a fan of this play,” Murphy wrote in a Q&A on the team’s website. “There is no skill involved and it is almost an automatic first down on plays of a yard or less…
“The play is bad for the game, and we should go back to prohibiting the push of the runner.”
Murphy’s use of the word “automatic” irked Eagles head coach Nick Sirianni, who called it “a little insulting.” But Jones believes changing rules because of entertainment purposes is fair game, and that one or two teams’ overwhelming success in an area does not maximize entertainment value in a league that claims to strive for parity.
“They referenced back to precedence when you’ve had plays that have been successful on one side of the ball or other and it was mainly, in my mind, a discussion of what we’ve done when a play started becoming popular,” Jones told Yahoo Sports shortly after the vote was tabled. “It’s the nature of how the game has evolved that when something creates a competitive imbalance or competitive issue, other clubs either do it or they check it.”
The Eagles and Bills converted for a first down or touchdown on 87% of tush push plays the last three years, per ESPN data, compared to the rest of the league’s 71% clip.
Advertisement
Entertainment concerns could help the Packers and fellow tush push ban advocates successfully remove the tactic from the game.
On one hand, eliminating the tush push risks a slippery slope of penalizing teams for creativity and innovation. On the other, the entertainment lens may help compel teams that want to change the rule but can’t justify relying on a data set that suggests the injury risk is inconclusive at best and negligible at worst.
Rams general manager Les Snead acknowledged Monday that “right now there’s not enough data to say one way or another” whether the tush push introduces a disproportionate injury risk.
But the optics of the play?
Advertisement
“It’d be interesting if everyone started doing tush push and football became rugby and you were just scrumming your way … all the way down the field,” Snead told Yahoo Sports. “Now, maybe people quit watching and you have to cut it out because it is not as entertaining.
“You never know how that evolves.”
What’s next for the tush push?
Publicly, league officials and the competition committee are not encouraging eliminating a play on the basis of competitive imbalance.
Proponents are messaging more around game integrity and medical considerations.
McKay said safety, football and history and the desire to eliminate on offense a play that defenders cannot legally replicate on defense were the three tiers of debate. McKay and NFL commissioner Roger Goodell cited hypothetical injury concerns where proven data ended.
Advertisement
“We have very little data from it, but beyond data, there’s also the mechanism of injury that we study, that type of thing that leads us to show the risk involved in a particular play or particular tackle,” Goodell said. “There are a lot of plays where you see someone pulling or pushing somebody that are not in the tush push formation that I think do have an increased risk of injury.”
The league’s rules session advanced quickly on several proposals but lasted “30-40 minutes,” McKay said, when reaching tush push debate.
“A lot of discussion about it,” McKay said. “A lot of teams had a lot of views.”
Advertisement
The most likely outcome, in the view of several league sources: Club representatives vote in May to return to the pre-2004 language prohibiting against pushing or pulling ball carriers.
The rule was deleted because of concern that officials could not successfully and consistently officiate it downfield. At least some in the league office believe 20 years of advances in officiating, including the introduction of technological aids, tip the scales in favor of banning the play.
The proposal will need at least 24 of 32 clubs’ approval to pass.
But concurring opinions will count all the same. The Packers and advocates are not relying on clubs to seek the rule passage for the same reason — they just need the requisite number of clubs to approve.
Advertisement
A rule could pass because some clubs want to reduce the Philadelphia advantage; others question the play’s authenticity to the game; others worry about injury risk; and still more — like Jones — worry dominance will be a bore.
“The committee will look at [it all],” Goodell said, “and come back in May with some proposal.”
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
Dodgers pitcher Tyler Glasnow leaves start before 2nd inning with shoulder discomfort
Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher Tyler Glasnow left Sunday's game versus the Pittsburgh Pirates after suffering an apparent injury while warming up for the second inning.Glasnow appeared to feel discomfort in his right arm as he threw his final warmup pitches. Following the second-to-last throw, he stretched out his shoulder and shook his arm out a couple of times. After his last warmup pitch, he appeared to be in pain as he stepped off the mound. (Though he likely would have stepped off anyway while catcher Austin Barnes made a throw to second baseman Enrique Hernández.)The right-hander then left the game and the Dodgers soon announced that Glasnow was feeling right shoulder discomfort.This story will be updated.
Hurricanes goalie Frederik Andersen leaves Game 4 after collision with Devils’ Timo Meier
NEWARK, N.J. — Carolina Hurricanes goaltender Frederik Andersen left Game 4 on Sunday after Timo Meier collided with him in the second period. Pyotr Kochetkov replaced him in net.Early in the second period, Meier skated to the Carolina net to try to redirect an Ondrej Palat pass. He made contact with Andersen as he charged into the crease, sending the goalie sprawling into the net. Officials blew the play dead, and Carolina’s trainer came onto the ice. Andersen eventually skated off without assistance.AdvertisementOfficials originally gave Meier a five-minute major penalty for the play, but after video review, it was deemed there was no penalty on the play.Andersen has had a strong start to the playoffs for Carolina. He had a .943 save percentage through Carolina’s first three games and stopped six of the seven shots he saw before the Meier […]
Shedeur Sanders’ slide shows there’s still a gap between NFL Draft’s spectacle and reality
Every spring, there are two NFL Drafts. There’s the capital-D Draft, the traveling-roadshow spectacle that’s a whirlwind of mock-draft specialists and jersey-clad fanatics alike. And then there’s the lowercase-d draft, the staffing convention where 32 organizations are looking to make half a dozen strategic entry-level hires.Early on, the Draft and the draft run on side-by-side, if not entirely parallel, tracks. Mock drafters and real drafters alike tend to agree that players like, say, Cam Ward, Travis Hunter and Abdul Carter don’t need to get too comfortable in the green room before they get their call to the stage.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementBut when draft “insiders” and actual drafters diverge, well, that’s when it gets interesting … and, in some notable cases, embarrassing.Shedeur Sanders was a favorite of the Draft crowd, and it’s not hard to see why — he plays the league’s marquee position, […]
Dodgers’ Tyler Glasnow leaves second consecutive start with injury
LOS ANGELES — Here things go again for the Los Angeles Dodgers’ Tyler Glasnow. The All-Star right-hander exited his second consecutive start due to right shoulder discomfort on Sunday against the Pittsburgh Pirates, with manager Dave Roberts and head athletic trainer Thomas Albert bolting from the dugout as soon as Glasnow completed his warmups to start the second inning.AdvertisementFor the Dodgers and Glasnow, the high-priced, high-upside starter who has dealt with a litany of ailments even in his short time in Los Angeles, it was a concerning sight.Glasnow exited almost immediately after Roberts and Albert arrived at the mound. Rookie reliever Ben Casparius relieved him. Glasnow threw a total of 17 pitches, surrendering solo home runs to Andrew McCutchen and Enmanuel Valdez. Trainer and Dave Roberts are out for Tyler Glasnow after he finished his warmups in the second inning. […]
Dodgers’ Tyler Glasnow leaves game with right shoulder discomfort, second injury-shortened start in a row
Getty Images After giving up two runs in the first inning against the Pirates on Sunday, Dodgers starter Tyler Glasnow was removed from the game with what the Dodgers later called right shoulder discomfort. He went out for his warm up pitches before summoning manager Dave Roberts and a trainer. He then left the game due to an apparent injury. Ben Casparius replaced Glasnow on the mound. Glasnow could be seen rotating his shoulder before the pitch then reacted immediately with a shout after releasing. The Dodgers entered the season with great rotation depth and that depth is being strenuously tested at present. Tony Gonsolin, Kyle Hurt, Clayton Kershaw, River Ryan, Emmet Sheehan, Blake Snell and Gavin Stone are currently on the injured list, leaving Glasnow, Roki Sasaki, Dustin May and Yoshinobu Yamamoto in the rotation. Gonsolin is slated to rejoin […]
Flamengo goleia o Corinthians com volta triunfal de Pedro como titular
O ex-treinador da seleção e também do Flamengo acompanhou um massacre em campo, com gols de Cebolinha, Arrascaeta e dois de Pedro, titular pela primeira vez após voltar de lesão. Com o resultado, o Rubro-negro assume a liderança provisória do Brasileirão, mas aguarda o jogo do Palmeiras.
Related
Dodgers pitcher Tyler Glasnow leaves start before 2nd inning with shoulder discomfort
Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher Tyler Glasnow left Sunday's game versus the Pittsburgh Pirates after suffering an apparent injury while warming up for the second inning.Glasnow appeared to feel discomfort in his right arm as he threw his final warmup pitches. Following the second-to-last throw, he stretched out his shoulder and shook his arm out a couple of times. After his last warmup pitch, he appeared to be in pain as he stepped off the mound. (Though he likely would have stepped off anyway while catcher Austin Barnes made a throw to second baseman Enrique Hernández.)The right-hander then left the game and the Dodgers soon announced that Glasnow was feeling right shoulder discomfort.This story will be updated.
Hurricanes goalie Frederik Andersen leaves Game 4 after collision with Devils’ Timo Meier
NEWARK, N.J. — Carolina Hurricanes goaltender Frederik Andersen left Game 4 on Sunday after Timo Meier collided with him in the second period. Pyotr Kochetkov replaced him in net.Early in the second period, Meier skated to the Carolina net to try to redirect an Ondrej Palat pass. He made contact with Andersen as he charged into the crease, sending the goalie sprawling into the net. Officials blew the play dead, and Carolina’s trainer came onto the ice. Andersen eventually skated off without assistance.AdvertisementOfficials originally gave Meier a five-minute major penalty for the play, but after video review, it was deemed there was no penalty on the play.Andersen has had a strong start to the playoffs for Carolina. He had a .943 save percentage through Carolina’s first three games and stopped six of the seven shots he saw before the Meier […]
Shedeur Sanders’ slide shows there’s still a gap between NFL Draft’s spectacle and reality
Every spring, there are two NFL Drafts. There’s the capital-D Draft, the traveling-roadshow spectacle that’s a whirlwind of mock-draft specialists and jersey-clad fanatics alike. And then there’s the lowercase-d draft, the staffing convention where 32 organizations are looking to make half a dozen strategic entry-level hires.Early on, the Draft and the draft run on side-by-side, if not entirely parallel, tracks. Mock drafters and real drafters alike tend to agree that players like, say, Cam Ward, Travis Hunter and Abdul Carter don’t need to get too comfortable in the green room before they get their call to the stage.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementBut when draft “insiders” and actual drafters diverge, well, that’s when it gets interesting … and, in some notable cases, embarrassing.Shedeur Sanders was a favorite of the Draft crowd, and it’s not hard to see why — he plays the league’s marquee position, […]
Dodgers’ Tyler Glasnow leaves second consecutive start with injury
LOS ANGELES — Here things go again for the Los Angeles Dodgers’ Tyler Glasnow. The All-Star right-hander exited his second consecutive start due to right shoulder discomfort on Sunday against the Pittsburgh Pirates, with manager Dave Roberts and head athletic trainer Thomas Albert bolting from the dugout as soon as Glasnow completed his warmups to start the second inning.AdvertisementFor the Dodgers and Glasnow, the high-priced, high-upside starter who has dealt with a litany of ailments even in his short time in Los Angeles, it was a concerning sight.Glasnow exited almost immediately after Roberts and Albert arrived at the mound. Rookie reliever Ben Casparius relieved him. Glasnow threw a total of 17 pitches, surrendering solo home runs to Andrew McCutchen and Enmanuel Valdez. Trainer and Dave Roberts are out for Tyler Glasnow after he finished his warmups in the second inning. […]
Dodgers’ Tyler Glasnow leaves game with right shoulder discomfort, second injury-shortened start in a row
Getty Images After giving up two runs in the first inning against the Pirates on Sunday, Dodgers starter Tyler Glasnow was removed from the game with what the Dodgers later called right shoulder discomfort. He went out for his warm up pitches before summoning manager Dave Roberts and a trainer. He then left the game due to an apparent injury. Ben Casparius replaced Glasnow on the mound. Glasnow could be seen rotating his shoulder before the pitch then reacted immediately with a shout after releasing. The Dodgers entered the season with great rotation depth and that depth is being strenuously tested at present. Tony Gonsolin, Kyle Hurt, Clayton Kershaw, River Ryan, Emmet Sheehan, Blake Snell and Gavin Stone are currently on the injured list, leaving Glasnow, Roki Sasaki, Dustin May and Yoshinobu Yamamoto in the rotation. Gonsolin is slated to rejoin […]
Flamengo goleia o Corinthians com volta triunfal de Pedro como titular
O ex-treinador da seleção e também do Flamengo acompanhou um massacre em campo, com gols de Cebolinha, Arrascaeta e dois de Pedro, titular pela primeira vez após voltar de lesão. Com o resultado, o Rubro-negro assume a liderança provisória do Brasileirão, mas aguarda o jogo do Palmeiras.
Be the first to leave a comment