
What a big win for the Toronto Maple Leafs.
Gustav Forsling fired a perfect slap shot to open the scoring in the early second, but William Nylander made a perfect pass to John Tavares 10 minutes later to tie the game through 40.
Toronto’s top line stepped up in a major way in the third. Auston Matthews set up Mitch Marner to give the Leafs the lead with nine minutes to play, and Marner then made a perfect stretch pass to set up Knies for a breakaway goal. Sam Reinhart pulled the Panthers within one with two minutes left, but that’s as close as they would get.
Advertisement
Toronto’s best players were their best players. The Leafs didn’t exactly dominate against a Panthers team that was without Matthew Tkachuk, Aleksander Barkov and Aaron Ekblad, but the overall team grade is still an A-.
William Nylander: A+
Nylander made a great play to set up Bobby McMann for a quality chance four minutes in, and he made an even better play to set up Toronto’s first goal in the second. Just about everyone in the building thought Nylander was going to shoot, but he ended up firing a perfect pass to Tavares for a tap-in. He broke in on a one-on-one rush earlier in the middle frame and sent McMann on a breakaway in the third.
He was one of the only players who consistently looked dangerous in a tightly-checked game.
Mitch Marner: A+
Marner was quiet by his standard through 40. Just when half of the fan base was about to grumble something about “can’t score in these types of games,” he snuck into the slot and scored the go-ahead goal halfway through the third. He then made an absolutely perfect stretch pass to set up Knies for a breakaway goal. Marner was also excellent defensively to generate two clears when Florida had their goalie pulled.
Bobby McMann: A
McMann was noticeable in the early minutes and generated a quality chance from the slot four minutes in. His speed helped to draw an interference penalty at the end of the first, and his work on the forecheck played a major role in his team’s first goal.
His line was Toronto’s best, and he showed it on a breakaway halfway through the third after executing a perfect give-and-go with Nylander.

Bobby McMann and Uvis Balinskis fight for the puck during the third period. (John E. Sokolowski / Imagn Images)
Matthew Knies: A-
Knies made a heads-up pass to set up Matthews for a great chance in front seven minutes in. He struggled to make much of an impact for most of the evening, but ended up scoring a massive breakaway goal with five minutes left to extend his team’s lead to two. The goal alone was enough to earn him a strong grade.
Advertisement
John Tavares: A-
Tavares tied the game at one by going to the net and taking advantage of a sweet pass from Nylander. He also made a heads-up pass to send Nylander on a one-on-one rush earlier in the middle frame. He was the third-best player on his line, but his trio impressed.
The second pair (Morgan Rielly and Brandon Carlo): A-
They complement each other so well. Rielly continues to look far better defensively than he did at the start of the season, and while Carlo didn’t do anything special, he continues to look like the best version of himself. Carlo is just so well-rounded defensively — a force in net-front battles and denying opposing zone entries quite well.
Auston Matthews: B+
Matthews had a grade-A scoring chance seven minutes in, but he wasn’t able to beat Panthers goalie Sergei Bobrovsky through the five-hole. He fired another two shots on goal in the opening frame and while he disappeared a bit in the second, he picked up a primary assist on Marner’s go-ahead goal in the third.
Anthony Stolarz: B+
Stolarz surrendered the game’s first goal one minute into the second as Forsling beat him with a wicked slapshot. While the shot had some serious zip on it, Stolarz wasn’t screened and it came from a ways away.
Stolarz bounced back well and ended up making a tough stop with his left pad against A.J. Greer right before Marner gave the Leafs the lead in the third. He was screened for Sam Reinhart’s power-play goal that pulled the game within one, and finished with 29 saves on 31 shots.
Max Domi: B
Domi generated two quality chances in the opening minutes of the second and it felt like he was playing with intensity. His line was outchanced, but I liked his effort.
The shutdown pair (Jake McCabe and Chris Tanev): B
They were just okay. Tanev had an iffy turnover eight minutes in and also took a high-sticking penalty at the end of the opening frame. While the Panthers didn’t score on the man advantage, they scored shortly after he came out of the box.
McCabe got caught on a two-minute shift and got beat on the rush for a quality chance against. It wasn’t all bad, as they were generally solid defensively, but they’ve set a high standard and this didn’t match it.

Chris Tanev shoulders his way past A.J. Greer. (John E. Sokolowski / Imagn Images)
Calle Järnkrok: B
Järnkrok’s hard work set up Domi for a quality scoring chance in the early second, and his effort on the forecheck forced an opposing turnover a handful of minutes later.
The fourth line (Steven Lorentz, David Kämpf, Pontus Holmberg): B-
Their minutes were incredibly boring, so they essentially did their job. Kämpf didn’t play in the third due to injury and finished with 8:10 of ice time. Holmberg took a penalty in the final minutes that led to a goal against, but Berube will ultimately be fine with this line’s results.
Advertisement
Scott Laughton: B-
I continue to watch Laughton and think, “What would you say you do here?” He throws the occasional hit, but he looks like a slower version of Alex Kerfoot most nights. He wasn’t on for many chances, for or against.
The third pair (Simon Benoit and Oliver Ekman-Larsson): C-
They were tough to watch. On a positive note, Benoit showed some poise with the puck and set up Matthews for a half-decent chance halfway through the first. Following that, this duo struggled to make a breakout pass and they spent shift after shift defending. They both gave the puck away multiple times.
Game Score
What’s next?
Staying at home to play the Columbus Blue Jackets on Saturday at 7 p.m. on Hockey Night in Canada and Sportsnet.
(Top photo of Matthew Knies: John E. Sokolowski / Imagn Images)
This news was originally published on this post .
Be the first to leave a comment