(This article was written with the assistance of Castmagic, an AI tool, and reviewed by our editorial team to ensure accuracy. Please reach out to us if you notice any mistakes.)
Here’s a recap of the favorite and least favorite Round 1 picks of the 2025 NFL Draft from the latest “Yahoo Fantasy Forecast / Football 301” podcast, based on what Charles McDonald, Nate Tice and Matt Harmon discussed:
Favorite picks of Round 1
McDonald: Mason Graham, DT, Cleveland Browns
Advertisement
Loved how the Browns traded down, acquired extra draft capital from Jacksonville, and addressed a genuine roster need. There’s a lot to like about the fit alongside Myles Garrett and Graham could bring significant pass rush ability.
Harmon: Armand Membou, OT, New York Jets
There’s reason to be high on Membou’s aggressive play and tone-setting style. He can be a finishing piece for a Jets offensive line that’s been in rebuilding mode. There’s potential for Membou and Olu Fashanu to be dynamic, young bookends and keys to a run-first Jets identity.
Tice: Mykel Williams, EDGE, San Francisco 49ers
Advertisement
The pairing of Williams with Nick Bosa was perfect — Bosa as the finesse rusher, Williams bringing power and run defense. It’s an ideal selection for the Niners’ defensive needs and style.
Jaxson Dart was QB2 of this NFL Draft after the Giants selected him. (Photo by James Gilbert/Getty Images)
(James Gilbert via Getty Images)
Least favorite picks of Round 1
Tice: Jaxson Dart, QB, New York Giants
None of the QBs in this draft class other than Cam Ward were first-round material. The Giants are in “win now or develop” limbo — stuck with veterans and now asking Dart to step into a questionable situation behind a shaky line.
McDonald: Omarion Hampton, RB, Los Angeles Chargers
Hampton is a fine player, but there’s reason to question the value here for the Chargers, who still have glaring needs, especially on the interior offensive line. The Chargers aren’t good enough to justify using a premium pick on a running back and the move doesn’t make their offense materially better.
Advertisement
Harmon: Tyler Warren, TE, Indianapolis Colts
A first-round TE is a luxury pick for a team that has needs elsewhere and a questionable QB situation. Warren isn’t an urgent upgrade given the Colts’ receivers weren’t being maximized anyway, and his skills overlap with what the Colts already have on the roster.
To hear more NFL discussions, tune into “Football 301” on Apple, Spotify or YouTube.
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
Damian Lillard injury update: Bucks star diagnosed with torn left Achilles tendon suffered during playoff game
Getty Images Milwaukee Bucks star Damian Lillard has torn his left Achilles tendon, the team announced Monday. It's news that the Bucks feared would be confirmed after an MRI Monday, and now the sobering reality has set in. Lillard will miss the rest of the playoffs for the Bucks, and will likely also miss a good chunk -- if not all -- of next season rehabbing from the injury.The injury occurred just six minutes into the first quarter of Game 3 on Sunday. Lillard was attempting to corral an offensive rebound off a missed Gary Trent Jr. 3-pointer, but as he tried to accelerate, the All-Star guard crumpled to the ground, visibly in pain. Play continued as Lillard sat at the 3-point line, and as Kyle Kuzma tried to help him off the floor at the next dead ball, Lillard […]
Jacobs Gibbs’ Quarterback Dynasty Rookie Rankings: Post 2025 NFL Draft edition; risers, fallers, more
/ Getty Images We are so back! With landing spots secured, all that is left to do is speculate for months on end. Before we know it, August preseason action will be upon us! Let's go!Dynasty Quarterback Rookie RankingsGREEN BAY, WISCONSIN - APRIL 24: Quarterback Cam Ward of Miami celebrates after being selected first overall pick by the Tennessee Titans during the first round of the 2025 NFL Draft at Lambeau Field on April 24, 2025 in Green Bay, Wisconsin. Stacy Revere / Getty Images QB1 -- Cam Ward, Tennessee TitansQB2 -- Jaxson Dart, New York GiantsQB3 -- Jalen Milroe, Seattle SeahawksQB4 -- Tyler Shough, New Orleans SaintsQB5 -- Shedeur Sanders, Cleveland BrownsQB6 -- Dillon Gabriel, Cleveland BrownsQB7 -- Will Howard, Pittsburgh SteelersQB RisersI already had Dart and Milroe ranked as QB2 and QB3, so nothing changed there. Dart rose […]
Dojemné gesto ligové hvězdy. Gólovou oslavu věnovala nemocnému fanouškovi
„V minulém týdnu jsem byl za Mírou, který bojuje s těžkou nemocí. Měl přání se se mnou potkat, tak jsem mu ho splnil,“ odhalil v klubovém videu na sociálních sítích.Pro mladého fanouška byla Šulcova návštěva překvapením. Čtyřiadvacetiletý záložník mu věnoval vlastnoručně podepsané hráčské kartičky a dres, míč plný autogramů všech plzeňských hráčů a kalendáře.PŘÍBĚH GÓLOVÉ OSLAVY ⚽✨Jsou důležitější věci než všechny góly světa 🌍❤️Pavel Šulc včera po své brance do sítě Sparty předvedl speciální oslavu, kterou dopředu upekl s naším fanouškem Mírou 🤝🏻 Podívejte se na její příběh! 📖VIDEO ➡️ https://t.co/wOmta2pRQu pic.twitter.com/D2iBrPIlCz— FC Viktoria Plzeň (@fcviktorkaplzen) April 28, 2025 „Vymysleli jsme jednu speciální věc. Jsem rád, že se mi to povedlo. Tímhle ho zdravím,“ pokračoval ofenzivní tahoun Viktorie.Jakou věc? Podívejte se.Šulc spojil ruce přesně tak, jak si to přál jeho fanda. Kolem očí si vytvořil pomyslné brýle, zbylé prsty natáhl. Jen palce spojil pod […]
Vanderlei Luxemburgo ganha força nos bastidores do Santos para a função de coordenador técnico
Luxa pode se tornar coordenador do Santos (Foto: Gustavo Aleixo/Cruzeiro) Enquanto busca seu futuro técnico, o Santos tentará resolver algumas situações internas de futebol, indicando a possibilidade de contratar um coordenador técnico para o departamento, O nome desejado para o cargo é o de um velho conhecido do torcedor santista, Vanderlei Luxemburgo Luxa de volta? Segundo Ricardo Martins, da TNT, o ex-treinador do Peixe é o nome preferido da diretoria para assumir o cargo e este vem conseguindo aprovação internamente no clube, muito devido ao histórico de suas passagens pela Vila Belmiro. Já houve uma conversa do presidente Marcelo Teixeira com Luxa sobre o assunto, e houve uma ‘resposta positiva’ sobre o assunto, de acordo com o que indica o Diário do Peixe. Sem clube desde 2023, quando deixou o Corinthians, o treinador tem trabalhado como comentarista na Band. PUBLICIDADE […]
What winning the Champions League would mean for the four remaining clubs
David Mosse Soccer Analyst <!--> And then there were four in this edition of the UEFA Champions League with the semifinals set to get underway this week. The competition began with 81 clubs from across the continent, but as has become commonplace in recent years, there is nary a Cinderella left at this stage.The increasingly top-heavy nature of European football means no one is surprised that four clubs with the pedigree of Arsenal, PSG, Barcelona and Inter are the last ones standing. All are in the top two in their domestic leagues, with the French side having already secured the Ligue 1 crown.But none of this star-studded quartet has lifted the trophy in the last nine years. Two have never won it, while the other two are desperate to end uncomfortable droughts. It should make for a dramatic conclusion to […]
Bills GM Brandon Beane expresses frustration on radio after being criticized for not drafting a receiver
The Buffalo Bills didn't win the Super Bowl last season, but the team had a lot going for it. After trading away Stefon Diggs last offseason, Buffalo's offense somehow improved and Josh Allen took home his first MVP award.While Allen and the rest of the offense look strong again in 2025, the Bills neglected to address that side of the ball during most of the 2025 NFL Draft, instead focusing on strengthening the team's defense. Buffalo's strategy — particularly the team's decision to not take a wide receiver early — came under fire on "The Jeremy and Joe" radio show in Buffalo.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementBeane made a scheduled appearance on the show shortly after that conversation, and wasn't happy about being criticized for not grabbing a receiver, according to ESPN."Well, you guys were b****ing in 2018 about Josh Allen, you guys wanted Josh […]
Related
Damian Lillard injury update: Bucks star diagnosed with torn left Achilles tendon suffered during playoff game
Getty Images Milwaukee Bucks star Damian Lillard has torn his left Achilles tendon, the team announced Monday. It's news that the Bucks feared would be confirmed after an MRI Monday, and now the sobering reality has set in. Lillard will miss the rest of the playoffs for the Bucks, and will likely also miss a good chunk -- if not all -- of next season rehabbing from the injury.The injury occurred just six minutes into the first quarter of Game 3 on Sunday. Lillard was attempting to corral an offensive rebound off a missed Gary Trent Jr. 3-pointer, but as he tried to accelerate, the All-Star guard crumpled to the ground, visibly in pain. Play continued as Lillard sat at the 3-point line, and as Kyle Kuzma tried to help him off the floor at the next dead ball, Lillard […]
Jacobs Gibbs’ Quarterback Dynasty Rookie Rankings: Post 2025 NFL Draft edition; risers, fallers, more
/ Getty Images We are so back! With landing spots secured, all that is left to do is speculate for months on end. Before we know it, August preseason action will be upon us! Let's go!Dynasty Quarterback Rookie RankingsGREEN BAY, WISCONSIN - APRIL 24: Quarterback Cam Ward of Miami celebrates after being selected first overall pick by the Tennessee Titans during the first round of the 2025 NFL Draft at Lambeau Field on April 24, 2025 in Green Bay, Wisconsin. Stacy Revere / Getty Images QB1 -- Cam Ward, Tennessee TitansQB2 -- Jaxson Dart, New York GiantsQB3 -- Jalen Milroe, Seattle SeahawksQB4 -- Tyler Shough, New Orleans SaintsQB5 -- Shedeur Sanders, Cleveland BrownsQB6 -- Dillon Gabriel, Cleveland BrownsQB7 -- Will Howard, Pittsburgh SteelersQB RisersI already had Dart and Milroe ranked as QB2 and QB3, so nothing changed there. Dart rose […]
Dojemné gesto ligové hvězdy. Gólovou oslavu věnovala nemocnému fanouškovi
„V minulém týdnu jsem byl za Mírou, který bojuje s těžkou nemocí. Měl přání se se mnou potkat, tak jsem mu ho splnil,“ odhalil v klubovém videu na sociálních sítích.Pro mladého fanouška byla Šulcova návštěva překvapením. Čtyřiadvacetiletý záložník mu věnoval vlastnoručně podepsané hráčské kartičky a dres, míč plný autogramů všech plzeňských hráčů a kalendáře.PŘÍBĚH GÓLOVÉ OSLAVY ⚽✨Jsou důležitější věci než všechny góly světa 🌍❤️Pavel Šulc včera po své brance do sítě Sparty předvedl speciální oslavu, kterou dopředu upekl s naším fanouškem Mírou 🤝🏻 Podívejte se na její příběh! 📖VIDEO ➡️ https://t.co/wOmta2pRQu pic.twitter.com/D2iBrPIlCz— FC Viktoria Plzeň (@fcviktorkaplzen) April 28, 2025 „Vymysleli jsme jednu speciální věc. Jsem rád, že se mi to povedlo. Tímhle ho zdravím,“ pokračoval ofenzivní tahoun Viktorie.Jakou věc? Podívejte se.Šulc spojil ruce přesně tak, jak si to přál jeho fanda. Kolem očí si vytvořil pomyslné brýle, zbylé prsty natáhl. Jen palce spojil pod […]
Vanderlei Luxemburgo ganha força nos bastidores do Santos para a função de coordenador técnico
Luxa pode se tornar coordenador do Santos (Foto: Gustavo Aleixo/Cruzeiro) Enquanto busca seu futuro técnico, o Santos tentará resolver algumas situações internas de futebol, indicando a possibilidade de contratar um coordenador técnico para o departamento, O nome desejado para o cargo é o de um velho conhecido do torcedor santista, Vanderlei Luxemburgo Luxa de volta? Segundo Ricardo Martins, da TNT, o ex-treinador do Peixe é o nome preferido da diretoria para assumir o cargo e este vem conseguindo aprovação internamente no clube, muito devido ao histórico de suas passagens pela Vila Belmiro. Já houve uma conversa do presidente Marcelo Teixeira com Luxa sobre o assunto, e houve uma ‘resposta positiva’ sobre o assunto, de acordo com o que indica o Diário do Peixe. Sem clube desde 2023, quando deixou o Corinthians, o treinador tem trabalhado como comentarista na Band. PUBLICIDADE […]
What winning the Champions League would mean for the four remaining clubs
David Mosse Soccer Analyst <!--> And then there were four in this edition of the UEFA Champions League with the semifinals set to get underway this week. The competition began with 81 clubs from across the continent, but as has become commonplace in recent years, there is nary a Cinderella left at this stage.The increasingly top-heavy nature of European football means no one is surprised that four clubs with the pedigree of Arsenal, PSG, Barcelona and Inter are the last ones standing. All are in the top two in their domestic leagues, with the French side having already secured the Ligue 1 crown.But none of this star-studded quartet has lifted the trophy in the last nine years. Two have never won it, while the other two are desperate to end uncomfortable droughts. It should make for a dramatic conclusion to […]
Bills GM Brandon Beane expresses frustration on radio after being criticized for not drafting a receiver
The Buffalo Bills didn't win the Super Bowl last season, but the team had a lot going for it. After trading away Stefon Diggs last offseason, Buffalo's offense somehow improved and Josh Allen took home his first MVP award.While Allen and the rest of the offense look strong again in 2025, the Bills neglected to address that side of the ball during most of the 2025 NFL Draft, instead focusing on strengthening the team's defense. Buffalo's strategy — particularly the team's decision to not take a wide receiver early — came under fire on "The Jeremy and Joe" radio show in Buffalo.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementBeane made a scheduled appearance on the show shortly after that conversation, and wasn't happy about being criticized for not grabbing a receiver, according to ESPN."Well, you guys were b****ing in 2018 about Josh Allen, you guys wanted Josh […]
Be the first to leave a comment