GRAPEVINE, Texas — On the fourth floor of the gargantuan Gaylord Texan Resort in this Dallas suburb, the conference commissioners spent three hours in the same room where the College Football Playoff selection committee members gather each December to decide the playoff field.
On the final day of three days of CFP meetings here this week, commissioners walked through a mock selection, getting a firsthand look at the data and process used by committee members — perhaps a last gasp from the CFP to show these decision-makers that the committee’s role should not be de-emphasized under any new playoff format.
Advertisement
“There was a lot of new learning,” CFP executive director Rich Clark said. “They got to see the depth that committee members go to with the process. They also gave us some feedback to help us think through how we could improve the committee.”
From this week’s annual spring meetings, no decisions were made on the three most important questions of any future playoff format:
(1) How many teams are in the bracket?
(2) How are teams selected for the bracket?
(3) And how are teams seeded in the bracket?
While the answers remain incomplete, the pathway to those answers is becoming more clear.
(1) There continues to be a desire, from both the commissioners and television partner ESPN, to expand the bracket to at least 14 teams. (Is 16 still on the table? Yes.)
Advertisement
(2) Leadership at the Big Ten and SEC, the leagues that hold decision-making power on format starting in 2026, continue to socialize a format that gives them more automatic qualifiers than any other conference — what’s become known as a “4-4-2-2-1” format granting four AQs to the top four finishers in both the SEC and Big Ten, two each to the ACC and Big 12, one to the Group of Six and one at-large in a 14-team model (to be clear, within the CFP meeting room, the Big Ten leadership has been most vocal about such a format).
(3) The selection committee needs an overhaul or, at the very least, some tweaks to their decision-making process, specifically as it relates to the strength-of-schedule metric.
How will it all end?
“That’s up to two conferences,” says one high-ranking college administrator.
What will the College Football Playoff look like in the future? (Amy Monks/Yahoo Sports)
The fact that the SEC and Big Ten haven’t rammed through the multi-AQ 4-4-2-2-1 format is telling. Despite work on the model from each of their conference staffs and wide support from their athletic directors and presidents, the conferences have yet to formally take procedural steps to adopt the format.
Advertisement
It may be a sign. Is compromise afoot?
Do the two conferences fear public backlash in adopting such a lopsided playoff model? Do the two leagues want to prevent further disadvantaging the Big 12 and ACC?
The commissioners of the four power leagues — Greg Sankey (SEC), Jim Phillips (ACC), Brett Yormark (Big 12) and Tony Petitti (Big Ten) — met separately here as they often do. After daylong meetings with the other FBS commissioners, the four of them held a dinner on Wednesday night, capping a furiously busy day with more work talk over wine and steaks.
During Wednesday’s CFP meetings, Clark introduced a new playoff format geared toward striking a compromise between the Big Ten’s multi-AQ model and the existing 12-team format that features seven at-large spots. Within the format, conferences would be ranked by the selection committee using a data-driven system, such as their non-conference winning percentage, previous playoff success, etc. The highest-ranked conference would receive four AQs, the second would get three, the third gets two AQs and so on, with one spot reserved for the best Group of Six program and as many as three at-large spots available in a 14-team model.
Advertisement
The format is expected to receive little to no serious traction.
But, at least, it’s something.
“No one else has brought anything to the table,” said one commissioner who was granted anonymity to speak freely.
The format for 2026 and beyond is tethered to the dilemma over the 2025 format. That’s right: CFP executives have not yet decided on changes to a playoff bracket that will begin in less than eight months.
The debate over moving to a straight seeding format rages onward. Big Ten and SEC commissioners have publicly expressed support for a change to straight seeding, meaning teams are seeded directly based on the committee’s rankings. Right now, the four highest-ranked conference champions are seeded Nos. 1-4.
Advertisement
However, unlike 2026 and beyond, any change to this year’s playoff takes unanimity from the 11 members of the CFP committee: the 10 FBS commissioners and Notre Dame’s athletic director.
The struggle between the Big Ten/SEC and the Big 12/ACC over any future format also impacts the vote for changes to this year’s playoff. Why, after all, would the ACC or Big 12 vote to put their schools at a further disadvantage in a straight-seeding model without a compromise on future formats?
“It’s a negotiating ploy,” said one conference leader.
Clark hinted at this debate during his meeting with reporters Thursday.
Advertisement
“We are discussing the format in its entirety,” he said. “Whatever we do this year will have an impact on 2026 and beyond. They’re trying not to make decisions in silos and are trying to do it holistically. They don’t want to rush just to get a decision out.”
In previous interviews, ACC commissioner Jim Phillips and Big 12 commissioner Brett Yormark have made it clear: It must take compromise to get our vote. But what does compromise look like?
Commissioners side-stepped that question (and most other questions) this week in Dallas. Would the SEC and Big Ten take three automatic qualifiers and not four? Would the field be expanded to 16 in their multi-AQ format as to give other leagues a chance at more at-large spots?
Either way, it’s clear that there is an effort to compromise on format. The goal: Arrive at a straight seeding model in 2025 and a new, more balanced format starting in 2026.
“They don’t want to rush just to get a decision out,” Clark said. “They’re not making any of these decisions in isolation. That’s why it takes a while.”
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
Nach Milliarden-Angebot – Riesen-Zoff um neuen Real-Vertrag von Vinicius!
Ist die Vertragsverlängerung doch nur heiße Luft?Die Gerüchteküche rund um Vinicius Jr. (24) und seine Vertragsverlängerung brodelt. Während mehrere Medien bereits von einem kurz bevorstehenden Abschluss und Einigkeit zwischen den Parteien berichtet hatten, dementieren dies nun Personen aus dem Umfeld des Brasilianers. Die Situation scheint komplexer als gedacht.Lesen Sie auch<!-->[-->Die Vertragsverhandlungen zwischen Vinicius und den Königlichen sollen laut Berichten schon seit Januar laufen. Damals wurde über ein Jahresgehalt zwischen 15 und 20 Millionen Euro diskutiert – abhängig von Bonuszahlungen und möglichen Titeln. Ein Modell, das mit dem von Topstars wie Kylian Mbappé (26) konkurrieren kann. Intern soll man sich sogar weitgehend einig gewesen sein.Doch jetzt weichen die Aussagen beider Seiten stark voneinander ab!Real Madrid: Vinicius nahm erstes Angebot wohl nicht anVinicius Jr. soll Real Madrid die Treue geschworen haben – aber nur unter fairen Bedingungen. Laut Quellen aus seinem Umfeld […]
Osm zápasů, tři trenéři. Vaclík o veletoči v novém klubu: Byl to extrém
Porto (od našeho zpravodaje) - Osmibodová ztráta na barážové místo je téměř pryč, Boavista stále může pomýšlet na udržení mezi elitou. V klubu z Porta lucemburského podnikatele Gérarda Lópeze je poslední měsíce ale rušno snad po všech stránkách. V zimě po odblokování přestupů dorazilo hned deset hráčů včetně Vaclíka právě s cílem se zachránit. V týdnu portugalská média informovala, že v areálu stadionu nešla kvůli dluhům elektrika. Zároveň od startu jarní části došlo k mnoha dalším personálním rošádám.Můžete krátce popsat, co všechno se v prvním týmu událo?Asi dva dny po mém příchodu skončil sportovní ředitel. Několikrát se změnil trenér gólmanů, na jedno utkání jsme dokonce žádného neměli. Co se týče hlavních koučů, skončil Lito Vidigal, který vedl tým jen šest utkání. Na dva zápasy to vzal Jorge Couto, tedy muž, který v Boavistě historicky pracoval. Následně byl angažován současný kouč Stuart Baxter. Takže tři hlavní a tři trenéři gólmanů za […]
Novak Djokovic’s tennis record made his ranking irrelevant, but he needs to care about it now
Novak Djokovic was as unequivocal as an athlete could be earlier this month, when he was asked what his goals were for the ongoing clay-court season.“Roland Garros,” he answered, referring to the French Open, in late May and early June, after losing his opening match in Monte Carlo, Monaco, to Alejandro Tabilo. “That’s it.”AdvertisementUnderstood. So what’s a player like that doing at a tournament like the Madrid Open?Sure, Madrid, which got underway this week, takes place on the red clay, just as the French Open does, but the similarities largely end there.The Spanish capital sits more than 2,000 feet above sea level, which allows the ball to fly and bounce during tennis matches in ways it won’t in Paris. The air is also dry, allowing the sun to bake the surface and make it behave more like a hard court […]
Welchem Klub er sich selbst anbietet – Spektakuläre Wende im Poker um Bayern-Flirt!
Alles schien klar mit Arsenal! Die Herausforderung der Premier League, die Chance auf Tore in der Königsklasse, große Titelhoffnungen – für Viktor Gyökeres (26) von Sporting Lissabon passte alles. Doch jetzt kommt es offenbar alles anders. Weil der Bayern-Flirt es offenbar so will!Obwohl die Gespräche mit den „Gunners“ bereits seit einiger Zeit laufen, hat sich der Schwede nun offenbar in den Kopf gesetzt, doch einem anderen Top-Verein den Vorzug zu geben. Seine Agenten sollen auf seinen „ausdrücklichen Wunsch“ Kontakt zu Real Madrid aufgenommen haben, um einen möglichen Wechsel zu besprechen, meldet „Defensa Central“.London oder doch lieber Madrid?Lesen Sie auch<!-->[-->Gyökeres hat sich in den letzten Jahren zu einem der besten Stürmer Europas entwickelt. 48 Tore und 12 Vorlagen in 47 Spielen in dieser Saison sprechen eine deutliche Sprache. Sporting-Trainer Rui Borges lobte ihn kürzlich als „außergewöhnlichen Stürmer“ und „besten der Liga“.Gyökeres will […]
NHL playoff picks, odds, schedule for Saturday’s Stanley Cup action including Stars-Avalanche
Saturday brings a quadruple header of Stanley Cup Playoffs action, including the first elimination game of the postseason. The Toronto Maple Leafs go for the sweep of the Ottawa Senators.In the first game of the day, the defending champion Florida Panthers go for a 3-0 lead after winning both games in Tampa. Plus, there are pivotal Game 4s in Minnesota and Colorado.AdvertisementViewing guide for Saturday GameTime (ET)TVStreamLightning at Panthers1 p.m.US: TBS, truTV, FDSN SunCanada: SportsnetGolden Knights at Wild4 p.m.US: TBS, truTV, FDSN NorthCanada: SportsnetMaple Leafs at Senators7 p.m.US: TBS, truTVCanada: Sportsnet, CBCMaxStars at Avalanche9:30 p.m.US: TBS, truTV, AltitudeCanada: Sportsnet All games on Saturday can be streamed on Max.Watching in person? Get tickets on StubHub.Tampa Bay Lightning at Florida PanthersPanthers lead series 2-0Series odds: Panthers -650, Lightning +475After the Panthers took Games 1 and 2 on the road, the biggest story […]
NASCAR Cup Series at Talladega odds, predictions: Team Penske favored but long shots shine at superspeedway
After the Easter break, the NASCAR Cup Series heads to party city Talladega this weekend for the Jack Link’s 500. Drivers will be looking for a dose of good luck at the superspeedway in their attempts to avoid the “Big One” and clinch a win. With an unbroken stretch of races from now until November, the unpredictability of Talladega could be exactly what a long-shot driver needs.AdvertisementAs always, we’re previewing the race and getting predictions from our NASCAR experts, Jeff Gluck and Jordan Bianchi. They’re answering our questions about the Cup Series’ upcoming schedule, All-Star race controversies, Rodney Childers’ future and who might cross the finish line first this weekend.Take it away, guys!How to watch the Jack Link’s 500 Track: Talladega Superspeedway — Lincoln, Ala. Time: Sunday, April 27, 3 p.m. ET TV: Fox Streaming: Fubo (try for free) NASCAR Cup Series […]
Related
Nach Milliarden-Angebot – Riesen-Zoff um neuen Real-Vertrag von Vinicius!
Ist die Vertragsverlängerung doch nur heiße Luft?Die Gerüchteküche rund um Vinicius Jr. (24) und seine Vertragsverlängerung brodelt. Während mehrere Medien bereits von einem kurz bevorstehenden Abschluss und Einigkeit zwischen den Parteien berichtet hatten, dementieren dies nun Personen aus dem Umfeld des Brasilianers. Die Situation scheint komplexer als gedacht.Lesen Sie auch<!-->[-->Die Vertragsverhandlungen zwischen Vinicius und den Königlichen sollen laut Berichten schon seit Januar laufen. Damals wurde über ein Jahresgehalt zwischen 15 und 20 Millionen Euro diskutiert – abhängig von Bonuszahlungen und möglichen Titeln. Ein Modell, das mit dem von Topstars wie Kylian Mbappé (26) konkurrieren kann. Intern soll man sich sogar weitgehend einig gewesen sein.Doch jetzt weichen die Aussagen beider Seiten stark voneinander ab!Real Madrid: Vinicius nahm erstes Angebot wohl nicht anVinicius Jr. soll Real Madrid die Treue geschworen haben – aber nur unter fairen Bedingungen. Laut Quellen aus seinem Umfeld […]
Osm zápasů, tři trenéři. Vaclík o veletoči v novém klubu: Byl to extrém
Porto (od našeho zpravodaje) - Osmibodová ztráta na barážové místo je téměř pryč, Boavista stále může pomýšlet na udržení mezi elitou. V klubu z Porta lucemburského podnikatele Gérarda Lópeze je poslední měsíce ale rušno snad po všech stránkách. V zimě po odblokování přestupů dorazilo hned deset hráčů včetně Vaclíka právě s cílem se zachránit. V týdnu portugalská média informovala, že v areálu stadionu nešla kvůli dluhům elektrika. Zároveň od startu jarní části došlo k mnoha dalším personálním rošádám.Můžete krátce popsat, co všechno se v prvním týmu událo?Asi dva dny po mém příchodu skončil sportovní ředitel. Několikrát se změnil trenér gólmanů, na jedno utkání jsme dokonce žádného neměli. Co se týče hlavních koučů, skončil Lito Vidigal, který vedl tým jen šest utkání. Na dva zápasy to vzal Jorge Couto, tedy muž, který v Boavistě historicky pracoval. Následně byl angažován současný kouč Stuart Baxter. Takže tři hlavní a tři trenéři gólmanů za […]
Novak Djokovic’s tennis record made his ranking irrelevant, but he needs to care about it now
Novak Djokovic was as unequivocal as an athlete could be earlier this month, when he was asked what his goals were for the ongoing clay-court season.“Roland Garros,” he answered, referring to the French Open, in late May and early June, after losing his opening match in Monte Carlo, Monaco, to Alejandro Tabilo. “That’s it.”AdvertisementUnderstood. So what’s a player like that doing at a tournament like the Madrid Open?Sure, Madrid, which got underway this week, takes place on the red clay, just as the French Open does, but the similarities largely end there.The Spanish capital sits more than 2,000 feet above sea level, which allows the ball to fly and bounce during tennis matches in ways it won’t in Paris. The air is also dry, allowing the sun to bake the surface and make it behave more like a hard court […]
Welchem Klub er sich selbst anbietet – Spektakuläre Wende im Poker um Bayern-Flirt!
Alles schien klar mit Arsenal! Die Herausforderung der Premier League, die Chance auf Tore in der Königsklasse, große Titelhoffnungen – für Viktor Gyökeres (26) von Sporting Lissabon passte alles. Doch jetzt kommt es offenbar alles anders. Weil der Bayern-Flirt es offenbar so will!Obwohl die Gespräche mit den „Gunners“ bereits seit einiger Zeit laufen, hat sich der Schwede nun offenbar in den Kopf gesetzt, doch einem anderen Top-Verein den Vorzug zu geben. Seine Agenten sollen auf seinen „ausdrücklichen Wunsch“ Kontakt zu Real Madrid aufgenommen haben, um einen möglichen Wechsel zu besprechen, meldet „Defensa Central“.London oder doch lieber Madrid?Lesen Sie auch<!-->[-->Gyökeres hat sich in den letzten Jahren zu einem der besten Stürmer Europas entwickelt. 48 Tore und 12 Vorlagen in 47 Spielen in dieser Saison sprechen eine deutliche Sprache. Sporting-Trainer Rui Borges lobte ihn kürzlich als „außergewöhnlichen Stürmer“ und „besten der Liga“.Gyökeres will […]
NHL playoff picks, odds, schedule for Saturday’s Stanley Cup action including Stars-Avalanche
Saturday brings a quadruple header of Stanley Cup Playoffs action, including the first elimination game of the postseason. The Toronto Maple Leafs go for the sweep of the Ottawa Senators.In the first game of the day, the defending champion Florida Panthers go for a 3-0 lead after winning both games in Tampa. Plus, there are pivotal Game 4s in Minnesota and Colorado.AdvertisementViewing guide for Saturday GameTime (ET)TVStreamLightning at Panthers1 p.m.US: TBS, truTV, FDSN SunCanada: SportsnetGolden Knights at Wild4 p.m.US: TBS, truTV, FDSN NorthCanada: SportsnetMaple Leafs at Senators7 p.m.US: TBS, truTVCanada: Sportsnet, CBCMaxStars at Avalanche9:30 p.m.US: TBS, truTV, AltitudeCanada: Sportsnet All games on Saturday can be streamed on Max.Watching in person? Get tickets on StubHub.Tampa Bay Lightning at Florida PanthersPanthers lead series 2-0Series odds: Panthers -650, Lightning +475After the Panthers took Games 1 and 2 on the road, the biggest story […]
NASCAR Cup Series at Talladega odds, predictions: Team Penske favored but long shots shine at superspeedway
After the Easter break, the NASCAR Cup Series heads to party city Talladega this weekend for the Jack Link’s 500. Drivers will be looking for a dose of good luck at the superspeedway in their attempts to avoid the “Big One” and clinch a win. With an unbroken stretch of races from now until November, the unpredictability of Talladega could be exactly what a long-shot driver needs.AdvertisementAs always, we’re previewing the race and getting predictions from our NASCAR experts, Jeff Gluck and Jordan Bianchi. They’re answering our questions about the Cup Series’ upcoming schedule, All-Star race controversies, Rodney Childers’ future and who might cross the finish line first this weekend.Take it away, guys!How to watch the Jack Link’s 500 Track: Talladega Superspeedway — Lincoln, Ala. Time: Sunday, April 27, 3 p.m. ET TV: Fox Streaming: Fubo (try for free) NASCAR Cup Series […]
Be the first to leave a comment