MINNEAPOLIS — For the second time in two months, the tush push is in danger.
The Philadelphia Eagles‘ signature quarterback sneak play survived debate over its future during early April league meetings in Palm Beach, Florida. But club and league officials did not feel comfortable enough with the play’s future to protect it for the long haul.
Advertisement
Rather than vote down the ban, officials tabled a vote until this week’s league meetings in Minneapolis.
Expect that vote to take place Wednesday.
As of late Friday, the Green Bay Packers had not amended their proposed ban to eliminate pushing or aiding the ball carrier, a league source confirmed to Yahoo Sports. The Packers could amend the language of the proposal this week in hopes of securing the necessary 24 of 32 votes to pass a league rule change.
The most likely amendment, per multiple league sources: a return to the league’s pre-2005 rule that prohibited all pushing and pulling of the ball carrier. Such a proposal would functionally eliminate the tush push but do so in a broader scope.
Advertisement
Competition committee chairman Rich McKay said in March that “nobody likes” how clearly a tush push-specific ban would target the Eagles and Buffalo Bills.
The tush push accounted for just 0.28% of plays last season, per ESPN data. The Eagles and Bills ran the play more over the past three seasons than the other 30 clubs combined.
Stopping Jalen Hurts and the Eagles in short-yardage situations has been quite a challenge for defenses across the NFL. (Photo by Cooper Neill/Getty Images)
(Cooper Neill via Getty Images)
The Eagles and Bills converted for a first down or touchdown on 87% of tush push plays the past three years, per ESPN data, compared to the rest of the league’s 71% clip.
While the Eagles and Bills’ plays will be more impacted by the statistically uncommon play, league opinion is split on how much it would actually hurt either team.
Advertisement
“The outcome of those 0.28% of plays is unlikely to change — teams are gonna get the sneak regardless of the push,” one source familiar with the debate considerations said. “Even when you watch the play. Sometimes the pusher doesn’t even get to make contact with [Jalen] Hurts.
“Other times he does, but it’s after the first down was reached.”
Injury data is lacking, but that isn’t stopping the push against the push
The Packers initially introduced the tush push ban this spring after team president Mark Murphy said he believed “the play is bad for the game” and “there is no skill involved.”
Some club officials balked at the Packers’ desire to litigate what plays do and don’t have skill.
Advertisement
Others, including Dallas Cowboys team owner Jerry Jones, embraced the removal of competitively imbalanced plays that could reduce entertainment value.
“The reason we got the 2-point play is [we] said the extra point alone kicking it is not exciting enough,” Jones told Yahoo Sports. “That reminded me of how those things have evolved.
“It was more from the entertainment standpoint — which from my perspective, is a good discussion. The fact that fans could be interested in what we do with it. We do things, and if somebody does it really well or get an edge, we might make defensive, offensive adjustments.
“That’s the discussion.”
Advertisement
Passing the vote would require two-thirds buy-in, but clubs need not all vote in favor of the ban for the same reason. If some clubs vote to slow the defending Super Bowl champions, others for health and safety reasons, and more on the basis of entertainment concerns? Their votes will count equally. Like Supreme Court concurring opinions, what matters is attaining a majority.
The requisite votes were not there six weeks ago. But one league source felt that this week’s meeting is “usually the meeting that gets what the league office wants if it couldn’t get the votes in March.”
In 2023, the NFL changed its kickoff rule at the May meetings, allowing for fair catches on kickoffs to result in beginning a possession on the receiving team’s 25-yard line.
Advertisement
Competition committee chairman Rich McKay described that change as “all really driven by health and safety” at the time.
Available data has not pointed to clear enough proof of increased injury risk to ban it purely on the basis of making the game safer, multiple coaches, general managers and league representatives confirmed in early April.
But NFL commissioner Roger Goodell has nonetheless expressed safety-related concern.
“We have very little data from it, but beyond data, there’s also the mechanism of injury that we study …that leads us to show the risk involved in a particular play or particular tackle,” Goodell said on April 2. “There are a lot of plays where you see someone pulling or pushing somebody that are not in the tush push formation that I think do have an increased risk of injury.”
Advertisement
Historically, the more the league has framed a rule change through the lens of health and safety, the more likely it was to pass. Last year’s hip-drop tackle ban was an example, though its data was more concrete than that of tush push injury concerns.
And the May meetings offers a different environment from the wider-tent March meetings, which invites all head coaches and general managers to participate in rule change debates.
The only coaches and general managers likely to be present for this meeting are the handful on the competition committee.
One general manager predicted the league will pass a banning of all pushing and pulling of the ball carrier this week.
“They’ll do a closed door vote and then the rules will change,” the general manager told Yahoo Sports. “Would be surprised if that didn’t happen.”
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
Manchester City appoint Hannah Dingley, ex-Forest Green manager, as girls’ Head of Academy
Hannah Dingley, the first woman to take charge of a men’s side in England’s top four divisions, has been appointed girls’ Head of Academy at Manchester City.Dingley was named caretaker manager of Forest Green Rovers — where she was head of the club’s academy — in July 2023, overseeing a friendly draw against Melksham Town that month, but was not appointed on a permanent basis.City say that Dingley’s role will be to ‘establish a clear pathway for youth players into the senior team while implementing our philosophy and methodology across individual athletes and teams’.Dingley said upon her appointment: “City is a leading force in women’s football and I am really excited to be joining such an ambitious and progressive club.”Charlotte O’Neill, City’s managing director, highlighted how the club’s youth graduates Gracie Prior, Lily Murphy and Codie Thomas all became part […]
Francesco Farioli announces Ajax exit day after missing out on league title
Ajax manager Francesco Farioli has announced his decision to leave the club after just a single season in charge.The news comes just a day after Ajax’s collapse in the title run-in led to PSV Eindhoven winning the Dutch title on a tense final day in the Eredivisie. Ajax blew a nine-point lead at the top of the table, and despite winning their final game of the season against FC Twente on Sunday, still had to settle for second place due to PSV’s 3-1 away victory over Sparta Rotterdam on the same day. AdvertisementFarioli repeatedly refused to confirm he would be staying on following Sunday’s game and leaves saying he and the club’s hierarchy have “different visions” on how to take the club forward.“My journey at Ajax started almost one year ago, at De Toekomst, with the aim of bringing Ajax back to […]
Tyler Batty, a rookie DL for the Vikings and son of a cowboy, is easy to root for
How many horses does Layne Batty own? It’s a question he doesn’t want to answer. He has nothing to hide. It’s just that if he were to say the number out loud, his wife, Peg, might cut him off from buying and raising more.Layne is a cowboy in every sense of the word. A white hat, stitched beautifully, usually sits atop his head. He wears a bandana-like scarf around his neck. The rest of his body is covered in different shades of denim. Holding his jeans up is a brown belt with a massive oval buckle.AdvertisementHe developed a passion for horses at an early age. His neighbors and extended family owned horses — that was his introduction to the animal. His relationship with them felt personal. By the time he was 11, he was training them on his own.“He was […]
Fan-Kritik an ihrem Aussehen – Mutter verteidigt Alisha Lehmann
Star-Fußballerin Alisha Lehmann (26) versorgt ihre Fans regelmäßig mit Schnappschüssen aus ihrem Leben. Auf Instagram folgen der Juventus-Spielerin satte 16,6 Millionen Follower. Im April holte sie mit Italien-Klub Turin die Meisterschaft und nahm bei der Party-Sause wie immer ihre Fans mit. Am Samstag gelang Juve sogar das Double mit dem Gewinn des Pokals nach dem 4:0-Sieg im Finale gegen die AS Rom. Kritiker warfen ihr zuletzt vor, dass sie sich mehr auf ihre Rolle als Influencerin als auf den Fußball konzentrieren würde. Fakt ist: In der laufenden Spielzeit erzielte Lehmann zwei Treffer in 22 Pflichtspielen. Lesen Sie auch<!-->[-->Jetzt bekommt sie Rückendeckung von ihrer Mama!Auf Instagram schreibt Sarah Guggisberg, die Mutter von Alisha Lehmann: „Schade, dass ihr immer wieder so negativ über meine Tochter lästern müsst. Sie ist geschminkt, ja und? Sie spielt seit Jahren in der höchsten Liga. Ganz sicher […]
Tennis wants its spectators to provide atmosphere, but abuse of players persists at tournaments
Welcome back to the Monday Tennis Briefing, where The Athletic will explain the stories behind the stories from the past week on court.This week, fan behavior was a key topic at the Italian Open, French Open preparations escalated — in esports — and American college tennis changed things up regarding the U.S. Open.If you’d like to follow our fantastic tennis coverage, click here.When does tennis decide to intervene on crowd behavior — and should it?While Carlos Alcaraz danced through the second set of the Italian Open final against Jannik Sinner, he did so in near total quiet. As it had done throughout the tournament, the crowd at the Foro Italico in Rome made its feelings known — this time with silence, rather than rancor.During her quarterfinal defeat against Zheng Qinwen, world No. 1 Aryna Sabalenka told a fan to “shut the […]
Nine numbers that reflect the state of the up-and-down Cleveland Guardians
The Cleveland Guardians need a sweep of the Cincinnati Reds next month or they’ll relinquish the Ohio Cup to their Buckeye State foes for the first time since 2014. These are desperate times in northeast Ohio.Let’s examine some numbers that shed some light on the Guardians’ state of play as they embark on a week of in-division play against the Minnesota Twins and Detroit Tigers, the two teams ahead of them in the AL Central.Advertisement29th: Guardians right fielders’ rank, by OPS, among the league’s 30 teamsThat OPS, by the way, was a meager .526 entering Sunday. Only the Royals’ right fielders have been less productive. Jhonkensy Noel is 12-for-80 with 27 strikeouts. Nolan Jones is 19-for-105 with 36 strikeouts. For an offense that, as a whole, ranks 21st in OPS, this has been the greatest problem area. Lane Thomas could […]
Related
Manchester City appoint Hannah Dingley, ex-Forest Green manager, as girls’ Head of Academy
Hannah Dingley, the first woman to take charge of a men’s side in England’s top four divisions, has been appointed girls’ Head of Academy at Manchester City.Dingley was named caretaker manager of Forest Green Rovers — where she was head of the club’s academy — in July 2023, overseeing a friendly draw against Melksham Town that month, but was not appointed on a permanent basis.City say that Dingley’s role will be to ‘establish a clear pathway for youth players into the senior team while implementing our philosophy and methodology across individual athletes and teams’.Dingley said upon her appointment: “City is a leading force in women’s football and I am really excited to be joining such an ambitious and progressive club.”Charlotte O’Neill, City’s managing director, highlighted how the club’s youth graduates Gracie Prior, Lily Murphy and Codie Thomas all became part […]
Francesco Farioli announces Ajax exit day after missing out on league title
Ajax manager Francesco Farioli has announced his decision to leave the club after just a single season in charge.The news comes just a day after Ajax’s collapse in the title run-in led to PSV Eindhoven winning the Dutch title on a tense final day in the Eredivisie. Ajax blew a nine-point lead at the top of the table, and despite winning their final game of the season against FC Twente on Sunday, still had to settle for second place due to PSV’s 3-1 away victory over Sparta Rotterdam on the same day. AdvertisementFarioli repeatedly refused to confirm he would be staying on following Sunday’s game and leaves saying he and the club’s hierarchy have “different visions” on how to take the club forward.“My journey at Ajax started almost one year ago, at De Toekomst, with the aim of bringing Ajax back to […]
Tyler Batty, a rookie DL for the Vikings and son of a cowboy, is easy to root for
How many horses does Layne Batty own? It’s a question he doesn’t want to answer. He has nothing to hide. It’s just that if he were to say the number out loud, his wife, Peg, might cut him off from buying and raising more.Layne is a cowboy in every sense of the word. A white hat, stitched beautifully, usually sits atop his head. He wears a bandana-like scarf around his neck. The rest of his body is covered in different shades of denim. Holding his jeans up is a brown belt with a massive oval buckle.AdvertisementHe developed a passion for horses at an early age. His neighbors and extended family owned horses — that was his introduction to the animal. His relationship with them felt personal. By the time he was 11, he was training them on his own.“He was […]
Fan-Kritik an ihrem Aussehen – Mutter verteidigt Alisha Lehmann
Star-Fußballerin Alisha Lehmann (26) versorgt ihre Fans regelmäßig mit Schnappschüssen aus ihrem Leben. Auf Instagram folgen der Juventus-Spielerin satte 16,6 Millionen Follower. Im April holte sie mit Italien-Klub Turin die Meisterschaft und nahm bei der Party-Sause wie immer ihre Fans mit. Am Samstag gelang Juve sogar das Double mit dem Gewinn des Pokals nach dem 4:0-Sieg im Finale gegen die AS Rom. Kritiker warfen ihr zuletzt vor, dass sie sich mehr auf ihre Rolle als Influencerin als auf den Fußball konzentrieren würde. Fakt ist: In der laufenden Spielzeit erzielte Lehmann zwei Treffer in 22 Pflichtspielen. Lesen Sie auch<!-->[-->Jetzt bekommt sie Rückendeckung von ihrer Mama!Auf Instagram schreibt Sarah Guggisberg, die Mutter von Alisha Lehmann: „Schade, dass ihr immer wieder so negativ über meine Tochter lästern müsst. Sie ist geschminkt, ja und? Sie spielt seit Jahren in der höchsten Liga. Ganz sicher […]
Tennis wants its spectators to provide atmosphere, but abuse of players persists at tournaments
Welcome back to the Monday Tennis Briefing, where The Athletic will explain the stories behind the stories from the past week on court.This week, fan behavior was a key topic at the Italian Open, French Open preparations escalated — in esports — and American college tennis changed things up regarding the U.S. Open.If you’d like to follow our fantastic tennis coverage, click here.When does tennis decide to intervene on crowd behavior — and should it?While Carlos Alcaraz danced through the second set of the Italian Open final against Jannik Sinner, he did so in near total quiet. As it had done throughout the tournament, the crowd at the Foro Italico in Rome made its feelings known — this time with silence, rather than rancor.During her quarterfinal defeat against Zheng Qinwen, world No. 1 Aryna Sabalenka told a fan to “shut the […]
Nine numbers that reflect the state of the up-and-down Cleveland Guardians
The Cleveland Guardians need a sweep of the Cincinnati Reds next month or they’ll relinquish the Ohio Cup to their Buckeye State foes for the first time since 2014. These are desperate times in northeast Ohio.Let’s examine some numbers that shed some light on the Guardians’ state of play as they embark on a week of in-division play against the Minnesota Twins and Detroit Tigers, the two teams ahead of them in the AL Central.Advertisement29th: Guardians right fielders’ rank, by OPS, among the league’s 30 teamsThat OPS, by the way, was a meager .526 entering Sunday. Only the Royals’ right fielders have been less productive. Jhonkensy Noel is 12-for-80 with 27 strikeouts. Nolan Jones is 19-for-105 with 36 strikeouts. For an offense that, as a whole, ranks 21st in OPS, this has been the greatest problem area. Lane Thomas could […]
Be the first to leave a comment