First-year North Carolina coach Bill Belichick has dominated college football headlines this offseason.
Belichick was always going to elicit outsized interest as many are fascinated to see how the NFL’s greatest coach will fare in his first foray into college football. However, the attention has surpassed anything anyone could have imagined as Belichick’s off-field life has shaped the narrative over the past few months.
It’s what his standing in CBS Sports’ annual coach rankings such a fascinating question. What do you value more: the six Super Bowls with the New England Patriots or the fact he’s never coached a college football game?
In the end, there was a wide disparity between our voters. Belichick finished No. 54 in the rankings, behind coaches such as Vanderbilt’s Clark Lea, Boston College’s Bill O’Brien (who worked for him in New England) and Michigan State’s Jonathan Smith.
We asked the voter highest on Belichick (John Talty at No. 19) and lowest (Richard Johnson at No. 67) to explain their thinking.
Complete Power Four coach rankings: 1-25 | 26-68
Why Belichick should be ranked at the bottom
My rationale is simple here, there are two men who have never coached college football at all in this group: Bill Belichick and Frank Reich. Belichick was a better NFL coach so he beat out Reich, but I have them second to last and last in my rankings on principle. Hiring the best coach of all time sounds good in a vacuum, but there is just no telling how good he’s actually going to be.
First of all, North Carolina wasn’t exactly great under Mack Brown — which is the reason why Belichick is in the job anyway. The Pats were also middling to terrible in his last three seasons as head coach — which is the reason he’s not still in that job. If you’re predicting anything beyond “I don’t know” when it comes to Belichick as a college football coach this year, it’s based on prior success with Tom Brady, which is not the reality of this current situation. He’s not that guy, and Heels aren’t that team, it’s just deeply unclear how good he can actually be. — Richard Johnson
Why Belichick is a top-20 coach
Call me crazy, but I’m betting on the NFL’s greatest coach finding a way to win in a wide-open ACC. Outside of Clemson, there aren’t any ACC teams on the schedule that feel like definite losses for Belichick’s Tar Heels. I believe in Belichick’s ability to get the most out of South Alabama QB transfer Gio Lopez and the rest of a moderately talented roster and win at least eight games in Year 1.
Will UNC compete for national championships under Belichick? Unlikely, but you never know. Can he elevate UNC and out-coach some teams that don’t exactly wow you with their Xs and Os prowess? Absolutely. We’ve seen successful NFL coaches like Lovie Smith fail in their transition to the college game, but Belichick is the best to ever attempt it and the one whose unrelenting desire to find any and every schematic advantage possible gives him a leg up on many of his new peers. I’m out on an island in my Belichick ranking but don’t be surprised to see him take a big leap in our rankings next year. — John Talty
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
Orioles sign/activate utility man Cooper Hummel
Feb 26, 2025; West Palm Beach, Florida, USA; Houston Astros outfielder Cooper Hummel (1) returns to the dugout following the third inning against the Washington Nationals at CACTI Park of the Palm Beaches. Mandatory Credit: Reinhold Matay-Imagn Images The Baltimore Orioles signed utility man Cooper Hummel to a free-agent deal and activated him to the active roster Sunday. In a corresponding move, infielder Terrin Vavra was designated for assignment. Hummel, 30, was released from his minor league contract by the New York Yankees on Saturday. He batted .258 with two RBIs and six runs in 10 games with Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre. Hummel also spent time with the Houston Astros in spring training before he was designated for assignment right before Opening Day. In parts of three major league seasons for the Arizona Diamondbacks (2022), Seattle Mariners (2023) and Astros (2024), Hummel […]
Orioles sign/activate utility man Cooper Hummel
Feb 26, 2025; West Palm Beach, Florida, USA; Houston Astros outfielder Cooper Hummel (1) returns to the dugout following the third inning against the Washington Nationals at CACTI Park of the Palm Beaches. Mandatory Credit: Reinhold Matay-Imagn Images The Baltimore Orioles signed utility man Cooper Hummel to a free-agent deal and activated him to the active roster Sunday. In a corresponding move, infielder Terrin Vavra was designated for assignment. Hummel, 30, was released from his minor league contract by the New York Yankees on Saturday. He batted .258 with two RBIs and six runs in 10 games with Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre. Hummel also spent time with the Houston Astros in spring training before he was designated for assignment right before Opening Day. In parts of three major league seasons for the Arizona Diamondbacks (2022), Seattle Mariners (2023) and Astros (2024), Hummel […]
Nadal se loučil s fanoušky na Roland Garros, neubránil se slzám
„Je to těžké,“ řekl Nadal během proslovu. „Nevím, kde po 20 letech hraní na tomto kurtu začít. Byla tu vítězství, porážky, ale hlavně dojetí pokaždé, když jsem tady mohl být,“ uvedl osmatřicetiletý Španěl.Místo sportovního oděvu známého z dřívějších let přišel na kurt v tmavém obleku a společenské košili. Na celoplošné obrazovce zhlédl vzpomínkové video a užil si ovace zhruba 15 tisíc fanoušků vestoje. Většina z diváků měla oranžová trička s bílým nápisem „Merci Rafa“. Skandovali také jeho přezdívku.Nadal má na Roland Garros bilanci 112 výher a čtyř porážek. Vyhrál všech 14 finálových duelů, do kterých nastoupil. Naposledy uspěl v roce 2022. Na antukovém grandslamu startoval ještě vloni, tehdy ale dohrál v 1. kole, když nestačil na Němce Alexandera Zvereva. „Byl to bezpochyby nejdůležitější turnaj mé tenisové kariéry,“ uvedl Nadal, který zde ještě hrál během loňských olympijských her.Při ceremoniálu poděkoval organizátorům turnaje, trenérům i své rodině. Na kurt za ním přišli také jeho bývalí rivalové Djokovič, Federer […]
Aston Villa denied Champions League qualification by dramatic referee error vs. Manchester United
Getty Images The final day of the Premier League season often ends with thoughts about what might have been if that one moment had broken their way. Rarely, though, does regretfulness and frustration come with the immediacy that it does for Aston Villa, who might reasonably conclude that they would be playing Champions League football -- and probably be $50 million or more better off -- had it not been for a critical error by their officials. A 2-0 loss to Manchester United on Sunday might have been a draw. It might even have been a 1-0 win. If only Thomas Bramall hadn't blown up so expeditiously when Morgan Rogers snuck in to punish an Altay Bayindir error.Villa, who had seen their goalkeeper Emiliano Martinez sent off in the first half for a foul on Rasmus Hojlund, thought they had […]
Indiana Pacers Are Six Wins From a Title, and It’s Time We Took Them Seriously
Not many people would have felt the Indiana Pacers were the best team in the NBA when the postseason began five weeks ago.It’s starting to feel a little bit different with the club just six victories away from its first NBA title. The Oklahoma City Thunder are the best team still playing basketball, but the Pacers now might be the most likely team to win the NBA Finals. The Pacers seem to have that aura — not to mention the much-needed playoff magic. They are a squad filled with team players, and anybody can be their brightest star on any given night. Just look at the first two games of the Eastern Conference finals against the host New York Knicks. The Pacers should have been ready to wave the white flag in Game 1 when they trailed by 14 with […]
Indiana Pacers Are Six Wins From a Title, and It’s Time We Took Them Seriously
Not many people would have felt the Indiana Pacers were the best team in the NBA when the postseason began five weeks ago.It’s starting to feel a little bit different with the club just six victories away from its first NBA title. The Oklahoma City Thunder are the best team still playing basketball, but the Pacers now might be the most likely team to win the NBA Finals. The Pacers seem to have that aura — not to mention the much-needed playoff magic. They are a squad filled with team players, and anybody can be their brightest star on any given night. Just look at the first two games of the Eastern Conference finals against the host New York Knicks. The Pacers should have been ready to wave the white flag in Game 1 when they trailed by 14 with […]
Related
Orioles sign/activate utility man Cooper Hummel
Feb 26, 2025; West Palm Beach, Florida, USA; Houston Astros outfielder Cooper Hummel (1) returns to the dugout following the third inning against the Washington Nationals at CACTI Park of the Palm Beaches. Mandatory Credit: Reinhold Matay-Imagn Images The Baltimore Orioles signed utility man Cooper Hummel to a free-agent deal and activated him to the active roster Sunday. In a corresponding move, infielder Terrin Vavra was designated for assignment. Hummel, 30, was released from his minor league contract by the New York Yankees on Saturday. He batted .258 with two RBIs and six runs in 10 games with Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre. Hummel also spent time with the Houston Astros in spring training before he was designated for assignment right before Opening Day. In parts of three major league seasons for the Arizona Diamondbacks (2022), Seattle Mariners (2023) and Astros (2024), Hummel […]
Orioles sign/activate utility man Cooper Hummel
Feb 26, 2025; West Palm Beach, Florida, USA; Houston Astros outfielder Cooper Hummel (1) returns to the dugout following the third inning against the Washington Nationals at CACTI Park of the Palm Beaches. Mandatory Credit: Reinhold Matay-Imagn Images The Baltimore Orioles signed utility man Cooper Hummel to a free-agent deal and activated him to the active roster Sunday. In a corresponding move, infielder Terrin Vavra was designated for assignment. Hummel, 30, was released from his minor league contract by the New York Yankees on Saturday. He batted .258 with two RBIs and six runs in 10 games with Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre. Hummel also spent time with the Houston Astros in spring training before he was designated for assignment right before Opening Day. In parts of three major league seasons for the Arizona Diamondbacks (2022), Seattle Mariners (2023) and Astros (2024), Hummel […]
Nadal se loučil s fanoušky na Roland Garros, neubránil se slzám
„Je to těžké,“ řekl Nadal během proslovu. „Nevím, kde po 20 letech hraní na tomto kurtu začít. Byla tu vítězství, porážky, ale hlavně dojetí pokaždé, když jsem tady mohl být,“ uvedl osmatřicetiletý Španěl.Místo sportovního oděvu známého z dřívějších let přišel na kurt v tmavém obleku a společenské košili. Na celoplošné obrazovce zhlédl vzpomínkové video a užil si ovace zhruba 15 tisíc fanoušků vestoje. Většina z diváků měla oranžová trička s bílým nápisem „Merci Rafa“. Skandovali také jeho přezdívku.Nadal má na Roland Garros bilanci 112 výher a čtyř porážek. Vyhrál všech 14 finálových duelů, do kterých nastoupil. Naposledy uspěl v roce 2022. Na antukovém grandslamu startoval ještě vloni, tehdy ale dohrál v 1. kole, když nestačil na Němce Alexandera Zvereva. „Byl to bezpochyby nejdůležitější turnaj mé tenisové kariéry,“ uvedl Nadal, který zde ještě hrál během loňských olympijských her.Při ceremoniálu poděkoval organizátorům turnaje, trenérům i své rodině. Na kurt za ním přišli také jeho bývalí rivalové Djokovič, Federer […]
Aston Villa denied Champions League qualification by dramatic referee error vs. Manchester United
Getty Images The final day of the Premier League season often ends with thoughts about what might have been if that one moment had broken their way. Rarely, though, does regretfulness and frustration come with the immediacy that it does for Aston Villa, who might reasonably conclude that they would be playing Champions League football -- and probably be $50 million or more better off -- had it not been for a critical error by their officials. A 2-0 loss to Manchester United on Sunday might have been a draw. It might even have been a 1-0 win. If only Thomas Bramall hadn't blown up so expeditiously when Morgan Rogers snuck in to punish an Altay Bayindir error.Villa, who had seen their goalkeeper Emiliano Martinez sent off in the first half for a foul on Rasmus Hojlund, thought they had […]
Indiana Pacers Are Six Wins From a Title, and It’s Time We Took Them Seriously
Not many people would have felt the Indiana Pacers were the best team in the NBA when the postseason began five weeks ago.It’s starting to feel a little bit different with the club just six victories away from its first NBA title. The Oklahoma City Thunder are the best team still playing basketball, but the Pacers now might be the most likely team to win the NBA Finals. The Pacers seem to have that aura — not to mention the much-needed playoff magic. They are a squad filled with team players, and anybody can be their brightest star on any given night. Just look at the first two games of the Eastern Conference finals against the host New York Knicks. The Pacers should have been ready to wave the white flag in Game 1 when they trailed by 14 with […]
Indiana Pacers Are Six Wins From a Title, and It’s Time We Took Them Seriously
Not many people would have felt the Indiana Pacers were the best team in the NBA when the postseason began five weeks ago.It’s starting to feel a little bit different with the club just six victories away from its first NBA title. The Oklahoma City Thunder are the best team still playing basketball, but the Pacers now might be the most likely team to win the NBA Finals. The Pacers seem to have that aura — not to mention the much-needed playoff magic. They are a squad filled with team players, and anybody can be their brightest star on any given night. Just look at the first two games of the Eastern Conference finals against the host New York Knicks. The Pacers should have been ready to wave the white flag in Game 1 when they trailed by 14 with […]
Be the first to leave a comment