Generally, hitters are correctly viewed as the back of their baseball cards. Any performance that deviates too far from that, especially regarding veteran hitters, is viewed as more of a fluke than a fact. Pitchers are different, given there are so many ways for them to radically improve or decline and sustain those new levels. Again, we should be skeptical when a player’s hitting significantly changes.
Advertisement
However, we now have new data: expected stats. If hitters are improving their contact profiles at a fundamental level a third of the way into the season, supported by their year-over-year data from Statcast/Baseball Savant, does that warrant a fresh projection? If that’s the case, some hitters are currently undervalued based on Yahoo roster rates. Additionally, some hitters have had an unexpected collapse in contact performance, with their fantasy managers still holding steady based on the baseball-card theory for hitting projections.
Pick up if possible?
Jorge Polanco (SEA, 3B) is 55% rostered. He’s been a 95th-percentile hitter in expected stats, and he’s improved 30.4% from 2024 (through Monday). He’s been a good hitter in the past, but we thought those days were over, even at age 31, given how he declined from 2023 to 2024. He doesn’t strike out much, has a top barrel rate and average bat speed. Polanco is an extreme pull hitter, making up for his suboptimal fly-ball rate. Expect the power to continue at the current pace, along with a top average.
Michael Busch (CHC, 1B) is 48% rostered. Everything is up across the board in his hitting stats, and his expected xwOBA is in the top 15%. He’s improved 17.2% in the stat from 2024. The K rate is still bad, but it’s down to 25% from 28.6% in 2024. Bat speed holds him down in the power department (he only has five expected homers, two fewer than his actual number). This roster rate feels about right, but you could do worse.
Colt Keith (DET, 2B) is 12% rostered. He’s a strong-side platoon option who has not hit lefties. But he’s getting more plate appearances against lefties than in 2024, so this doesn’t account for his 17.4% boost in expected performance compared to last year. He was viewed as a top college hitter and, as a top 20% MLB bat in these expected stats, he’s beginning to realize that potential.
Advertisement
Ryan Jeffers (MIN, C) is just 17% rostered. Even in one-catcher leagues, this roster rate is too low. He’s been batting leadoff. There’s no reason he can’t finish the season at a 20-homer pace. His Ks are down so much that he should help at least a little in batting average. His 75th-percentile walk rate should keep him in the leadoff spot even when Byron Buxton returns. He had an .859 actual OPS in 2023, when his xwOBA was less than what it is now (.333 vs. today’s .352 — 72nd percentile).
Reassess?
These players are slumping badly, but no one seems to believe it. Should w,e though? All are very young players in MLB experience.
Lawrence Butler (ATH, OF) is delivering homers and steals at the rates we wanted, but he’s been an unexceptional hitter overall — actual OPS of .729 vs. .807 last year and an almost identical 9% decline in xwOBA. His whiff rate on breaking balls is 48.2%, compared to 26.9% last year. He has adjustments to make, but can he make them on the fly?
Jackson Chourio (MIL, OF) is, like Butler, undroppable for the homers and steals. But he’s still a big disappointment, failing to pick up where he left off as one of the game’s best hitters in the second half of 2024. His OPS is just .695. His expected stats are down 11.9% — gross! He’s chasing way more than last year (3rd percentile). He’s a 16th-percentile hitter. Coming into the season, I wanted all the Chourio I could get, and I obviously got ahead of myself.
Gunnar Henderson (BAL, SS) is surprisingly a below-average hitter in expected statistics and has arguably gotten lucky to have only a 108-point OPS decline from 2024. The Ks are moving in the wrong direction. He’s also struggling with breaking balls, whiffing on 42%, compared to 26% last year. Sometimes the pitchers force you to adjust and address your weaknesses. This could change at any time, given his talent, particularly his bat speed, which is in the 93rd percentile. Jackson Holliday (70% rostered) has actually been a better hitter, though he has a lower ceiling due to much less bat speed.
Hold steady?
Now, some general words on hitters who are way off with actual stats. What do their expected stats say?
Juan Soto (NYM, OF) was fairly discussed early in the “Sunday Night Baseball” telecast, which touched on the inescapable point that Soto is probably MLB’s most unlucky hitter right now. Then the announcers spent the next two hours ripping him at every at-bat for all the things he’s doing wrong. It was quite bizarre. His expected stats are down 8%, but from a remarkably high level. He’s solidly a top-10 overall hitter in the data. He is owed a white-hot month or two.
Advertisement
Mookie Betts (LAD, SS) is down 5% in expected stats but is only a 50th-percentile hitter. That’s shocking. He’s 84th overall in xwOBA — Soto is fifth. Betts has lost so much bat speed – from 71 mph in 2023 to 69 in 2024 and now 68 mph this season, which is 14th percentile. He has to be nearly perfect in squaring up the baseball to produce. That’s a tough way to make a living.
Elly De La Cruz (CIN, SS) is only down 1% from last year in expected stats, but is unable to overcome it by outpacing gravity in 2025. So while his 8% decline in actual stats may seem like a fluke, it isn’t. He’s crushing steals with 17 (pace of about 50), though that’s also disappointing for someone who stole 67 last season. His homers are on track to replicate his 2024 mark of 25. He’s sort of in Julio Rodriguez land as a hitter who just isn’t breaking out the way we’ve built it into his cost. You may wish you had taken the new Cruz — Oneil — at Elly’s price instead. They’re basically the same player, though Elly strikes out marginally less.
(Top photo of Mookie Betts: Gary A. Vasquez / Imagn Images)
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
Packers WR Jayden Reed clarifies report about role: ‘A lot of people misinterpreted that’
GREEN BAY, Wis. — Packers wide receiver Jayden Reed knew what reporters wanted to ask even before fielding his first question of the offseason.“Y’all been waiting to hear from me, huh?” Reed said as he walked in front of microphones at Lambeau Field after Wednesday’s OTA practice.ESPN’s Adam Schefter reported that in early May, Reed’s new agent, Drew Rosenhaus, met with general manager Brian Gutekunst to clarify Reed’s role after the Packers drafted wide receivers Matthew Golden in the first round and Savion Williams in the third. Schefter reported that the Packers informed Rosenhaus that those draft picks wouldn’t affect Reed’s status as their top receiver.The question lingered whether Reed was unsettled after the draft and wanted reassurance about his depth chart standing or if Rosenhaus had spoken with Gutekunst on his own.“A lot of people misinterpreted that,” Reed said. […]
Potential of a surprise Crown witness sparks courtroom spat at Hockey Canada trial
LONDON, Ont. – Prosecutors have introduced the possibility of a surprise player witness in the Hockey Canada sexual assault trial.In an animated exchange at the end of Wednesday’s proceedings, Crown attorney Meaghan Cunningham told Justice Maria Carroccia that the Crown was “nearing the end” of its case but that there were some “late-breaking events” about an additional witness who may be called, prompting defense attorney Megan Savard to object to the timing.Advertisement“Sorry, Your Honor,” Savard said. “This was, I think, the first we’re hearing that this is not the Crown’s last witness.”Savard said that the defense was just learning about this development and asked the Crown to make a decision by the end of Wednesday’s proceedings to provide the defense ample notice to prepare its own evidence. Carroccia rejected that bid from Savard, stating that Cunningham was “entitled to think […]
Grêmio tenta, mas Juventude faz jogo duro para negociar o volante Caíque, destaque da equipe
Volante do Juventude tem sido sondado pelo Grêmio (Foto: Divulgação/Juventude) O Grêmio já vem buscando se movimentar no mercado da bola à espera da abertura da janela de transferências do meio do ano. O meio-campo é uma das posições mais visadas pelo clube e um dos nomes desejados é o de Caíque Negociação difícil O atleta do Juventude foi alvo de sondagem gremista, segundo informação do GE, para se tornar uma espécie de ‘terceiro homem do meio-campo’, ajudando na criação. No entanto, o Alviverde da Serra Gaúcha não tem o interesse em negociar o jogador com o rival estadual neste momento. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADE Para os dirigentes do Papo, a proposta financeira a qual o Grêmio estaria acenando para contratar o volante estaria abaixo dos valores aos quais poderia considerar conversar. Outro ponto é que o clube vê o atleta, que […]
Commanders OTA practice features a ‘little bit thicker’ version of Jayden Daniels
ASHBURN, Va. — How does Jayden Daniels follow one of the most powerful rookie seasons in NFL history? Get stronger.“Put on a little muscle, huh? Yeah, for sure,” said center Tyler Biadasz, one of the blockers tasked with protecting the Washington Commanders’ franchise quarterback. “He said what he was going to do, and he did it.”AdvertisementLet’s be clear: Daniels will never be confused physically with quarterback behemoths like reigning MVP Josh Allen or Cam Newton, even if the 210-pounder’s arms appeared a smidge bulkier on Wednesday at the start of organized team activities. The coaching staff did not demand that the Southern California native spend his offseason lifting weights at Los Angeles’ famed Muscle Beach.Still, fans were abuzz on social media about a potentially swole Daniels. The always even-keeled quarterback smiled when asked about his fitness regimen.“I was just in […]
Torcedores do Flamengo criticam bônus de gols exigido por Memphis Depay em 2024: “Loucura”
Memphis Depay em ação pelo Corinthians (Rodrigo Coca/Ag. Corinthians) Memphis Depay, antes de fechar com o Corinthians, teve seu nome ventilado no Flamengo. De acordo com o GE, o pacote atrelado ao atacante, que exigiu cifras milionárias, fez o clube descartar qualquer tipo de investida. Isso porque o custo do jogador, que chegaria ganhando R$ 4 milhões por mês com o somatório de salário, premiações e luvas, tornou a situação totalmente inviável. Salário de R$ 2 milhões por mês livre de impostos. Luvas de 4 milhões de euros (R$ 25 milhões). Contrato de 27 meses. Além do salário elevado, Memphis Depay queria receber bonificações ao balançar as redes em torneios nacionais e internacionais (R$ 200 a R$ 400 mil). Por fim, gatilhos envolvendo convocações e gols na seleção holandesa também estariam presentes no contrato, algo que trouxe um sentimento de […]
Thunder e Pacers com pés na final? Viradas de 3 a 1 são raras na NBA; veja lista
As finais de conferência da NBA, que seguem nesta quarta-feira com o jogo 5 entre Oklahoma City Thunder e Minnesota Timberwolves, no Oeste, têm vencedores altamente prováveis. Pelo menos é o que dizem as estatísticas históricas da liga. Vencendo suas séries por 3 a 1, tanto o Thunder quanto o Indiana Pacers, que enfrenta o New York Knicks no Leste, precisam evitar a virada desse placar, um cenário que só aconteceu 13 vezes na história dos playoffs. A primeira vez que uma equipe virou um 3 a 1 foi em 1968, quando o formato de conferências ainda não existia. O Boston Celtics superou o Philadelphia 76ers nas finais da Divisão Leste. A mais recente foi há cinco anos, quando o Denver Nuggets virou sobre o Los Angeles Clippers na semifinal do Oeste de 2020. No mesmo ano, os Nuggets já […]
Related
Packers WR Jayden Reed clarifies report about role: ‘A lot of people misinterpreted that’
GREEN BAY, Wis. — Packers wide receiver Jayden Reed knew what reporters wanted to ask even before fielding his first question of the offseason.“Y’all been waiting to hear from me, huh?” Reed said as he walked in front of microphones at Lambeau Field after Wednesday’s OTA practice.ESPN’s Adam Schefter reported that in early May, Reed’s new agent, Drew Rosenhaus, met with general manager Brian Gutekunst to clarify Reed’s role after the Packers drafted wide receivers Matthew Golden in the first round and Savion Williams in the third. Schefter reported that the Packers informed Rosenhaus that those draft picks wouldn’t affect Reed’s status as their top receiver.The question lingered whether Reed was unsettled after the draft and wanted reassurance about his depth chart standing or if Rosenhaus had spoken with Gutekunst on his own.“A lot of people misinterpreted that,” Reed said. […]
Potential of a surprise Crown witness sparks courtroom spat at Hockey Canada trial
LONDON, Ont. – Prosecutors have introduced the possibility of a surprise player witness in the Hockey Canada sexual assault trial.In an animated exchange at the end of Wednesday’s proceedings, Crown attorney Meaghan Cunningham told Justice Maria Carroccia that the Crown was “nearing the end” of its case but that there were some “late-breaking events” about an additional witness who may be called, prompting defense attorney Megan Savard to object to the timing.Advertisement“Sorry, Your Honor,” Savard said. “This was, I think, the first we’re hearing that this is not the Crown’s last witness.”Savard said that the defense was just learning about this development and asked the Crown to make a decision by the end of Wednesday’s proceedings to provide the defense ample notice to prepare its own evidence. Carroccia rejected that bid from Savard, stating that Cunningham was “entitled to think […]
Grêmio tenta, mas Juventude faz jogo duro para negociar o volante Caíque, destaque da equipe
Volante do Juventude tem sido sondado pelo Grêmio (Foto: Divulgação/Juventude) O Grêmio já vem buscando se movimentar no mercado da bola à espera da abertura da janela de transferências do meio do ano. O meio-campo é uma das posições mais visadas pelo clube e um dos nomes desejados é o de Caíque Negociação difícil O atleta do Juventude foi alvo de sondagem gremista, segundo informação do GE, para se tornar uma espécie de ‘terceiro homem do meio-campo’, ajudando na criação. No entanto, o Alviverde da Serra Gaúcha não tem o interesse em negociar o jogador com o rival estadual neste momento. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADE Para os dirigentes do Papo, a proposta financeira a qual o Grêmio estaria acenando para contratar o volante estaria abaixo dos valores aos quais poderia considerar conversar. Outro ponto é que o clube vê o atleta, que […]
Commanders OTA practice features a ‘little bit thicker’ version of Jayden Daniels
ASHBURN, Va. — How does Jayden Daniels follow one of the most powerful rookie seasons in NFL history? Get stronger.“Put on a little muscle, huh? Yeah, for sure,” said center Tyler Biadasz, one of the blockers tasked with protecting the Washington Commanders’ franchise quarterback. “He said what he was going to do, and he did it.”AdvertisementLet’s be clear: Daniels will never be confused physically with quarterback behemoths like reigning MVP Josh Allen or Cam Newton, even if the 210-pounder’s arms appeared a smidge bulkier on Wednesday at the start of organized team activities. The coaching staff did not demand that the Southern California native spend his offseason lifting weights at Los Angeles’ famed Muscle Beach.Still, fans were abuzz on social media about a potentially swole Daniels. The always even-keeled quarterback smiled when asked about his fitness regimen.“I was just in […]
Torcedores do Flamengo criticam bônus de gols exigido por Memphis Depay em 2024: “Loucura”
Memphis Depay em ação pelo Corinthians (Rodrigo Coca/Ag. Corinthians) Memphis Depay, antes de fechar com o Corinthians, teve seu nome ventilado no Flamengo. De acordo com o GE, o pacote atrelado ao atacante, que exigiu cifras milionárias, fez o clube descartar qualquer tipo de investida. Isso porque o custo do jogador, que chegaria ganhando R$ 4 milhões por mês com o somatório de salário, premiações e luvas, tornou a situação totalmente inviável. Salário de R$ 2 milhões por mês livre de impostos. Luvas de 4 milhões de euros (R$ 25 milhões). Contrato de 27 meses. Além do salário elevado, Memphis Depay queria receber bonificações ao balançar as redes em torneios nacionais e internacionais (R$ 200 a R$ 400 mil). Por fim, gatilhos envolvendo convocações e gols na seleção holandesa também estariam presentes no contrato, algo que trouxe um sentimento de […]
Thunder e Pacers com pés na final? Viradas de 3 a 1 são raras na NBA; veja lista
As finais de conferência da NBA, que seguem nesta quarta-feira com o jogo 5 entre Oklahoma City Thunder e Minnesota Timberwolves, no Oeste, têm vencedores altamente prováveis. Pelo menos é o que dizem as estatísticas históricas da liga. Vencendo suas séries por 3 a 1, tanto o Thunder quanto o Indiana Pacers, que enfrenta o New York Knicks no Leste, precisam evitar a virada desse placar, um cenário que só aconteceu 13 vezes na história dos playoffs. A primeira vez que uma equipe virou um 3 a 1 foi em 1968, quando o formato de conferências ainda não existia. O Boston Celtics superou o Philadelphia 76ers nas finais da Divisão Leste. A mais recente foi há cinco anos, quando o Denver Nuggets virou sobre o Los Angeles Clippers na semifinal do Oeste de 2020. No mesmo ano, os Nuggets já […]
Be the first to leave a comment