(This article was written with the assistance of Castmagic, an AI tool, and reviewed by our editorial team to ensure accuracy. Please reach out to us if you notice any mistakes.)
On the latest episode of “Baseball Bar-B-Cast,” Jake Mintz and Jordan Shusterman officially kicked off their 2026 World Baseball Classic (WBC) content. With Aaron Judge recently named captain of Team USA, the duo couldn’t resist diving into one of their favorite pastimes: dreaming up the most stacked, no-holds-barred Team USA rosters imaginable.
Advertisement
Here are the rules:
-
30-man roster: Standard for the WBC
-
At least 14 pitchers and two (or three) catchers: Jake and Jordan opted for three catchers, as Team USA had in 2023.
-
“Dream” means optimistic: This draft leans on hopeful speculation. Expect a few wishful leaps.
Let’s break down the hosts’ picks, debates and a few wild cards.
Catcher
-
Cal Raleigh and Adley Rutschman were locks for Shusterman and Mintz.
-
For the third spot, Jake went with defensive ace Patrick Bailey, while Jordan zagged and picked Austin Hedges for his veteran prowess, admitting that the main weakness is if Hedges has to hit.
First base
-
Bryce Harper and Pete Alonso took the spots, with both hosts agreeing that Harper’s defense makes him the starter.
-
Matt Olson got a shout-out as the toughest cut, and Freddie Freeman’s Canadian allegiance meant he wasn’t eligible.
Second base
-
Mookie Betts: Pure star power and versatility won out. Both hosts took him at second.
Shortstop
-
Bobby Witt Jr. was the hosts’ consensus starting shortstop.
-
Mintz picked Gunnar Henderson as his backup (and starting third-base option).
-
Shusterman chose Corey Seager, citing his big-game track record.
Third base
-
Shusterman stuck up for Matt Chapman’s defensive wizardry.
-
Mintz gave the hot corner to Alex Bregman.
-
Both said they would happily stash Austin Riley or Gunnar Henderson on the bench, with Riley earning the “toughest cut” label.
Utility
-
Mintz lobbied to get Tommy Edman (despite his playing for Team Korea previously) as his roster’s super-utility guy.
Outfield
-
The locks were Aaron Judge (the captain!), Mike Trout, Kyle Tucker and Corbin Carroll.
-
Kyle Schwarber made Mintz’s team as a DH/OF bench bat.
-
Center-field defense came up as a need. Mintz filled that with Corbin Carroll, and Jackson Merrill was a tough cut.
-
Mintz included Pete Crow-Armstrong as the 2026 “Bobby Witt Jr.” of outfielders: a blazing baserunner and elite defender, on the team to pinch run and patrol center field in the late innings but not swing the bat.
Starting pitching
The hardest part of this is that elite pitchers rarely all say yes to the WBC. But it’s a dream roster, so the hosts shot for the stars.
-
Locks: Tarik Skubal, Paul Skenes, Garrett Crochet, Zack Wheeler, Hunter Greene
-
Contenders: Logan Gilbert (Shusterman’s pick), Spencer Strider (Mintz’s “duh” addition), Corbin Burnes, Michael King, Logan Webb, Dylan Cease, Cole Ragans and Jacob deGrom (on a “pray he’s healthy” basis)
Relievers
-
Locks: Ryan Helsley, Josh Hader, Tanner Scott, Mason Miller and Kirby Yates
-
Contenders: Mason Montgomery, Tyler Rogers, Griffin Jax, Ryan Walker, Tyler Holton and a few others garnered enthusiastic discussion due to their versatility or unique arm angles.
-
Devin Williams was dubbed a “should be a lock, but …” after his recent wildness.
Honorable mentions & toughest cuts
-
Trey Turner: He was incredible in the previous WBC and is likely to be back, but he didn’t make the initial cut for the hosts’ dream teams.
-
Matt Olson, Marcus Semien, Austin Riley: All would be perfectly credible roster members.
-
In the outfield, Brenton Doyle, Jackson Merrill, Michael Harris II and Brice Turang as defense/speed specialists got brief consideration.
The bottom line: If half this roster shows up in 2026, the rest of the world is playing for second place.
What’s your Dream Team USA 2026 roster? Drop your picks and arguments in the comments!
For more deep dives into baseball’s hypothetical (and less hypothetical) debates, tune in to “Baseball-Bar-B-Cast” on Apple, Spotify or YouTube.
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
Colts draft Notre Dame QB Riley Leonard: How he fits, pick grade and scouting intel
The Indianapolis Colts drafted Notre Dame quarterback Riley Leonard with the No. 189 pick in the sixth round of the 2025 NFL Draft, adding an intriguing athlete who set the Fighting Irish’s rushing touchdowns record for a QB.A one-year starter at Notre Dame, Leonard transferred to the program following three seasons at Duke. Leonard put up one of the best seasons of his collegiate career with the Fighting Irish, posting career highs in completion percentage (66.7 percent) and touchdown passes (21). Leonard also flexed his abilities as a dual-threat quarterback, rushing for 906 yards and 17 touchdowns over 16 games.AdvertisementA team captain, he led the Fighting Irish to a 14-2 record and the national championship game, their first title-game appearance since 2012.An above-average athlete, the 6-foot-4, 216-pound Leonard is not as competent of a passer as other quarterbacks in the 2025 draft […]
Shedeur Sanders selected by Browns in NFL Draft: ‘Thankful for the opportunity for people to actually see the real me’
Shedeur Sanders finally found an NFL home.After a winding evaluation process that cast him as one of the NFL draft’s biggest mysteries — and following a huge slide that saw him bypassed by multiple QB-needy franchises — the Colorado Buffaloes quarterback was chosen in Saturday’s fifth round by the Cleveland Browns. Taken No. 144 overall, the pick comes following a draft slide that stunned even some of his most critical talent evaluators in the league.Sanders jumped into a pool with his socks on in celebration:"We live by our board," Browns general manager Andrew Berry told the media after the pick. "We felt like he was a good, solid prospect at the most important position. We felt it got to a point where he was probably mispriced relative to the draft. Really the acquisition cost was pretty light and it's a […]
Casagrande se revolta contra jogador ‘mimado’ no Brasileirão: “Traiçoeiro”
Casagrande, comentarista e ex-jogador (Reprodução) Cortado do jogo entre Cruzeiro x Vasco, pelo Brasileirão, Dudu foi tema da coluna de Casagrande. O colunista classificou o atacante como um jogador ‘mimado’ e que começa a dar problemas semelhantes quando ainda estava no Palmeiras. Para o comentarista, o atacante não agrega tecnicamente e pode agora minar o ambiente cruzeirense. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADE “Alguém tinha dúvida de que o ‘mimado’ Dudu iria criar problemas no Cruzeiro? Eu não tinha nenhuma dúvida. Já não era titular do Palmeiras há um tempo, é mimado, se acha mais jogador do que realmente é, além de viver num universo paralelo em relação ao seu momento atual”, iniciou Casagrande. Casagrande detona postura de Dudu No meio da semana, Dudu reclamou de ter sido colocado na reserva pelo técnico Leonardo Jardim. Publicamente, o camisa 7 questionou a decisão do comandante […]
Skip Bayless lashes out at the Cleveland Browns for drafting Shedeur Sanders
Shedeur Sanders finally heard his name called in the 2025 NFL Draft, but Skip Bayless isn't happy about it. The popular sports commentator erupted on social media after learning that the Cleveland Browns selected the former Colorado star in the fifth round, 144th overall.This year's draft was one of the most controversial in recent years. Although Cam Ward lived up to expectations by becoming the first overall pick by the Tennessee Titans, media and fans expected Shedeur to also be among the top picks.However, when it came to the crunch, every team ignored him. The son of the legendary Deion Sanders slipped through the cracks until the Browns picked him up in the fifth round, and Bayless won't forgive the NFL for this snub.Skip Bayless's angerMinutes after Sanders' selection was announced, an outraged Bayless took to his X (formerly Twitter) […]
Terence Crawford criticizes Mike Tyson’s performance against Jake Paul
Undefeated boxing champion Terence Crawford has voiced strong disapproval regarding Mike Tyson's recent exhibition bout against social media personality-turned-boxer Jake Paul. Speaking on the Club Shay Shay podcast hosted by Shannon Sharpe, Crawford made it clear that, while he respects Tyson's legacy, the fight did not reflect well on the sport or the former heavyweight champion.Shannon Sharpe almost eats a right hand from boxing champ Terence Crawford"I love Tyson," Crawford said. "Tyson shouldn't have been out there. At all." He elaborated that the match lacked competitive integrity and leaned heavily toward spectacle over substance. The fight, which drew massive attention globally, pitted the 58-year-old Tyson against the 27-year-old Paul-an age gap that was not lost on fans or experts.Crawford also took to social media following the bout, bluntly stating, "That s*** was trash," and highlighting the wide gap in punch […]
Lawrence Taylor sacks Abdul Carter’s request to wear his retired No. 56 with Giants
<!--> Abdul Carter gave it a shot, figuring he had nothing to lose.Sure, Lawrence Taylor's No. 56 is retired by the New York Giants and is one of the most revered jersey numbers in franchise history. But Carter, the third overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft on Thursday night, idolizes Taylor and wanted to see if he'd be cool with him going after quarterbacks all these years later while wearing that familiar number.Well, L.T. sacked those dreams quickly.Taylor heard of Carter's request and, while honored, thinks the former Penn State pass rusher needs to do a number on opposing offenses in something other than No. 56.ADVERTISEMENT -->"He has to be the player that he is," Taylor told ESPN. "He can’t be another Lawrence Taylor. Well, he may be better than a Lawrence Taylor. Who knows? But he has to […]
Related
Colts draft Notre Dame QB Riley Leonard: How he fits, pick grade and scouting intel
The Indianapolis Colts drafted Notre Dame quarterback Riley Leonard with the No. 189 pick in the sixth round of the 2025 NFL Draft, adding an intriguing athlete who set the Fighting Irish’s rushing touchdowns record for a QB.A one-year starter at Notre Dame, Leonard transferred to the program following three seasons at Duke. Leonard put up one of the best seasons of his collegiate career with the Fighting Irish, posting career highs in completion percentage (66.7 percent) and touchdown passes (21). Leonard also flexed his abilities as a dual-threat quarterback, rushing for 906 yards and 17 touchdowns over 16 games.AdvertisementA team captain, he led the Fighting Irish to a 14-2 record and the national championship game, their first title-game appearance since 2012.An above-average athlete, the 6-foot-4, 216-pound Leonard is not as competent of a passer as other quarterbacks in the 2025 draft […]
Shedeur Sanders selected by Browns in NFL Draft: ‘Thankful for the opportunity for people to actually see the real me’
Shedeur Sanders finally found an NFL home.After a winding evaluation process that cast him as one of the NFL draft’s biggest mysteries — and following a huge slide that saw him bypassed by multiple QB-needy franchises — the Colorado Buffaloes quarterback was chosen in Saturday’s fifth round by the Cleveland Browns. Taken No. 144 overall, the pick comes following a draft slide that stunned even some of his most critical talent evaluators in the league.Sanders jumped into a pool with his socks on in celebration:"We live by our board," Browns general manager Andrew Berry told the media after the pick. "We felt like he was a good, solid prospect at the most important position. We felt it got to a point where he was probably mispriced relative to the draft. Really the acquisition cost was pretty light and it's a […]
Casagrande se revolta contra jogador ‘mimado’ no Brasileirão: “Traiçoeiro”
Casagrande, comentarista e ex-jogador (Reprodução) Cortado do jogo entre Cruzeiro x Vasco, pelo Brasileirão, Dudu foi tema da coluna de Casagrande. O colunista classificou o atacante como um jogador ‘mimado’ e que começa a dar problemas semelhantes quando ainda estava no Palmeiras. Para o comentarista, o atacante não agrega tecnicamente e pode agora minar o ambiente cruzeirense. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADE “Alguém tinha dúvida de que o ‘mimado’ Dudu iria criar problemas no Cruzeiro? Eu não tinha nenhuma dúvida. Já não era titular do Palmeiras há um tempo, é mimado, se acha mais jogador do que realmente é, além de viver num universo paralelo em relação ao seu momento atual”, iniciou Casagrande. Casagrande detona postura de Dudu No meio da semana, Dudu reclamou de ter sido colocado na reserva pelo técnico Leonardo Jardim. Publicamente, o camisa 7 questionou a decisão do comandante […]
Skip Bayless lashes out at the Cleveland Browns for drafting Shedeur Sanders
Shedeur Sanders finally heard his name called in the 2025 NFL Draft, but Skip Bayless isn't happy about it. The popular sports commentator erupted on social media after learning that the Cleveland Browns selected the former Colorado star in the fifth round, 144th overall.This year's draft was one of the most controversial in recent years. Although Cam Ward lived up to expectations by becoming the first overall pick by the Tennessee Titans, media and fans expected Shedeur to also be among the top picks.However, when it came to the crunch, every team ignored him. The son of the legendary Deion Sanders slipped through the cracks until the Browns picked him up in the fifth round, and Bayless won't forgive the NFL for this snub.Skip Bayless's angerMinutes after Sanders' selection was announced, an outraged Bayless took to his X (formerly Twitter) […]
Terence Crawford criticizes Mike Tyson’s performance against Jake Paul
Undefeated boxing champion Terence Crawford has voiced strong disapproval regarding Mike Tyson's recent exhibition bout against social media personality-turned-boxer Jake Paul. Speaking on the Club Shay Shay podcast hosted by Shannon Sharpe, Crawford made it clear that, while he respects Tyson's legacy, the fight did not reflect well on the sport or the former heavyweight champion.Shannon Sharpe almost eats a right hand from boxing champ Terence Crawford"I love Tyson," Crawford said. "Tyson shouldn't have been out there. At all." He elaborated that the match lacked competitive integrity and leaned heavily toward spectacle over substance. The fight, which drew massive attention globally, pitted the 58-year-old Tyson against the 27-year-old Paul-an age gap that was not lost on fans or experts.Crawford also took to social media following the bout, bluntly stating, "That s*** was trash," and highlighting the wide gap in punch […]
Lawrence Taylor sacks Abdul Carter’s request to wear his retired No. 56 with Giants
<!--> Abdul Carter gave it a shot, figuring he had nothing to lose.Sure, Lawrence Taylor's No. 56 is retired by the New York Giants and is one of the most revered jersey numbers in franchise history. But Carter, the third overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft on Thursday night, idolizes Taylor and wanted to see if he'd be cool with him going after quarterbacks all these years later while wearing that familiar number.Well, L.T. sacked those dreams quickly.Taylor heard of Carter's request and, while honored, thinks the former Penn State pass rusher needs to do a number on opposing offenses in something other than No. 56.ADVERTISEMENT -->"He has to be the player that he is," Taylor told ESPN. "He can’t be another Lawrence Taylor. Well, he may be better than a Lawrence Taylor. Who knows? But he has to […]
Be the first to leave a comment