The Athletic Hockey Show NHL Draft debate: Our panel ranks the top 12 prospects

SPORTIVO
Article arrow_drop_down

By Max Bultman, Scott Wheeler and Corey Pronman

By this point in the 2025 NHL Draft cycle, you know what the top of Corey Pronman’s list looks like, just as you know Scott Wheeler’s. If you’re a regular listener to The Athletic Hockey Show Prospect Series or the Flo Hockey podcast “Called Up,” you’re also familiar with Max Bultman’s and Chris Peters’ takes on the 2025 draft class.

Advertisement

But what happens when those differing lists and perspectives are forced to collaborate and produce one shared list? Not just by taking the averages of each panelist’s ranking, but through debate, persuasion and compromise?

That was the question the most recent episode of TAHS Prospect Series set to answer. And the results lived up to the curiosity.

By the end of nearly an hour and a half debating 12 prospects, the group settled on four tiers of players ranked 1 through 12, and no one on the panel got exactly what they wanted.

Whether it was a favorite player slotted a little lower than hoped, or having to compromise high on a prospect with some risk, the collaborative nature of the process, meant to loosely mimic the process NHL teams go through to compare thoughts and produce a draft list, meant everyone had to give in somewhere.

In most cases, our panel was able to reach satisfactory conclusions and cut deals to keep everyone content, even if there were some gritted teeth involved. But in cases of true gridlock, each analyst was given one “super vote,” allowing them to break a 2-2 tie on a player they were particularly passionate about, in either direction.

You can listen to the whole episode to hear how it all went down, but here were some of the key debates and takeaways from the exercise.

Where to slot James Hagens?

This was our liveliest debate, which is fitting given Hagens has among the widest ranges of potential outcomes of the top group we debated. He came into the season as the favorite to be the first pick in the draft, but after a strong, though not necessarily spectacular, freshman season at Boston College — and perhaps some nitpicking of such a known player — there’s real debate over where he fits within the top of this class.

That was true in our debate, too.

Pronman noted Hagens’ outstanding track record over the years, including a “really, really good” draft year at Boston College. He called him arguably the most offensively skilled player in the class, headlined by his skating. But he also raised the issue of Hagens’ size, as a 5-foot-10 forward, and whether the relative lack of interior offense in his game this season could be a product of playing against bigger, stronger opponents — the kind he will continue to see as he progresses to the NHL.

Advertisement

Wheeler and Peters, meanwhile, were adamant in Hagens’ favor, with Wheeler advocating for Hagens at No. 3 on our list and threatening to use his Super Vote to keep him no lower than No. 4 on the collective list.

“I have, actually, fewer questions — despite the fact that he’s 5-foot-10, despite the fact that he didn’t score a ton — I’ve got fewer questions about projecting James Hagens than I do about protecting Anton Frondell or Porter Martone,” Wheeler said.

Peters took it a step further in rejecting Pronman’s argument, telling Pronman, “Corey, put the f—ing tape measure away, all right?”

“I think that we are gonna see a very different James Hagens this year,” Peters said. “And I do think he’ll be one of the best players in college hockey, and I feel like we’re gonna have a reset. And when we’re doing a redraft, he’s gonna be really high on a redraft. … In terms of potential, he is my number three with a bullet.”

But Hagens did not finish at No. 3. Bultman sided with Pronman on the debate between Hagens and Martone (the 6-foot-3 winger from the Brampton Steelheads), creating a 2-2 gridlock. Rather than use his tie-breaker, though, Wheeler opted to strike a compromise with Pronman that Hagens would sit behind Martone on the final list, but ahead of Frondell. Moncton (QMJHL) center Caleb Desnoyers was also mentioned at No. 3, but ultimately finished at No. 5.

Peters still wanted Hagens at No. 3, but with the other three panelists already agreeing to that order, he had no choice but to, in his words, “sit and stew in the corner.”

How the need for consensus affected other prospects

Prior compromises came into play on multiple occasions through our process.

The Martone-Hagens compromise, for example, resurfaced as an issue for Peters when discussing which tier to place Desnoyers into. He had Hagens ahead of Desnoyers, but Desnoyers ahead of Martone, making it tricky to place Desnoyers with Martone already ahead of Hagens on the consensus list.

Advertisement

And later on, Wheeler nominated Seattle (WHL) defenseman Radim Mrtka at number seven, but had to watch as the other analysts’ votes not only bumped Mrtka down, but into a separate tier, which ultimately left him outside the top 10.

But Wheeler did get passionate and use his veto vote to ensure that one of the draft’s most divisive players did not end up higher than where he was comfortable. Brandon (WHL) center Roger McQueen has some of the best athletic tools in the class as a highly skilled 6-foot-5 center who can skate, but has struggled with a back injury. When the group was deadlocked as to which tier McQueen should fit into, Wheeler stepped in “against taking a chance that we risk making a mistake on Roger McQueen.”

That put McQueen into the fourth tier with Mrtka, instead of into a third tier that ultimately included OHL center Jake O’Brien, Swedish winger Victor Eklund, OHL forward Brady Martin and OHL defenseman Kashawn Aitcheson.

The final collaborative list

After all the debating, the final top 12 — separated into four tiers — came out like this:

Tier 1

Matthew Schaefer
Michael Misa

Tier 2

Porter Martone
James Hagens
Caleb Desnoyers
Anton Frondell

Tier 3

Jake O’Brien
Victor Eklund
Brady Martin
Kashawn Aitcheson

Tier 4

Roger McQueen
Radim Mrtka

(Photo of James Hagens: Richard T Gagnon / Getty Images)

This news was originally published on this post .

About the author

About the author call_made

SPORTIVO

More posts

trending_flat
Taylor Swift not behind Travis Kelce’s tough NFL form: Why is the Chiefs’ star struggling?

As Travis Kelce enters another NFL season with the Kansas City Chiefs, speculation has intensified over the tight end's recent dip in production and the reasons behind it. Now the latest theory is here - and it's nothing to do with Taylor Swift.Despite his long-standing reputation as one of the league's elite players, his performance is showing signs of natural decline, prompting some to wrongly suggest that his relationship is to blame.Travis Kelce swaps Patrick for Taylor Swift on the dance floor and the vibe is totally differentHowever, data and analysis from credible football sources point to a more grounded explanation: Time. The 35-year-old, who has been a cornerstone of the Chiefs' offense for more than a decade, is simply aging. It waits for no man, and that includes even the most dominant athletes in the NFL, who eventually face […]

trending_flat
Shedeur Sanders is perfect for the Cleveland Browns and Kevin Stefanski’s offense

As time progresses and September draws closer, positive commentary surrounding Shedeur Sanders continues to grow as he battles to secure the starting quarterback role with the Cleveland Browns.It's striking how the narrative has shifted-from early criticism of the former Colorado quarterback's attitude to recent praise highlighting his talent and leadership potential. Many now view Sanders as a legitimate candidate to be the future of the franchise.Shedeur Sanders makes a surprise visit to a youth football program and gets a hilarious responseIs Shedeur Sanders Perfect for the Cleveland Browns?That's certainly the belief of former NFL quarterback and ESPN analyst Dan Orlovsky. During his appearance on ESPN's Get Up, Orlovsky described Shedeur Sanders as "perfect" and "tailor-made" for head coach Kevin Stefanski's offensive system.Orlovsky broke down why he believes Sanders is such a great fit for the Cleveland Browns offense:"He's perfect for […]

trending_flat
2025 U.S. Open odds, predictions, free picks: Justin Thomas, Patrick Cantlay among longshots to back

Scottie Scheffler and Xander Schauffele are two golfers in the 2025 U.S. Open field seeking a victory in the third major of the year to pull within one of completing a career grand slam. Both have won a major in the last 12 months, with Schauffele taking the 2024 Open Championship and Scheffler coming off his victory at the PGA Championship. Despite being listed among the top-five betting favorites, their 2025 U.S. Open odds are drastically different, with Scheffler as the +280 favorite and Schauffele at +2200 to win the U.S. Open 2025 from Oakmont Country Club starting on Thursday.If you're looking for 2025 U.S. Open sleepers, a longshot like Tyrrell Hatton could be your best option for online sports betting. Hatton has a victory on the DP World Tour this year, and with at least one top-15 finish in […]

trending_flat
Cowboys stars Micah Parsons, Trevon Diggs arrive at team facility, expected to attend minicamp

Getty Images Two notable members of the Dallas Cowboys arrived at the team's facility a day before the start of mandatory minicamp. All-Pro linebacker Micah Parsons and former All-Pro cornerback Trevon Diggs were back at The Star on Monday, and the expectation is that both players will be in the attendance for the start of minicamp. While expected (Parsons himself recently said that he would be at minicamp), Parsons' presence is nonetheless significant because of his contract situation. While he is expected to sign a longterm deal at some point this offseason, Parsons, at this point, is still slated to play under his fifth-year option that was picked up by the team last spring. Despite that, Parsons participated in a portion of the team's OTAs. Diggs' arrival at The Star was also financially motivated, albeit in a different way. His contract stipulates […]

trending_flat
2025 U.S. Open expert picks, bets, odds, sleepers: Golf insider ducking Rory McIlroy at Oakmont Country Club

The 2025 U.S. Open tees off Thursday, when defending champion Bryson DeChambeau will attempt to do what's only been done once in the last 35 years. Brooks Koepka (2017-18) is the only back-to-back U.S. Open champion since 1989, but DeChambeau has proven he has what it takes to compete with the world's best players. He secured a T-5 finish at the Masters in April and recorded a T-2 finish at the PGA Championship in May. The U.S. Open 2025 will be held at Oakmont Country Club. DeChambeau is going off at +700 to repeat, according to the latest 2025 U.S. Open odds. Scottie Scheffler, the No. 1-ranked player in the world, is the +280 favorite on the PGA odds board, followed by DeChambeau, Rory McIlroy (+1100), Jon Rahm (+1200), and Xander Schauffele (+2200). Before making any 2025 U.S. Open picks, […]

trending_flat
Fantasy Baseball: Roman Anthony is here and under more pressure to perform than most prospect call-ups

You don't need me to tell you Roman Anthony is good. From the moment Roki Sasaki exhausted his rookie eligibility, Anthony has been the consensus top prospect in baseball (and probably should have been before then, to be honest). So now that he's been called up, officially joining the Red Sox on Monday, what am I going to tell you to do? Pick him up? He's already rostered in 82 percent of CBS Sports leagues. We've been counting down to this day for months now. Clearly, he hasn't done anything to diminish his stock in 2025. This stat line paints a nice enough picture: But it doesn't tell the whole story. Anthony's 95.0 mph average exit velocity at Triple-A would rank fourth among all major-leaguers -- behind the big three of Oneil Cruz, Shohei Ohtani and Aaron Judge -- and […]

Related

trending_flat
Taylor Swift not behind Travis Kelce’s tough NFL form: Why is the Chiefs’ star struggling?

As Travis Kelce enters another NFL season with the Kansas City Chiefs, speculation has intensified over the tight end's recent dip in production and the reasons behind it. Now the latest theory is here - and it's nothing to do with Taylor Swift.Despite his long-standing reputation as one of the league's elite players, his performance is showing signs of natural decline, prompting some to wrongly suggest that his relationship is to blame.Travis Kelce swaps Patrick for Taylor Swift on the dance floor and the vibe is totally differentHowever, data and analysis from credible football sources point to a more grounded explanation: Time. The 35-year-old, who has been a cornerstone of the Chiefs' offense for more than a decade, is simply aging. It waits for no man, and that includes even the most dominant athletes in the NFL, who eventually face […]

trending_flat
Shedeur Sanders is perfect for the Cleveland Browns and Kevin Stefanski’s offense

As time progresses and September draws closer, positive commentary surrounding Shedeur Sanders continues to grow as he battles to secure the starting quarterback role with the Cleveland Browns.It's striking how the narrative has shifted-from early criticism of the former Colorado quarterback's attitude to recent praise highlighting his talent and leadership potential. Many now view Sanders as a legitimate candidate to be the future of the franchise.Shedeur Sanders makes a surprise visit to a youth football program and gets a hilarious responseIs Shedeur Sanders Perfect for the Cleveland Browns?That's certainly the belief of former NFL quarterback and ESPN analyst Dan Orlovsky. During his appearance on ESPN's Get Up, Orlovsky described Shedeur Sanders as "perfect" and "tailor-made" for head coach Kevin Stefanski's offensive system.Orlovsky broke down why he believes Sanders is such a great fit for the Cleveland Browns offense:"He's perfect for […]

trending_flat
2025 U.S. Open odds, predictions, free picks: Justin Thomas, Patrick Cantlay among longshots to back

Scottie Scheffler and Xander Schauffele are two golfers in the 2025 U.S. Open field seeking a victory in the third major of the year to pull within one of completing a career grand slam. Both have won a major in the last 12 months, with Schauffele taking the 2024 Open Championship and Scheffler coming off his victory at the PGA Championship. Despite being listed among the top-five betting favorites, their 2025 U.S. Open odds are drastically different, with Scheffler as the +280 favorite and Schauffele at +2200 to win the U.S. Open 2025 from Oakmont Country Club starting on Thursday.If you're looking for 2025 U.S. Open sleepers, a longshot like Tyrrell Hatton could be your best option for online sports betting. Hatton has a victory on the DP World Tour this year, and with at least one top-15 finish in […]

trending_flat
Cowboys stars Micah Parsons, Trevon Diggs arrive at team facility, expected to attend minicamp

Getty Images Two notable members of the Dallas Cowboys arrived at the team's facility a day before the start of mandatory minicamp. All-Pro linebacker Micah Parsons and former All-Pro cornerback Trevon Diggs were back at The Star on Monday, and the expectation is that both players will be in the attendance for the start of minicamp. While expected (Parsons himself recently said that he would be at minicamp), Parsons' presence is nonetheless significant because of his contract situation. While he is expected to sign a longterm deal at some point this offseason, Parsons, at this point, is still slated to play under his fifth-year option that was picked up by the team last spring. Despite that, Parsons participated in a portion of the team's OTAs. Diggs' arrival at The Star was also financially motivated, albeit in a different way. His contract stipulates […]

trending_flat
2025 U.S. Open expert picks, bets, odds, sleepers: Golf insider ducking Rory McIlroy at Oakmont Country Club

The 2025 U.S. Open tees off Thursday, when defending champion Bryson DeChambeau will attempt to do what's only been done once in the last 35 years. Brooks Koepka (2017-18) is the only back-to-back U.S. Open champion since 1989, but DeChambeau has proven he has what it takes to compete with the world's best players. He secured a T-5 finish at the Masters in April and recorded a T-2 finish at the PGA Championship in May. The U.S. Open 2025 will be held at Oakmont Country Club. DeChambeau is going off at +700 to repeat, according to the latest 2025 U.S. Open odds. Scottie Scheffler, the No. 1-ranked player in the world, is the +280 favorite on the PGA odds board, followed by DeChambeau, Rory McIlroy (+1100), Jon Rahm (+1200), and Xander Schauffele (+2200). Before making any 2025 U.S. Open picks, […]

trending_flat
Fantasy Baseball: Roman Anthony is here and under more pressure to perform than most prospect call-ups

You don't need me to tell you Roman Anthony is good. From the moment Roki Sasaki exhausted his rookie eligibility, Anthony has been the consensus top prospect in baseball (and probably should have been before then, to be honest). So now that he's been called up, officially joining the Red Sox on Monday, what am I going to tell you to do? Pick him up? He's already rostered in 82 percent of CBS Sports leagues. We've been counting down to this day for months now. Clearly, he hasn't done anything to diminish his stock in 2025. This stat line paints a nice enough picture: But it doesn't tell the whole story. Anthony's 95.0 mph average exit velocity at Triple-A would rank fourth among all major-leaguers -- behind the big three of Oneil Cruz, Shohei Ohtani and Aaron Judge -- and […]

Be the first to leave a comment

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sportivo bridges the gap between talent and opportunity.

About SPORTIVO

Sportivo Network is a dedicated social platform for sports enthusiasts, athletes, and scouts. Whether you’re an aspiring athlete looking for opportunities, a coach searching for talent, or simply a sports lover wanting to connect with like-minded people, Sportivo is your go-to network. With features like direct messaging, profile showcasing, and talent scouting, Sportivo bridges the gap between talent and opportunity. Here, you can share your achievements, interact with professionals, and open doors to the next level in your sports journey. Join Sportivo Network – because every great athlete deserves to be discovered!
Copyright © 2025 SPORTIVO News. and SPORTIVO Network. All rights reserved.

Login to enjoy full advantages

Please login or subscribe to continue.

Go Premium!

Enjoy the full advantage of the premium access.

Stop following

Unfollow Cancel

Cancel subscription

Are you sure you want to cancel your subscription? You will lose your Premium access and stored playlists.

Go back Confirm cancellation