Welcome to Snyder’s Soapbox! Here, I pontificate about matters related to Major League Baseball on a weekly basis. Some of the topics will be pressing matters, some might seem insignificant in the grand scheme of things, and most will be somewhere in between. The good thing about this website is that it’s free, and you are allowed to click away. If you stay, you’ll get smarter, though. That’s a money-back guarantee. Let’s get to it.
If there’s a major weakness in commissioner Rob Manfred’s game, it’s his seemingly constant — and possibly even subconscious — itch to emulate the NFL when it comes to Major League Baseball. Replay started as a mirror to how football replay operates and we even have an extra innings (overtime) mechanism now to end the game as soon as possible.
One of many examples is the MLB Draft, which takes place this coming weekend at the site of the All-Star Game. In recent years, it’s been shifted on the calendar from June to mid-July, squeezed into the All-Star festivities. Why? Well, MLB wants a huge stage for the draft and is trying to make it destination television viewing in similar fashion to how the NFL Draft and, to a lesser extent, NBA Draft command attention.
There are a lot of problems with the approach of trying to make our draft the same level of an event as the NFL one. Foremost on the list would be that the NFL is a monster and MLB isn’t even in the same ballpark in terms on attention paid by casual fans.
Secondly, the biggest names in the NFL Draft have already commanded a ton of attention in college football, which is also wildly popular. To a lesser extent, a similar rule applies in the NBA Draft, when many of the top names off the board have already been heavily televised in college basketball games, including March Madness.
Baseball at the college ranks does have a national following, but it’s a fraction of college basketball and barely a blip in terms of popularity compared to college football.
Simply, people just don’t know these players. The only reason the overwhelming majority of fans this draft season have heard of any players would be the last name “Holliday.” That’s about it.
This isn’t to suggest there are no fans of prospects and/or the draft. There are. It’s just a niche audience and not a mainstream audience while Major League Baseball wants to treat it as the latter.
To wit, the MLB Draft last season saw its second-best TV audience ever at 863,000 (via Sports Business Journal). Wanna guess what the NFL got for Round 1 this year? It was 13.6 million.
With MLB not even drawing a million fans to watch the draft on TV, it isn’t worth the headache the league is causing the scouting departments of its 30 ballclubs. The draft is right now only a few weeks before the trade deadline. The league does it just so they can work the draft into All-Star Game coverage, but the resources of the 30 teams are better served concentrating on the draft right after the high school and college seasons conclude and leaving the early part of July to the trade deadline.
Further, MLB prospects are drafted and then head to the minors before eventually joining the big-league clubs. In the NFL and NBA, draftees make an immediate impact. If you want the masses of fans to pay attention to a draft, telling them they’ll have to wait two or three years to see a real impact on the big-league club is a good way to turn off the attention span. It just isn’t the same thing at all.
No, the prospects in Double-A and Triple-A are the ones who are close to making an impact on the MLB rosters and they already have a showcase during All-Star week. That would be the Futures Game, which has now been relegated to Saturday night, competing against actual MLB games.
How about putting the draft back where it belongs in early or mid-June and then showcasing the Futures Game on Sunday night in primetime on national TV? The main reason fans love the draft for other sports is because it can directly impact how good their favorite team is in the near future. The Futures Game is a much better sign for that in baseball than the draft. Oh, and it’s actually game action instead of just watching someone read off a bunch of names most fans haven’t yet heard of.
No, it won’t move the needle the way the NFL does with its draft — not even remotely close — but we can’t do that with any event in baseball. We can’t focus on what the NFL does. We should only focus on what matters for Major League Baseball and squeezing the draft into All-Star activities just doesn’t work.
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
Brentford contacted Ange Postecoglou about replacing Thomas Frank after Tottenham exit
Brentford contacted former Tottenham Hotspur head coach Ange Postecoglou about replacing Thomas Frank.In what would have been an extraordinary sequence of events and effectively a job swap, Brentford considered Postecoglou as an option to succeed Frank, who left to join Tottenham on a three-year deal after they sacked the 59-year-old Australian.AdvertisementBrentford director of football Phil Giles held informal discussions with Postecoglou but he was not interviewed for the role, as both parties agreed moving forward was not the best option. Other candidates Brentford considered included former Ajax head coach Francesco Farioli, who has now joined Porto, but they instead promoted set-piece coach Keith Andrews.Postecoglou joined Spurs in June 2023 and he guided them to a fifth-place finish in his first season.His second year in charge was disrupted by a crippling injury crisis. Spurs lost 22 league matches and finished 17th […]
New football watchdog set to be established following MPs’ backing
MPs have backed plans to set up the Independent Football Regulator and roll out operating licences for football clubs.The Football Governance Bill is poised to become law after it cleared the Commons, with MPs voting in favour at third reading by 415 votes to 98, a majority of 317. The Bill will introduce a football watchdog for the top five tiers of the men's game to ensure clubs are run sustainably and are accountable to their fans.The regulator will also have "backstop" powers to impose a financial settlement between the English Football League (EFL) and the Premier League if they cannot agree one themselves.Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy told the Commons: "We promised in our manifesto that we would end years of inaction and make the changes that fans have fought for for so long and are so overdue. "I am […]
Quarterbacks with most to gain this season with Mike Golic Jr + NFL All-Quarter Century Team
Subscribe to Inside CoverageJason Fitz & Frank Schwab are joined by the great Mike Golic Jr. to dive into NFL quarterbacks who can change their public perception the most heading into the 2025 season, including Sam Darnold, Daniel Jones, Justin Herbert, C.J. Stroud and Jared Goff.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementLater, Frank reveals his NFL All-Quarter Century Team made up of the best NFL players at each position over the last 25 years, and Fitz and GoJo react and discuss the biggest snubs on offense and defense.(2:15) - Quarterbacks who can change their perception the most(28:50) - NFL All-Quarter Century Team reactions: Offense(39:00) - NFL All-Quarter Century Team reactions: DefenseJared Goff (Detroit Lions) & Justin Herbert (Los Angeles Chargers) are among the QBs with the most to prove entering the 2025 NFL season. (Photos by Michael Owens & Perry Knotts/Getty Images) (Photos by Michael Owens […]
LeBron James pressiona o Los Angeles Lakers e jornalista afirma: “Vem querendo sair há algum tempo”
LeBron James se destaca aos 40 anos de idade na NBA. Foto: Divulgação/Los Angeles LakersO futuro de LeBron James segue gerando assunto na NBA. Segundo informações do jornalista Howard Beck, do The Ringer, ‘The King’ vem há algum tempo sinalizando que pode sair do Los Angeles Lakers, enquanto deseja um time competitivo para brigar por mais um título em sua reta final de carreira. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADE“Isso tudo pode ser apenas uma forma de criar pressão sobre o front office, ele fez isso em todos os lugares onde passou na sua carreira”, pontuou o comunicador norte-americano sobre a postura do camisa 23, em declaração no programa The Zach Lowe Show.“Um outro cenário possível é de que ele realmente queira sair”, alertou Beck, que prosseguiu explicando: “Eu ouvi de uma fonte que ele não apenas quer sair, como vem querendo já há […]
Alexi Lalas: U.S. Men’s Team Forged New Identity Despite Gold Cup Loss
<!--> [--> Alexi Lalas Soccer Analyst <!--> --> I think the United States-Mexico rivalry is the best in international soccer. And it sucks to lose against your rivals. We saw that on Sunday when the U.S., missing a bunch of star players, lost to a more experienced Mexico team in the Gold Cup final. There are no moral victories. I don't care how inexperienced you are. I don't care how young you are. Having said that, this Gold Cup run was valuable for United States manager Mauricio Pochettino, especially heading into the 2026 World Cup. Chris Richards and Malik Tillman made the most of their Gold Cup appearances. (Photo by John Dorton/ISI Photos/USSF/Getty Images) <!--> -->Players like Diego Luna, Malik Tillman, and Chris Richards used it to either establish (or re-establish) themselves going forward. I also think Pochettino will be a big […]
Filipe Gamba minimiza decisão da Recopa Gaúcha com o São José: “O Grêmio só tem a perder”
Mano Menezes, técnico do Grêmio (LUCAS UEBEL/GREMIO FBPA)Os torcedores do Grêmio vão poder matar a saudade de ver o Tricolor Gaúcho jogar depois de quase um mês. A equipe de Mano Menezes entrará em campo hoje (8) contra o São José na Arena, pela decisão da Recopa Gaúcha. O torneio organizado anualmente pela Federação Gaúcha de Futebol (FGF) reúne o campeão estadual da temporada anterior e o último vencedor da Copa FGF. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADEMesmo com a partida valendo taça, ela não entusiasma Filipe Gamba. Para o apresentador dos “Donos da Bola RS” na afiliada gaúcha da Band, o confronto diante do Zequinha, um adversário do Brasileirão Série D, não traz nenhuma vantagem para o Tricolor Gaúcho.“Do ponto de vista prático, sejamos realistas. A Recopa não tem importância. Por isso que eu falei, o Grêmio só tem a perder com o […]
Related
Brentford contacted Ange Postecoglou about replacing Thomas Frank after Tottenham exit
Brentford contacted former Tottenham Hotspur head coach Ange Postecoglou about replacing Thomas Frank.In what would have been an extraordinary sequence of events and effectively a job swap, Brentford considered Postecoglou as an option to succeed Frank, who left to join Tottenham on a three-year deal after they sacked the 59-year-old Australian.AdvertisementBrentford director of football Phil Giles held informal discussions with Postecoglou but he was not interviewed for the role, as both parties agreed moving forward was not the best option. Other candidates Brentford considered included former Ajax head coach Francesco Farioli, who has now joined Porto, but they instead promoted set-piece coach Keith Andrews.Postecoglou joined Spurs in June 2023 and he guided them to a fifth-place finish in his first season.His second year in charge was disrupted by a crippling injury crisis. Spurs lost 22 league matches and finished 17th […]
New football watchdog set to be established following MPs’ backing
MPs have backed plans to set up the Independent Football Regulator and roll out operating licences for football clubs.The Football Governance Bill is poised to become law after it cleared the Commons, with MPs voting in favour at third reading by 415 votes to 98, a majority of 317. The Bill will introduce a football watchdog for the top five tiers of the men's game to ensure clubs are run sustainably and are accountable to their fans.The regulator will also have "backstop" powers to impose a financial settlement between the English Football League (EFL) and the Premier League if they cannot agree one themselves.Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy told the Commons: "We promised in our manifesto that we would end years of inaction and make the changes that fans have fought for for so long and are so overdue. "I am […]
Quarterbacks with most to gain this season with Mike Golic Jr + NFL All-Quarter Century Team
Subscribe to Inside CoverageJason Fitz & Frank Schwab are joined by the great Mike Golic Jr. to dive into NFL quarterbacks who can change their public perception the most heading into the 2025 season, including Sam Darnold, Daniel Jones, Justin Herbert, C.J. Stroud and Jared Goff.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementLater, Frank reveals his NFL All-Quarter Century Team made up of the best NFL players at each position over the last 25 years, and Fitz and GoJo react and discuss the biggest snubs on offense and defense.(2:15) - Quarterbacks who can change their perception the most(28:50) - NFL All-Quarter Century Team reactions: Offense(39:00) - NFL All-Quarter Century Team reactions: DefenseJared Goff (Detroit Lions) & Justin Herbert (Los Angeles Chargers) are among the QBs with the most to prove entering the 2025 NFL season. (Photos by Michael Owens & Perry Knotts/Getty Images) (Photos by Michael Owens […]
LeBron James pressiona o Los Angeles Lakers e jornalista afirma: “Vem querendo sair há algum tempo”
LeBron James se destaca aos 40 anos de idade na NBA. Foto: Divulgação/Los Angeles LakersO futuro de LeBron James segue gerando assunto na NBA. Segundo informações do jornalista Howard Beck, do The Ringer, ‘The King’ vem há algum tempo sinalizando que pode sair do Los Angeles Lakers, enquanto deseja um time competitivo para brigar por mais um título em sua reta final de carreira. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADE“Isso tudo pode ser apenas uma forma de criar pressão sobre o front office, ele fez isso em todos os lugares onde passou na sua carreira”, pontuou o comunicador norte-americano sobre a postura do camisa 23, em declaração no programa The Zach Lowe Show.“Um outro cenário possível é de que ele realmente queira sair”, alertou Beck, que prosseguiu explicando: “Eu ouvi de uma fonte que ele não apenas quer sair, como vem querendo já há […]
Alexi Lalas: U.S. Men’s Team Forged New Identity Despite Gold Cup Loss
<!--> [--> Alexi Lalas Soccer Analyst <!--> --> I think the United States-Mexico rivalry is the best in international soccer. And it sucks to lose against your rivals. We saw that on Sunday when the U.S., missing a bunch of star players, lost to a more experienced Mexico team in the Gold Cup final. There are no moral victories. I don't care how inexperienced you are. I don't care how young you are. Having said that, this Gold Cup run was valuable for United States manager Mauricio Pochettino, especially heading into the 2026 World Cup. Chris Richards and Malik Tillman made the most of their Gold Cup appearances. (Photo by John Dorton/ISI Photos/USSF/Getty Images) <!--> -->Players like Diego Luna, Malik Tillman, and Chris Richards used it to either establish (or re-establish) themselves going forward. I also think Pochettino will be a big […]
Filipe Gamba minimiza decisão da Recopa Gaúcha com o São José: “O Grêmio só tem a perder”
Mano Menezes, técnico do Grêmio (LUCAS UEBEL/GREMIO FBPA)Os torcedores do Grêmio vão poder matar a saudade de ver o Tricolor Gaúcho jogar depois de quase um mês. A equipe de Mano Menezes entrará em campo hoje (8) contra o São José na Arena, pela decisão da Recopa Gaúcha. O torneio organizado anualmente pela Federação Gaúcha de Futebol (FGF) reúne o campeão estadual da temporada anterior e o último vencedor da Copa FGF. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADEMesmo com a partida valendo taça, ela não entusiasma Filipe Gamba. Para o apresentador dos “Donos da Bola RS” na afiliada gaúcha da Band, o confronto diante do Zequinha, um adversário do Brasileirão Série D, não traz nenhuma vantagem para o Tricolor Gaúcho.“Do ponto de vista prático, sejamos realistas. A Recopa não tem importância. Por isso que eu falei, o Grêmio só tem a perder com o […]
Be the first to leave a comment