Bueckers is already facing the same issue that Clark had in her rookie season

SPORTIVO
Article arrow_drop_down

There are still 33 games left in the 2025 WNBA regular season, but the Rookie of the Year conversation is already becoming a firestorm.

At the heart of it is Paige Bueckers, who’s putting up standout numbers for the struggling Dallas Wings. But instead of celebrating her dominance, fans are pointing to a familiar line of criticism, one that was used against Caitlin Clark just a season ago.

Paige Bueckers was guarding her teammates from temptation at the pool party

The Dallas Wings are currently sitting at a dismal 1-10, dead last in the league. But that hasn’t stopped Bueckers from putting together a sensational rookie campaign.

Bueckers’ case

According to official WNBA statistics, she’s leading all rookies in points (17.6), assists (6.3), and steals (1.9) per game, while ranking third in rebounds and owning the highest efficiency rating among first-year players at 21.9.

Still, critics have begun pointing to Dallas‘ lack of success as a mark against Bueckers‘ case for Rookie of the Year, just like they did to Caitlin Clark in 2024.

During last year’s ROTY debate, ESPN’s Monica McNutt argued in favor of Angel Reese by emphasizing team performance over individual output.

“My rookie of the year is gonna go based on the standing. Because I think that is how you have the opportunity to measure impact,” McNutt said on air. “The Sky right now are in the playoffs, so you’d have to give the nod, in my mind, to Angel Reese.”

That take didn’t age particularly well. Chicago ultimately missed the postseason, finishing 10th at 13-27, while Clark and the Indiana Fever surged in the second half of the season.

They finished 20-20, clinched a playoff berth for the first time since 2016, and saw Clark make WNBA history as the first true rookie to lead the league in assists.

To her credit, McNutt later clarified her remarks, noting on a podcast that if Reese broke the rookie double-double record but Clark had the higher seed, “the award should go to Clark.”

Despite the heated debate, the WNBA’s Rookie of the Year voting process doesn’t formally consider team success. The award, established in 1998, is decided by a national panel of 56 sportswriters and broadcasters who vote on a 5-3-1 point system.

Voters are asked to weigh individual performance, milestones, and impact. Yet, last season’s controversy showed that for some, team success can act as an informal tiebreaker or justification.

This news was originally published on this post .

About the author

About the author call_made

SPORTIVO

More posts

Casagrande destaca Fabrício Bruno no Cruzeiro e aprova nome na seleção brasileira: “Fez bem em sair do Flamengo”

Casagrande projeta duelo decisivo na Copa do Brasil - Reprodução/YouTubeWalter Casagrande viu méritos na convocação de Fabrício Bruno na seleção brasileira. Mais do que o gol anotado sobre o Atlético no triunfo por 2 a 0 da Raposa na partida de ida das quartas de final da Copa do Brasil, o comentarista acredita que o defensor acertou na decisão de deixar o Flamengo no início deste ano, isso porque ficou claro que seria pouco aproveitado pelo técnico Filipe Luís. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADEDurante o programa UOL News Esporte, desta quinta (28), Casão elegeu o zagueiro da Raposa como um dos melhores em atividade no futebol brasileiro. Além do camisa 15 celeste, o ídolo do Corinthians também enalteceu a dupla de zaga do Rubro-Negro.“O Fabrício Bruno é um ótimo zagueiro e fez bem em sair do Flamengo porque seria difícil ele jogar dentro […]

trending_flat
2025 College Football Week 1 Picks, Preview: What To Expect in Texas-Ohio State

<!--> [--> Joel Klatt Lead College Football Analyst <!--> --> College football doesn’t ease into the season — it kicks the door down.Week 1 is here, and we've got the biggest season-opening showdown the sport has ever seen: Texas and Ohio State will meet in The Shoe as the No. 1 Longhorns take on the defending national champion. It really doesn’t get bigger than that, does it? I’ll be on the call for that game on FOX, but it’s just the start. We’ve got two other top-10 clashes, some spicy non-conference showdowns, and yes — Bill Belichick’s head coaching debut at North Carolina.So, let’s preview the top matchups of Week 1. Texas vs. Ohio StateWhile this is a top-three matchup, both teams are introducing new quarterbacks. Of course, with Texas, "Arch Mania" has finally arrived. Arch Manning has to take a program […]

trending_flat
LeBron James acknowledges the power of her wife Savannah James on her birthday tribute

NBA superstar LeBron James took a break from the court spotlight this week to commemorate a more closer triumph: his wife Savannah James' 39th birthday. The Lakers' forward posted a tender dedication on social media, giving followers a glimpse into family life that has kept him grounded throughout his legendary career.More Than a Heartfelt MessageSavannah James and daughter Zhuri nail smooth dance moves to Chris Brown hitLeBron shared an Instagram story on Wednesday of Savannah smiling alongside a candlelit cake. The post was brief but full of love:"HAPPY BIRTHDAY BEAUTIFUL QUEEN!!! Have a helluva year ahead of you! Love you girl!!!"LeBron James on his IG accountThe post created a lot of buzz on social media, with fans appreciating the couple's longstanding love dedication. The James family social media account, @teamjamesfamily, also shared and provided comments thanking Savannah for being such […]

trending_flat
Tom Brady turns to his ex Bridget Moynahan to attack Gisele Bundchen again in her role as a mother

Tom Brady has once again turned the spotlight toward his personal life, using his latest newsletter to reflect on fatherhood while implicitly drawing a contrast between his parenting with former partners, Bridget Moynahan and Gisele Bundchen.The 48-year-old NFL legend recently celebrated his eldest son Jack's 18th birthday, an occasion he described as a revealing moment in his journey as a parent alongside the first mother of his children.Tom Hiddleston froze when Taylor Swift was mentioned in the middle of an interview"As a parent, the home is the classroom and you are in pure teaching mode all the way up until your kids reach 13 or 14 years old," Brady wrote. "That's when their friend group starts to have a huge impact on the shape of their social personality and you begin to learn what kind of teacher you really are."A […]

trending_flat
Parker’s team question Usyk injury amid world title stand-off

Joseph Parker's promoter David Higgins has questioned Oleksandr Usyk's injury amid a stand-off in fight negotiations.Usyk, the undisputed world heavyweight champion, has requested an extension to the deadline for talks for a WBO mandatory title fight against Parker due to an injury. But footage has recently emerged on social media of the Ukrainian dancing at a music concert.Parker's promoter Higgins told Sky Sports: "I haven't actually seen the medical evidence but you would think that a serious injury would prevent that sort of activity."Usyk and Parker are yet to open talks for the fight, which was initially ordered on July 24 with a 30-day window to agree terms before a purse bid. "As far as I'm concerned, things are exactly as they were," said Higgins. "In boxing, nothing surprises me." Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player […]

trending_flat
2026 NFL Draft preseason big board: This QB class is going to be fun; OL and EDGE are deep and talented groups

Twelve months ago, quarterback Cameron Ward was No. 24 on my top 50 big board. By late April, he was the first-overall pick. It was the seventh time in the last eight drafts (and nine of the last 11) that a quarterback has been selected No. 1. The lesson: there's a lot we don't know as the college football season gets underway, and much will change between now and the 2026 NFL Draft. Ward, for example, was considered an early Day 3 prospect during his 2023 season. He then transferred from Washington State to Miami, had a fantastic 2024 campaign and ended up going first overall to the Titans.This is my annual preseason top 50 Big Board. I like to think of it more as a starting point on a road map that ends 239 days from now in Pittsburgh at […]

Related

Casagrande destaca Fabrício Bruno no Cruzeiro e aprova nome na seleção brasileira: “Fez bem em sair do Flamengo”

Casagrande projeta duelo decisivo na Copa do Brasil - Reprodução/YouTubeWalter Casagrande viu méritos na convocação de Fabrício Bruno na seleção brasileira. Mais do que o gol anotado sobre o Atlético no triunfo por 2 a 0 da Raposa na partida de ida das quartas de final da Copa do Brasil, o comentarista acredita que o defensor acertou na decisão de deixar o Flamengo no início deste ano, isso porque ficou claro que seria pouco aproveitado pelo técnico Filipe Luís. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADEDurante o programa UOL News Esporte, desta quinta (28), Casão elegeu o zagueiro da Raposa como um dos melhores em atividade no futebol brasileiro. Além do camisa 15 celeste, o ídolo do Corinthians também enalteceu a dupla de zaga do Rubro-Negro.“O Fabrício Bruno é um ótimo zagueiro e fez bem em sair do Flamengo porque seria difícil ele jogar dentro […]

trending_flat
2025 College Football Week 1 Picks, Preview: What To Expect in Texas-Ohio State

<!--> [--> Joel Klatt Lead College Football Analyst <!--> --> College football doesn’t ease into the season — it kicks the door down.Week 1 is here, and we've got the biggest season-opening showdown the sport has ever seen: Texas and Ohio State will meet in The Shoe as the No. 1 Longhorns take on the defending national champion. It really doesn’t get bigger than that, does it? I’ll be on the call for that game on FOX, but it’s just the start. We’ve got two other top-10 clashes, some spicy non-conference showdowns, and yes — Bill Belichick’s head coaching debut at North Carolina.So, let’s preview the top matchups of Week 1. Texas vs. Ohio StateWhile this is a top-three matchup, both teams are introducing new quarterbacks. Of course, with Texas, "Arch Mania" has finally arrived. Arch Manning has to take a program […]

trending_flat
LeBron James acknowledges the power of her wife Savannah James on her birthday tribute

NBA superstar LeBron James took a break from the court spotlight this week to commemorate a more closer triumph: his wife Savannah James' 39th birthday. The Lakers' forward posted a tender dedication on social media, giving followers a glimpse into family life that has kept him grounded throughout his legendary career.More Than a Heartfelt MessageSavannah James and daughter Zhuri nail smooth dance moves to Chris Brown hitLeBron shared an Instagram story on Wednesday of Savannah smiling alongside a candlelit cake. The post was brief but full of love:"HAPPY BIRTHDAY BEAUTIFUL QUEEN!!! Have a helluva year ahead of you! Love you girl!!!"LeBron James on his IG accountThe post created a lot of buzz on social media, with fans appreciating the couple's longstanding love dedication. The James family social media account, @teamjamesfamily, also shared and provided comments thanking Savannah for being such […]

trending_flat
Tom Brady turns to his ex Bridget Moynahan to attack Gisele Bundchen again in her role as a mother

Tom Brady has once again turned the spotlight toward his personal life, using his latest newsletter to reflect on fatherhood while implicitly drawing a contrast between his parenting with former partners, Bridget Moynahan and Gisele Bundchen.The 48-year-old NFL legend recently celebrated his eldest son Jack's 18th birthday, an occasion he described as a revealing moment in his journey as a parent alongside the first mother of his children.Tom Hiddleston froze when Taylor Swift was mentioned in the middle of an interview"As a parent, the home is the classroom and you are in pure teaching mode all the way up until your kids reach 13 or 14 years old," Brady wrote. "That's when their friend group starts to have a huge impact on the shape of their social personality and you begin to learn what kind of teacher you really are."A […]

trending_flat
Parker’s team question Usyk injury amid world title stand-off

Joseph Parker's promoter David Higgins has questioned Oleksandr Usyk's injury amid a stand-off in fight negotiations.Usyk, the undisputed world heavyweight champion, has requested an extension to the deadline for talks for a WBO mandatory title fight against Parker due to an injury. But footage has recently emerged on social media of the Ukrainian dancing at a music concert.Parker's promoter Higgins told Sky Sports: "I haven't actually seen the medical evidence but you would think that a serious injury would prevent that sort of activity."Usyk and Parker are yet to open talks for the fight, which was initially ordered on July 24 with a 30-day window to agree terms before a purse bid. "As far as I'm concerned, things are exactly as they were," said Higgins. "In boxing, nothing surprises me." Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player […]

trending_flat
2026 NFL Draft preseason big board: This QB class is going to be fun; OL and EDGE are deep and talented groups

Twelve months ago, quarterback Cameron Ward was No. 24 on my top 50 big board. By late April, he was the first-overall pick. It was the seventh time in the last eight drafts (and nine of the last 11) that a quarterback has been selected No. 1. The lesson: there's a lot we don't know as the college football season gets underway, and much will change between now and the 2026 NFL Draft. Ward, for example, was considered an early Day 3 prospect during his 2023 season. He then transferred from Washington State to Miami, had a fantastic 2024 campaign and ended up going first overall to the Titans.This is my annual preseason top 50 Big Board. I like to think of it more as a starting point on a road map that ends 239 days from now in Pittsburgh at […]

Be the first to leave a comment

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sportivo bridges the gap between talent and opportunity.

About SPORTIVO

Sportivo Network is a dedicated social platform for sports enthusiasts, athletes, and scouts. Whether you’re an aspiring athlete looking for opportunities, a coach searching for talent, or simply a sports lover wanting to connect with like-minded people, Sportivo is your go-to network. With features like direct messaging, profile showcasing, and talent scouting, Sportivo bridges the gap between talent and opportunity. Here, you can share your achievements, interact with professionals, and open doors to the next level in your sports journey. Join Sportivo Network – because every great athlete deserves to be discovered!
Copyright © 2025 SPORTIVO News. and SPORTIVO Network. All rights reserved.

Login to enjoy full advantages

Please login or subscribe to continue.

Go Premium!

Enjoy the full advantage of the premium access.

Stop following

Unfollow Cancel

Cancel subscription

Are you sure you want to cancel your subscription? You will lose your Premium access and stored playlists.

Go back Confirm cancellation