Sports
Calling an athlete “the greatest of all time” (GOAT) should be analyzed by their performance during the peak of their career and the record they achieved, leaving aside the activities carried out after their retirement. However, Jeff Mayweather has seen how Evander Holyfield’s legacy is often overshadowed, especially when considering that he is a four-time heavyweight champion, surpassing the three reigns of Muhammad Ali.
Naturally, when a legend like Holyfield challenges the narrative, Ali’s great career provokes strong reactions. After all, Ali remains the face of boxing for many. What makes it even more difficult is that some argue that Holyfield does not even surpass Mike Tyson in legacy, despite beating him.
Mike Tyson takes off his shirt and starts a street fight in one of boxing’s most iconic videos
In the midst of this debate, Floyd Mayweather’s uncle, Jeff Mayweather, offered a more measured perspective when asked about Holyfield’s claim, acknowledging his achievements but also pointing out why public perception has not caught up.
Is Evander Holyfield greater than Muhammad Ali?
The Mayweather Channel recently aired an episode featuring the thoughtful yet firm disagreement of Jeff Mayweather who acknowledged Evander Holyfield’s achievements, but also argued that greatness in boxing is not defined solely by titles. “It’s much more than just winning the title with Muhammad Ali, … he was bigger than boxing”. While Evander Holyfield’s argument was based solely on boxing merit, the reporter pointed out a critical flaw: being a four-time champion also means losing the title three times.
But then the discussion turned to longevity and dominance. “If you were champion once and held the belt for 20 years, aren’t you the best because someone else won it four times?” the reporter asked, challenging the logic. Jeff Mayweather agreed. “But I don’t know, it just doesn’t seem like Holyfield,” he added, hinting that Holyfield’s legacy doesn’t reach the elite of the all-time greats in the public perception. The reporter then pointed out that some fans don’t even rank him among the top five boxers, prompting Mayweather to reflect further. “The only thing I know about Holyfield as a heavyweight is that he beat Mike Tyson,” he said bluntly.
For critics, one win does not put a boxer at the top
However, Jeff argued that the victory over Mike Tyson does not elevate Evander Holyfield above Iron Mike in the eyes of most fans. When asked if Holyfield was a superior heavyweight to Tyson, Jeff replied: “Well, he’ll never be considered superior to Mike Tyson.” The reason? “Because people will say that by the time he fought Mike Tyson, he wasn’t the Mike Tyson that everyone knows. So he won’t get any credit for that.” It’s a sentiment shared by many who believe that Tyson’s decline (at 30) had already begun when The Real Deal fought him at 43.
Insisting further on the subject, the reporter asked who would win if both boxers had faced each other at their best. Jeff replied: “I don’t know. Mike Tyson was a real beast. I mean, he was really fast. But Holyfield beat him quite easily. But I don’t know. I just think Mike Tyson, his background, the way he grew up made him bigger than anyone else.” So, while Evander Holyfield may believe he surpasses Muhammad Ali in greatness, Jeff Mayweather is not convinced that he even surpasses Tyson.
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
ALDS Game 1: Blue Jays bats come alive during 10-1 rout of the Yankees
The Toronto Blue Jays used good pitching and continuous hitting to help rout the New York Yankees 10-1 in Game 1 of the ALDS.Yankees starter Luis Gil didn't reach the third inning as the Blue Jays hit him four times — two of those hits ending up as solo blasts by Alejandro Kirk and Vladimir Guerrero Jr. for an early 2-0 lead.Through five innings, the Yankees had no answers for Gausman, who kept the aggressive Bronx Bombers bats quiet. It wasn't until the top of the sixth inning where he finally got into trouble after loading the bases with no outs. He managed to strike out Aaron Judge during an eight-pitch at-bat, but walked Cody Bellinger to give New York their only run of the game.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisement[Yahoo Sports TV is here! Watch live shows and highlights 24/7]Not clear of trouble yet, […]
No. 10 Alabama avenges loss from a season ago with 30-14 win over No. 16 Vanderbilt
Vanderbilt QB Diego Pavia turned the ball over twice inside Alabama’s 20-yard line as the No. 16 Commodores failed to get back-to-back wins over the Crimson Tide in a 30-14 defeat.Vanderbilt had the chance to take the lead early in the fourth quarter after Alabama kicked a field goal to go up 20-14 in the third. But a play after Pavia hit Cole Spence for a 33-yard gain to the Alabama 17-yard line, Pavia was intercepted by Alabama’s Keon Sabb.Alabama put the game away on its next drive as the Tide chewed up over eight minutes running the ball over and over through the Vanderbilt defense. Offensive lineman Kadyn Proctor even got in on the fun, lining up in the backfield for a 2-yard third-down conversion a week after motioning out wide and catching a pass in the Crimson Tide’s […]
Florida upsets No. 9 Texas 29-21 as Longhorns drop to 3-2 ahead of rivalry game vs. No. 5 Oklahoma
Arch Manning and Texas do not look like national title contenders.The No. 9 Longhorns fell to 3-2 with a 29-21 loss at Florida on Saturday. Texas’ offense struggled mightily for much of the game as Florida’s defensive front wreaked havoc.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementThe Longhorns finally got on track in the third quarter as Manning avoided two rushers and stepped up in the pocket to find a wide-open Ryan Wingo for a 38-yard TD to cut Florida’s lead to 22-14.The Gators immediately responded and pushed the lead back to 15 points, however. DJ Lagway found freshman Dallas Wilson down the sideline and Wilson ran over multiple defenders as he scored on a 55-yard TD.Texas's chances of coming back took a huge hit after Wilson’s score thanks to an overthrow by Manning that was intercepted by Jordan Castell in Gators territory.After cutting the Gators' lead […]
MLB playoffs 2025: Milwaukee Brewers land first blow of NLDS with lopsided Game 1 win vs. Cubs
MILWAUKEE — In his former life, Brewers manager Pat Murphy was a young boxer who was no stranger to a good fight. And in any high-stakes bout, you can expect two rivals such as the Milwaukee Brewers and Chicago Cubs — separated by just 90 miles — to take big swings.And it was Murphy’s Brewers who took the fight to the Cubs from the start on Saturday in the first postseason matchup between the franchises, using a six-run first inning en route to a 9-3 Game 1 victory to set the tone for an intense NLDS.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisement“Promise me you’ll be ready for the first pitch,” Murphy said of his message to his team this week. “When the bell rings, you’re ready. You don’t get a couple of rounds to figure out if you wanna fight. Be ready in the first round — […]
2025 CFB Odds: UCLA Takes Down Penn State in Historic Upset
FOX Sports Research UCLA did the unthinkable.A week after losing a thriller to Oregon in overtime, James Franklin & Co. lost to an 0-4 UCLA team. The Bruins fired head coach Deshaun Foster three games into the season, and named former Fresno State head coach Tim Skipper as the interim. The Bruins entered as a 24.5-point underdog, with +1300 odds to win. Prior to today, there had been four teams all-time to have been 0-4 or worse and beat an AP top 10 team:UTEP (0-6) beats No. 7 BYU in 1985Tulane (0-4) beats No. 6 Navy in 1958Purdue (0-4) beats No. 2 Michigan State in 1953Pittsburgh (0-5) beats No. 3 Fordham in 1941Below we've further broken down just how historic this upset is, from both a statistical and odds perspective. Let's take a look: ADVERTISEMENT This page may contain affiliate links […]
Mariners vs. Tigers ALDS schedule, prediction, odds, TV channel with Game 1 set for Saturday
Getty Images The Seattle Mariners earned a bye to the ALDS round by virtue of finishing 90-72 this season, which was good enough for their first AL West title since 2001 and the second-best record among AL division winners. The Detroit Tigers had hopes of getting a bye for nearly the entire season, but blowing a 14-game lead in the AL Central meant they needed to hit the road in the Wild Card Series as a No. 6 seed. No matter -- the Tigers took down the Guardians in three games to advance here.The Tigers and Mariners have never squared off in the playoffs before, so it's a fresh matchup. The Tigers haven't won the World Series since 1984, while the Mariners are the only team in baseball to have never been to the World Series. Bet Tigers vs. Mariners […]
Related
ALDS Game 1: Blue Jays bats come alive during 10-1 rout of the Yankees
The Toronto Blue Jays used good pitching and continuous hitting to help rout the New York Yankees 10-1 in Game 1 of the ALDS.Yankees starter Luis Gil didn't reach the third inning as the Blue Jays hit him four times — two of those hits ending up as solo blasts by Alejandro Kirk and Vladimir Guerrero Jr. for an early 2-0 lead.Through five innings, the Yankees had no answers for Gausman, who kept the aggressive Bronx Bombers bats quiet. It wasn't until the top of the sixth inning where he finally got into trouble after loading the bases with no outs. He managed to strike out Aaron Judge during an eight-pitch at-bat, but walked Cody Bellinger to give New York their only run of the game.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisement[Yahoo Sports TV is here! Watch live shows and highlights 24/7]Not clear of trouble yet, […]
No. 10 Alabama avenges loss from a season ago with 30-14 win over No. 16 Vanderbilt
Vanderbilt QB Diego Pavia turned the ball over twice inside Alabama’s 20-yard line as the No. 16 Commodores failed to get back-to-back wins over the Crimson Tide in a 30-14 defeat.Vanderbilt had the chance to take the lead early in the fourth quarter after Alabama kicked a field goal to go up 20-14 in the third. But a play after Pavia hit Cole Spence for a 33-yard gain to the Alabama 17-yard line, Pavia was intercepted by Alabama’s Keon Sabb.Alabama put the game away on its next drive as the Tide chewed up over eight minutes running the ball over and over through the Vanderbilt defense. Offensive lineman Kadyn Proctor even got in on the fun, lining up in the backfield for a 2-yard third-down conversion a week after motioning out wide and catching a pass in the Crimson Tide’s […]
Florida upsets No. 9 Texas 29-21 as Longhorns drop to 3-2 ahead of rivalry game vs. No. 5 Oklahoma
Arch Manning and Texas do not look like national title contenders.The No. 9 Longhorns fell to 3-2 with a 29-21 loss at Florida on Saturday. Texas’ offense struggled mightily for much of the game as Florida’s defensive front wreaked havoc.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementThe Longhorns finally got on track in the third quarter as Manning avoided two rushers and stepped up in the pocket to find a wide-open Ryan Wingo for a 38-yard TD to cut Florida’s lead to 22-14.The Gators immediately responded and pushed the lead back to 15 points, however. DJ Lagway found freshman Dallas Wilson down the sideline and Wilson ran over multiple defenders as he scored on a 55-yard TD.Texas's chances of coming back took a huge hit after Wilson’s score thanks to an overthrow by Manning that was intercepted by Jordan Castell in Gators territory.After cutting the Gators' lead […]
MLB playoffs 2025: Milwaukee Brewers land first blow of NLDS with lopsided Game 1 win vs. Cubs
MILWAUKEE — In his former life, Brewers manager Pat Murphy was a young boxer who was no stranger to a good fight. And in any high-stakes bout, you can expect two rivals such as the Milwaukee Brewers and Chicago Cubs — separated by just 90 miles — to take big swings.And it was Murphy’s Brewers who took the fight to the Cubs from the start on Saturday in the first postseason matchup between the franchises, using a six-run first inning en route to a 9-3 Game 1 victory to set the tone for an intense NLDS.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisement“Promise me you’ll be ready for the first pitch,” Murphy said of his message to his team this week. “When the bell rings, you’re ready. You don’t get a couple of rounds to figure out if you wanna fight. Be ready in the first round — […]
2025 CFB Odds: UCLA Takes Down Penn State in Historic Upset
FOX Sports Research UCLA did the unthinkable.A week after losing a thriller to Oregon in overtime, James Franklin & Co. lost to an 0-4 UCLA team. The Bruins fired head coach Deshaun Foster three games into the season, and named former Fresno State head coach Tim Skipper as the interim. The Bruins entered as a 24.5-point underdog, with +1300 odds to win. Prior to today, there had been four teams all-time to have been 0-4 or worse and beat an AP top 10 team:UTEP (0-6) beats No. 7 BYU in 1985Tulane (0-4) beats No. 6 Navy in 1958Purdue (0-4) beats No. 2 Michigan State in 1953Pittsburgh (0-5) beats No. 3 Fordham in 1941Below we've further broken down just how historic this upset is, from both a statistical and odds perspective. Let's take a look: ADVERTISEMENT This page may contain affiliate links […]
Mariners vs. Tigers ALDS schedule, prediction, odds, TV channel with Game 1 set for Saturday
Getty Images The Seattle Mariners earned a bye to the ALDS round by virtue of finishing 90-72 this season, which was good enough for their first AL West title since 2001 and the second-best record among AL division winners. The Detroit Tigers had hopes of getting a bye for nearly the entire season, but blowing a 14-game lead in the AL Central meant they needed to hit the road in the Wild Card Series as a No. 6 seed. No matter -- the Tigers took down the Guardians in three games to advance here.The Tigers and Mariners have never squared off in the playoffs before, so it's a fresh matchup. The Tigers haven't won the World Series since 1984, while the Mariners are the only team in baseball to have never been to the World Series. Bet Tigers vs. Mariners […]
Be the first to leave a comment