Why there’s so much we don’t (quite) know about college QBs in 2025

SPORTIVO
Article arrow_drop_down

The Pulse Newsletter 📣 | This is The Athletic’s daily sports newsletter. Sign up here to receive The Pulse directly in your inbox.


Good morning! Be the leader of your offense today.


Quarterbacks: The year of the probably pretty good college QB

Pulse Hypothesis, six days before the start of college football season: Now that teams can pay players, nobody with a clear shot at the playoff will ever go into a season with a black hole at quarterback.

All 25 teams in the preseason Associated Press poll have a QB situation that I would at least describe as “hopeful.” The highest-ranked team that doesn’t is BYU, which came in first in the “also receiving votes” section. That’s because the Cougars’ starter exited in July. A safe bet: If you are spending several million dollars on an otherwise good team, you won’t forget to stock a QB.

Advertisement

There’s something funny about how this is all playing out in 2025. Every team has reason for QB optimism, but the number that should expect QB dominance is roughly zero. There’s nothing resembling a clear Heisman favorite this year — though looking for a value pick is fun — and this moment in quarterbacking explains why. The floor is high. The ceiling may be low.

A few teams have multiyear starters who are definitely good but have left a little meat on the expectation bone. (Of the QBs at the top of The Athletic’s QB Tiers, Clemson’s Cade Klubnik and Penn State’s Drew Allar fit here.) South Carolina’s LaNorris Sellers, Florida’s DJ Lagway and LSU’s Garrett Nussmeier are clearly good, but also either young (Lagway) or fresh off a breakout that didn’t make them a Heisman-type player yet (Sellers, Nussmeier). SMU’s Kevin Jennings and Boise State’s Maddux Madsen are good-ish, but you will recall the combined six interceptions they threw to Penn State defenders in the playoff. And there is a long list of hopefuls:

Oh, and the No. 1 team in the country will start a Manning scion who happens to be the most famous QB prospect maybe ever. Across two years, he has thrown a majority of his college passes in two games against ULM and Mississippi State. Arch Manning is probably good, butQuinn Ewers was once almost as hyped as Manning is now, and I wouldn’t claim that Ewers turned out to be “good” in the way that Texas fans (or Ohio State fans before them) hoped.

So, does your top-25 team have a good QB? The answer is simple: Yeah, maybe. Probably! I think so. All of this makes for the main reason this season is unusually mysterious.


News to Know

Big Ten discusses 28-team CFP

No, that headline is somehow not a joke. While it’s just an idea at this point, the Big Ten has at least had preliminary discussions surrounding a college football tournament with as many as 28 teams. The report comes as CFP expansion talks have hit a wall in recent months, with the Big Ten continuing to push for a 16-team model and four auto bids for its own teams. More details on what a 28-team playoff would even look like in Ralph Russo’s full report.

Advertisement

Brewers extend winning streak to 14

Milwaukee may never lose another game. After erasing a seven-run deficit Friday, the Brewers put together another storybook comeback last night to extend their winning streak to a franchise-record 14 games. Last night’s comeback featured the Brewers tying the game with two outs in the ninth before a pinch-hit three-run homer in the 11th sealed the deal. Unreal scenes.

More news:

  • Phillies ace Zack Wheeler was put on the 15-day injured list after medical staff found a blood clot near his shoulder. It could put the rest of his season in jeopardy.

  • Luka Dončić appears to have avoided serious injury after a scary play during Slovenia’s EuroBasket game yesterday, The Athletic’s Dan Woike reported.

  • Jamaican sprinter Kishane Thompson barely bested American Noah Lyles in their first meeting in the 100-meter since Lyles won Olympic gold. A budding track rivalry.

  • Five former Wisconsin women’s basketball players filed a federal lawsuit against former coach Marisa Moseley, alleging psychological abuse. More here.


Watch Guide

📺 EPL: Manchester United vs. Arsenal 

11:30 a.m. ET on NBC 

United try to get started on the right foot after last season’s disaster. Here’s a good overview of the club’s plan to not be terrible this year.

📺 Golf: BMW Championship, Final Round

Golf Channel/NBC until around 6 p.m. ET

The top 30 players in the FedExCup standings after today’s round will advance to the TOUR Championship. Robert MacIntyre, whose putter is on fire this week, leads the field by four strokes.

📺 MLB: Mariners at Mets 

7 p.m. ET on ESPN 

The Mariners are my personal World Series pick at the moment. I’ll also use this space to point you toward Sam Blum’s story about a dog whose owner dresses her in Mets gear and farms her out for photos in the New York heat all summer. Good reporting, bad dog ownership.

Get tickets to games like these here.


Pulse Picks

Greg Olsen has strong opinions on the biggest issues facing youth sports right now. This interview is worth a read today.

Even the 7-year-old now eats one Reese’s cup and is willing to wait for the other out of the freezer. That’s growth. Refridge your Reese’s, people. — Chris Sprow

If our crash course for new card collectors in last weekend’s Pulse piqued your interest, you’ll be fascinated by this story on a Jay Cutler card selling for over $12,000 last week. The buyer of the card got in touch to explain the situation, and his explanation is frankly hilarious.

Advertisement

My daughter went back to school this week (what a delight) and our new water bottle, this “Caticorns” Thermos, is a massive hit. — Chris Branch

The Athletic’s weekly sports news quiz.

How many times have I heard the title of Octavia E. Butler’s classic 1993 novel “The Parable of the Sower”? Hundreds, probably. But I hadn’t read it until this week. It’s set in — or at least it starts in — a dystopian version of 2024 and goes through the next few years, so it’s a good time to start it if you haven’t. — Levi Weaver

Jim Bowden has an early look at the top 25 potential MLB free agents as the offseason draws nearer. Kyle Tucker is about to get paid how much?

I finally bought into the HOKA hype my family has been selling me on for years. Unfortunately, they were right. Incredibly comfortable — and a little extra height never hurt anyone either. — Sam Settleman

Matt Baker had a fun story this weekend on Missouri State football’s rise to the FBS level, 10 years after a 70-7 loss ended any conversation of the Bears leaving the FCS. Not as fun: Their FBS debut is at the Coliseum against USC in two weeks.

Most-clicked in the newsletter yesterday: The Brewers’ first comeback of the weekend.

Most-read on the website yesterday: How a catfishing scam is putting both fans and female golfers in danger. Scary stuff.

Ticketing links in this article are provided by partners of The Athletic. Restrictions may apply. The Athletic maintains full editorial independence. Partners have no control over or input into the reporting or editing process and do not review stories before publication.

(Top photo: Tim Warner / Getty Images)

This news was originally published on this post .

About the author

About the author call_made

SPORTIVO

More posts

NFL Betting 2025: Best TE props to target in Week 1

T.J. Hockenson to cook again versus the Bears: Kevin O’Connell leaned heavily on Hockenson down the stretch last season, with the tight end seeing the sixth-most targets at his position (67) after returning from injury. That included 12 catches on 17 targets across two games against Chicago. Chigoziem Okonkwo faces a tough matchup against Denver: The Broncos led the NFL with an 85.6 PFF coverage grade on throws to tight ends last season, while also ranking top-six in passer rating allowed (81.5), yards per target (6.4), and open target rate (54.6%). The brand new PFF Player Props tool is LIVE!Now you can get betting insights, matchup data, historical hit rates and much more right at your fingertips. No matter if you're a seasoned bettor or just getting into the swing of things, the new Player Props Tool gives you actionable takes to […]

trending_flat
PFF’s All-Time Single-Season Teams: AFC West

Khalil Mack‘s greatness spans multiple teams: Mack recorded two of the highest-graded campaigns in both Raiders and Chargers history. Estimated Reading Time: 6 minutes In honor of PFF heading into its 20th season of grading and data collection, we’re taking a look back at the best single-season performances for each team according to PFF grading. As such, we’ve built a series of starting offensive and defensive lineups for all 32 teams using the highest-graded seasons at every position. There are a few rules: A player must have played at least 500 snaps in a given season A player can only make one appearance per roster (e.g., Julio Jones can’t take up all three WR slots for Atlanta) A player who was acquired midseason can still be slotted provided he fulfilled the required snap minimum for that team. Without further ado, […]

Slavia oznámila soupisku pro Ligu mistrů. Chybí Zmrzlý

Čekalo se, že se pro Ligu mistrů objeví poslední akvizice jako Prekop nebo záložník Muhammed Cham. I že na ní bude záložník Christos Zafeiris, jenž v lednu odejde do PAOK Soluň. Možné překvapení? Levý bek Youssoupha Mbodji, jenž do Slavie přišel nedávno z druholigové Jihlavy a za sešívané dosud nenastoupil.Naopak se nedostalo na Zmrzlého, který sezonu sice začal v základní sestavě, ale postupně z ní vypadl. Po třech zápasech na lavičce hrál naposledy třináct minut v Mladé Boleslavi. Na list pro milionářskou soutěž se nedostali ani Vorlický, který se rozehrává po velkém zranění a přijde o zajímavou konfrontaci s italskou Alatantou, kde dřív působil. A také Botos, Teah a Fully.Slavia může soupisku doplnit o hráče z B-listu do jednadvaceti let, kteří v klubu působí minimálně dva roky v kuse nebo tři roky s ročním hostováním.Červenobílí začnou Ligu mistrů doma 17. září proti Bodö/Glimt. Pak hrají na Interu, v Bergamu, doma s Arsenalem, Bilbaem, na Tottenhamu, s Barcelonou a na půdě Pafosu.

trending_flat
Evolution over revolution: Man Utd’s transfer strategy explained

Manchester United came into the summer transfer window tasked with beginning to remedy the reasons for the club's worst-ever Premier League season.A 15th-place finish last term represented an all-time low for United, who failed to inspire on the pitch. The season ended in further disappointment in the form of a Europa League final defeat to Tottenham, denying them Champions League football, which further raised the importance of this summer window. Having arrived in November of last season, the last few months have represented Ruben Amorim's first summer window in charge at Old Trafford. United were busy from the off, getting Matheus Cunha done early before completing moves for Bryan Mbeumo, Benjamin Sesko and securing Senne Lammens' services on the final day.Within that there were also departures for Antony and Alejandro Garnacho, in permanent deals to Chelsea and Real Betis respectively, […]

Mám české fanoušky, těší Američanku. Že jí parťačka sebrala pozici jedničky, Siniakovou netrápí

„Nevyšlo to v singlu, ale to neznamená, že nechci titul v deblu,“ prohlásila odhodlaně Townsendová. Mezi nejlepší čtyři páry posledního grandslamu roku se nepřekvapivě dostaly čtyři nejvýše nasazené dvojice. A právě T+S jsou nasazené jedničky, což na Louis Armstrong Stadium dokonale potvrdily.„Jsem nadšená z toho, jak jsme hrály. Splnily jsme plán, naši trenéři byli moc rádi. Solidní výkon od začátku do konce,“ tvrdila Američanka za souhlasného přikyvování Siniakové, která ve Flushing Meadows usiluje už o svůj celkem dvanáctý grandslamový titul. Deset jich má z ženského deblu, jeden z mixu. S Townsendovou by teď mohly ukořistit třetí společný vavřín.„Díky tomu, že hraju s Kat, tak mám české fanoušky a ona má zase příznivce tady v New Yorku,“ usmívala se devětadvacetiletá Američanka, která si dala za cíl změnit mentalitu lidí, kteří čtyřhru podceňují. „Je to stejně těžké jako singl, ale vyžaduje to jiné dovednosti,“ hájila debl.Foto: Geoff Burke, ReutersKateřina Siniaková s Taylor Townsendovou děkují […]

trending_flat
Australia aiming for ‘upset of the tournament’ against Red Roses in blockbuster clash

Australia co-captain Emily Chancellor wants to pull off the "upset of the tournament" when her side take on the Red Roses in the final Pool A game on Saturday.In what is set to be a straight shootout for top spot in the Group, the Wallaroos will be vying to end a remarkable 29-game winning streak from the Red Roses. The Red Roses head into the contest on the back of a record-breaking 92-3 win over Samoa.However, Australia will be looking to bounce back after a 31-31 draw against the United States. Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player Former England rugby player Shaunagh Brown says that the Red Roses' chances of victory are 'incredibly high', but warns of the risk of Canada A close defeat to England looks set to be enough for Australia to put themselves […]

Related

NFL Betting 2025: Best TE props to target in Week 1

T.J. Hockenson to cook again versus the Bears: Kevin O’Connell leaned heavily on Hockenson down the stretch last season, with the tight end seeing the sixth-most targets at his position (67) after returning from injury. That included 12 catches on 17 targets across two games against Chicago. Chigoziem Okonkwo faces a tough matchup against Denver: The Broncos led the NFL with an 85.6 PFF coverage grade on throws to tight ends last season, while also ranking top-six in passer rating allowed (81.5), yards per target (6.4), and open target rate (54.6%). The brand new PFF Player Props tool is LIVE!Now you can get betting insights, matchup data, historical hit rates and much more right at your fingertips. No matter if you're a seasoned bettor or just getting into the swing of things, the new Player Props Tool gives you actionable takes to […]

trending_flat
PFF’s All-Time Single-Season Teams: AFC West

Khalil Mack‘s greatness spans multiple teams: Mack recorded two of the highest-graded campaigns in both Raiders and Chargers history. Estimated Reading Time: 6 minutes In honor of PFF heading into its 20th season of grading and data collection, we’re taking a look back at the best single-season performances for each team according to PFF grading. As such, we’ve built a series of starting offensive and defensive lineups for all 32 teams using the highest-graded seasons at every position. There are a few rules: A player must have played at least 500 snaps in a given season A player can only make one appearance per roster (e.g., Julio Jones can’t take up all three WR slots for Atlanta) A player who was acquired midseason can still be slotted provided he fulfilled the required snap minimum for that team. Without further ado, […]

Slavia oznámila soupisku pro Ligu mistrů. Chybí Zmrzlý

Čekalo se, že se pro Ligu mistrů objeví poslední akvizice jako Prekop nebo záložník Muhammed Cham. I že na ní bude záložník Christos Zafeiris, jenž v lednu odejde do PAOK Soluň. Možné překvapení? Levý bek Youssoupha Mbodji, jenž do Slavie přišel nedávno z druholigové Jihlavy a za sešívané dosud nenastoupil.Naopak se nedostalo na Zmrzlého, který sezonu sice začal v základní sestavě, ale postupně z ní vypadl. Po třech zápasech na lavičce hrál naposledy třináct minut v Mladé Boleslavi. Na list pro milionářskou soutěž se nedostali ani Vorlický, který se rozehrává po velkém zranění a přijde o zajímavou konfrontaci s italskou Alatantou, kde dřív působil. A také Botos, Teah a Fully.Slavia může soupisku doplnit o hráče z B-listu do jednadvaceti let, kteří v klubu působí minimálně dva roky v kuse nebo tři roky s ročním hostováním.Červenobílí začnou Ligu mistrů doma 17. září proti Bodö/Glimt. Pak hrají na Interu, v Bergamu, doma s Arsenalem, Bilbaem, na Tottenhamu, s Barcelonou a na půdě Pafosu.

trending_flat
Evolution over revolution: Man Utd’s transfer strategy explained

Manchester United came into the summer transfer window tasked with beginning to remedy the reasons for the club's worst-ever Premier League season.A 15th-place finish last term represented an all-time low for United, who failed to inspire on the pitch. The season ended in further disappointment in the form of a Europa League final defeat to Tottenham, denying them Champions League football, which further raised the importance of this summer window. Having arrived in November of last season, the last few months have represented Ruben Amorim's first summer window in charge at Old Trafford. United were busy from the off, getting Matheus Cunha done early before completing moves for Bryan Mbeumo, Benjamin Sesko and securing Senne Lammens' services on the final day.Within that there were also departures for Antony and Alejandro Garnacho, in permanent deals to Chelsea and Real Betis respectively, […]

Mám české fanoušky, těší Američanku. Že jí parťačka sebrala pozici jedničky, Siniakovou netrápí

„Nevyšlo to v singlu, ale to neznamená, že nechci titul v deblu,“ prohlásila odhodlaně Townsendová. Mezi nejlepší čtyři páry posledního grandslamu roku se nepřekvapivě dostaly čtyři nejvýše nasazené dvojice. A právě T+S jsou nasazené jedničky, což na Louis Armstrong Stadium dokonale potvrdily.„Jsem nadšená z toho, jak jsme hrály. Splnily jsme plán, naši trenéři byli moc rádi. Solidní výkon od začátku do konce,“ tvrdila Američanka za souhlasného přikyvování Siniakové, která ve Flushing Meadows usiluje už o svůj celkem dvanáctý grandslamový titul. Deset jich má z ženského deblu, jeden z mixu. S Townsendovou by teď mohly ukořistit třetí společný vavřín.„Díky tomu, že hraju s Kat, tak mám české fanoušky a ona má zase příznivce tady v New Yorku,“ usmívala se devětadvacetiletá Američanka, která si dala za cíl změnit mentalitu lidí, kteří čtyřhru podceňují. „Je to stejně těžké jako singl, ale vyžaduje to jiné dovednosti,“ hájila debl.Foto: Geoff Burke, ReutersKateřina Siniaková s Taylor Townsendovou děkují […]

trending_flat
Australia aiming for ‘upset of the tournament’ against Red Roses in blockbuster clash

Australia co-captain Emily Chancellor wants to pull off the "upset of the tournament" when her side take on the Red Roses in the final Pool A game on Saturday.In what is set to be a straight shootout for top spot in the Group, the Wallaroos will be vying to end a remarkable 29-game winning streak from the Red Roses. The Red Roses head into the contest on the back of a record-breaking 92-3 win over Samoa.However, Australia will be looking to bounce back after a 31-31 draw against the United States. Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player Former England rugby player Shaunagh Brown says that the Red Roses' chances of victory are 'incredibly high', but warns of the risk of Canada A close defeat to England looks set to be enough for Australia to put themselves […]

Be the first to leave a comment

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sportivo bridges the gap between talent and opportunity.

About SPORTIVO

Sportivo Network is a dedicated social platform for sports enthusiasts, athletes, and scouts. Whether you’re an aspiring athlete looking for opportunities, a coach searching for talent, or simply a sports lover wanting to connect with like-minded people, Sportivo is your go-to network. With features like direct messaging, profile showcasing, and talent scouting, Sportivo bridges the gap between talent and opportunity. Here, you can share your achievements, interact with professionals, and open doors to the next level in your sports journey. Join Sportivo Network – because every great athlete deserves to be discovered!
Copyright © 2025 SPORTIVO News. and SPORTIVO Network. All rights reserved.

Login to enjoy full advantages

Please login or subscribe to continue.

Go Premium!

Enjoy the full advantage of the premium access.

Stop following

Unfollow Cancel

Cancel subscription

Are you sure you want to cancel your subscription? You will lose your Premium access and stored playlists.

Go back Confirm cancellation