In some ways, Notre Dame on Tuesday announcing CJ Carr as its starting quarterback was what everyone expected.
Carr is, after all, the quarterback the program long projected as its future. The grandson of former Michigan head coach Lloyd Carr and a top-50 recruit from the 2024 class, the Fighting Irish skipped signing a transfer quarterback this offseason because of the program’s belief in Carr, per multiple sources.
But when Marcus Freeman told his team Tuesday — just moments before the program posted its announcement on social media — it did come as a surprise to some in the program.
College football QB battles 2025: Ohio State, Alabama, Tennessee settle depth charts as Week 1 approaches
Will Backus
Not because some doubted Carr. Instead, it’s because of how close redshirt sophomore quarterback Kenny Minchey made the competition.
“It could have gone either way,” one source said of the competition.
“I think it was 50-50 where guys think it could have went either way where some guys expected one guy and some the other,” another source said.
Minchey, a four-star recruit in the 2023 class, appeared in four games total his first two years at Notre Dame but only attempted three passes during that span.
There were times in camp where sources in and around the program felt like Minchey had a legitimate advantage in the competition. Part of that was the consistency of Minchey’s play. Part of that is Carr can occasionally be aggressive with the football, which can lead to turnovers.
Ultimately, Carr did enough in Notre Dame’s final scrimmage to convince coach Freeman and offensive coordinator Mike Denbrock he was the right guy to lead an Irish offense that’s expected to be among the best rushing attacks in the FBS.
Those around Notre Dame seem to think Carr’s biggest advantage in the competition was his ability to create big plays in the passing game. He’s an aggressive downfield passer who generates explosives. That matters for an Irish program that finished 117th nationally among all FBS teams in passes of 40-plus yards in 2024.
“He has that big-play ability,” said one source.
“Football’s in his blood,” said one source. “He’s got the moxie. He’s got the leadership. He’s got that ‘it’ factor to play that position. Now, he’s just got to go do it.”
Everyone CBS Sports spoke to for this story pointed out that any handwringing about Notre Dame’s quarterback battle is misplaced.
After all, the player that finished, at best, 2A in the quarterback competition during the spring — Steve Angeli — is now the starting quarterback at Syracuse, a job he won in just a matter of months.
“Steve leaving tells you what type of talent these kids have,” said a source.
Notre Dame will find out quickly exactly what Carr will bring as QB1. The No. 6 Irish open the season at No. 10 Miami on Aug. 31 in a Sunday evening primetime matchup. FanDuel currently has Notre Dame favored by 2.5. Two weeks later, the Irish play host to No. 19 Texas A&M.
The extended quarterback battle does raise some potential questions about Carr. But the Irish believes they have one of the nation’s top offensive lines and running back rooms along with an upgraded wide receiver group.
And if Carr hits? The results could be incredible.
“If it turns out really good, it’ll be really, really good,” a source said.
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
Atlético-MG x Cruzeiro pela Copa do Brasil já tem 30 mil ingressos vendidos e pode ter recorde de 2025
Arena MRV ainda não passou de 40 mil presentes em 2025 (Foto: Divulgação/Facebook Atlético-MG)O clássico entre Atlético-MG x Cruzeiro, pelo jogo de ida das quartas de final da Copa do Brasil, promete casa cheia na Arena MRV. Até o momento, mais de 28 mil ingressos já foram comercializados para o duelo que está marcado para esta quarta-feira (27). A bola rola às 19h30 (de Brasília). PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADEA venda de ingressos começou na última quarta-feira (20) e os preços dos bilhetes variam entre R$ 60 e R$ 967. Vale lembrar que Atlético-MG x Cruzeiro tem torcida única como previamente combinado pelos clubes. Assim, apenas atleticanos estarão presentes na Arena MRV.Clássico pode ter recorde da Arena no anoA expectativa da diretoria do Atlético-MG é que o clássico marque o recorde de público da Arena MRV em 2025. Atualmente essa marca pertence ao […]
Sparta se probrala po přestávce, obrat s Duklou dokonal fantom Uchenna
Právě duel v Lotyšsku zohlednil trenér Brian Priske při skládání základní sestavy, jen na lavičce začaly opory Lukáš Haraslín, Jan Kuchta, Kaan Kairinen a Matěj Ryneš. Dánskému kouči se tento tah málem nevyplatil.Zápas přitom začal pro Spartu ideálně - ve 20. minutě si na rohový kop Magnuse Andersena sběhl na přední tyč Uchenna a hlavičkou otevřel skóre. Jenže z vedení se Letenští radovali přesně tři minuty. Útočník Cissé stál sice v ofsajdu, využil však nechtěné přihrávky sparťana Andersena. Převzal míč, obehrál Patrika Vydru a propálil Petera Vindahla - 1:1. Dvaadvacetiletého Rakušana ale nenapadlo nic lepšího než jít slavit pod letenský kotel a navíc si svléknout trenky, takže zároveň vyfasoval i žlutou kartu. Jeho zásah byl prvním gólem Dukly na Letné v samostatné české lize. Naposledy se v jejím dresu na stadionu Sparty trefil v roce 1991 někdejší záložník Jozef Kostelník.Vrátit Spartě vedení mohl Angelo Preciado, který si na hranici šestnáctky kličkou vytvořil výtečnou pozici, […]
Krejčího Girona utrpěla na hřišti Villarrealu debakl, Pamplona gólem Budimira porazila Valencii
Villarreal šel do vedení už v sedmé minutě, kdy hrubou chybu obrany v rozehrávce potrestal Pépé. O devět minut později se poprvé prosadil Buchanan, jenž těsně před gólovou střelou na 2:0 nasadil Krejčímu „jesličky“. Kanadský reprezentant pak ještě před přestávkou zvýšil na 4:0 poté, co třetí branku přidal Marín.Domácí po přestávce zvolnili tempo, ale i přesto se Buchananovi v 64. minutě podařilo završit hattrick poté, co na přední tyči nachytal nejistého brankáře Krapyvcova. Šestadvacetiletý Kanaďan je od léta kmenovým hráčem „Žluté ponorky“, v jarní části předchozího ročníku v týmu hostoval z Interu Milán a ze třinácti ligových startů jednou skóroval.Girona má po dvou zápasech na dně tabulky skóre 1:8. Krejčí odehrál stejně jako v prvním kole celý zápas. Podle spekulací médií má reprezentační obránce namířeno do anglického Wolverhamptonu.Espaňol vedl v San Sebastianu už od desáté minuty po brance Milly a v závěru poločasu zvýšil z penalty Puado. Brankář Remiro sice jeho první pokus vyrazil, ale rozhodčí nařídil […]
College football Week 1: Boise State vs. South Florida and Ohio vs. Rutgers spread among Thursday’s best bets
We got our first taste of college football for the 2025 season with a five-game "Week 0" slate over the weekend, but the real action begins this week with a locked and loaded Week 1 schedule that begins on Thursday, Aug. 28. The Inside the Lines team conceived of, developed and powers the SportsLine model. The Inside the Lines betting system combines 1) our strongest projected values, 2) with relevant supporting trends and 3) pinpointed best lines and prices to identify our Best Bets. In a majority of cases lines move in our direction so you will want to ACT NOW before lines move and you lose value. College Football Week 1 Best BetsBoise State -6 (-110, BetMGM) vs. South FloridaModel: Boise State 37, South Florida 24This line has actually moved in our favor from -6.5 to -6, but we don't think it will move […]
Neville: Man Utd display opened scars, they need a midfield signing
Manchester United's performance in their 1-1 draw with Fulham dampened optimism around the side and underlined the need for midfield reinforcements, according to Gary Neville.Emile Smith Rowe's equaliser in a dramatic game at Craven Cottage cancelled out a contentious own goal by Rodrigo Muniz as Manchester United's wait for a first Premier League win of the season continued following last weekend's 1-0 loss to Arsenal. The opening-weekend performance at Old Trafford offered encouragement as new signings Matheus Cunha and Bryan Mbeumo impressed, but Sky Sports pundit Neville felt Sunday's game highlighted familiar problems - particularly in midfield.Ruben Amorim persisted with Casemiro and Bruno Fernandes as his central pairing, with the latter missing a first-half penalty as Kobbie Mainoo remained an unused substitute. Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player Highlights from the Premier League match between Manchester […]
Browns release Tyler Huntley, appear positioned to carry four QBs on 53-man Cleveland roster
The Cleveland Browns trimmed their quarterback room to four active players following the release of Tyler Huntley, according to Adam Schefter. Cleveland "has been planning to keep its other four" quarterbacks. This comes after Huntley led the Browns on a game-winning drive during the preseason finale against the Los Angeles Rams after substituting into the game with in place of Shedeur Sanders.Huntley signed with the Browns at the start of preseason following Kenny Pickett's hamstring injury to ensure Cleveland had enough quarterback options. Huntley, 27, spent last training camp with Cleveland before failing to make the 53-man roster. The Browns appear prepared to keep Joe Flacco (starter), Pickett and rookies Dillon Gabriel and Sanders.Browns general manager Andrew Berry told NFL Network during Saturday's game that keeping four quarterbacks on the 53-man roster is "not much of a decision" for the franchise."We have […]
Related
Atlético-MG x Cruzeiro pela Copa do Brasil já tem 30 mil ingressos vendidos e pode ter recorde de 2025
Arena MRV ainda não passou de 40 mil presentes em 2025 (Foto: Divulgação/Facebook Atlético-MG)O clássico entre Atlético-MG x Cruzeiro, pelo jogo de ida das quartas de final da Copa do Brasil, promete casa cheia na Arena MRV. Até o momento, mais de 28 mil ingressos já foram comercializados para o duelo que está marcado para esta quarta-feira (27). A bola rola às 19h30 (de Brasília). PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADEA venda de ingressos começou na última quarta-feira (20) e os preços dos bilhetes variam entre R$ 60 e R$ 967. Vale lembrar que Atlético-MG x Cruzeiro tem torcida única como previamente combinado pelos clubes. Assim, apenas atleticanos estarão presentes na Arena MRV.Clássico pode ter recorde da Arena no anoA expectativa da diretoria do Atlético-MG é que o clássico marque o recorde de público da Arena MRV em 2025. Atualmente essa marca pertence ao […]
Sparta se probrala po přestávce, obrat s Duklou dokonal fantom Uchenna
Právě duel v Lotyšsku zohlednil trenér Brian Priske při skládání základní sestavy, jen na lavičce začaly opory Lukáš Haraslín, Jan Kuchta, Kaan Kairinen a Matěj Ryneš. Dánskému kouči se tento tah málem nevyplatil.Zápas přitom začal pro Spartu ideálně - ve 20. minutě si na rohový kop Magnuse Andersena sběhl na přední tyč Uchenna a hlavičkou otevřel skóre. Jenže z vedení se Letenští radovali přesně tři minuty. Útočník Cissé stál sice v ofsajdu, využil však nechtěné přihrávky sparťana Andersena. Převzal míč, obehrál Patrika Vydru a propálil Petera Vindahla - 1:1. Dvaadvacetiletého Rakušana ale nenapadlo nic lepšího než jít slavit pod letenský kotel a navíc si svléknout trenky, takže zároveň vyfasoval i žlutou kartu. Jeho zásah byl prvním gólem Dukly na Letné v samostatné české lize. Naposledy se v jejím dresu na stadionu Sparty trefil v roce 1991 někdejší záložník Jozef Kostelník.Vrátit Spartě vedení mohl Angelo Preciado, který si na hranici šestnáctky kličkou vytvořil výtečnou pozici, […]
Krejčího Girona utrpěla na hřišti Villarrealu debakl, Pamplona gólem Budimira porazila Valencii
Villarreal šel do vedení už v sedmé minutě, kdy hrubou chybu obrany v rozehrávce potrestal Pépé. O devět minut později se poprvé prosadil Buchanan, jenž těsně před gólovou střelou na 2:0 nasadil Krejčímu „jesličky“. Kanadský reprezentant pak ještě před přestávkou zvýšil na 4:0 poté, co třetí branku přidal Marín.Domácí po přestávce zvolnili tempo, ale i přesto se Buchananovi v 64. minutě podařilo završit hattrick poté, co na přední tyči nachytal nejistého brankáře Krapyvcova. Šestadvacetiletý Kanaďan je od léta kmenovým hráčem „Žluté ponorky“, v jarní části předchozího ročníku v týmu hostoval z Interu Milán a ze třinácti ligových startů jednou skóroval.Girona má po dvou zápasech na dně tabulky skóre 1:8. Krejčí odehrál stejně jako v prvním kole celý zápas. Podle spekulací médií má reprezentační obránce namířeno do anglického Wolverhamptonu.Espaňol vedl v San Sebastianu už od desáté minuty po brance Milly a v závěru poločasu zvýšil z penalty Puado. Brankář Remiro sice jeho první pokus vyrazil, ale rozhodčí nařídil […]
College football Week 1: Boise State vs. South Florida and Ohio vs. Rutgers spread among Thursday’s best bets
We got our first taste of college football for the 2025 season with a five-game "Week 0" slate over the weekend, but the real action begins this week with a locked and loaded Week 1 schedule that begins on Thursday, Aug. 28. The Inside the Lines team conceived of, developed and powers the SportsLine model. The Inside the Lines betting system combines 1) our strongest projected values, 2) with relevant supporting trends and 3) pinpointed best lines and prices to identify our Best Bets. In a majority of cases lines move in our direction so you will want to ACT NOW before lines move and you lose value. College Football Week 1 Best BetsBoise State -6 (-110, BetMGM) vs. South FloridaModel: Boise State 37, South Florida 24This line has actually moved in our favor from -6.5 to -6, but we don't think it will move […]
Neville: Man Utd display opened scars, they need a midfield signing
Manchester United's performance in their 1-1 draw with Fulham dampened optimism around the side and underlined the need for midfield reinforcements, according to Gary Neville.Emile Smith Rowe's equaliser in a dramatic game at Craven Cottage cancelled out a contentious own goal by Rodrigo Muniz as Manchester United's wait for a first Premier League win of the season continued following last weekend's 1-0 loss to Arsenal. The opening-weekend performance at Old Trafford offered encouragement as new signings Matheus Cunha and Bryan Mbeumo impressed, but Sky Sports pundit Neville felt Sunday's game highlighted familiar problems - particularly in midfield.Ruben Amorim persisted with Casemiro and Bruno Fernandes as his central pairing, with the latter missing a first-half penalty as Kobbie Mainoo remained an unused substitute. Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player Highlights from the Premier League match between Manchester […]
Browns release Tyler Huntley, appear positioned to carry four QBs on 53-man Cleveland roster
The Cleveland Browns trimmed their quarterback room to four active players following the release of Tyler Huntley, according to Adam Schefter. Cleveland "has been planning to keep its other four" quarterbacks. This comes after Huntley led the Browns on a game-winning drive during the preseason finale against the Los Angeles Rams after substituting into the game with in place of Shedeur Sanders.Huntley signed with the Browns at the start of preseason following Kenny Pickett's hamstring injury to ensure Cleveland had enough quarterback options. Huntley, 27, spent last training camp with Cleveland before failing to make the 53-man roster. The Browns appear prepared to keep Joe Flacco (starter), Pickett and rookies Dillon Gabriel and Sanders.Browns general manager Andrew Berry told NFL Network during Saturday's game that keeping four quarterbacks on the 53-man roster is "not much of a decision" for the franchise."We have […]
Be the first to leave a comment