Does Neil Critchley need Scottish Cup success for Hearts after his failure to lead them to a top-six finish?
A draw at Motherwell, coupled with St Mirren’s win over Ross County, meant that Hearts slipped into the bottom six in their final pre-split match, meaning they are now in a relegation battle rather than a race for a European place.
Their next match is a Scottish Cup semi-final against Aberdeen on Saturday as they aim to reach the Hampden Park final for the first time since 2022.
Highlights from the Scottish Premiership match between Motherwell and Hearts
The Tynecastle Park side were bottom of the table when Critchley replaced Steven Naismith in October, with the club yet to win a game in the Scottish Premiership.
That is in contrast to Edinburgh rivals Hibs who spent part of the season propping up the table before a 17-game unbeaten run lifted them to third.
Paul Hartley, who won the Scottish Cup with Hearts in 2006, believes he needs to beat the Dons this weekend to win the fans back.
“For Hearts not to get into the top-six was a huge shock, to be quite honest with you,” he told Sky Sports News.
Hearts have struggled this season
“The supporters voiced their opinion on Saturday [at Motherwell]. If they don’t get into the cup final, it becomes more pressure heaped on the manager.
“A poor start to the season, change of manager, had a wee spell where you looked like they’d turn things around and they’ve just never really got going.
“I just don’t think they’ve shown a consistency level.
“If you look at the squad, size of the club, fan base, for them not to get into the top six is very, very disappointing. Saturday is a massive game for them in terms of their season.”
Should Critchley be under pressure?
Is Neil Critchley running out of time at Hearts?
Sky Sports pundits Kris Boyd and Chris Sutton have clashed over their opinions on Critchley’s future at Tynecastle Park.
While Boyd is adamant that his failure to secure a top-six place puts his position under threat, Sutton claimed their form under Steven Naismith meant that survival was his only remit this season.
Kris Boyd
“It’s been a disappointing season for them. Stephen Naismith lost his job because of the start they had obviously.
“Neil Critchley came in and got a lot of plaudits but, for me, he’s under pressure now.
“They’re the third biggest team in the country and they’re in the top, the bottom six again.
“Saturday [vs Aberdeen] is huge for Hearts now, huge.
“Hearts have underperformed this season, there’s no getting away from it and they’ve failed.”
Chris Sutton
“He’s had one transfer window which he’s had; his aim when he came in was to keep the club in the top flight. The wheels were off [before he took charge].
“The disappointment will be it was in their hands, they were in the top six.
“You can’t start sacking managers when it’s not really his decision. It would be ridiculous to sack him.
“He wasn’t the manager at the start of the season when recruitment was one of the biggest issues at Hearts.”
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
NBA playoffs: Draymond Green narrowly avoids ejection after heated first half with Rockets in Game 4
Draymond Green got into a bit of trouble early on Monday night at the Chase Center.Though he managed to avoid an ejection in the first half of the Golden State Warriors’ Game 4 matchup with the Houston Rockets, he did so just barely after getting into back-to-back altercations.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementThings popped off in the first half after Green, Stephen Curry and Dillon Brooks got into an incident that felt like it was a few games in the making.After Green set a hard screen on Amen Thompson, Brooks hip-checked Curry and sent him down to the floor. Curry, taunting a bit, threw up two fingers at Brooks after he was called for a foul. Brooks then tried to grab the ball out of Curry’s hands, which sparked the incident and sent plenty of people rushing in to try and break it all up.In […]
7ª rodada do Brasileirão Feminino tem Ferroviária e Cruzeiro empatados na liderança e empates nos clássicos
Resumo da 7ª rodada do Brasileirão Feminino (Reprodução/Flickr/CBF) A 7ª rodada do Brasileirão Feminino foi cheio de emoções, tendo oito partidas com muitos gols e reviravoltas. Enquanto que a parte de cima da tabela teve mudanças, a zona de rebaixamento continua sem ter alterações. Entre os principais destaques, está a vitória da Ferroviária, que venceu um adversário direto na parte de cima da tabela, o Palmeiras, fora de casa. Além disso, tivemos a grande vitória do Bahia, entrou no G8 e promete brigar por uma vaga na próxima fase da competição. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADE Veja como foram os jogos da 7ª rodada do Brasileirão Feminino Cruzeiro 2 x 1 Bragantino Jogando em casa, o Cruzeiro enfrentou o Red Bull Bragantino em busca de permanecer na liderança da competição. Com gols de Stella contra e Leticia Ferreira, a raposa venceu as bragantinas […]
Astros’ Jose Altuve asks to move out of leadoff spot for more time to prepare after playing left field
For the first time in nearly two years, Jose Altuve did not bat in the leadoff spot when the Houston Astros played the Detroit Tigers on Monday.The 15-year veteran requested the change, according to Astros manager Joe Espada. And he did so because of his move to left field this season."I just told Joe that maybe he can hit me second some games at some point and he did it today,” Altuve explained, via the Associated Press. “I just need like that little extra time to come from left field, and he decided to put Jeremy [Peña] there.”AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementPeña, Houston's shortstop, has the second-best on-base percentage on the team at .327. Only third baseman Isaac Paredes, who bats fourth, is better at .342. Altuve's OBP is .310, down from his career mark of .362.“I just need like 10 more seconds,” Altuve […]
NBA playoffs takeaways: Cavs sweep Heat, handing Miami another record defeat
On Saturday, the Miami Heat experienced their worst-ever loss in the postseason, dropping Game 3 to the Cleveland Cavaliers 124-87. It only took two days to beat that record. The Heat lost 138-83 to the Cavaliers in Miami on Monday night, as Cleveland completed a 4-0 sweep to advance to the Eastern Conference semifinals.AdvertisementCleveland took hold of the game from the outset and never let go, leading Miami 72-31 at halftime. To further put that final score in perspective, the Cavaliers shot 54.7 percent from the field compared to the Heat’s 36 percent.Miami played Monday’s game without Kevin Love, whose father, former NBA player Stan Love, died this week at 76.The Cavaliers will play the winner of the series between Indiana and Milwaukee, which the Pacers lead 3-1.Cavaliers 138, Heat 83(Cavaliers win series 4-0)Cleveland dominates without Darius GarlandAt one point, […]
Cavs sweep Heat and complete the most lopsided series in NBA playoff history
<!--> Cleveland left no doubt on its way to Round 2 — and finished off the most lopsided series in NBA playoff history.Donovan Mitchell scored 22 points, De’Andre Hunter added 19 and the Cavaliers rolled past the Miami Heat 138-83 on Monday night to sweep their Eastern Conference first-round series in four games.Ty Jerome had 18 points, Evan Mobley added 17 and Jarrett Allen had 14 points, 12 rebounds and six steals for the Cavaliers — who led by as many as 60 points.Cleveland won the four games by a combined 122 points. The previous record: a 121-point combined win by Denver over New Orleans in 2009.ADVERTISEMENT -->The 55-point margin in Game 4 was the fourth-biggest playoff win ever. The record for biggest playoff win is 58 points, done twice: Minneapolis over St. Louis in 1956 and Denver over New […]
2025 NBA playoff bracket: First-round matchups, schedule, game times as Cavaliers join Thunder in second round
Keytron Jordan, CBS Sports The 2025 NBA playoffs are in full swing, and the Cleveland Cavaliers joined the Oklahoma City Thunder in the second round on Monday night. The Cavs finished off a sweep of the Miami Heat in Game 4, matching their top-seeded West counterpart after OKC swept the Memphis Grizzlies. To close out Monday's schedule, the Golden State Warriors have a chance to take a commanding series lead against the Houston Rockets.Four teams went up 3-1 in their series on Sunday: the Knicks, Timberwolves, Celtics and Pacers were all Game 4 winners, respectively putting the Pistons, Lakers, Magic and Bucks on the brink of elimination.The only series that is tied entering Monday's action is Clippers vs. Nuggets as the two teams have split the first four games of an evenly matched series in the West. The winner of that […]
Related
NBA playoffs: Draymond Green narrowly avoids ejection after heated first half with Rockets in Game 4
Draymond Green got into a bit of trouble early on Monday night at the Chase Center.Though he managed to avoid an ejection in the first half of the Golden State Warriors’ Game 4 matchup with the Houston Rockets, he did so just barely after getting into back-to-back altercations.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementThings popped off in the first half after Green, Stephen Curry and Dillon Brooks got into an incident that felt like it was a few games in the making.After Green set a hard screen on Amen Thompson, Brooks hip-checked Curry and sent him down to the floor. Curry, taunting a bit, threw up two fingers at Brooks after he was called for a foul. Brooks then tried to grab the ball out of Curry’s hands, which sparked the incident and sent plenty of people rushing in to try and break it all up.In […]
7ª rodada do Brasileirão Feminino tem Ferroviária e Cruzeiro empatados na liderança e empates nos clássicos
Resumo da 7ª rodada do Brasileirão Feminino (Reprodução/Flickr/CBF) A 7ª rodada do Brasileirão Feminino foi cheio de emoções, tendo oito partidas com muitos gols e reviravoltas. Enquanto que a parte de cima da tabela teve mudanças, a zona de rebaixamento continua sem ter alterações. Entre os principais destaques, está a vitória da Ferroviária, que venceu um adversário direto na parte de cima da tabela, o Palmeiras, fora de casa. Além disso, tivemos a grande vitória do Bahia, entrou no G8 e promete brigar por uma vaga na próxima fase da competição. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADE Veja como foram os jogos da 7ª rodada do Brasileirão Feminino Cruzeiro 2 x 1 Bragantino Jogando em casa, o Cruzeiro enfrentou o Red Bull Bragantino em busca de permanecer na liderança da competição. Com gols de Stella contra e Leticia Ferreira, a raposa venceu as bragantinas […]
Astros’ Jose Altuve asks to move out of leadoff spot for more time to prepare after playing left field
For the first time in nearly two years, Jose Altuve did not bat in the leadoff spot when the Houston Astros played the Detroit Tigers on Monday.The 15-year veteran requested the change, according to Astros manager Joe Espada. And he did so because of his move to left field this season."I just told Joe that maybe he can hit me second some games at some point and he did it today,” Altuve explained, via the Associated Press. “I just need like that little extra time to come from left field, and he decided to put Jeremy [Peña] there.”AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementPeña, Houston's shortstop, has the second-best on-base percentage on the team at .327. Only third baseman Isaac Paredes, who bats fourth, is better at .342. Altuve's OBP is .310, down from his career mark of .362.“I just need like 10 more seconds,” Altuve […]
NBA playoffs takeaways: Cavs sweep Heat, handing Miami another record defeat
On Saturday, the Miami Heat experienced their worst-ever loss in the postseason, dropping Game 3 to the Cleveland Cavaliers 124-87. It only took two days to beat that record. The Heat lost 138-83 to the Cavaliers in Miami on Monday night, as Cleveland completed a 4-0 sweep to advance to the Eastern Conference semifinals.AdvertisementCleveland took hold of the game from the outset and never let go, leading Miami 72-31 at halftime. To further put that final score in perspective, the Cavaliers shot 54.7 percent from the field compared to the Heat’s 36 percent.Miami played Monday’s game without Kevin Love, whose father, former NBA player Stan Love, died this week at 76.The Cavaliers will play the winner of the series between Indiana and Milwaukee, which the Pacers lead 3-1.Cavaliers 138, Heat 83(Cavaliers win series 4-0)Cleveland dominates without Darius GarlandAt one point, […]
Cavs sweep Heat and complete the most lopsided series in NBA playoff history
<!--> Cleveland left no doubt on its way to Round 2 — and finished off the most lopsided series in NBA playoff history.Donovan Mitchell scored 22 points, De’Andre Hunter added 19 and the Cavaliers rolled past the Miami Heat 138-83 on Monday night to sweep their Eastern Conference first-round series in four games.Ty Jerome had 18 points, Evan Mobley added 17 and Jarrett Allen had 14 points, 12 rebounds and six steals for the Cavaliers — who led by as many as 60 points.Cleveland won the four games by a combined 122 points. The previous record: a 121-point combined win by Denver over New Orleans in 2009.ADVERTISEMENT -->The 55-point margin in Game 4 was the fourth-biggest playoff win ever. The record for biggest playoff win is 58 points, done twice: Minneapolis over St. Louis in 1956 and Denver over New […]
2025 NBA playoff bracket: First-round matchups, schedule, game times as Cavaliers join Thunder in second round
Keytron Jordan, CBS Sports The 2025 NBA playoffs are in full swing, and the Cleveland Cavaliers joined the Oklahoma City Thunder in the second round on Monday night. The Cavs finished off a sweep of the Miami Heat in Game 4, matching their top-seeded West counterpart after OKC swept the Memphis Grizzlies. To close out Monday's schedule, the Golden State Warriors have a chance to take a commanding series lead against the Houston Rockets.Four teams went up 3-1 in their series on Sunday: the Knicks, Timberwolves, Celtics and Pacers were all Game 4 winners, respectively putting the Pistons, Lakers, Magic and Bucks on the brink of elimination.The only series that is tied entering Monday's action is Clippers vs. Nuggets as the two teams have split the first four games of an evenly matched series in the West. The winner of that […]
Be the first to leave a comment