

Carson Beck‘s transfer from the University of Georgia to the University of Miami has raised eyebrows across the college football landscape, and one NFL scout believes the switch isn’t a good display of his professional qualities.
Once hailed as a rising star following a promising 2023 campaign, the quarterback’s trajectory took a sharp turn in 2024, ultimately leading to questions about both his performance and character.
Among the critics is the renowned analyst Todd McShay, whose cold assessment has brought new scrutiny to Beck’s departure from Athens on January 9, shortly after declaring for the NFL Draft before opting against it.
Despite the 23-year-old throwing for 24 touchdowns and just six interceptions, expectations for the Georgia signal-caller soared heading into 2024. However, that optimism quickly faded. Beck struggled with inconsistency, throwing 12 interceptions and failing to meet the high standards he had previously set.
His decline in form coincided with increased media attention, particularly surrounding his public relationship with the Hurricanes’ Hanna Cavinder, which then ended via injury during the SEC Championship Game.
Despite his status as the face of Georgia’s offense, the program showed little hesitation in moving on. The seemingly quiet parting of ways sparked speculation that deeper issues may have been at play.
And McShay did not hold back during a July 14 episode of his show as he suggested that Georgia’s willingness to let go of Beck might reflect concerns that go beyond football, centered about his personality.
“Do you trust the guy,” McShay questioned. “And I’m not talking about the quarterback. I’m talking, ‘Do you trust the guy?’
“If this guy was that good, and more importantly, if they trusted him and they loved the guy… and it was about the team, and about the guys in his huddle, the guys in the locker room…
“You’re telling me the dawgs wouldn’t have come up with the money and made sure that this was the No. 1 priority?”
Can Beck respond in Miami?
Now in Florida, Beck has a chance to reset his career. Though the pressure to replace their departed standout, Cam Ward, is substantial, the environment may be more favorable. Miami’s offense, which is regarded as more dynamic than Georgia’s.
This offers Beck a new platform supported by a strong offensive line led by Francis Mauigoa and weapons like SEC transfer CJ Daniels. Even the schedule falls in his favor too as the Hurricanes rank 36th in terms of most difficult, whilst the Bulldogs are 13th.
Still, expectations remain high. With the team hoping to build on Ward’s success, Beck will need to show immediate progress and avoid the turnovers that plagued his final year in Athens.
His talent is unquestioned but as McShay pointed out, NFL teams and college programs alike want more than just skill so Beck’s time in Miami will not only be a test of performance but also of trust, leadership, and accountability.
This news was originally published on this post .
Be the first to leave a comment