- Tyler Warren might be the best bet to continue the rookie TE1 trend: It’s not going to be easy, and he’ll need some help, but Warren boasts the talent and opportunity to deliver another great rookie season for fantasy managers.
- Dalton Kincaid has plenty of untapped potential heading into 2025: After a sophomore slump in 2024, there are plenty of reasons to believe in Kincaid returning that top-five tight end potential this season.
- Subscribe to PFF+: Get access to player grades, PFF Premium Stats, fantasy football rankings, all of the PFF fantasy draft research tools and more!
Estimated reading time: 12 minutes

The overall fantasy TE1 used to belong solely to Travis Kelce, but as Kelce has declined, the youngsters have emerged in each of the past two seasons to steal the crown and set the tone for new blood to take over. Brock Bowers and Sam LaPorta have proven that the field can be opened up for newcomers and shift away from our usual suspect(s) at the position, which is the basis of this list heading into the 2025 season.
To fit the darkhorse theme and qualifications, we’ll look at tight ends going outside the top 10 in their positional average draft position to find another potential outlier, like Bowers and LaPorta last season, as difficult as that may seem. Looking back at the impressive numbers that Bowers, LaPorta, Kelce, and even Mark Andrews posted in their TE1 seasons, we should at least have a starting point for what to look for in our potential darkhorse options.
- Averaging close to 14 PPR points per game should be considered the absolute minimum for our TE1 candidates this season — a mark that Trey McBride, Brock Bowers and George Kittle all hit last year.
- Several tight ends cleared double-digit PPR points per game last season, so it will be necessary for a darkhorse tight end to add a few more points per game to get themselves into that upper echelon in 2025.
- Several other underlying metrics create the high-end points per game totals that our past TE1s provided over the past few seasons, which will hopefully help us narrow down who can break through this season.
- As is the case with most high-end receiving options, optimal efficiency goes hand in hand with our top fantasy finishers at the position.
- Yards per route run is one of the key stable metrics for tight ends, so those who have a history of being the most efficient at the position should be able to produce close to 2.00 yards per route run to get within reach of the overall TE1.
- Each past TE1 finished top-five in PFF receiving grade in those seasons as well, so having the skillset to get to that range should also be considered.
- Lastly, touchdown opportunities are going to be key for elite fantasy production at the position, so a red-zone target rate of close to 20% is crucial.
- 2021 was the only season from 2018 to 2022 where Kelce didn’t finish as the overall TE1, and it was also the only year in that range that he did not come close to that 20%-plus red-zone target rate (15.1%).
- Commanding a large piece of the team’s target share is crucial to elite fantasy success across an entire season, as all previous TE1s saw at least 21% of the target pie on the year.
- As long as this is the case, it matters less about other potential target competition, as each of these past TE1s, aside from 2022 Travis Kelce, had one other player on the team earn a minimum 20% target share themselves.
With all the criteria in mind, we can take on the difficult task of identifying which tight ends going outside the top five at their position could make a real push to become 2025’s TE1.

Best shot: Tyler Warren, Indianapolis Colts
- Sleeper ADP: TE11
- Underdog ADP: TE9
- ESPN ADP: TE14
- Consensus ADP: TE11
After back-to-back seasons of a rookie finishing as the overall TE1, it was going to be impossible not to include another on the list this year, especially in such a strong rookie tight end class. Warren and even Colston Loveland are great options to continue that elite fantasy tight end trend right out of the gate, but choosing one for 2025, Warren might just have the best path to do so.
This news was originally published on this post .
Be the first to leave a comment