NFL Head Coach Hot Seat Ranking: Who’s Under Most Pressure To Win Now?

SPORTIVO
Article arrow_drop_down

–>

Not a single regular-season game has been played yet, but a good case can be made that about one-quarter of the NFL’s coaches are on seats that are already warming up.

Less than eight months after seven of the league’s 32 teams changed coaches at the end of last season, there are at least seven more who begin the season with at least one toe out the door. Some of them are in more danger than others. But all of them know they need to win.

How fast? And how long can any of them survive more losing? Listed below are the seven head coaches under the most pressure heading into Week 1.

*We’ll update these rankings periodically throughout the season.

1. Mike McDaniel, Miami Dolphins 

It’s a little unfair that McDaniel might enter the season on the hottest seat in the league, because a lot of his work has been undone by the health of QB Tua Tagovailoa. In Tagovailoa’s only fully healthy season with McDaniel, the Dolphins went 11-6. But overall, McDaniel is 28-23 and 0-2 in the playoffs, while the brilliance and speed of his offense has never lived up to its promise. There is a feeling in Miami that if they don’t reach the playoffs this year, and maybe even win a game in January, that both McDaniel and GM Chris Grier will be out amid a big housecleaning. Since the first half of the season is the easiest part of the schedule, it sure would help if Miami got off to a hot start.

2. Shane Steichen, Indianapolis Colts 

The fate of new coaches who take over struggling teams are almost always tied to their young, franchise quarterbacks. Unfortunately for Steichen, his was tied to Anthony Richardson. And that’s gone so well that the Colts’ starting quarterback to begin the season is Daniel Jones, the failed franchise quarterback from the Giants. That’s not good news for a team that seemingly has a wild-card ceiling or for a head coach with a two-season record of 17-17. If the Colts end up dismissing Richardson as a bust, you can bet they’ll blow the whole thing up this winter, including likely firing GM Chris Ballard. After the untimely death of owner Jim Irsay, the new bosses could be headed that direction regardless.

Two years ago, the Colts hired Shane Steichen and drafted Anthony Richardson with the No. 4 overall pick. Now, Richardson begins his third season on the bench as Indianapolis looks to snap a four-year playoff drought. (Photo by Logan Bowles/Getty Images) <!–>

–>

ADVERTISEMENT

3. 6. Brian Daboll, New York Giants

His job situation is one of the more interesting in the NFL. There was a case to fire him after the Giants went 3-14 last season, dropping his three-year record to 18-32-1, but co-owner John Mara showed the kind of patience he hasn’t displayed much in the last decade. The Giants then went out and got Daboll the kind of quality quarterback he needs in veteran Russell Wilson, but they’ll be fighting an uphill battle playing one of the toughest schedules in the league. Here’s the most complicating part, though: Daboll’s fate might be more tied to the development of rookie QB Jaxson Dart, who looked good in preseason but might not play until late in the season, if at all. Daboll needs to win, so he won’t rush Dart. But how much losing can he survive, even if Dart shows promise? Mara could face a very complicated decision at the end of the year.

4. Kevin Stefanski, Cleveland Browns 

He’s 40-44 in five seasons in Cleveland, coming off a miserable, 3-14 year, and nobody has been dealt a worse hand at quarterback over the years than he has. This season’s edition isn’t much better. Maybe he can squeeze a little more out of 40-year-old Joe Flacco. But the real question is whether he can develop rookie Dillon Gabriel into a viable starter — or maybe Shedeur Sanders, if Gabriel doesn’t work out. And oh, by the way, Deshaun Watson is still there, trying to resume his career, just to make this the biggest mess in the NFL. Stefanski is a well-regarded coach — he’s been selected Coach of the Year twice — but ownership can be a little crazy, so another bad year or failure to fix the quarterback issues could easily spark a change.

Kevin Stefanski could be cycling through multiple starting QBs this season after the Browns took two of them in the 2025 draft. (Photo by Jason Miller/Getty Images) <!–>

–>

5. Dave Canales, Carolina Panthers 

His first team in Carolina went 5-12, but the most important thing for him was that there were finally signs of life out of QB Bryce Young. Not a lot, but enough to convince some that the first overall pick of the 2023 draft might actually live up to some of his potential. If the trajectory continues for Young, Canales will get credit. But any regression at all will be a bad sign for his future. And Panthers owner David Tepper has shown he’s willing to make rash decisions, no matter how much damage they might do.

6. Brian Callahan, Tennessee Titans 

If it sounds ridiculous that a team could fire a coach in or after his second season … well, yeah. But the Titans haven’t been known for sound decisions lately. Also, they have put the future of the franchise in the hands of QB Cam Ward, which could be shaky hands even though he was the No. 1 pick of the 2025 draft. Coming off a 3-14 season, the Titans aren’t likely to win a lot of games this year. It means Callahan, a former OC, will largely be judged by how quickly Ward is developing. It better be fast, otherwise the Titans might scour the market for another young quarterback whisperer to save their franchise.

The Titans had the worst record in the NFL in 2024, which netted them the No. 1 pick and Cam Ward. But if he doesn’t improve as the season goes along and Tennessee doesn’t either, where would that leave second-year coach Brian Callahan? (Photo by Kevin Sabitus/Getty Images) <!–>

–>

7. Zac Taylor, Cincinnati Bengals

He probably deserves to be higher on this list because he coaches one of the most talented yet underachieving teams in the league. But the notoriously cheap Bengals won’t do it before they absolutely have to, and Taylor is signed through 2026. At the very least, Taylor should be put on notice that another false start to the season won’t be tolerated. He’s got one of the best quarterbacks in football, a new hand-picked defensive coordinator (Al Golden), and a team that should be one of the four best in the AFC. The Bengals can’t bury themselves with another 0-3 start, like they did last season. Taylor should pay the price if they do.

Ralph Vacchiano is an NFL Reporter for FOX Sports. He spent six years covering the Giants and Jets for SNY TV in New York, and before that, 16 years covering the Giants and the NFL for the New York Daily News. Follow him on Twitter at @RalphVacchiano.

Want great stories delivered right to your inbox? Create or log in to your FOX Sports account, follow leagues, teams and players to receive a personalized newsletter daily.

What did you think of this story?



Get more from the National Football League Follow your favorites to get information about games, news and more


in this topic

This news was originally published on this post .

About the author

About the author call_made

SPORTIVO

More posts

Felipe Melo indica time que pode surpreender Palmeiras, Flamengo e Cruzeiro no Brasileirão: “Botafogo tem um bom time”

Jogadores do Botafogo comemoram gol marcado (Foto: Vítor Silva/Botafogo)O Campeonato Brasileiro tem uma pausa agora durante a Data Fifa, mas já volta daqui dez dias e a disputa pelo título segue ferrenha, principalmente por Flamengo, Cruzeiro e Palmeiras, os três primeiros colocados atualmente. Na opinião do ex-jogador Felipe Melo, a disputa deve seguir até o fim com esses três times, mas o Botafogo tem potencial e também pode entrar na briga. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADEEm vídeo publicado nas redes sociais, o comentarista do SporTV destacou que não consegue cravar quem será o campeão do Brasileirão 2025, pois “não tem uma bola de cristal”, mas que não acredita em grandes surpresas na disputa pelo troféu, a não ser o Fogão, que tem um time forte capaz de bater de frente com os três primeiros na tabela de classificação.“Acho que vai ficar entre esses […]

Felipe Melo ignora Pedro, do Flamengo, e crava João Pedro camisa 9 da seleção brasileira: “Hoje é o mais preparado”

João Pedro durante treino da seleção - FOTO: @rafaelribeirorio / CBFEm ascensão no Flamengo, Pedro ainda não convence Felipe Melo na seleção brasileira. Na avaliação do ex-volante, o camisa 9 estaria atrás, por exemplo, de outros dois centroavantes que atualmente figuram entre os principais para a posição: João Pedro e Kaio Jorge. Em sua análise, o jogador do Chelsea desponta como melhor opção para Carlo Ancelotti pela sequência adquirida no clube inglês. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADEIndagado por torcedores, o comentarista destacou o artilheiro do Brasileirão e imagina que ele possa futuramente ser a referência de gols do Brasil, mas se pudesse escolher na disputa entre os dois optaria pelo atleta dos Blues.“É um cara que ganhou a Copa do Mundo com o Chelsea, foi peça super importante, titular de um dos maiores clubes do mundo na atualidade, joga na Premier League. Hoje […]

Grêmio ainda aguarda Willian, mas confirma seis reforços na segunda janela de transferências; Noriega é o mais caro

Grêmio vem de empate fora de casa com Flamengo - Foto: Lucas Uebel/GrêmioCiente de que precisava agregar mais qualidade e experiência ao seu elenco, o Grêmio aproveitou o período da segunda janela de transferências no futebol brasileiro para se reforçar e ampliar as alternativas do treinador Mano Menezes. Seis nomes já foram confirmados e o sétimo deverá ser o meia-atacante Willian, livre no mercado desde a saída do Fulham, da Inglaterra. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADEO jogador gostou do projeto apresentado pelo clube e deve ser anunciado em breve – a CBF, aliás, “furou” o anúncio gremista ao publicar nos seus registros na última terça-feira uma imagem do atleta de 37 anos já com a camisa do Grêmio.“Tivemos a estreia do Noriega, que foi bem, fez bem as duas funções, não é fácil enfrentar um ataque como esse volume todo. Fez bem. Isso […]

Palmeiras gasta quase R$ 700 milhões em 2025, contrata 12 reforços e Andreas Pereira é o mais caro do segundo semestre

Vitor Roque é uma das contratações de destaque do Palmeiras em 2025 - Miguel Schincariol/Getty ImagesO Palmeiras tem o seu maior ano da história, em se tratando de contratações, com o Verdão chegando no último dia da janela de transferências de 2025 sem pendências para resolver, e com quase R$ 700 milhões gastos no ano, sendo o maior investimento da história do clube e também do futebol brasileiro. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADEPara sermos mais exatos nos números, o Palmeiras contratou 12 jogadores em 2025 e bateu R$ 688 milhões em investimentos e um elenco forte para o final da temporada e próximos anos.Entre as contratações, a de Andreas Pereira é comemorada nas alamedas do clube, pois custou aos cofres do Verdão 10 milhões de euros ou R$ 63,5 milhões, mas no começo do ano, os valores giravam perto dos 20 milhões de […]

Corinthians tem janela de transferências discreta e vê rivais como Flamengo e Palmeiras se reforçarem

Vitinho, jogador do Corinthians (Rodrigo Coca / Agência Corinthians)A janela de transferências do Brasil teve seu encerramento na última terça-feira (2), e o Corinthians teve apenas Vitinho como novidade. Com apenas um reforço contratado, o Timão foi quem menos se movimento no mercado da bola entre todos os clubes da Série A do Brasileirão. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADEFlamengo e Palmeiras, por exemplo, abriram os cofres para fechar com cinco novos atletas, considerando também a janela especial para o Mundial de Clubes. Já o Santos, que também vive um momento financeiro conturbado, apostou em oito novos jogadores.Importante frisar que o Corinthians teve diversos atletas oferecidos nos últimos meses, chegando a abrir negociações com alguns deles, mas não conseguiu chegar a um acordo para fechar a contratação. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADEEntre os principais nomes que foram especulados no Timão estão:Agustín Anello (atacante)Esgalo (lateral-direito)Kaio César (atacante)Pedrinho (meia)Mantuan […]