The Brewers cruised against the Cubs, 9-3, in Game 1 of the NLDS Saturday (box score). Cubs leadoff man Michael Busch started the series with a home run, but it was 9-1 Brewers before the end of the second inning and the rest of the game became a mere formality.
The Cubs went with left-handed All-Star Matthew Boyd on the mound for this one. In a vacuum, it might sound like the reasonable move. In context, though, it was a head-scratcher even before the implosion.
First off, Boyd was starting on short rest. He worked Game 1 of the Wild Card Series against the Padres on Tuesday. He had previously started three games on short rest in his career and those came one time each in 2015, 2016 and 2017.
Further, Boyd ran out of gas in the second half. Remember, he was returning from major surgery last season and made only 11 appearances between the 2024 regular season and playoffs, amounting to 51 ⅓ innings. Boyd threw 179 ⅔ innings this season and posted a 5.51 ERA in his last eight regular-season starts. Even with a few good starts mixed in, he just wasn’t the same guy who was the unquestioned ace of the Cubs’ staff with a 2.20 ERA through July 22.
Maybe the Cubs liked that Boyd only threw 58 pitches in Game 1? Plus, rookie frontline starter Cade Horton is hurt while Shota Imanaga and Jameson Taillon were unavailable due to their own Wild Card Series starts. It should also be noted that four of the six runs Boyd allowed were unearned due to a uncharacteristic error from Nico Hoerner, one of the best defenders in baseball.
Still, Boyd had already allowed three straight doubles to start the game and then a one-out walk before the Hoerner error. After the error, he coughed up another single.
To summarize: Horton’s hurt, Taillon and Imanaga were unavailable and Hoerner made a huge error. There were plenty of things working against the Cubs in Game 1, but Boyd was very much one of them.
Why’d he start?
“I think we just didn’t feel like the number of pitches that he threw on Tuesday [was too many],” Cubs manager Craig Counsell said after Game 1. “What he’s done all season, [he’s] been our best starting pitcher.”
The other options were Colin Rea, who is starting Game 2, and Javier Assad, who was left off the NLDS roster. Going with either in Game 1 would have meant extra rest for Boyd before Game 2, as there’s a scheduled day off on Sunday. Rea (11-7, 3.95 ERA) and Assad (4-1, 3.65) are the Cubs’ fifth and sixth starters, but Boyd sure got peppered in Game 1 like he shouldn’t have been out there.
The silver lining for the Cubs is that Aaron Civale and Ben Brown carried enough of a load in relief that the Cubs didn’t use their five best relievers at all and there are days off flanking Monday’s Game 2. The bad news is they are trailing the best-of-five series 1-0 and didn’t even make the Brewers’ pitchers sweat in this one.
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
NFL Week 6 Team of the Week: Rico Dowdle Stays Hot; Smith-Njigba Continues Rise
Each week, we’ll offer up the very best of the NFL for a given week, kind of like the fantasy football team you wished you had.We’ll pick one quarterback, two running backs, two receivers and a tight end – OK, this is sounding a lot like a super-hindsight fantasy football team – as a way to look back on the weekend that was.An unlikely running back returns to the team, while wide receiver features two players who are ascending to stardom:QB: Drake Maye, PatriotsThe second-year quarterback already has four multi-touchdown games in six weeks this season – Sunday was 18-for-26 for 261 yards with three touchdowns and no interceptions, and he led the Patriots in rushing with 28 yards. New England is off to a 4-2 start after finishing 4-13 last season. Few quarterbacks in the league have less to work […]
Patrick Mahomes, Brian Branch Involved in Lions vs. Chiefs Post-Game Scuffle
An intense primetime battle between the Kansas City Chiefs and Detroit Lions didn't end after the final whistle Sunday night as the bad blood spilled over post-game.A heated scuffle broke out in the final seconds of a 30-17 Chiefs win after an altercation between Patrick Mahomes and Lions safety Brian Branch. Mahomes looked to shake hands with Branch, but the safety ignored his attempt, prompting his wide receiver JuJu Smith-Schuster to come to his defense.Branch, taking exception to the wideout's interference, knocked him down with a smack before Smith-Schuster jumped to his feet and charged at Branch. The two tussled for a few moments as players from both sides exchanged shoves in an unreal scene to close the night. ADVERTISEMENT During his post-game interview, Mahomes declined to address what started the skirmish but made sure to send a message to […]
‘We all Love Baker to Death’: Baker Mayfield Continues MVP-like Output
TAMPA - No Mike Evans. No Chris Godwin. No Jalen McMillan. No Bucky Irving.Then, midway through Sunday's game against the 49ers, clinging to a one-point lead, the Bucs lost rookie phenom Emeka Egbuka to a hamstring injury.The players on the receiving end for Tampa Bay keep changing, but the guy throwing the passes hasn't. Baker Mayfield pulled out another close win Sunday as the Bucs improved to an improbable 5-1 on the season.Mayfield has been a wizard late in games this season, engineering fourth-quarter comebacks for each of the Bucs' first four wins. Sunday was close to a fifth -- the Bucs were clinging to a 20-19 lead late in the third quarter and facing a third-and-14 play when he eluded a sack, scrambled and reached out with the ball for 15 yards and a first down."It's awesome. We all […]
Dillon Gabriel Is in a No-Win Situation Trying to Win The Browns’ Starting QB Job
PITTSBURGH - Rookie quarterbacks are rarely thrown into great situations, because great teams don’t usually need them. Most are thrust into the middle of messes.And there aren’t many situations as messy as the one Dillon Gabriel is in right now.Two starts into his NFL career, the Cleveland Browns’ 2025 third-round pick — and their potential quarterback of the future — might literally be in the league’s biggest no-win situation. It’s not just that he’s on a 1-5 team coming off a 3-14 season. And it’s not just that looming over his shoulder is one of the most high-profile backup quarterbacks in the league.It’s that his passes are being dropped at an alarming rate by even his best receivers. It’s that the 5-foot-11 lefty is playing behind an offensive line that nearly got him killed in a 23-9 loss to the […]
4 Takeaways from the Mariners’ ALCS Game 1 Win Over the Blue Jays
TORONTO - The Mariners stole a game.Improbably, Seattle was on the winning end of the opener of the American League Championship Series after a wild 48 hours that included playing in the longest winner-take-all game in MLB postseason history. After all that, the Mariners won Game 1 on the road against the Blue Jays.Here are my takeaways:1. The 'Dumper’ deliversThe only way Cal Raleigh can top a historic regular season is by having an equally impressive postseason — and he’s in the middle of achieving that. Blue Jays right-hander Kevin Gausman was carving up the Mariners lineup, having retired 15 consecutive batters, and the situation was starting to look bleak for Seattle. The offense was coming off an emotional 15-inning elimination game against the Tigers. Nobody had reached base against Gausman since the first inning. The Mariners were playing from behind, […]
Emotional Denny Hamlin Hits Jackpot at Las Vegas for Another Title Shot
LAS VEGAS — Denny Hamlin has the most wins this season and now has the most time to prepare for the 2025 championship race.Hamlin earned his 60th career victory in capturing his season-high sixth win Sunday at Las Vegas Motor Speedway, a triumph that vaulted him into the Championship 4 in three weeks at Phoenix Raceway. The Joe Gibbs Racing driver doesn’t know the other three drivers who will compete against him for the title Nov. 2. All he knows is this will be his fifth try in the one-race championship round since the current format started in 2014. The 60th victory tied him with Kevin Harvick for 10th on the all-time wins list and a championship is the only thing the 44-year-old Hamlin lacks on his racing resume."Is this my last chance to do it?" asked Hamlin, who has […]
Related
NFL Week 6 Team of the Week: Rico Dowdle Stays Hot; Smith-Njigba Continues Rise
Each week, we’ll offer up the very best of the NFL for a given week, kind of like the fantasy football team you wished you had.We’ll pick one quarterback, two running backs, two receivers and a tight end – OK, this is sounding a lot like a super-hindsight fantasy football team – as a way to look back on the weekend that was.An unlikely running back returns to the team, while wide receiver features two players who are ascending to stardom:QB: Drake Maye, PatriotsThe second-year quarterback already has four multi-touchdown games in six weeks this season – Sunday was 18-for-26 for 261 yards with three touchdowns and no interceptions, and he led the Patriots in rushing with 28 yards. New England is off to a 4-2 start after finishing 4-13 last season. Few quarterbacks in the league have less to work […]
Patrick Mahomes, Brian Branch Involved in Lions vs. Chiefs Post-Game Scuffle
An intense primetime battle between the Kansas City Chiefs and Detroit Lions didn't end after the final whistle Sunday night as the bad blood spilled over post-game.A heated scuffle broke out in the final seconds of a 30-17 Chiefs win after an altercation between Patrick Mahomes and Lions safety Brian Branch. Mahomes looked to shake hands with Branch, but the safety ignored his attempt, prompting his wide receiver JuJu Smith-Schuster to come to his defense.Branch, taking exception to the wideout's interference, knocked him down with a smack before Smith-Schuster jumped to his feet and charged at Branch. The two tussled for a few moments as players from both sides exchanged shoves in an unreal scene to close the night. ADVERTISEMENT During his post-game interview, Mahomes declined to address what started the skirmish but made sure to send a message to […]
‘We all Love Baker to Death’: Baker Mayfield Continues MVP-like Output
TAMPA - No Mike Evans. No Chris Godwin. No Jalen McMillan. No Bucky Irving.Then, midway through Sunday's game against the 49ers, clinging to a one-point lead, the Bucs lost rookie phenom Emeka Egbuka to a hamstring injury.The players on the receiving end for Tampa Bay keep changing, but the guy throwing the passes hasn't. Baker Mayfield pulled out another close win Sunday as the Bucs improved to an improbable 5-1 on the season.Mayfield has been a wizard late in games this season, engineering fourth-quarter comebacks for each of the Bucs' first four wins. Sunday was close to a fifth -- the Bucs were clinging to a 20-19 lead late in the third quarter and facing a third-and-14 play when he eluded a sack, scrambled and reached out with the ball for 15 yards and a first down."It's awesome. We all […]
Dillon Gabriel Is in a No-Win Situation Trying to Win The Browns’ Starting QB Job
PITTSBURGH - Rookie quarterbacks are rarely thrown into great situations, because great teams don’t usually need them. Most are thrust into the middle of messes.And there aren’t many situations as messy as the one Dillon Gabriel is in right now.Two starts into his NFL career, the Cleveland Browns’ 2025 third-round pick — and their potential quarterback of the future — might literally be in the league’s biggest no-win situation. It’s not just that he’s on a 1-5 team coming off a 3-14 season. And it’s not just that looming over his shoulder is one of the most high-profile backup quarterbacks in the league.It’s that his passes are being dropped at an alarming rate by even his best receivers. It’s that the 5-foot-11 lefty is playing behind an offensive line that nearly got him killed in a 23-9 loss to the […]
4 Takeaways from the Mariners’ ALCS Game 1 Win Over the Blue Jays
TORONTO - The Mariners stole a game.Improbably, Seattle was on the winning end of the opener of the American League Championship Series after a wild 48 hours that included playing in the longest winner-take-all game in MLB postseason history. After all that, the Mariners won Game 1 on the road against the Blue Jays.Here are my takeaways:1. The 'Dumper’ deliversThe only way Cal Raleigh can top a historic regular season is by having an equally impressive postseason — and he’s in the middle of achieving that. Blue Jays right-hander Kevin Gausman was carving up the Mariners lineup, having retired 15 consecutive batters, and the situation was starting to look bleak for Seattle. The offense was coming off an emotional 15-inning elimination game against the Tigers. Nobody had reached base against Gausman since the first inning. The Mariners were playing from behind, […]
Emotional Denny Hamlin Hits Jackpot at Las Vegas for Another Title Shot
LAS VEGAS — Denny Hamlin has the most wins this season and now has the most time to prepare for the 2025 championship race.Hamlin earned his 60th career victory in capturing his season-high sixth win Sunday at Las Vegas Motor Speedway, a triumph that vaulted him into the Championship 4 in three weeks at Phoenix Raceway. The Joe Gibbs Racing driver doesn’t know the other three drivers who will compete against him for the title Nov. 2. All he knows is this will be his fifth try in the one-race championship round since the current format started in 2014. The 60th victory tied him with Kevin Harvick for 10th on the all-time wins list and a championship is the only thing the 44-year-old Hamlin lacks on his racing resume."Is this my last chance to do it?" asked Hamlin, who has […]
Be the first to leave a comment