(This article was written with the assistance of Castmagic, an AI tool, and reviewed by our editorial team to ensure accuracy. Please reach out to us if you notice any mistakes.)
In a podcast episode of “Football 301,” Yahoo Sports’ Nate Tice and the Athletic’s Dane Brugler dove into the pros and cons of the top five quarterbacks in the 2025 NFL Draft.
Advertisement
Each of these quarterbacks offers a unique set of strengths and challenges, making evaluation largely dependent on team needs and their willingness to develop certain traits.
Pros: Ward has shown significant improvement and has a calm, cool demeanor that’s attractive for leading a team. He’s very creative in and out of structure, is good at pushing the ball downfield and can scramble effectively. His improvisation skills and ability to elude pursuit are highlights.
Cons: He can sometimes be nonchalant, leading to forced plays or “hero ball” moments. Ward needs to improve his mechanics for more consistent ball spiraling and can drift in the pocket too much, which may not work against NFL defenses.
Pros: Sanders is polished with strong mechanics and plays with good rhythm. He has shown an ability to lead teams effectively, as seen in the turnaround at Colorado. He also takes care of the football, limiting turnover-worthy attempts.
Advertisement
Cons: Concerns arise with his tendency to drift back and take sacks, along with being somewhat mechanical. There are questions about his ability to make progression reads in real time, especially when moving off his first read.
Pros: Dart has an impressive toolbox that includes his size, athleticism and arm strength. He can make some high-level throws and offers mobility as a player who can be effective on designed runs.
Cons: He’s often seen leaning too heavily on a quick first read before deciding to scramble, which isn’t sustainable in the NFL. His decision-making under pressure can be questionable.
Jalen Milroe’s athleticism is his calling card in this NFL Draft. (Photo by Joe Robbins/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)
(Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)
Jalen Milroe, Alabama
Pros: Milroe is explosive with his legs and has an impressive display of physical talent and arm strength. His mental toughness is praised, and he’s drawn comparisons with Jalen Hurts for his resilience.
Advertisement
Cons: There are inconsistencies with his play, particularly against strong defenses. His third- and fourth-down accuracy is concerning, along with his struggles when playing on the road.
Pros: Shough has a strong arm with a hitchless delivery and some mobility. His mental toughness and the ability to deliver under pressure have been highlighted by talent evaluators.
Cons: Age and multiple injuries are potential red flags. His consistency over his college career isn’t strong, and there’s skepticism about his ability to transition to the NFL given his history.
To hear more NFL discussions, tune into “Football 301” on Apple, Spotify or YouTube.
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
Ranking the 25 best players in the College Football Playoff: Ohio State, Miami standouts lead the way
The College Football Playoff has arrived, and with it a smaller stage where a handful of elite players can decide games. This list is pulled directly from our full Top 150 player rankings -- which will be published later this week -- and narrows that broader evaluation to the best players still competing for a national championship.That approach produces some telling results. Group of Five representatives Tulane and James Madison do not place a single player in the Top 150 or on this list. Oklahoma, despite hosting a playoff game Friday night, has just two players in the Top 150 and none among the top 25. Ohio State accounts for seven of the 25 players ranked here, while seven more will be on the field when Miami plays Texas A&M on Saturday afternoon, a matchup guaranteed to eliminate one of the […]
NFL Week 16 picks and score predictions: Rams top Seahawks in Thursday thriller, Packers get sweep of Bears
Happy Holidays to everyone, except for the commissioner of my fantasy league, who knocked me out of our playoffs over the weekend. Did I mention that I hate fantasy football? Last week, I think I said that I love fantasy football, but I've changed my mind after losing in the playoffs by 1.42 points. I only lost because Brandon Aubrey missed two field goals. If he makes just one of of those kicks, I win. And this is the part where I remind you that Aubrey has NEVER MISSED TWO FIELD GOALS IN ANY HOME GAME IN HIS ENTIRE CAREER, but the minute I need him to perform for my team, he falls apart. It's fitting that a Cowboys player let me down, because now I know how their fans have felt for the past 30 years. Cowboys players and the […]
Fastest NFL game of the century: Eagles win over Raiders was the shortest game the league has seen in decades
With temperatures hovering around 30 degrees at kickoff on Sunday, it was a cold day in Philadelphia, but the good news for Eagles fans is that they didn't have to sit around in the cold weather for very long because they got to watch their team pull out a dominant win in what turned out to be one of the fastest games in NFL history.The Eagles destroyed the Raiders, 31-0, in a game that took just two hours and 31 minutes, which made it the shortest game of the century. Since 2000, there have only been two other games that even clocked in at under two hours and 35 minutes. The last one came in 2008 when the Titans beat the Colts in a game that lasted just two hours and 33 minutes. In 2007, the Buccaneers took down the […]
CBF divulga tabela do Brasileirão com início em janeiro e novas regras; veja o que mudou
O Flamengo é o atual campeão do Brasileirão, que tem novas regras (Photo: Jorge Rodrigues/AGIF)A CBF divulgou, na noite desta segunda-feira, a tabela do Campeonato Brasileiro de 2026. Além disso, a entidade divulgou ainda o Regulamento Específico da Competição e o Plano Geral de Ações, que nada mais é do que os detalhes de datas e mandos de campo das partidas e oficializam mudanças que antes eram apenas especulações. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADETalvez a principal mudança seja em relação às trocas de clube durante a competição. Até a edição deste ano, cada jogador tinha o limite de seis jogos para poder se transferir para outra agremiação e jogar o Brasileirão. No entanto, a partir do ano que vem, esse limite dobra. Ou seja, cada jogador passa a ter 12 jogos para escolher outro time para jogar o campeonato.Outra mudança significativa está nas […]
NFL Panic Meter: Packers’ championship dreams might be done after Micah Parsons’ injury
After last season ended well short of a Super Bowl, Green Bay Packers general manager Brian Gutekunst spoke of the franchise operating with more urgency."I think it's time that we start competing for championships, right?" Gutekunst said, via NFL.com.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementThat's why the Packers traded for Micah Parsons. It was a push to going from good to great. And Parsons transformed the Packers defense with his 12.5 sacks.And now, with Parsons done for the season with a torn ACL, the worry has to be that the Packers go from a potentially great season and revert to being good.The Packers aren't going to go away without Parsons. There's still a lot of talent. But Super Bowl dreams are much less realistic without their best player, and one of the best players in the entire NFL. Even beating the Chicago Bears for the NFC […]
Grading all 32 first-round rookies after Week 15
Abdul Carter finished Week 15 as the Giants' highest-graded player: He tallied five defensive stops and four pressures, including a strip sack. Carter also forced a fumble with just under three minutes remaining in the game, which gave New York a chance to put together a game-tying drive. Colston Loveland has become an important weapon in Chicago: He earned an outstanding 89.7 PFF receiving grade in the Bears’ lopsided victory over the Browns. He also played his blocking role well this week, earning a solid 68.4 PFF run-blocking grade. Get PFF+ for 30% off: Use promo code HOLIDAY30 to unlock the PFF Player Prop Tool, Premium Stats, fantasy dashboards, the PFF Mock Draft Simulator, industry-leading fantasy rankings and much more — everything you need to win your season. Estimated Reading Time: 12 minutes The NFL's rookie class is in the […]
Related
Ranking the 25 best players in the College Football Playoff: Ohio State, Miami standouts lead the way
The College Football Playoff has arrived, and with it a smaller stage where a handful of elite players can decide games. This list is pulled directly from our full Top 150 player rankings -- which will be published later this week -- and narrows that broader evaluation to the best players still competing for a national championship.That approach produces some telling results. Group of Five representatives Tulane and James Madison do not place a single player in the Top 150 or on this list. Oklahoma, despite hosting a playoff game Friday night, has just two players in the Top 150 and none among the top 25. Ohio State accounts for seven of the 25 players ranked here, while seven more will be on the field when Miami plays Texas A&M on Saturday afternoon, a matchup guaranteed to eliminate one of the […]
NFL Week 16 picks and score predictions: Rams top Seahawks in Thursday thriller, Packers get sweep of Bears
Happy Holidays to everyone, except for the commissioner of my fantasy league, who knocked me out of our playoffs over the weekend. Did I mention that I hate fantasy football? Last week, I think I said that I love fantasy football, but I've changed my mind after losing in the playoffs by 1.42 points. I only lost because Brandon Aubrey missed two field goals. If he makes just one of of those kicks, I win. And this is the part where I remind you that Aubrey has NEVER MISSED TWO FIELD GOALS IN ANY HOME GAME IN HIS ENTIRE CAREER, but the minute I need him to perform for my team, he falls apart. It's fitting that a Cowboys player let me down, because now I know how their fans have felt for the past 30 years. Cowboys players and the […]
Fastest NFL game of the century: Eagles win over Raiders was the shortest game the league has seen in decades
With temperatures hovering around 30 degrees at kickoff on Sunday, it was a cold day in Philadelphia, but the good news for Eagles fans is that they didn't have to sit around in the cold weather for very long because they got to watch their team pull out a dominant win in what turned out to be one of the fastest games in NFL history.The Eagles destroyed the Raiders, 31-0, in a game that took just two hours and 31 minutes, which made it the shortest game of the century. Since 2000, there have only been two other games that even clocked in at under two hours and 35 minutes. The last one came in 2008 when the Titans beat the Colts in a game that lasted just two hours and 33 minutes. In 2007, the Buccaneers took down the […]
CBF divulga tabela do Brasileirão com início em janeiro e novas regras; veja o que mudou
O Flamengo é o atual campeão do Brasileirão, que tem novas regras (Photo: Jorge Rodrigues/AGIF)A CBF divulgou, na noite desta segunda-feira, a tabela do Campeonato Brasileiro de 2026. Além disso, a entidade divulgou ainda o Regulamento Específico da Competição e o Plano Geral de Ações, que nada mais é do que os detalhes de datas e mandos de campo das partidas e oficializam mudanças que antes eram apenas especulações. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADETalvez a principal mudança seja em relação às trocas de clube durante a competição. Até a edição deste ano, cada jogador tinha o limite de seis jogos para poder se transferir para outra agremiação e jogar o Brasileirão. No entanto, a partir do ano que vem, esse limite dobra. Ou seja, cada jogador passa a ter 12 jogos para escolher outro time para jogar o campeonato.Outra mudança significativa está nas […]
NFL Panic Meter: Packers’ championship dreams might be done after Micah Parsons’ injury
After last season ended well short of a Super Bowl, Green Bay Packers general manager Brian Gutekunst spoke of the franchise operating with more urgency."I think it's time that we start competing for championships, right?" Gutekunst said, via NFL.com.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementThat's why the Packers traded for Micah Parsons. It was a push to going from good to great. And Parsons transformed the Packers defense with his 12.5 sacks.And now, with Parsons done for the season with a torn ACL, the worry has to be that the Packers go from a potentially great season and revert to being good.The Packers aren't going to go away without Parsons. There's still a lot of talent. But Super Bowl dreams are much less realistic without their best player, and one of the best players in the entire NFL. Even beating the Chicago Bears for the NFC […]
Grading all 32 first-round rookies after Week 15
Abdul Carter finished Week 15 as the Giants' highest-graded player: He tallied five defensive stops and four pressures, including a strip sack. Carter also forced a fumble with just under three minutes remaining in the game, which gave New York a chance to put together a game-tying drive. Colston Loveland has become an important weapon in Chicago: He earned an outstanding 89.7 PFF receiving grade in the Bears’ lopsided victory over the Browns. He also played his blocking role well this week, earning a solid 68.4 PFF run-blocking grade. Get PFF+ for 30% off: Use promo code HOLIDAY30 to unlock the PFF Player Prop Tool, Premium Stats, fantasy dashboards, the PFF Mock Draft Simulator, industry-leading fantasy rankings and much more — everything you need to win your season. Estimated Reading Time: 12 minutes The NFL's rookie class is in the […]
Be the first to leave a comment