VAR a ‘muddle’ and ‘an embarassment’ for refs – Merse

SPORTIVO
Article arrow_drop_down

Paul Merson says he is concerned that the buzz and excitement is being taken out of football as he calls for former footballers to help improve VAR decisions after another weekend of controversial calls in the Premier League.

From the overturn of Arsenal’s ‘penalty’ at Newcastle to Nathan Collins avoiding a red card for Brentford against Manchester United and Brighton not being given a penalty at Chelsea, it was another busy weekend for the officials in the top-flight.

Once again, there has been plenty of debate over decisions and in a passionate column for Sky Sports, Merson has had his say on officiating in the top-flight, discussing the use of VAR, muddled rules, how ex-pros could help and his concerns for the future of football…

Read the Magic Man’s thoughts in full below.

‘Football in danger of losing its buzz’

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Burnley manager Scott Parker says he believes that VAR is making football sterile and doesn’t want emotion going out of the game

There is no bigger buzz in football than scoring a goal.

That adrenaline that goes through you when you score that goal and there’s that release from the crowd, it’s an ‘out of this world’ feeling.

I can’t tell you how good that feeling was, but it’s going from the game.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Chelsea’s Malo Gusto escaped a red card for a high-boot challenge on Brighton’s Yankuba Minteh as the on-field referee and the VAR officials both rejected the Seagulls’ penalty claims, much to the Soccer Saturday panel’s disbelief

You can’t celebrate a goal anymore with VAR. There’s no point.

You should wait until they give it now to celebrate because all they are trying to do is stop a goal. They are never trying to get you a goal, just stop it.

This isn’t right, particularly for the fans that pay their money every week to watch football. They want that buzz. There’s no better buzz for them. But the worrying thing for me, is that is going from the game.

‘The constant checking of goals is a grind’

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Howard Webb talks us through the process where officials decided to rule out Josh King’s goal for Fulham against Chelsea, and how the referees ‘misjudged’ the situation

We’re in a situation where the referees have to go to VAR and every goal is being looked at. They go further and further back to look at incidents. They are trying so hard to stop every goal.

This is an entertaining sport.

The decision-making was part of that over the years. We’ve lived with bad results against our teams or the feeling of getting away with one. Now, you can’t celebrate a goal.

Scott Parker said that the other week and he’s bang on.

We don’t just check offside. They check fouls right the way back down the pitch and minor handballs. It’s a grind.

‘The monitor checks are embarrassing’

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Howard Webb explains the reasoning behind overturning Arsenal’s penalty against Newcastle after Nick Pope was adjudged to have touched the ball before making contact with Viktor Gyokeres

One day, I’d absolutely love for a referee to give a penalty and then be called by VAR to the monitor, only for them to ignore the ‘I don’t think it’s a penalty’ stuff and say: “You know what, I do think that’s a penalty. I’m the ref and it’s a penalty.”

It’s embarrassing when they go over. They might as well not go over and just let the VAR give the penalty. It’s a waste of everyone’s time.

They are just telling to change the decision he’s given, and that’s what happens almost 100 per cent of the time.

It drives me up the wall.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Former Premier League referee Dermot Gallagher takes a closer look at the big talking points from the Super Sunday match between Newcastle and Arsenal

Let’s look at the Viktor Gyokeres penalty.

Nick Pope might get the slightest touch on the ball, but he still wipes the striker out.

In a game, if you nick the ball but the forward can still get to it, and then you bring them down, is that not a free-kick?

It’s still a free-kick. You can’t just wipe people out even if you do get the ball.

Merse on ‘muddled’ rules: ‘I don’t get them anymore’

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Listen to how match officials decided that Robert Sanchez’s challenge on Bryan Mbeumo was worthy of a red card when Chelsea travelled to Old Trafford to face Manchester United on September 20

The officials are totally muddled.

One week we get one explanation, the next week we get another. Someone will go through next week and the defender will get a touch to the ball to knock it away but then follow through and bring the player down. That will be a penalty next week.

Look at Robert Sanchez getting sent off at Old Trafford. He got a touch to the ball, didn’t he?

I am struggling with the rules now.

I was sat at home earlier in the season and I ended up shouting at the TV. I couldn’t believe what I was watching. It was Fulham vs Man Utd and Calvin Bassey gave away a penalty for a foul on Mason Mount, wrestling him to the floor.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Dermot Gallagher believes Calvin Bassey’s challenge was rightly penalised by a penalty but admits Leny Yoro was fortunate to avoid a similar punishment

I don’t know what they are watching.

Bassey is one of the best at heading the ball for Fulham, Mount is nowhere near that level heading the ball. He puts his arms around Bassey to try and interfere with him. All Bassey does is throw him away. Why can’t he do that? Mount has his arms around him.

When he throws him away, Mount loses his balance and goes to ground. Ninety-nine out of 100 times, he wouldn’t even fall over.

They give the penalty and it is Mount who has started the grabbing. Why shouldn’t Bassey be allowed to get Mount off him? It frustrates me!

‘Ex-pros can help VAR’

Darren England reviews Eberechi Eze's goal for Crystal Palace against Chelsea on the pitchside monitor
Image:
Darren England reviews Eberechi Eze’s goal for Crystal Palace against Chelsea on the pitchside monitor

I’ve always said it, and I will continue to say it until the cows come home, they need to have someone with VAR who has played the game.

I’m not talking about a superstar or a top Premier League player, I’m talking about potentially a League One or League Two player, who may have to work after finishing football.

Put someone like that with VAR and they will give you that football context.

I am not saying that because we played the game, we know more than the referees or the public. It is not that at all. We love football because the game is about opinions, and everyone can have one.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Speaking on Ref Watch, Jay Bothroyd and Dermot Gallagher take a look at Nathan Collins’ challenge on Mbeumo and if he was lucky to not see red

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Kris Boyd and Mike Dean are in total agreement that Brentford should have had a man sent off against Manchester United when Nathan Collins gave a penalty away for a foul on Bryan Mbeumo

That’s the beauty of our game.

However, what having an ex-pro with VAR would do, it would provide context. It would tell the officials about those key moments, and it would take you inside the mind of footballer. Could he have stayed on his feet? Did he go over too softly? Did he mean that reckless tackle?

An ex-pro has been there and done it, and they can give you those answers.

It’s priceless knowledge and it is something the referees haven’t got. Their conversations on the pitch show you that.

This news was originally published on this post .

About the author

About the author call_made

SPORTIVO

More posts

Técnico do Real Madrid define o futuro de Endrick e elogia Rodrygo

Xabi Alonso no comando do Real Madrid. Foto Alamy.O técnico do Real Madrid, Xabi Alonso comentou neste sábado (18) sobre o futuro de Endrick e Rodrygo. O comandante negou os rumores sobre as saídas dos brasileiros e informou que os dois estão nos planos da equipe para a temporada. No entanto, destacou que a disputa por posição é grande. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADESegundo Alonso, Endrick e o jovem Gonzalo García estão preparados para competir de igual para igual. Ele ressaltou que o foco é mantê-los envolvidos nas partidas e que não há intenção de negociar o brasileiro.“No momento, isso não está na minha cabeça. Os dois estão prontos para jogar em uma posição com muita concorrência”, afirmou Alonso em entrevista coletiva. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADEEndrick segue nos planos do Real MadridEndrick, de 18 anos, ainda não voltou a atuar desde que se recuperou de […]

The two incredible offers the Patriots turned down for Drake Maye

The New England Patriots' decision to stay at No. 3 to draft Drake Maye raised eyebrows at the time, but recent reports reveal just how much they turned away. According to renowned journalist Albert Breer of Sports Illustrated, several teams plied New England with major packages in an attempt to move up and grab the North Carolina product. "So the Vikings offered them the 11th pick, the 23rd pick, a 2025 firstround pick," Breer said during an appearance on 98.5 The Sports Hub. "So they were offered three firstround picks and then pick swaps later on. And then the Giants offered their firstround pick, which was sixth. So they would only have to move down three spots. Then their 2025 firstround pick. Then, I believe, a thirdround pick." Ultimately, the Patriots stood firm. Even though the franchise still had significant holes to fill, they believed Maye was worth more […]

Chelsea vyhrála v Nottinghamu

Hlavní postavou zápasu byl portugalský záložník Neto, který v rozpětí tří minut druhého poločasu připravil premiérový gól pro devatenáctiletého Acheamponga a druhý přidal sám po nakrátko rozehraném přímém kopu. Hladké vítězství dovršil šest minut před koncem obránce James. Výsledek se nezměnil, ani když hosté v závěru přišli o vyloučeného Francouze Gusta.Postecoglou, který v září vystřídal na lavičce Portugalce Nuna, čekal marně na první vítězství osm soutěžních zápasů, což byla nejdelší klubová série za posledních sto let. Na lavičce vydržel jen 39 dní. Favoritem na jeho místo je bývalý hráč Nottinghamu Sean Dyche, který je od lednového propuštění z Evertonu bez práce.Anglická fotbalová liga - 8. kolo:Nottingham - Chelsea 0:3 (50. Acheampong, 52. Neto, 84. James),16:00 Brighton - NewcastleBurnley - LeedsCrystal Palace - BournemouthManchester City - Everton, Sunderland - Wolverhampton,18:30 Fulham - Arsenal

Tarik Skubal and the Detroit Tigers $250 Million Standoff Explained

Tarik Skubal is likely to win his second Cy Young in as many years, and is undoubtedly one of the two best pitchers in the entire sport. He’s due for a big pay day when he becomes a free agent after the 2026 season, but it’s starting to look like that pay day won’t be coming from the Detroit Tigers.It was reported that negotiations between Skubal and the Tigers stalled after the sides offers were separated by $250 million. This is one of the least surprising outcomes in the Skubal negotiations because: One, he is represented by Scott Boras and every player represented by him will bleed their team for every single penny they can, and two, unlike his father, Tigers’ owner, Chris Illitch, isn’t willing to bring big money to the table like his father. This leaves Detroit in […]

trending_flat
Trawlerman holds off Sweet William to win Long Distance Cup

Trawlerman reiterated his dominance of the staying division when leading home a one-two for John and Thady Gosden in the Qipco British Champions Long Distance Cup at Ascot.The Godolphin-owned bay was the 5-6 favourite under William Buick and was patiently ridden around the two-mile trip before being sent for home as the field turned the final bend. Stablemate Sweet William went with him and was closing all the while under Robert Havlin, but he could not close the gap and it was the favourite who prevailed by a length and a half with Al Qareem back in third, beaten 12 lengths.John Gosden said: "They are two lovely horses - one seven, one six (years old) - great staying horses and they are part of the family at home."He led the other day in the Lonsdale at York. When the others […]

Palmeiras já tem resposta sobre saída de Flaco López para o Al-Rayyan

Flaco Lopez comemora mais um gol. Foto: Leco Viana/TheNEWS2 via ZUMA Press WireO interesse do Al-Rayyan, do Catar, em Flaco López aumentou nas últimas semanas, devido a boa fase do jogador. O cenário despertou a atenção do Palmeiras, que não pretende perder sua dupla de atacantes para a próxima de temporada. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADEA informação do interesse foi divulgada pelo jornalista Jorge Nicola, que afirmou que o clube árabe monitora a situação do camisa 42. No entanto, nenhuma proposta oficial foi feita até o momento.Verdão mantém posição firme por FlacoInternamente, a diretoria do Palmeiras avalia que Flaco López faz parte do planejamento esportivo para 2026. No entendimento da gestão, o jogador só sairia mediante uma proposta considerada “fora da curva”. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADENo entanto, apesar das especulações envolvendo o atacante argentino, o Palmeiras não recebeu nenhuma proposta oficial e considera improvável a […]

Related

Técnico do Real Madrid define o futuro de Endrick e elogia Rodrygo

Xabi Alonso no comando do Real Madrid. Foto Alamy.O técnico do Real Madrid, Xabi Alonso comentou neste sábado (18) sobre o futuro de Endrick e Rodrygo. O comandante negou os rumores sobre as saídas dos brasileiros e informou que os dois estão nos planos da equipe para a temporada. No entanto, destacou que a disputa por posição é grande. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADESegundo Alonso, Endrick e o jovem Gonzalo García estão preparados para competir de igual para igual. Ele ressaltou que o foco é mantê-los envolvidos nas partidas e que não há intenção de negociar o brasileiro.“No momento, isso não está na minha cabeça. Os dois estão prontos para jogar em uma posição com muita concorrência”, afirmou Alonso em entrevista coletiva. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADEEndrick segue nos planos do Real MadridEndrick, de 18 anos, ainda não voltou a atuar desde que se recuperou de […]

The two incredible offers the Patriots turned down for Drake Maye

The New England Patriots' decision to stay at No. 3 to draft Drake Maye raised eyebrows at the time, but recent reports reveal just how much they turned away. According to renowned journalist Albert Breer of Sports Illustrated, several teams plied New England with major packages in an attempt to move up and grab the North Carolina product. "So the Vikings offered them the 11th pick, the 23rd pick, a 2025 firstround pick," Breer said during an appearance on 98.5 The Sports Hub. "So they were offered three firstround picks and then pick swaps later on. And then the Giants offered their firstround pick, which was sixth. So they would only have to move down three spots. Then their 2025 firstround pick. Then, I believe, a thirdround pick." Ultimately, the Patriots stood firm. Even though the franchise still had significant holes to fill, they believed Maye was worth more […]

Chelsea vyhrála v Nottinghamu

Hlavní postavou zápasu byl portugalský záložník Neto, který v rozpětí tří minut druhého poločasu připravil premiérový gól pro devatenáctiletého Acheamponga a druhý přidal sám po nakrátko rozehraném přímém kopu. Hladké vítězství dovršil šest minut před koncem obránce James. Výsledek se nezměnil, ani když hosté v závěru přišli o vyloučeného Francouze Gusta.Postecoglou, který v září vystřídal na lavičce Portugalce Nuna, čekal marně na první vítězství osm soutěžních zápasů, což byla nejdelší klubová série za posledních sto let. Na lavičce vydržel jen 39 dní. Favoritem na jeho místo je bývalý hráč Nottinghamu Sean Dyche, který je od lednového propuštění z Evertonu bez práce.Anglická fotbalová liga - 8. kolo:Nottingham - Chelsea 0:3 (50. Acheampong, 52. Neto, 84. James),16:00 Brighton - NewcastleBurnley - LeedsCrystal Palace - BournemouthManchester City - Everton, Sunderland - Wolverhampton,18:30 Fulham - Arsenal

Tarik Skubal and the Detroit Tigers $250 Million Standoff Explained

Tarik Skubal is likely to win his second Cy Young in as many years, and is undoubtedly one of the two best pitchers in the entire sport. He’s due for a big pay day when he becomes a free agent after the 2026 season, but it’s starting to look like that pay day won’t be coming from the Detroit Tigers.It was reported that negotiations between Skubal and the Tigers stalled after the sides offers were separated by $250 million. This is one of the least surprising outcomes in the Skubal negotiations because: One, he is represented by Scott Boras and every player represented by him will bleed their team for every single penny they can, and two, unlike his father, Tigers’ owner, Chris Illitch, isn’t willing to bring big money to the table like his father. This leaves Detroit in […]

trending_flat
Trawlerman holds off Sweet William to win Long Distance Cup

Trawlerman reiterated his dominance of the staying division when leading home a one-two for John and Thady Gosden in the Qipco British Champions Long Distance Cup at Ascot.The Godolphin-owned bay was the 5-6 favourite under William Buick and was patiently ridden around the two-mile trip before being sent for home as the field turned the final bend. Stablemate Sweet William went with him and was closing all the while under Robert Havlin, but he could not close the gap and it was the favourite who prevailed by a length and a half with Al Qareem back in third, beaten 12 lengths.John Gosden said: "They are two lovely horses - one seven, one six (years old) - great staying horses and they are part of the family at home."He led the other day in the Lonsdale at York. When the others […]

Palmeiras já tem resposta sobre saída de Flaco López para o Al-Rayyan

Flaco Lopez comemora mais um gol. Foto: Leco Viana/TheNEWS2 via ZUMA Press WireO interesse do Al-Rayyan, do Catar, em Flaco López aumentou nas últimas semanas, devido a boa fase do jogador. O cenário despertou a atenção do Palmeiras, que não pretende perder sua dupla de atacantes para a próxima de temporada. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADEA informação do interesse foi divulgada pelo jornalista Jorge Nicola, que afirmou que o clube árabe monitora a situação do camisa 42. No entanto, nenhuma proposta oficial foi feita até o momento.Verdão mantém posição firme por FlacoInternamente, a diretoria do Palmeiras avalia que Flaco López faz parte do planejamento esportivo para 2026. No entendimento da gestão, o jogador só sairia mediante uma proposta considerada “fora da curva”. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADENo entanto, apesar das especulações envolvendo o atacante argentino, o Palmeiras não recebeu nenhuma proposta oficial e considera improvável a […]

Be the first to leave a comment

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sportivo bridges the gap between talent and opportunity.

About SPORTIVO

Sportivo Network is a dedicated social platform for sports enthusiasts, athletes, and scouts. Whether you’re an aspiring athlete looking for opportunities, a coach searching for talent, or simply a sports lover wanting to connect with like-minded people, Sportivo is your go-to network. With features like direct messaging, profile showcasing, and talent scouting, Sportivo bridges the gap between talent and opportunity. Here, you can share your achievements, interact with professionals, and open doors to the next level in your sports journey. Join Sportivo Network – because every great athlete deserves to be discovered!
Copyright © 2025 SPORTIVO News. and SPORTIVO Network. All rights reserved.

Login to enjoy full advantages

Please login or subscribe to continue.

Go Premium!

Enjoy the full advantage of the premium access.

Stop following

Unfollow Cancel

Cancel subscription

Are you sure you want to cancel your subscription? You will lose your Premium access and stored playlists.

Go back Confirm cancellation