What to make of Tony Vitello’s surprising move from the Tennessee Volunteers to the San Francisco Giants

Sports

add

In a groundbreaking move, Tony Vitello, the head baseball coach at the University of Tennessee, has accepted an offer to be the next manager of the San Francisco Giants, according to Jeff Passan and Pete Thamel of ESPN. Reports of mutual interest between Vitello, 47, and Giants president of baseball operations Buster Posey broke last week, unleashing something of a mini-saga in Knoxville as Vitello deliberated on his next step.

Volunteers fans hung a banner during a recent fall practice that read “PLEASE STAY TONY.” University of Tennessee diehards appeared to create fake San Francisco Giants fan accounts intent on raising faux concerns about the hire in a last-ditch attempt to keep Vitello in town. But in the end, Vitello, who led the Vols to the first national championship in program history in 2024, apparently couldn’t pass up a shot at the bigs. In San Francisco, he’ll replace Bob Melvin, who went 161-163 in two seasons at the helm and was fired after the 2025 season ended.

Advertisement

It is, quite simply, a shocking development for a number of reasons.

Most importantly, Vitello becomes the first college head coach in the sport’s history to make the direct jump to an MLB skipper’s chair. Brewers manager Pat Murphy served as the head man at Arizona State University from 1995 to 2009, but then he spent four-plus years in the minors with the Padres organization and eight years as Milwaukee’s bench coach before becoming a big-league manager. Former Yankees manager Dick Howser spent 10 seasons as the third-base coach in New York before managing his alma mater, FSU, for a year and then becoming the Yankees’ skipper.

Vitello, on the other hand, will go straight from coaching class-bound teenagers to managing multimillionaire superstars such as Rafael Devers and Willy Adames. While other American sports see occasional crossover between the pro and amateur sides, this type of move is unprecedented in baseball, where the gap between college and MLB remains daunting.

[Yahoo Sports TV is here! Watch live shows and highlights 24/7]

The son of a successful St. Louis-area high school coach, Vitello played collegiately at the Division II level for a year before transferring to the University of Missouri, where he was teammates with multi-time All-Star second baseman Ian Kinsler. One year after graduating, he joined the Tigers’ coaching staff, serving there for eight seasons in a number of roles. Vitello then secured assistant-coaching gigs at Division I powerhouses Texas Christian University and the University of Arkansas. In 2017, he parlayed his success with the Horned Frogs and Razorbacks into the first head-coaching job of his career, taking over a Tennessee program that was something of a conference doormat.

Advertisement

It took Vitello only four seasons — one of which was scuttled by the pandemic — to lead the Vols to the Men’s College World Series for the first time since 2005. The program has since solidified itself as one of the nation’s best, reaching the CWS again in 2023 and winning the whole thing in 2024. The Volunteers’ home ballpark, Lindsey Nelson Stadium, is currently undergoing renovations that cost north of $100 million. Vitello’s brash, no-nonsense style has turned his team into a main attraction in Knoxville and made him something of a cartoon villain in the world of college baseball. It also earned him what was then the largest contract in the sport in 2024, a five-year extension worth more than $3 million per year.

At no point did anybody in the pro or college baseball universe expect Vitello, a man at the top of his craft, to leave all that behind to try his hand in the big leagues.

Enter Giants exec and future Hall of Famer Buster Posey, who took control of his former club’s baseball operations department a little more than a year ago. In the time since, Posey has acted boldly and decisively to try to refurbish a franchise that had grown to epitomize mediocrity. His June blockbuster to acquire Devers shocked the industry and gave San Francisco a middle-of-the order bat for the next seven years. Posey’s decision to fire Melvin was also seen as a surprise, given that he’d picked up a one-year option on Melvin’s contract in July. But a late September slide pushed the Giants out of postseason contention, further unearthing cracks in Melvin’s old-school managerial style.

Advertisement

Vitello, for better or worse, will bring a much different energy. He is immensely charismatic, boisterous, eccentric, unyielding and unafraid to express himself. The reality of Vitello conducting more than 350 media sessions per MLB season should produce some highly entertaining moments. His is a rah-rah style of leadership that, traditionally, has not been thought to translate to the pro level, where the season is longer and the players are richer.

But Posey and Vitello are willing to take the risk.

Part of the reason is the shrinking chasm between the highest levels of college baseball — Vitello’s Volunteers are an SEC powerhouse — and the big leagues. Schools are pulling in and spending more money than ever before. Programs such as Tennessee have become legitimate developmental hubs, more advanced in some respects than the more archaic big-league orgs. The advent of NIL dollars and the transfer portal have fostered a general professionalization of the college ranks.

The rising tide of college baseball has also caused salaries to skyrocket. Vitello’s record-breaking extension signed last summer has been surpassed by LSU’s Jay Johnson, who this year shepherded the Tigers to a second national championship in three seasons. Three other skippers — Brian O’Connor at Mississippi State, Tim Corbin at Vanderbilt and Jim Schlossnagle at Texas — are making more than $2 million per year.

Advertisement

That’s part of what makes San Francisco’s wrangling of Vitello so surprising and potentially perilous. This is a relatively huge financial investment. Although a dollar figure has yet to be reported, the Giants are surely giving Vitello a raise, meaning his salary is somewhere north of $3.5 million. The Giants are still on the hook for at least $3 million to Bob Melvin after picking up his 2026 option, and they’ll need to pay Tennessee the $3 million buyout on Vitello’s contract.

For the Giants, this is a massive roll of the dice on someone who hasn’t spent a single second of his accomplished coaching life working in professional ball. It’s a bet that Vitello’s attributes as a leader, a developer and a motivator will translate. That is far from a given. Vitello is a special coach, but this situation could go sideways in a million different directions.

Advertisement

For Vitello, the move is something of a no-brainer, if the money is right. He has already won all there is to win in Knoxville, a city that should adore him forever for turning its baseball team into a juggernaut. If things don’t work out with the Giants, Vitello would have his pick of top-shelf college openings, not to mention another multi-million-dollar contract.

But if everything goes right?

Vitello could become the first coach in baseball history to win championships at the college and professional levels. That dream, it seems, was worth the leap of faith.

This news was originally published on this post .

Share on

email

Previous

trending_flat

Rumo às oitavas? Veja o que a Seleção Brasileira sub-17 precisa para avançar no Mundial Feminino

DESTAQUE, Futebol Feminino

Next

trending_flat

UNLV’s rent-a-coach system may be the way smaller schools keep up in new era of college sports

Sports