Less than three weeks out from the announcement of the College Football Playoff field, it seems we could be headed for another head-scratching decision regarding this year’s 12-team bracket.
In Tuesday’s updated rankings from the selection committee, Notre Dame sits at No. 9 while Miami is 13th.
Both teams are 8–2. Miami beat Notre Dame 27–24 back in Week 1. And yet, it seems clear the Fighting Irish will comfortably be in the field once again if they win their final two games, while the Hurricanes will probably need chaos to break their way since they’re very likely to miss the ACC Championship Game.
How is this the case when we literally have proof of what happens when these two seemingly comparable teams face off on the field?
“I think when you look at Notre Dame and Miami, we really compare the losses of those two teams. Miami has lost to two unranked teams,” new selection committee chair Hunter Yurachek said Tuesday. “We really haven’t compared those two teams, they haven’t been in similar comparative pools to date. But Miami is creeping up to where they will be compared to Notre Dame if something happens above them.”
Yurachek, who took over the role on Nov. 13 when Mack Rhoades stepped down while taking a leave of absence as Baylor’s athletic director, is technically right about Miami’s losses.
Louisville was ranked before losing a second straight game Saturday, but in the updated rankings, the Hurricanes’ two losses are indeed to unranked ACC teams. Still, Louisville and SMU are a combined 14–6 (9–4 in ACC), so they aren’t exactly pushovers.
They also aren’t the top-15 teams that Notre Dame lost to in its first two games (Miami and now-No. 3 Texas A&M) before rattling off its current eight-game winning streak.
But that’s only half the equation. Who you lose to matters — but who you beat should matter just as much.
Miami has a top-10 win over Notre Dame and what was another ranked win over South Florida until the Bulls took their third loss Saturday and fell out of the top 25.
Notre Dame has a win over No. 15 USC and a win over a Pitt team it just knocked out of the rankings. Beyond that, the Irish have beaten two Group of Six teams above .500 (Boise State at 6–4 and Navy at 8–2) and four Power Four opponents who are a combined 10–32 this season.
Miami has the worse losses. It also has the best win — and arguably a better overall set of wins.
Shouldn’t both of those things matter? And if the résumés are as similar as many believe, shouldn’t the tiebreaker be the head-to-head matchup they literally played this season?
Sometimes I feel like I’m taking crazy pills listening to some of the CFP committee’s ranking logic. The most frustrating part is how the committee seems to value entirely different criteria every single year.
Some seasons, good wins matter most. Other years, it’s all about avoiding bad losses. In 2014, it was “game control.” Then there was the dreadful Florida State snub in 2023, credited largely to Jordan Travis’ injury.
All we ask for is consistency, and apparently that’s too much to request.
Pittsburgh could do the CFP selection committee a real solid by knocking off Miami in the final week of the regular season and making this comparison point irrelevant.
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
Michigan State HC Tom Izzo: Jeremy Fears Jr. ‘As Good As Any Guard I’ve Had’
Jeremy Fears Jr. is off to a spectacular start for the Michigan State Spartans on both ends of the floor, and it shows in the box score.Over Michigan State's last two games, Fears has totaled 26 points, 24 assists and five steals, and the redshirt sophomore guard has caught head coach Tom Izzo's attention."I'm never satisfied. I think his defense can be a little better because I think he's an absolute dog defensively, meaning he'll dog you. Not a dog in a bad way. He can get after you. He's a pitbull in that when he wants to be," Izzo said about Fears after Michigan State's win over Detroit Mercy on Friday night. "Now we're getting him a little rest, 28-29 minutes [per game] is probably perfect if we can do that because he's got to push the ball, he's […]
Sparta zdržovala, mínila Boleslav. Vítej v mém světě, řekl Priske kolegovi
Boleslavský trenér Aleš Majer, který byl v hodně chladném odpoledni do utkání tak ponořen, že koučoval jen ve svetru, se u postranní čáry několikrát chytal za hlavu. Sparťanský kouč Brian Priske se pak dostal do výměny názorů s domácí lavičkou a po utkání si vše vyříkával s vedoucím domácího mužstva Markem Matějovským.Reakce aktérů? „Bylo to úplně v pohodě. Nešlo o nic zásadního. Říkali jsme si (s trenérem Priskem - pozn. aut.) něco k tomu, že Sparta hrála v závěru pomalu. On mi to totiž vytýkal po zápase na Spartě, že po 80. minutě za stavu 2:2 jsme pomalu rozehrávali. Říkal jsem mu, že tady je to to samé,“ vylíčil Majer.Zmínka o tom, že zdržovali, hosty nenechala v klidu. „Nepřijeli jsme sem zdržovat utkání. To nikdy není náš záměr, naopak my jsme ten tým, který chce držet tempo utkání. Ale když máte pět minut do konce, vedete o gól, hráči jsou pod tlakem a mají zodpovědnost […]
Vini Jr e Real Madrid voltam a avançar sobre renovação e tomam decisão
Vini Jr. tem contrato com o Real Madrid até o meio de 2027 (Foto: Magara Press SL/Alamy Live News)Vini Jr e Real Madrid voltaram a tratar da renovação de contrato nas últimas semanas, com mais clareza e menos ruído nos bastidores. A expectativa é de que um novo contrato seja firmado em breve, ampliando o vínculo que hoje termina em junho de 2027. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADEApós uma série de polêmicas que aumentaram a especulação sobre uma possível saída, a direção merengue e o atacante brasileiro alinharam o desejo mútuo de seguir juntos. Segundo o jornal espanhol ‘AS’, ambas as partes enxergam o acordo encaminhado, após um período desgastante de nove meses de negociações.“Eles conversaram recentemente e uma solução está a caminho para que se chegue a um acordo final”, diz o jornal. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADELeia também: Lewandowski pode sair do Barcelona e […]
Slalomář Krejčí je Králem divoké vody za letošní rok, uspěl na MS i ME
Krejčí potvrdil postavení z celosvazové ankety o Kanoistu roku, kde skončil druhý hned za mistrem světa v rychlostní kanoistice Martinem Fuksou. Mezi závodníky na divoké vodě dostal v celkovém pořadí 153 bodů a vyhrál s výrazným náskokem 55 bodů před kanoistou Matějem Vaňkem. „Já jsem celkově vděčný za celou sezonu a tohle už je jenom takový bonus. Je to fajn, je to hezké dojet se podívat do Olomouce a vyzvednout si cenu. Jsem za to rád,“ řekl Krejčí v nahrávce pro média.Druhý Vaněk díky světovému titulu ve sjezdu nechal o sedm bodů za sebou slalomáře Jiřího Prskavce. Ten získal na kajaku evropské zlato a světový bronz.Krejčí vyhrál i hodnocení seniorské kategorie ve vodním slalomu, kde za ním skončil druhý Prskavec. Třetí příčku obsadila kanoistka a kajakářka Gabriela Satková, která loni ovládla celkové pořadí této ankety. Mezi slalomovými nadějemi byli nejlepší juniorský mistr světa na kajaku Michal Kopeček a světový šampion mezi kanoisty do 23 let Lukáš Kratochvíl.Pořadí […]
What now for England after Ashes implosion in Perth?
You head into an intimidating environment with hopes of success and then it goes so epically, spectacularly badly.No, we are not referring to Monty Panesar's appearance on Celebrity Mastermind back in 2019, which made a surprise entry into an eventful Ashes build-up as the former England spinner became embroiled in a spat with current Australia batter Steve Smith Instead, we are talking about England's fortunes in the first Test. As you surely know by now, that match didn't end well for them. It didn't start well for them either (172 all out inside 33 overs on day one) but at lunch on day two they had wrestled control: leading Australia by 99 runs with nine second-innings wickets in hand. Two and half hours later, they had somehow lost, through their own errors and the unbridled brilliance of makeshift opener Travis […]
Lane Kiffin’s Decision Looms as LSU Reportedly Prepares Massive $90M Offer
Lane Kiffin’s decision on his coaching future feels like it's holding college football hostage.Ole Miss confirmed Friday that Kiffin will announce his future on Nov. 29 — one day after the Rebels meet Mississippi State — leaving Florida, LSU, and even his own program stuck in an uncomfortable position.The uncertainty intensified late Friday night, when reports surfaced that LSU officials are preparing to make an aggressive push to pry Kiffin from Oxford, Mississippi. According to a report from Yahoo Sports, key decision-makers are preparing a formal offer that could reach seven years and at least $90 million, which would place Kiffin among the highest-paid coaches in college football.According to the same report, LSU is also prepared to invest more than $25 million in NIL and roster-building support. While Florida is also in the mix for Kiffin, LSU’s surge has instantly […]
Related
Michigan State HC Tom Izzo: Jeremy Fears Jr. ‘As Good As Any Guard I’ve Had’
Jeremy Fears Jr. is off to a spectacular start for the Michigan State Spartans on both ends of the floor, and it shows in the box score.Over Michigan State's last two games, Fears has totaled 26 points, 24 assists and five steals, and the redshirt sophomore guard has caught head coach Tom Izzo's attention."I'm never satisfied. I think his defense can be a little better because I think he's an absolute dog defensively, meaning he'll dog you. Not a dog in a bad way. He can get after you. He's a pitbull in that when he wants to be," Izzo said about Fears after Michigan State's win over Detroit Mercy on Friday night. "Now we're getting him a little rest, 28-29 minutes [per game] is probably perfect if we can do that because he's got to push the ball, he's […]
Sparta zdržovala, mínila Boleslav. Vítej v mém světě, řekl Priske kolegovi
Boleslavský trenér Aleš Majer, který byl v hodně chladném odpoledni do utkání tak ponořen, že koučoval jen ve svetru, se u postranní čáry několikrát chytal za hlavu. Sparťanský kouč Brian Priske se pak dostal do výměny názorů s domácí lavičkou a po utkání si vše vyříkával s vedoucím domácího mužstva Markem Matějovským.Reakce aktérů? „Bylo to úplně v pohodě. Nešlo o nic zásadního. Říkali jsme si (s trenérem Priskem - pozn. aut.) něco k tomu, že Sparta hrála v závěru pomalu. On mi to totiž vytýkal po zápase na Spartě, že po 80. minutě za stavu 2:2 jsme pomalu rozehrávali. Říkal jsem mu, že tady je to to samé,“ vylíčil Majer.Zmínka o tom, že zdržovali, hosty nenechala v klidu. „Nepřijeli jsme sem zdržovat utkání. To nikdy není náš záměr, naopak my jsme ten tým, který chce držet tempo utkání. Ale když máte pět minut do konce, vedete o gól, hráči jsou pod tlakem a mají zodpovědnost […]
Vini Jr e Real Madrid voltam a avançar sobre renovação e tomam decisão
Vini Jr. tem contrato com o Real Madrid até o meio de 2027 (Foto: Magara Press SL/Alamy Live News)Vini Jr e Real Madrid voltaram a tratar da renovação de contrato nas últimas semanas, com mais clareza e menos ruído nos bastidores. A expectativa é de que um novo contrato seja firmado em breve, ampliando o vínculo que hoje termina em junho de 2027. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADEApós uma série de polêmicas que aumentaram a especulação sobre uma possível saída, a direção merengue e o atacante brasileiro alinharam o desejo mútuo de seguir juntos. Segundo o jornal espanhol ‘AS’, ambas as partes enxergam o acordo encaminhado, após um período desgastante de nove meses de negociações.“Eles conversaram recentemente e uma solução está a caminho para que se chegue a um acordo final”, diz o jornal. PUBLICIDADE PUBLICIDADELeia também: Lewandowski pode sair do Barcelona e […]
Slalomář Krejčí je Králem divoké vody za letošní rok, uspěl na MS i ME
Krejčí potvrdil postavení z celosvazové ankety o Kanoistu roku, kde skončil druhý hned za mistrem světa v rychlostní kanoistice Martinem Fuksou. Mezi závodníky na divoké vodě dostal v celkovém pořadí 153 bodů a vyhrál s výrazným náskokem 55 bodů před kanoistou Matějem Vaňkem. „Já jsem celkově vděčný za celou sezonu a tohle už je jenom takový bonus. Je to fajn, je to hezké dojet se podívat do Olomouce a vyzvednout si cenu. Jsem za to rád,“ řekl Krejčí v nahrávce pro média.Druhý Vaněk díky světovému titulu ve sjezdu nechal o sedm bodů za sebou slalomáře Jiřího Prskavce. Ten získal na kajaku evropské zlato a světový bronz.Krejčí vyhrál i hodnocení seniorské kategorie ve vodním slalomu, kde za ním skončil druhý Prskavec. Třetí příčku obsadila kanoistka a kajakářka Gabriela Satková, která loni ovládla celkové pořadí této ankety. Mezi slalomovými nadějemi byli nejlepší juniorský mistr světa na kajaku Michal Kopeček a světový šampion mezi kanoisty do 23 let Lukáš Kratochvíl.Pořadí […]
What now for England after Ashes implosion in Perth?
You head into an intimidating environment with hopes of success and then it goes so epically, spectacularly badly.No, we are not referring to Monty Panesar's appearance on Celebrity Mastermind back in 2019, which made a surprise entry into an eventful Ashes build-up as the former England spinner became embroiled in a spat with current Australia batter Steve Smith Instead, we are talking about England's fortunes in the first Test. As you surely know by now, that match didn't end well for them. It didn't start well for them either (172 all out inside 33 overs on day one) but at lunch on day two they had wrestled control: leading Australia by 99 runs with nine second-innings wickets in hand. Two and half hours later, they had somehow lost, through their own errors and the unbridled brilliance of makeshift opener Travis […]
Lane Kiffin’s Decision Looms as LSU Reportedly Prepares Massive $90M Offer
Lane Kiffin’s decision on his coaching future feels like it's holding college football hostage.Ole Miss confirmed Friday that Kiffin will announce his future on Nov. 29 — one day after the Rebels meet Mississippi State — leaving Florida, LSU, and even his own program stuck in an uncomfortable position.The uncertainty intensified late Friday night, when reports surfaced that LSU officials are preparing to make an aggressive push to pry Kiffin from Oxford, Mississippi. According to a report from Yahoo Sports, key decision-makers are preparing a formal offer that could reach seven years and at least $90 million, which would place Kiffin among the highest-paid coaches in college football.According to the same report, LSU is also prepared to invest more than $25 million in NIL and roster-building support. While Florida is also in the mix for Kiffin, LSU’s surge has instantly […]
Be the first to leave a comment