Were the 2025 Cubs a success?
It probably depends on whom you ask.
For some franchises, a campaign of 92 wins, a wild-card series victory and a well-fought, five-game NLDS loss would be dreamland stuff. During the regular season, Chicago’s offense was a legitimate wagon, the only lineup in baseball with six position players worth at least 4.0 bWAR: Nico Hoerner, Dansby Swanson, Ian Happ, Pete Crow-Armstrong, Michael Busch and Kyle Tucker. Wrigley Field, per usual, was packed and rocking for most of the summer as the Cubbies reached October for the first time since 2020 and won their first playoff game since 2018. There was a lot to like.
Advertisement
[Get more Chicago news: Cubs team feed]
Yet at no point in the second half did the Cubs feel like legitimate World Series contenders. The gap between them and the eventual champion Los Angeles Dodgers was gargantuan. Milwaukee comfortably took the division crown. Kyle Tucker, for whom the Cubs traded away a haul last winter, was injured and underwhelming down the stretch and into the postseason. Chicago’s pitching was quite obviously substandard. There was a lot for fans to gripe about.
And halfway through the offseason, there still is, as president of baseball operations Jed Hoyer has done little this winter to quiet the noise. Because while the Cubs have signed more free agents so far this winter (6) than any other team, none of those additions is a true needle-mover. Five are one-year deals. Four are relievers. One was retaining Shota Imanaga on a qualifying offer. In short, the Cubs are not better today than they were the day they lost the NLDS.
Here are the three major questions that will define the rest of their offseason.
1. Will they try to replace Kyle Tucker?
That the Cubs seem entirely content to let Tucker, the market’s consensus top free agent, leave town remains one of this winter’s most underrated developments. Chicago parted with significant pieces to acquire him a year ago, yet the team appears to have zero interest in retaining his services moving forward. That says something about Tucker’s profile and the Cubs’ financial stinginess.
Advertisement
With Tucker’s departure a foregone conclusion, the Cubs will need to replace that production somehow. Because for all the consternation over Tucker’s relatively underwhelming walk year, the 28-year-old posted an .841 OPS, banged 22 homers and won a Silver Slugger. Those types of players, as will soon be showcased by Tucker’s enormous contract, do not grow on trees.
At present, Chicago seems content to fill the void internally. Outfielder Owen Caissie, a 23-year-old who struggled in a brief, 12-game ristretto, has enormous power and prospect pedigree. That should earn the rookie a sustained look in right field at some point. The same is true for top prospect Kevin Alcántara. Seiya Suzuki DH’ed for most of 2025 but could slide back into right in order to give positionless rookie Moisés Ballesteros some DH at-bats.
In Moneyball parlance, Hoyer and Co. will seek to replace Tucker in the aggregate. That’s a reasonable strategy, given the glut of internal options and the holes on the pitching side.
Advertisement
2. How will they reinforce the rotation?
Chicago’s 2025 pitching staff was far from a catastrophe. The quintet of Matthew Boyd, Cade Horton, Shota Imanaga, Jameson Taillon and Colin Rea was capable, sufficient and, as a unit, right around league average. Horton, in particular, was a revelation. The rookie dominated for the Cubs down the stretch, and his absence due to injury in October played a significant role in Chicago’s NLDS exit. As volatile as pitching can be, Horton looks like a real frontline arm.
Behind him, however, there are myriad questions. Boyd, a first-time All-Star at 34, was a wonderful story but ran a 4.63 ERA after the break and didn’t reach five innings in any of his three postseason starts. In fact, not a single Cubs pitcher worked past the fifth in the team’s eight playoff games. Taillon was effective in his two starts, yet the club clearly didn’t feel confident pushing him. Rea and Imanaga were both utilized after openers.
Advertisement
Imanaga returned to town on the qualifying offer after a convoluted series of contractual maneuvering, but barring an unforeseen, late-career velocity jump, he’s probably a mid-rotation arm moving forward.
It doesn’t take a professional prognosticator to see that this rotation could use some help. Another frontline arm to pair alongside Horton would work wonders. Thankfully for Chicago, the starting pitching market has been slow-moving. Framber Valdez, Tatsuya Imai, Ranger Suarez and Zac Gallen all remain available. All four would be reasonable upgrades for the Cubs. However, all four will also require a significant financial outlay, the type Chicago has been hesitant to make of late. Speaking of which …
3. Are the Cubs really going to be this cheap?
If the season started tomorrow, the Cubs would enter 2026 with a payroll just over $200 million, good for 11th in MLB. For such a profitable, historic, popular franchise, that is an embarrassingly paltry figure. In no world should the Chicago Cubs trail the Arizona Diamondbacks in big-league spending. Wrigley Field and all the real estate that surrounds it is a piggy bank, yet Chicago’s ownership group continues to operate like small-market paupers.
Advertisement
The Cubs have gone above the luxury tax just once since tearing down the Bryant-Báez-Rizzo core. That was in 2024, when Chicago surpassed the threshold by less than $3 million. Currently, the Cubs are projected by Spotrac for an outlay $43 million under the tax. Presumably, that should give Hoyer and Co. room to spend big on a free agent or two. However, all reporting out of Cubs World suggests that such a splash is far from a given.
Given the state of Chicago’s roster, that would be a shame.
This news was originally published on this post .
About the author
Lakers’ Austin Reaves out at least 4 weeks with calf strain
The Los Angeles Lakers have hit their first rough stretch of the season. If they want to get out of it, they’re probably going to have to do it without Austin Reaves.Reaves has been diagnosed with a grade 2 left gastrocnemius strain (the gastrocnemius is a muscle in the calf) and will be out until he’s re-evaluated in four weeks, the Lakers announced Friday via Brad Turner of the Los Angeles Times.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementThe announcement comes two weeks after Reaves first suffered a mild left calf strain, which caused him to miss three games. He was deemed ready to return last week, but left Thursday’s game against the Houston Rockets with another calf injury, and will now be out for at least a month.It’s a badly timed injury for the Lakers. The team has lost three games in a row, with losses […]
Minnesota Extends Bowl Game Win Streak to 9 After Beating New Mexico
Jalen Smith scored his second touchdown on a diving 12-yard catch in the first overtime and Minnesota extended its postseason winning streak to nine games with a 20-17 win over New Mexico in the Rate Bowl on Friday.A year after Kansas State beat Rutgers 44-41 in the Rate Bowl, the 2025 version turned defensive in the desert — until a flurry early in the fourth quarter.Minnesota (8-5) went up 14-6 when Darius Taylor scored on a 5-yard touchdown run, but Damon Bankston returned the ensuing kickoff 100 yards for a touchdown. New Mexico's 2-point conversion on a trick play tied the game at 14-all.The teams returned to trading punts, sending the game to overtime at Chase Field, home of baseball’s Arizona Diamondbacks.New Mexico (9-4) failed to get a first down on the opening possession and Luke Drzewiecki kicked a 36-yard […]
Jalen Smith’s second diving TD grab wins Rate Bowl as Minnesota denies New Mexico first 10-win season since 1982
With leading wideout Le'Meke Brockington not playing in Friday's Rate Bowl, Minnesota needed someone to step up in a relatively thin receiver room.Jalen Smith leaped at the opportunity. The redshirt freshman dove for a pair of touchdown catches, the second a game-winner in overtime.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementWith a 20-17 victory, the Gophers (8-5, 5-4 Big Ten) improved to 7-0 in bowl games under head coach P.J. Fleck and denied New Mexico (9-4, 6-2 Mountain West) its first 10-win season since 1982.Smith came into the day with only two touchdown receptions this season. He matched that total while recording six catches for 64 yards.His classmate, quarterback Drake Lindsey, gave him a chance in the end zone on third-and-8 in overtime after New Mexico started the extra frame with a 36-yard field goal.Lindsey threw off his back foot. As the ball reached the paint, Smith […]
Northwestern Beats Central Michigan in GameAbove Sports Bowl
Preston Stone threw three touchdown passes, and Northwestern turned four turnovers into touchdowns and beat Central Michigan 34-7 in the GameAbove Sports Bowl at Ford Field on Friday.The Wildcats (7-6) extended their bowl game winning streak to six. They haven't lost in the postseason since a 45-6 loss to Pittsburgh in the 2015 Outback Bowl.Central Michigan (7-6) is 0-3 against the Big Ten in bowl games, with all three losses coming at Ford Field. The Chippewas lost 51-48 to Purdue in the 2007 Motor City Bowl and 21-14 to Minnesota in the 2015 Quick Lane Bowl.Central Michigan had the first scoring opportunity of the game after stopping Northwestern on 4th-and-1 at the Wildcats 34, but Cade Graham missed a 43-yard field goal attempt.The game was still scoreless midway through the second quarter, but Braden Turner intercepted Angel Flores' pass at […]
ECHL players go on strike; games postponed
Florida Everblades forward Logan Will (62) tries to fight off Orlando Solar Bears defender Jarid Lukosevicius (57) during the first period of an ECHL preseason game at Hertz Arena in Estero, Fla., on Thursday, Oct. 9, 2025. The players of the ECHL have initiated a midseason strike, with their union Friday accusing the league of refusing to bargain in good faith. The ECHL postponed 13 games slated for Friday as a result of the work stoppage. The Professional Hockey Players' Association (PHPA) represents minor league hockey players in the American Hockey League and the ECHL, formerly called the East Coast Hockey League. The ECHL is two tiers below the NHL and has 30 teams that all hold an affiliation with an NHL franchise. In a vote last week, PHPA members voted to authorize its bargaining committee to call for a […]
ECHL players go on strike; games postponed
Florida Everblades forward Logan Will (62) tries to fight off Orlando Solar Bears defender Jarid Lukosevicius (57) during the first period of an ECHL preseason game at Hertz Arena in Estero, Fla., on Thursday, Oct. 9, 2025. The players of the ECHL have initiated a midseason strike, with their union Friday accusing the league of refusing to bargain in good faith. The ECHL postponed 13 games slated for Friday as a result of the work stoppage. The Professional Hockey Players' Association (PHPA) represents minor league hockey players in the American Hockey League and the ECHL, formerly called the East Coast Hockey League. The ECHL is two tiers below the NHL and has 30 teams that all hold an affiliation with an NHL franchise. In a vote last week, PHPA members voted to authorize its bargaining committee to call for a […]
Related
Lakers’ Austin Reaves out at least 4 weeks with calf strain
The Los Angeles Lakers have hit their first rough stretch of the season. If they want to get out of it, they’re probably going to have to do it without Austin Reaves.Reaves has been diagnosed with a grade 2 left gastrocnemius strain (the gastrocnemius is a muscle in the calf) and will be out until he’s re-evaluated in four weeks, the Lakers announced Friday via Brad Turner of the Los Angeles Times.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementThe announcement comes two weeks after Reaves first suffered a mild left calf strain, which caused him to miss three games. He was deemed ready to return last week, but left Thursday’s game against the Houston Rockets with another calf injury, and will now be out for at least a month.It’s a badly timed injury for the Lakers. The team has lost three games in a row, with losses […]
Minnesota Extends Bowl Game Win Streak to 9 After Beating New Mexico
Jalen Smith scored his second touchdown on a diving 12-yard catch in the first overtime and Minnesota extended its postseason winning streak to nine games with a 20-17 win over New Mexico in the Rate Bowl on Friday.A year after Kansas State beat Rutgers 44-41 in the Rate Bowl, the 2025 version turned defensive in the desert — until a flurry early in the fourth quarter.Minnesota (8-5) went up 14-6 when Darius Taylor scored on a 5-yard touchdown run, but Damon Bankston returned the ensuing kickoff 100 yards for a touchdown. New Mexico's 2-point conversion on a trick play tied the game at 14-all.The teams returned to trading punts, sending the game to overtime at Chase Field, home of baseball’s Arizona Diamondbacks.New Mexico (9-4) failed to get a first down on the opening possession and Luke Drzewiecki kicked a 36-yard […]
Jalen Smith’s second diving TD grab wins Rate Bowl as Minnesota denies New Mexico first 10-win season since 1982
With leading wideout Le'Meke Brockington not playing in Friday's Rate Bowl, Minnesota needed someone to step up in a relatively thin receiver room.Jalen Smith leaped at the opportunity. The redshirt freshman dove for a pair of touchdown catches, the second a game-winner in overtime.AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementWith a 20-17 victory, the Gophers (8-5, 5-4 Big Ten) improved to 7-0 in bowl games under head coach P.J. Fleck and denied New Mexico (9-4, 6-2 Mountain West) its first 10-win season since 1982.Smith came into the day with only two touchdown receptions this season. He matched that total while recording six catches for 64 yards.His classmate, quarterback Drake Lindsey, gave him a chance in the end zone on third-and-8 in overtime after New Mexico started the extra frame with a 36-yard field goal.Lindsey threw off his back foot. As the ball reached the paint, Smith […]
Northwestern Beats Central Michigan in GameAbove Sports Bowl
Preston Stone threw three touchdown passes, and Northwestern turned four turnovers into touchdowns and beat Central Michigan 34-7 in the GameAbove Sports Bowl at Ford Field on Friday.The Wildcats (7-6) extended their bowl game winning streak to six. They haven't lost in the postseason since a 45-6 loss to Pittsburgh in the 2015 Outback Bowl.Central Michigan (7-6) is 0-3 against the Big Ten in bowl games, with all three losses coming at Ford Field. The Chippewas lost 51-48 to Purdue in the 2007 Motor City Bowl and 21-14 to Minnesota in the 2015 Quick Lane Bowl.Central Michigan had the first scoring opportunity of the game after stopping Northwestern on 4th-and-1 at the Wildcats 34, but Cade Graham missed a 43-yard field goal attempt.The game was still scoreless midway through the second quarter, but Braden Turner intercepted Angel Flores' pass at […]
ECHL players go on strike; games postponed
Florida Everblades forward Logan Will (62) tries to fight off Orlando Solar Bears defender Jarid Lukosevicius (57) during the first period of an ECHL preseason game at Hertz Arena in Estero, Fla., on Thursday, Oct. 9, 2025. The players of the ECHL have initiated a midseason strike, with their union Friday accusing the league of refusing to bargain in good faith. The ECHL postponed 13 games slated for Friday as a result of the work stoppage. The Professional Hockey Players' Association (PHPA) represents minor league hockey players in the American Hockey League and the ECHL, formerly called the East Coast Hockey League. The ECHL is two tiers below the NHL and has 30 teams that all hold an affiliation with an NHL franchise. In a vote last week, PHPA members voted to authorize its bargaining committee to call for a […]
ECHL players go on strike; games postponed
Florida Everblades forward Logan Will (62) tries to fight off Orlando Solar Bears defender Jarid Lukosevicius (57) during the first period of an ECHL preseason game at Hertz Arena in Estero, Fla., on Thursday, Oct. 9, 2025. The players of the ECHL have initiated a midseason strike, with their union Friday accusing the league of refusing to bargain in good faith. The ECHL postponed 13 games slated for Friday as a result of the work stoppage. The Professional Hockey Players' Association (PHPA) represents minor league hockey players in the American Hockey League and the ECHL, formerly called the East Coast Hockey League. The ECHL is two tiers below the NHL and has 30 teams that all hold an affiliation with an NHL franchise. In a vote last week, PHPA members voted to authorize its bargaining committee to call for a […]
Be the first to leave a comment